
That’s the question Robert Samuelson asks in his most recent Washington Post column:
In today’s contentious political climate, when hardly anyone agrees on anything, here’s a rare subject of consensus: Health spending is slowing, and almost everyone thinks that’s a good thing. Aside from relieving pressures on federal and state budgets, it could help reverse stagnant wages by moderating the cost of employer-paid insurance. Compensation would shift from insurance to wages. What the experts don’t agree on is who (or what) caused the slowdown and whether it will continue.
First, the basic figures. In each of 2009, 2010 and 2011, U.S. health spending increased a modest 3.9 percent, virtually identical with the slow growth of the economy (gross domestic product, or GDP). So health spending remained steady at 17.9 percent of GDP after years of increases. Almost no one predicted this.
There are practically as many answers to this question as there are people answering it. The Obama Administration and its staunch supporters, as you might expect, say that, of course, it’s ObamaCare. Others, like Samuelson, are skeptical. Explanations that have been offered include the recession and “structural changes”, e.g. use of less-expensive generic drugs, higher patient co-payments and deductibles, and lower administrative costs in doctors’ offices and hospitals.
I would also suggest that very slow increases in the Medicare reimbursement rate, the recession, and the higher patient co-pays and deductibles work synergistically to reduce the ability of providers to pass cost increases along which in turn incentivizes a search for ways to lower administrative costs, etc.
Some of the slowing may merely be a mathematical artifact. Healthcare spending continues to rise but as healthcare becomes a larger proportion of the economy the gap between the general rate of inflation and the rate of increase in healthcare costs narrows. With healthcare spending at 100% of the economy the two would be identical by definition.
In the final analysis Mr. Samuelson offers no answer in which we can have any confidence. Nobody knows. I do think it’s too early to declare victory.






