The Stupidest Advice

Jimmy Carter’s national security advisor, Zbigniew Brzezinski takes to the opinion pages of the Washington Post urging action on President Obama in response to the situation in Ukraine:

If Ukraine is crushed while the West is simply watching, the new freedom and security in bordering Romania, Poland and the three Baltic republics would also be threatened.

This does not mean that the West, or the United States, should threaten war. But in the first instance, Russia’s unilateral and menacing acts mean the West should promptly recognize the current government of Ukraine as legitimate. Uncertainty regarding its legal status could tempt Putin to repeat his Crimean charade. Second, the West should convey — privately at this stage, so as not to humiliate Russia — that the Ukrainian army can count on immediate and direct Western aid so as to enhance its defensive capabilities. There should be no doubt left in Putin’s mind that an attack on Ukraine would precipitate a prolonged and costly engagement, and Ukrainians should not fear that they would be left in the lurch.

Meanwhile, NATO forces, consistent with the organization’s contingency planning, should be put on alert. High readiness for some immediate airlift to Europe of U.S. airborne units would be politically and militarily meaningful. If the West wants to avoid a conflict, there should be no ambiguity in the Kremlin as to what might be preciptated by further adventurist use of force in the middle of Europe.

Keep in mind that Dr. Brzezinski has been wrong about practically every major foreign policy issue over the period of the last 35 years. I’ve made no secret of my lack of regard for his advice see here and here. I believe that his advice in this op-ed is flawed as well.

Ukraine’s situation is distinctive, different from that of Poland, Romania, Lithuania, Estonia, or Latvia. It was part of Tsarist Russia, it was a republic of the Soviet Union, it is predominantly Slavic, and Russia’s strategic posture demands secure access to Black Sea ports. Is there any real evidence that Poland will be threatened—not feel threatened but be threatened—by Russia? Poland is a member of NATO, as are the other countries mentioned. Ukraine is not a NATO member. Once again, Dr. Brzezinski is asking the U. S. to provide the same assurances to non-NATO members as it does to members without producing a conceptual framework for doing so.

And what would you do if you were Vladimir Putin and NATO forces were put on alert? Would you consider it provocative? I certainly would. Rather than defusing the situation it would be an escalation of it.

I honestly don’t know why the man continues to have access to the editorial pages of major newspapers.

42 comments

Mussel Bound

Thirty years ago zebra mussels, a European native species, were introduced into the Great Lakes. These illegal aliens are believed to have arrived in the ballast water of ocean-going ships that entered the Lakes through the St. Lawrence Seaway. They form great clumps, eat the indigenous phytoplankton, and have generally been an environmental catastrophe. A clever biologist believes he has found a way to attack them safely. Safe for everything but the zebra mussels, that is:

Now the mussels may have met their match: Daniel P. Molloy, an emeritus biologist at the New York State Museum in Albany and a self-described “Bronx boy who became fascinated by things living in water.”

Inspired by Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” in high school, Dr. Molloy, now 66, has long been a pioneer in the development of environmentally safe control agents to replace broad-spectrum chemical pesticides.

Leading a team at the museum’s Cambridge Field Research Laboratory in upstate New York, he discovered a bacterium, Pseudomonas fluorescens strain CL145A, that kills the mussels but appears to have little or no effect on other organisms.

Although I would rejoice at an effective way to combat the zebra mussels that have wreaked havoc on fishing in the Great Lakes, I’ve got to admit to a healthy skepticism about the strategy that’s being described. I think the same thing was said about releasing rabbits in Australia and then about releasing the succession of viruses that have been tried to reduce the rabbit population. Over time the population of genetically resistant rabbits grows and the merry-go-round takes another spin.

4 comments

The Continuing Adventures of an Insurance Company With an Army

Jeffrey Dorfman observes that barring some transcendent conversion experience large federal deficits are here to stay:

Defense spending is up by $232 billion above inflation and population growth, representing about 22 percent of the inflation and population-adjusted spending increase. Obviously, we have the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan to thank for some of this, but those wars are winding down now. Secretary Hagel is proposing spending cuts to stay within the sequester-proposed spending limits. If Republicans are serious about reducing government spending, they probably need to find some defense cuts that they can live with.

Spending on social safety net programs-Medicaid, unemployment benefits, housing subsidies, food assistance, and another seventy-plus programs the federal government runs-has increased a total of $294 billion beyond inflation and population growth, accounting for 28 percent of the extra spending growth. Certainly some of this is related to the 2007-2009 recession and to the increased cost of health care, but the recession ended 56 months ago so it seems somewhat specious to blame these costs on economic conditions five and one-half years ago. Rather, it seems likely that the Obama administrations persistent and extremely active efforts to sign more people up for all these government benefits is a significant contributing factor to the explosion in this spending category.

Finally, we get to the government benefit programs for the elderly. Spending on Social Security and Medicare has risen by $415 billion above and beyond if it had grown at the rate of inflation plus population growth. Partly this is due, to the number of elderly growing at a faster percentage than the overall population and partly it is due to President Bush’s Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage program. Regardless of the causes, spending to benefit the elderly accounts for 39 percent of our above-inflation-and-population-growth spending increase.

There is no ready alternative to any of those programs, there is no will on the part of either major political party to cut any of those programs enough to make a difference, and there’s even less will to raise taxes enough to pay for them. Hence, his conclusion: mammoth federal budget deficits are here for the foreseeable future.

That’s all well and good for the federal government which is a monetary sovereign and can credit itself with the money to finance its deficits with a wave of an electronic wand. The situation is different for state and local governments. Their budgets will be pressed by the poor and elderly as well and they’re already about at their credit limit. Illinois, for example, has raised its taxes substantially, still has a fiscal nightmare on its hands, and has the worst credit rating among the states. Additionally, in the low trust environment we’ve been entering even more law enforcement, something traditionally left to state and local governments, will be required. Their problems are likely to become worse rather than better.

That brings up something I’m surprised isn’t more obvious to people. An aggressive regulatory state inherently produces greater income inequality. The rich will always get preferential treatment and they’ll inevitably use it to become even richer. That’s an alternative not open to the rest of us.

3 comments

Building On Sand

The editors of the New York Times have finally recognized that the economic policies of the last three administrations, founded as they were on increased higher education as the key to economic security, have been built on sand:

Research by three economists — Paul Beaudry, David Green and Benjamin Sand — goes beyond familiar explanations for wage stagnation like global competition and labor-saving technology. Examining the demand for college-educated workers, they found that businesses increased hiring of college graduates in the 1980s and 1990s in adapting to technological changes. But as the information technology revolution matured, employer demand waned for the “cognitive skills” associated with a college education.

As a result, since 2000, many college graduates have taken jobs that do not require college degrees and, in the process, have displaced less-educated lower-skilled workers. “In this maturity stage,” the report says, “having a B.A. is less about obtaining access to high paying managerial and technology jobs and more about beating out less-educated workers for the barista or clerical job.”

The problem with that as a strategy is that the cost of higher education and the way we finance higher education have burdened the new college grads, employed in jobs that don’t actually require college educations and paid commensurately, with high levels of debt which reduces their spending on other things, further slowing the economy. I have some difficuly, however, relating their prescription to their diagnosis:

Increasing the number of high-paying jobs also depends on strategies like enhancing public spending to fix roads and bridges and to hire more teachers, as well as developing new energy and technology industries through government-financed research. Otherwise, the norm may very well be an economy where even college-educated workers cannot thrive.

I, on the other hand, think that fixing roads and building bridges primarily produces jobs that don’t require college educations and hiring more teachers? Please. We’re back to the story of the cat and rat farm.

Mort Zuckerman on the other hand sees things a little differently:

Job losses in the low-wage and minimum-wage category is the critical issue of our day: Too many of the poor are not working full time or at all. Income inequality isn’t so much the problem as income inadequacy. A more robust economy, stoked by growth-oriented policies from Washington, would help produce the jobs and opportunities that millions of Americans need to climb the economic ladder.

A landmark new study by Harvard economics professor Raj Chetty asserts that advances in opportunity provided by expanded social programs have been offset by increased global trade and advanced technology that in turn have limited the traditional sources of middle-income jobs. But there is a simpler reason that the country remains mired in the weakest recovery from a recession since World War II: Government has diminished animal spirits by displaying a hostile attitude toward business.

That attitude is evident in everything from excessive corporate taxes to the incompetence and dishonesty of the ObamaCare rollout. Government is perpetually establishing economic policies and rules that business perceives as overregulation, dampening the willingness to invest—as witnessed by the slowest rate of capital investment in decades on corporate plant equipment and machinery.

but his solution, too, is more education.

I think the solution is more economic activity and that the problem with the present administration’s economic policy is not a “hostile attitude toward business” but a systematic preference for policies that don’t increase economic activity. That includes everything from energy policy to trade policy to tax policy to healthcare policy. It’s not that the administration is opposed to more economic activity but that they want other things more.

7 comments

Don’t Just Do Something

I’ve already mentioned the Washington Post’s scathing editorial against the Obama Administration’s reactions to the situation unfolding in Ukraine. Now the editors of the Wall Street Journal come out in a similar vein, albeit with more specific recommendations. They suggest restricting Russian banks’ access to the international banking system (something the Europeans will all but certainly oppose) and moving ships into the Black Sea:

Mr. Obama and the West must act, rather than merely threaten, because it’s clear Mr. Putin believes the American President’s words can’t be taken seriously. After the 2008 invasion of Georgia, President Obama pretended the problem was Dick Cheney and tried to “reset” relations with Moscow. Mr. Putin has defied the civilized world on Syria and Mr. Obama rewarded him by making Russia a partner in phony peace talks. Mr. Putin gave NSA leaker Edward Snowden asylum over U.S. objections, and he got away with that too.

I think that’s almost exactly the wrong advice. Moving ships into the Black Sea would be seen as a provocation and would maximize the likelihood of an unfortunate incident. I would prefer that the president not even threaten since there’s little in the way of an effective response that he can make and idle threats are worse than silence.

Here are some things to chew on while thinking about the escalating crisis in Ukraine:

  1. Russia has legitimate interests in Ukraine in the form of military and commercial ports, historical ties, millions of ethnic Russians in eastern Ukraine, and millions of ethnic Ukrainians who speak Russian as their first language.
  2. Russia has legitimate concerns based on the actions of the nationalist Ukrainian parliament and the mobs in the streets.
  3. Russia will accept friendly countries on its border or “satrapies” as they’re being called and will tolerate neutral countries that convince the Russians they’re not a threat cf. the history of Finland but it will not accept hostile countries on its border, particularly among the old Soviet republics.
  4. Our material interests in Ukraine are not nearly as compelling.
36 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

A Harsh Editorial on the President’s Foreign Policy

The editors of the Washington Post published an editorial highly critical of the president’s foreign policy, generally, and his response to the situation in Ukraine in particular. What’s less clear: what he should do differently or why.

14 comments

Watching the Academy Awards, 2014

My wife and I are watching the Academy Awards this evening. We’ll probably just watch the first hour or so.

They don’t seem to be cutting off the acceptance speeches quite as ruthlessly as they have the last few years. Any bets on how long the Award ceremony will last? At this rate they’ll go ’til 1:00am.

0 comments

Firm Steps and Missteps

As an example of why I’m concerned about the reactions of official Washington to the situation in Ukraine, consider this press release from Secretary of State John Kerry:

The United States condemns the Russian Federation’s invasion and occupation of Ukrainian territory, and its violation of Ukrainian sovereignty and territorial integrity in full contravention of Russia’s obligations under the UN Charter, the Helsinki Final Act, its 1997 military basing agreement with Ukraine, and the 1994 Budapest Memorandum. This action is a threat to the peace and security of Ukraine, and the wider region.

I spoke with President Turchynov this morning to assure him he had the strong support of the United States and commend the new government for showing the utmost restraint in the face of the clear and present danger to the integrity of their state, and the assaults on their sovereignty. We also urge that the Government of Ukraine continue to make clear, as it has from throughout this crisis, its commitment to protect the rights of all Ukrainians and uphold its international obligations.

As President Obama has said, we call for Russia to withdraw its forces back to bases, refrain from interference elsewhere in Ukraine, and support international mediation to address any legitimate issues regarding the protection of minority rights or security.

From day one, we’ve made clear that we recognize and respect Russia’s ties to Ukraine and its concerns about treatment of ethnic Russians. But these concerns can and must be addressed in a way that does not violate Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, by directly engaging the Government of Ukraine.

Unless immediate and concrete steps are taken by Russia to deescalate tensions, the effect on U.S.-Russian relations and on Russia’s international standing will be profound.
I convened a call this afternoon with my counterparts from around the world, to coordinate on next steps. We were unified in our assessment and will work closely together to support Ukraine and its people at this historic hour.

In the coming days, emergency consultations will commence in the UN Security Council, the North Atlantic Council, and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe in defense of the underlying principles critical to the maintenance of international peace and security. We continue to believe in the importance of an international presence from the UN or OSCE to gather facts, monitor for violations or abuses and help protect rights. As a leading member of both organizations, Russia can actively participate and make sure its interests are taken into account.

The people of Ukraine want nothing more than the right to define their own future – peacefully, politically and in stability. They must have the international community’s full support at this vital moment. The United States stands with them, as we have for 22 years, in seeing their rights restored.

The first paragraph:

The United States condemns the Russian Federation’s invasion and occupation of Ukrainian territory, and its violation of Ukrainian sovereignty and territorial integrity in full contravention of Russia’s obligations under the UN Charter, the Helsinki Final Act, its 1997 military basing agreement with Ukraine, and the 1994 Budapest Memorandum. This action is a threat to the peace and security of Ukraine, and the wider region.

is fine. It says what’s needed to be said and, if that were the complete statement, in my view it would be enough. Sadly, it does not. The conclusion:

The people of Ukraine want nothing more than the right to define their own future – peacefully, politically and in stability. They must have the international community’s full support at this vital moment. The United States stands with them, as we have for 22 years, in seeing their rights restored.

We may not see it that way but I believe that from the point-of-view of the Russians it’s both provocative and offensive. Sec. Kerry is speaking on behalf of the Ukrainian people here and his characterization does not appear to comport with the facts of the case or, at the very least, with the facts of the case as they are known to the Russians. From their point-of-view the fairly and democratically-elected president of Ukraine has been ousted by an armed mob. He was not removed according to Ukrainian law or even by an action of a majority of Ukrainians.

There are other quibbles I could make about the statement. For example, I don’t think that Sec. Kerry is a particularly good spokesman to condemn violation of international law or national sovereignty. I have a vague recollection that as a senator he voted in favor of the Authorization to Use Military Force that empowered President Bush to invade Iraq, a country far from our borders and one in which we have national interests far less than Russia has in Ukraine. As my old business partner once put it, I may agree with what you say but I will condemn to the death your right to say it. But, as I say, that’s a quibble.

My point here is not that we should say nothing. It is that we should be careful in what we say.

25 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB (Updated)

I’ve just published a couple of foreign policy-related posts at Outside the Beltway:

The Russian People Demand Intervention in Ukraine

The Russian people just aren’t getting the same story on what’s going on in Ukraine as we are.

Update

The Ukrainian Demonstrations

In this post I take notice of a post at the New York Review of Books on the Ukrainian demonstrations. Although I think that the Russians’ view of the goings-on is largely based on propaganda, I think that our view probably is, too.

1 comment

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

The Ukraine Crisis in Three Maps

Looking at a few maps is a pretty good way to get some quick understanding of the situation in Ukraine. The very name of the country means, roughly, “the border”, and you can guess whose border is meant. The situation is a lot more complicated than some of the commentary might lead you to believe.

32 comments