What Are Our Interests in Ukraine?

I’ve long held a view that seems to be unpopular. Since Russia is the only country in the world that actually could destroy us, not to mention the entire world, it would be prudent for us to cultivate a good relationship with Russia. Instead, we’ve gone out of our way to insult and aggravate Russia with no particular gain for ourselves. For more in that vein see here.

I have a question. I can understand why Russia would be concerned about U. S. adventurism in its neighborhood. What I can’t understand is why we should be concerned about Russia pursuing what have been its interests in its own neighborhood for the last 300 years. Can someone explain that to me?

49 comments

A Tale of Two Editorials

The editors of the New York Times and Washington Post have, more or less, come out on opposite sides on the proposed tax reform on which I posted yesterday. The NYT editors oppose the measure for what are to me short-sighted and puzzling reasons. Their first argument is that if tax expenditures are cut or limited, they can’t be cut or limited in the future for a more worthy goal, i.e. increasing revenues:

The plan, intended only to simplify the tax code rather than redistribute the burden, reduces the number of tax brackets from seven to three. Low-income taxpayers would pay a 10 percent rate, those in the middle would pay 25 percent, and families making $450,000 and above would pay 35 percent instead of the current 39.6 percent.

In many cases, that represents a tax cut, and to make up for the loss in revenue — since the plan aims to be revenue-neutral — a large number of deductions and breaks are eliminated. But ending those breaks just to reduce rates means the savings can’t be used for important expenses in the future — which is a Republican goal.

The second objection is that putting a cap on the home mortgage deduction and eliminating the deductibility of state and local taxes would be unfair to New York:

One big break that would be affected is the mortgage-interest deduction. By limiting it to $500,000, the plan would hurt many middle-class families that must borrow more than that to afford a house in expensive markets like New York. Even worse, it would repeal the deduction for state and local taxes, a deliberate attempt to make it more difficult for “blue” states to provide the services and safety-net protections that they have decided are necessary.

IMO this is flummery. According to the Census Bureau the median home price in New York County is more than $800,000 and, understandably, it has one of the lowest rates of home ownership—a bit over 50%. Nearly by definition people who buy homes valued at more than $800,000 aren’t middle income—they’re upper middle income or upper income. In New York middle income people rent. Additionally, I find it excessive to expect the federal tax code to solve New York’s problems with home affordability. That’s properly a role for the state.

However, the NYT’s complaints bring into sharp relief the problem with the home mortgage deduction and many of the other “tax expenditures”: they are subsidies to people with higher incomes. They go overwhelmingly to the 3% or the 1%. I would think that a tax code that reduced subsidies to the rich would be an improvement.

The editors of the Times do not seem to recognize that a simple tax code will itself be a better tax code, trimming the costs of compliance and reducing the opportunities for gaming the system, opportunities most available to the highest income earners.

The editors of the Washington Post on the other hand seem favorably predisposed to the plan, would be even more favorably disposed to beginning a discussion of tax reform, but are mournful about tax reform’s chances of being enacted into law:

In a properly functioning Washington, the tax reform plan unveiled Wednesday by House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Dave Camp (R-Mich.) would kick off a major debate over how to fix the federal government’s inefficient system of revenue collection. Mr. Camp proposes to overhaul both the corporate and individual tax codes, based on the principle that lower rates should be applied to a broader base of income — that is, one that is purged of many loopholes and deductions that litter current law.

[…]

In the actual Washington, alas, Mr. Camp’s proposal has basically no chance of passage, or even of being acted upon this year. Much of the blame for that belongs with the leaders of his party, who smell victory in the November elections and don’t want to do anything controversial — such as committing themselves to an actual positive agenda — that might put that prospect at risk. Instead of praising their fellow Republican’s plan, House Speaker John A. Boehner (Ohio) and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) threw cold water on it.

10 comments

The Political Theater of the IRS Scandal

I have a question about the politics of the ongoing, interminable unfolding of the IRS scandal, based upon comments in this post. I think it’s obvious why the House Republicans aren’t giving Lois Lerner immunity in exchange for her testimony. It keeps the ball up in the air, she remains prosecutable for any crimes she may have committed, and they can always give her immunity later if it’s useful.

What’s not so clear to me is why the Senate Democrats aren’t eager to grant her immunity in exchange for her complete testimony. If there’s nothing there, wouldn’t think they would?

12 comments

Currency Manipulation Is Not Free Trade

I didn’t want to let this paper by Robert E. Scott from the progressive Economic Policy Institute go by without comment. I’ve made no secret of my belief many of the United State’s economic woes can be dated to China’s effectgively pegging the yuan to the dollar in the early 1990s and Dr. Scott’s article documents the costs that the actions of China and other countries that have engaged in currency manipulation have had on us. As he points out the currency manipulation practice not only by China but by Denmark, Hong Kong, South Korea, Malaysia, Singapore, Switzerland, Taiwan, and Japan have increased our trade deficit beyond what it would otherwise have been and cost us a significant number of manufacturing jobs:

Overall, reducing U.S. goods trade deficits would create between 891,500 and 2,337,300 jobs in manufacturing (38.8 percent to 40.3 percent of jobs gained across industries), representing the largest jobs gain of any major industry. Within manufacturing, the largest gains would occur in durable goods, specifically “machinery, except electrical,” with 170,500 to 353,900 jobs gained (respectively, 7.4 percent and 6.1 percent of total jobs gained). Jobs gained in non-electrical machinery would increase total employment by 14.4 percent to 29.8 percent in that sector. Other manufacturing industries with large gains would include transportation equipment (164,100 to 352,400 jobs), computer and electronic parts (127,600 to 338,000 jobs), fabricated metal products (104,200 jobs to 251,800 jobs), and miscellaneous manufactured commodities (99,400 to 243,300 jobs).

Major job winners outside of manufacturing include agriculture, forestry, and fisheries (246,800 to 486,100 jobs); health care and social assistance (167,900 to 430,600 jobs); administrative and support industries (166,700 to 413,900 jobs); professional, scientific, and technical services (140,300 to 357,100 jobs); and accommodation and food services (142,500 to 358,600 jobs).

It could be retorted that the out-sized purchases of dollars by various other countries is the price that the U. S. pays for the dollar being the world’s reserve currency. That could well be true but

  1. All of the countries listed above with the possible exception of Switzerland (the Swiss have a tendency not to be participants in international accords) have engaged in trade in dollars in violation of commitments they’ve made.
  2. It’s not enough to point out that the dollar is the reserve currency. Critics of the analysis have an obligation to quantify the net costs to us incurred by the dollar being a reserve currency and IMO the individuals and companies that benefit from that should be taxed by that amount and the proceeds used to support wage subsidies, apprenticeship programs, and other policies that would foster job creation here.
6 comments

Sometimes a Dot…

is just a dot. Bradley Smith produces a timeline of political and IRS activities that looks highly suspicious and demands that the media “connect the dots”. To my mind there’s little doubt that politicians have been putting pressure on the IRS to act against their political opponents that is, to say the least, unseemly. Unless you believe that intent can be inferred from the actions that’s still not enough for the IRS scandal to catch fire.

2 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

AFSA Reviews Obama Appointments

For the first time in its history the American Foreign Service Association, the professional organization for foreign service professionals, is considering a protest of a president’s ambassadorial appointments. The minimum requirements for political appointments have changed over time and it may be time for ambassadorial appointments to receive more scrutiny.

19 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Will Rogers On Congress

My little jokes never hurt anyone, but when Congress makes a joke, it’s a law

And kid Congress and the Senate, don’t scold ’em. They are just children thats never grown up. They don’t like to be corrected in company. Don’t send messages to ’em, send candy. (advice to Roosevelt)

This country has come to feel the same when Congress is in session as when the baby gets hold of a hammer.

The rest of the people know the condition of the country, for they live in it, but Congress has no idea what is going on in America, so the President has to tell ’em.

But with Congress — every time they make a joke it’s a law. And every time they make a law it’s a joke.

The difference between death and taxes is that death doesn’t get worse when Congress meets. (attributed)

3 comments

The Op-Ed Style That Won’t Go Away

I really wish that op-eds whose titles are questions would at least make a stab at answering the questions in those titles. Take the example of Thomas Edsall’s recent New York times column, “Why the IRS Scandal Won’t Go Away”. After reading it I came away disappointed. Unless you’re convinced that the only reasons the scandal won’t go away are Karl Rove and the Koch brothers, it doesn’t even try to address the question.

I think the reasons the scandal won’t go away are that

  1. It’s a legitimate scandal.
  2. The House has a legitimate oversight responsibility.
  3. IRS officials have lied, misled, and stonewalled House committees.
  4. The lying, misleading, and stonewalling keep the ball up in the air.
  5. The draft rules proposed by the IRS to remedy the abuses have been deemed even worse than the rules under which they have been operating by just about everybody. At least they’re bringing people together. The ACLU, Heritage Foundation, and Sierra Club all hate the new rules.

Does the scandal reach as far as the White House? Frankly, I doubt it but who knows? As the late Dan Rostenkowski used to say “Never take a bribe. Just hand ’em your business card.” Clear directions and a smoking gun aren’t necessary to make something an abuse of power and, consequently, a scandal. Departments of the federal government should not be, as one editorial put it, “weaponized” as attack vehicles deployed against the administration’s political opponents.

Now maybe Mr. Edsall never intended to answer that question in his column. Maybe the title was supplied by an editor. If that’s the case, it’s pretty lousy editing.

17 comments

The Poor, Abused Robber Barons

In his recent column castigating “net neutrality”, the idea that all content should be treated equally by Internet service providers, nowhere does Holman Jenkins mention that the cable and telephone companies that control the “last mile”, the ultimate delivery of Internet service to end users, achieved their privileged positions by being monopolies. Not natural monopolies. Government-granted monopolies. I see net neutrality as a means of leveling the playing field between companies that used their monopoly power to charge exorbitant rates for mediocre service, slowing the pace of inovation, and upstarts. He sees it as upstarts exploiting FCC rules to steal cable companies’ core TV customers.

As I’ve said before I’d like the cable companies to be treated as common carriers and the law of common carriers is well-developed. But I’d be satisfied with transparency, allowing customers to pay for bandwidth, and giving them the ability to select the bandwidth they need in advance.

3 comments