Putting the Ship of State in Dry Dock

As the due date for federal personal income taxes approaches, taxes seem to be very much on many people’s minds today. Not the least of those is the chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee who takes to the pages of the Wall Street Journal to pitch the tax reform his committee has come up with:

Last year, my Democratic counterpart on the Ways and Means Committee, Sandy Levin of Michigan, and I created 11 bipartisan working groups to tackle different parts of the tax code. One of those, headed by Diane Black (R., Tenn.) and Danny Davis (D., Ill.), looked into those education provisions. After months of work, the leaders of the working group recently came forward with a plan that consolidates four of these provisions into one improved credit, making it easier for families and students to afford a college education.

Paired with more commonsense reforms like increasing the standard deduction and the child tax credit will mean that nearly 95% of the country can get the lowest possible tax rate by just filing the basic IRS 1040A form—no more itemizing, no more keeping track of all those receipts, and no more filling out all those extra schedules, forms and work sheets.

Second, the tax code will be made more effective and efficient by getting rid of special-interest handouts, which will mean lower tax rates for individuals, families and all businesses. Under this plan, over 99% of tax filers will face a top tax rate of 25%—allowing small and large businesses alike to expand operations, hire new workers and increase benefits and take home pay. On the individual side, there will be an introductory bracket of 10%.

[…]

Third, make the tax code fairer and more accountable. That means no more hidden provisions that benefit a favored few, and no more tax increases to fuel more spending.

Most Americans aren’t aware of it but the chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee is one of the most powerful people in the country, second or third most powerful in the House by most accounts. Remember Tommy Lee Jones’s portrayal of Thaddeus Stevens in Lincoln? Stevens was chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee. It used to be that the majority leader and chairman of W&M were synonymous. The committee has its finger in almost every pie, determining what the House will or won’t do. The Speaker decides what will come to the floor. The chairman of Ways and Means determines its contours.

Tax reform isn’t just a discussion about the minutiae of tax rates. It’s an argument about the nature of the country. Historically, we’ve had major tax reform roughly once every twenty years. The last such reform was 30 years ago—we’re overdue.

Tax law doesn’t stand still between major reform. It’s changed so frequently it’s impossible for anyone to really understand it. It gathers accretions like a ship gathers barnacles and, like barnacles, the accretions impede progress. Postponing major tax reform is a statement itself. It says that wealthy and powerful interests will have increasing power in the country.

8 comments

Watching Ghostbusters

for the first time:

So how does Ghostbusters hold up for someone who not only hasn’t seen it but was also born six years after its original release? Apparently, really goddamn well.

Some interesting observations. For example, it’s not particularly topical which means that it holds up well over time.

2 comments

Great Ideas in Marketing

Girl Scouts in Colorado are not allowed to sell cookies in front of marijuana dispensaries:

Danielle Lei, an enterprising Girl Scout, sold more than 100 boxes of cookies in just two hours outside of a San Francisco medical marijuana dispensary last week. But the Girl Scouts of Colorado leadership is killing the buzz for local members, saying that Colorado scouts cannot likewise sell cookies in front of pot shops, despite recreational marijuana being legal in the state.

“Our position is really pretty simple,” Rachelle Trujillo, chief marketing officer for the Girl Scouts of Colorado, told The Huffington Post. “For years in our council, we’ve said it’s not appropriate for Girl Scouts to sell cookies outside of adult-oriented businesses, and marijuana dispensaries fall right in line with this policy. There’s a place for everything, and just like a liquor store or a gun show, a marijuana dispensary isn’t a place for young girls to be selling cookies. There are plenty of other options for customers of adult businesses to purchase cookies at other locations.”

A post on the official GSCO Facebook page noted Friday that cookie sales also aren’t allowed outside of bars, strip clubs or casinos.

There’s another great idea shot down.

2 comments

Congress Doesn’t Share Our Interests

I found the graph above from the Gallup organization (hat tip: The American Interest) on Americans’ priorities on various public policy issues very interesting. Perhaps a little explanation is in order. The graph is divided two ways: left to right and top to bottom. The farther something is to the right in the graph the more important people think it is. The farther down something is in the graph the more satisified people are with things as they are. Consequently, people are pretty satisifed and/or disinterested in issues in the lower left hand corner and dissatisfied and/or interested in issues in the upper right hand corner.

The issue about which people are most dissatisfied and think is the highest priority is the economy. The issues that people think aren’t particularly important and/or are satisfied with aren’t quite as clear-cut: those are either the “acceptance of gays and lesbians” or “race relations” depending on whether you give more weight to dissatisfaction or priority. However, both of those issues plus abortion, environment, and energy policy are in the low dissatisfaction/low priority quadrant while poverty and homelessness, public education, federal taxes, affordable healthcare, and Social Security and Medicare round out the high dissatisfaction/high priority quadrant.

Note that the bulk of government spending is pretty well represented in the high dissatisfaction/high priority quadrant. “Military”, interestingly, is in the high priority/low dissatisfaction quadrant which I would interpret as a belief that the issue is being handled about right.

I think there are confounding factors in this kind of analysis. Some people are highly interested in issues that most people aren’t particularly interested in one way or another. It seems to me that could skew the results. Additionally, are priority and satisfaction really independent variables? I would think that the less satisfied one is with something would grant priority to an issue it might otherwise not have. Finally, my observation is that some people need permission before they feel comfortable about expressing dissatisfaction or interest in an issue. For those people leaders have a profound influence and that’s why public opinion can sometimes turn on a dime.

I’m not sure how I’d respond if I had to select from among the issues in Gallup’s list. I think I’d rate the economy as the highest issue with which I’m the least satisfied followed by affordable healthcare, world affairs, immigration, and energy policy. However, I tend to see many of the issues as interconnected, e.g. I think that an improved economy would go a long way to fixing the problems with issues I’d prioritize other than, perhaps, affordable healthcare. So, for example, I think improving the economy and getting some control over immigration would go a long way to improving race relations or, at least, bring our issues with race relations into sharper relief. I also think that a more energy-friendly energy policy would go a long way towards improving our economy.

16 comments

Harold Ramis, 1944-2014

Harold Ramis the actor, writer, and director who wrote some of the funniest comedies of the last thirty years including Animal House, Ghostbusters, Groundhog Day, and Analyze This has died:

Harold Ramis was one of Hollywood’s most successful comedy filmmakers when he moved his family from Los Angeles back to the Chicago area in 1996. His career was still thriving, with “Groundhog Day” acquiring almost instant classic status upon its 1993 release and 1984’s “Ghostbusters” ranking among the highest-grossing comedies of all time, but the writer-director wanted to return to the city where he’d launched his career as a Second City performer.

“There’s a pride in what I do that other people share because I’m local, which in L.A. is meaningless; no one’s local,” Ramis said upon the launch of the first movie he directed after his move, the 1999 mobster-in-therapy comedy “Analyze This,” another hit. “It’s a good thing. I feel like I represent the city in a certain way.”

Ramis, a longtime North Shore resident, was surrounded by family when he died at 12:53 a.m. from complications of autoimmune inflammatory vasculitis, a rare disease that involves swelling of the blood vessels, his wife Erica Mann Ramis said. He was 69.

His pictures had some of the glorious silliness and anarchy of the Marx Brothers, clearly an influence on his work.

Today the world is less funny than it used to be.

4 comments

The 21st Century Robber Barons

The term “robber baron” was coined to describe medieval German nobles who extracted tolls, tariffs, and tithes from passing traffic on the river Rhine. You can still see their castles, built close to the banks, looming over the river. It was later used to describe rapacious industrialists who lined their pockets without adding much value to the detriment of the common good. We have them today, too.

It’s being reported that Netflix has agreed to pay Comcast for access to its network:

Netflix Inc. has agreed to pay Comcast Corp. to ensure Netflix movies and television shows stream smoothly to Comcast customers, a landmark pact that could set a precedent for Netflix’s dealings with other broadband providers, people familiar with the matter said.

In exchange for payment, Netflix will get direct access to Comcast’s broadband network.

The deal comes just 10 days after Comcast agreed to buy Time Warner Cable Inc. The acquisition, if approved, would establish Comcast as by far the dominant provider of broadband in the U.S., serving 32 million households before any divestitures it might make. It also comes amid growing signs that congestion deep in the Internet is causing interruptions for customers trying to stream Netflix movies and TV shows.

or, said another way, the robber baron is now extracting tolls from passing traders. That’s certainly a better outcome than Comcast’s just silently strangling Netflix and, until and unless Congress acts to counteract the Court’s recent rulings or the FCC figures out a way to re-write its regulations to fit within its Congressionally-delegated powers it’s probably the wave of the future.

Comcast didn’t develop the Internet and if it had tried on its own it would have flopped, as so many proprietary networks did. It doesn’t own the Internet but it’s profiting mightily from it. Its power should be limited to the “last mile” and all traffic on the Internet should be treated equally, consistent with the law of common carriers.

18 comments

The Slavic Languages

Just a little side note about the Slavic languages. The Slavic languages, which include Russian, Polish, Ukrainian, Serbo-Croatian, Macedonian, Czech, and Slovak, just to name a few are divided into three subgroups: the East Slavic languages (e.g. Russian), the West Slavic languages (e.g. Czech), and the South Slavic languages (e.g. Serbo-Croatian).

A millennium ago there was probably only one Slavic language. The story you generally hear is that the Tatar invasion isolated the Slavs from one another, allowing their languages to diverge.

Distinguishing between language and dialect is a fractious subject, governed as much by politics and tradition as linguistics and, since national boundaries have changed frequently, a subject for debate. The differences between Serbian and Croatian is mostly that Serbian is written in Cyrillic and Croatian is written in Roman letters and they have slightly different borrow words. Bosnian adds more Turkish and Arabic borrow words.

In general, the Slavic languages are pretty close to one another—closer than the Romance languages are to each other. One wisecrack I’ve heard that I liked was that the speakers of the various Slavic languages understand one another they just pretend not to.

0 comments

Partitioning Ukraine

In a comment on the situation in Ukraine I said:

The EU is repeating the mistakes it made in Yugoslavia and it’s getting the same results.

Apparantly, that’s not limited to the EU. David Goldman, AKA “Spengler”, calls for partition of Ukraine:

I’ve argued for years that partition is the best solution for Ukraine, which never was a country but an almalgam of provinces left over from failed empires–Russian, Austrian, Lithuanian, Ottoman–cobbled together into a Soviet “republic” and cast adrift after the collapse of Communism. Lviv (Lemberg) was a German-speaking city, part of Silesia; before World War II a quarter of its people were Jews. Jews were two-fifths of the population of Odessa.

A fifth of the population, mainly in the East, are ethnic Russians; a tenth, mainly in the West, are Uniate Catholics, who have a special place in Catholic policy since the papacy of John Paul II. Ukrainian nationality is as dubious as Byelorussian nationality: neither of them had a dictionary of their language until 1918.

The Ukrainians would probably dispute his assertion. The Princedom of Kiev was a major power from the 9th century through the 14th century. However, does a country not protected from its neighbors by natural boundaries, constisting of multiple ethnicities, some in the same ethnicity speaking different languages, some Orthodox, some Catholic ring any bells?

He concludes:

Russia never will permit the integration of Ukraine into NATO; were it to come to that, Russia would use force, and the West would stand by cursing. But Russia will settle for half a loaf, namely a Russian-allied Eastern Ukraine. Whatever we do, Ukraine will continue its slow, sad slide into oblivion. The diplomats have the dour duty of managing this decline with the minimum of friction.

The first sentence is quite correct. I’m skeptical of the second sentence but, unfortunately, Mr. Goldman produces no evidence in support of his opinion.

I think that quite to the contrary, Russia will not allow a former Soviet republic to join NATO or the EU except under the circumstance of Russia itself joining the EU. As evidence just take a glance at any Russian language newspaper. They’re full of saber-rattling and assertions that Putin is only waiting for an invitation to send Russian troops in to take control of the situation. The only part of that I doubt is that he’s waiting for an invitation.

The entire situation is being painted very differently in the Russian press than it is here or in Europe. Here there’s a major emphasis on human rights. In the Russian press the emphasis is on stability with a side emphasis on the Nazi past of Ukrainian rightwing nationalists. They think the EU’s views are entirely predicated on gas and oil and I think they’re right.

41 comments

Headline

The following headline at The Week caught my eye:

“How do you weaponize a rabbit?”

Now, anyone who knows much about rabbits—I mean actual rabbits rather than their popular image—knows that’s a silly question. They already come pre-weaponized.

The article itself is about using rabbits as a delivery system for tularemia as a weapon of war and is mildly interesting.

5 comments

What Could Possibly Go Wrong?


I don’t know if you find the graph above as concerning as I do. It illustrates the growth of U. S. bank assets and Chinese bank assets from 2008 to the present. Here’s a slightly longer timeframe to put the increase in U. S. bank assets over time into a little bit better perspective:

ZeroHedge quotes the Bank of America:

We posit that this large rise was in part driven by the carry trade offered up by QE – China banks and corporates issued substantial forex-denominated bonds, and borrowed straight loans from international banks. We recognize the caveat that correlation does not imply causation. The USD655bn rise in China debt issuance is highly correlated to the Fed’s balance sheet since late-2008. As Chart 11 shows, the rise in China debt issuance of USD 655bn has (along with FDI and the C/A surplus), boosted international reserves by USD1,773bn since late-2008. Also, as Chart 11 shows, the USD1,773bn rise in China international reserves mirrors the rise of USD2,585bn in the EM monetary base. Lastly, the rise of China’s monetary base of USD2,585bn correlates well with the USD10.9tr rise in China’s broad money expansion.

Considering the very large proportion of non-productive loans believed to be on the books and the notorious opacity of Chinese banks it will be interesting to see how this unfolds.

3 comments