Could BNH Be Created Now?

In an op-ed in the New York Times economist Victor R. Fuchs offers a suggestion for trimming U. S. healthcare spending which, despite the fact that I agree it, I think is impossible:

The excess in the United States is primarily attributable to a more expensive mix of procedures and services, higher prices paid to drug companies and physicians, and inefficiencies in the financing of health care. There are undoubtedly cultural differences between the United States and other countries, but it is also true that Swedes differ from Italians, Germans from French, and the English from all of the above.

What these countries have in common that distinguishes their health care systems from the American is universal insurance for basic care, a larger share of government in financing health care (typically about 75 percent of the total versus 50 percent in the United States), and more aggressive control of expenditures.

It reminds me of one of my favorite Yiddish wisecracks: if my grandmother had balls she’d be my grandfather.

Rather than return to something we’ve argued about around here, perhaps, fifty times over the last 10 years, I want to turn the question on its ear: would the British have created the British National Health system under the conditions that prevail in Britain and in healthcare today? I do not believe they would.

We have the additional problems that we have not historically been willing to limit government medical programs to “basic care” or control expenditures aggressively, viz. the annual postponing of cost control referred to as the “doc fix”.

2 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

The Ukrainian Situation: I Yam What I Yam

This post originally was an evocation of “The Blind Men and the Elephant”. Then I realized there was a much better hook. There are lots of different perspectives on the Ukrainian crisis around today. In this post I discuss Christopher Clark’s historical perspective, Tyler Cowen’s game theoretical analysis, and what we can learn about the situation from Popeye.

2 comments

Keep Smiling

I find this obvious but interesting. Moods spread:

Over one billion status updates were made anonymous, then studied, covering Jan. 2009 through March 2012. The results, published in PLOS ONE, come from over 100 million different users across all major American cities. Exposure to positive posts results in more positive posts, and negative posts work the same way and spread more negative posts. However, positivity is a better contagion, and the more upbeat posts are more likely to spread.

“We wanted to see if emotional changes in one person caused emotional changes in another person and that’s exactly what we found,” said UC San Diego political scientist James Fowler, lead author of the study. He is also a professor of medical genetics and political sciences at UCSD.

They tracked rainfall and watched to see if cloudy days Chicago would affect how Sand Diego friends felt about their day. “When it rains on you, you write more negative posts,” Fowler said, “but it affects your friends too.” There will be a “transmission” or transfer, of those emotions through Facebook as one or two people reading will take on these contagions emotions expressed within the post they read.

The message here is something that is no surprise—moods spread. The Internet facilitates such spread. The Internet vector by which moods are expressed most frequently is Facebook. Consequently, moods expressed on Facebook are likely to be quite influential.

Interestingly, they found that positive moods spread more easily than negative ones so keep smiling!

It also suggests that there is a “spirit of the times” and it’s becoming progressively easier to influence it. Since I know people who, in essence, post on Facebook for a living, I’m sure that their jobs are secure will be a reassurance to them.

1 comment

Science: the 5 Second Rule Is True

Well, I’m glad that’s settled:

Biology students at Aston University in the UK monitored how quickly E.coli and common bacteria spread from surfaces to food such as toast (butter side down, no doubt), pasta and sticky sweets — with time being a significant factor in the transfer of germs.

Food picked up just a few seconds after being dropped is less likely to contain bacteria than if it is left for longer periods of time according to the findings.

The type of flooring the food has been dropped on has an effect, with bacteria least likely to transfer from carpeted surfaces and most likely to transfer from laminate or tiled surfaces to moist foods making contact for more than five-seconds.

“We have found evidence that transfer from indoor flooring surfaces is incredibly poor with carpet actually posing the lowest risk of bacterial transfer onto dropped food,” said Professor Anthony Hilton who headed the study.

It’s better not to drop food at all but if you’re going to drop it the faster you pick it up the safer it is. I’m glad that’s settled. It will be very reassuring to my wife.

I now look forward to a definitive answer on whether the jelly side lands down a majority of the time.

6 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Did the Russians Intercept an American Drone?

Well, this is interesting. A Russian company is claiming that it intercepted an American drone flying over Crimea:

Moscow (AFP) – A United States surveillance drone has been intercepted above the Ukranian region of Crimea, a Russian state arms and technology group said Friday.

“The drone was flying at about 4,000 metres (12,000 feet) and was virtually invisible from the ground. It was possible to break the link with US operators with complex radio-electronic” technology, said Rostec in a statement.

The drone fell “almost intact into the hands of self-defence forces” added Rostec, which said it had manufactured the equipment used to down the aircraft, but did not specify who was operating it.

“Judging by its identification number, UAV MQ-5B belonged to the 66th American Reconnaissance Brigade, based in Bavaria,” Rostec said on its website, which also carried a picture of what it said was the captured drone.

There’s an enormous amount of tantalizing information packed into a two hundred some-odd word news report. American drone over Crimea. Brought down using technology from Russian electronics firm. Brought down intact. And so on.

If true, it has some very troubling implications. Foremost among them is I don’t know how you make a credible complaint about Russians violating Ukrainian sovereignty if you’re violating it yourself.

Update

This is getting even more interesting rapidly. Rostec, the company that produced the equipment that reportedly brought down the drone which it calls “Autobase” has denied the report:

Rostec State Corporation does not confirm the information concerning the facts of use of the “Autobase” technical utility on the Crimea Peninsula, which was published in a number of mass media.

The State Corporation bears responsibility for the quality of its products but is by no means responsible for the relocation and the results of the use of the equipment supplied by the Corporation’s organizations within the framework of contractors’ orders.

characterizing the above as an “official denial”. Never believe anything until it’s been officially denied.

The original article reporting the interception is here. If it’s as interesting as it appears I may produce a translation.

Update 2

The article isn’t interesting enough to translate. There are only two interesting additional tidbits in it. The first is the claim that they’ve observed American unmanned aerial vehicles over the area since the beginning of March. The other is the picture of Autobase:

If it did bring down an American UAV, there’s probably a pretty fair market for the product.

6 comments

The Problem of Commitment

I think that Dana Milbank’s interepretation of the failure of the Millennials to sign up for healthcare insurance in droves as their abandoning Obama’s White House:

Young voters, after playing a big role in the campaign, became little more than an e-mail list for the White House and Obama’s Organizing for Action group. Then came health-care reform. The millennials, very liberal overall, saw Obama’s plan as too timid; they were disillusioned by his failure to fight for the “public option” of government-run health plans.

This cost Obama the young activists he would need to rally enrollment in Obamacare. Polling by the nonpartisan Pew Research Center found that, while the generation looks more favorably on big-government solutions than do older generations, the millennials disapprove of Obamacare in the same proportion as the rest of the population.

is wrong. I think they’re like most of the rest of us. It’s easier to support projects that don’t actually make any demands of us. Which reminds me of a joke that was a favorite of a dear old now-departed friend of mine.

It was Farmer Brown’s birthday. The farm animals were talking about what they would do for him in celebration. The cows suggested that they make him breakfast. The chickens asked “What shall we make?” The cows responded “We were thinking of bacon and eggs.” The pig protested “Hey! You’re convinced but I’m committed!”

Commitment is hard, especially when you have other priorities. Among young people who are too old to be covered under their parents’ insurance plans, are saddled with large education debt not dischargeable in bankruptcy, and are drastically underemployed those priorities include food and shelter.

7 comments

Ten Years

Today marks ten years to the day since my first post on this blog. It wasn’t much. Just putting a message in a bottle. I wrote my first decent post a couple of days later, “It’s not a pretty story”, a character study of a woman I encountered when working as an election judge.

It wasn’t until June of that year that I wrote what I think is still one of my best posts, “Anthems”. It’s a study of my own mood and, possibly, the mood of the country at that time as epitomized by three national anthems, the official one and two that I think of as unofficial anthems. There’s actually the beginnings of a good discussion in the comments of that post.

That was and continues to be one of the enduring purposes of this blog—fostering thoughtful comment. Nowadays this blog has a coterie of commenters who provide comments that are, mostly, civil and considered. Such commentary is becoming rare in the blogosphere which to my ear has become more of a place for people who want to have their opinions affirmed rather than challenged and too frequently respond to challenges with invective rather than discourse. The other day in the comments of one of my posts at Outside the Beltway a commenter lamented that I gave any “bandwidth” as he put it to the opinions of a columnist with whom he (and I) disagree. The answer to that is obvious: if you only air opinions with which you agree, you’re an echo chamber.

One of the posts of which I’m proudest is “Learning from history: the relief and rebuilding of New Orleans”. The post examined the prospects for New Orleans’s recovery through the prism of three historical natural disasters: the Chicago fire, the Galveston flood, and the San Francisco earthquake. In my view and sadly those involved with the rebuilding of New Orleans did not heed the lessons of history and, consequently, New Orleans’s recovery has not been as great as it might have been.

Another post of which I’m proud came a year later: “The influence of immigrants on American political thought”. It’s another historical reflection that considers the long-lasting political impact that the famine Irish and the Scandinavian immigrants of the later 19th century had on American politics along with some speculation about the influence that our latest wave of immigrants might have on our politics.

In the early years of this blog I was more predisposed to long, painstakingly researched, analytical pieces than I am now. I’ve learned those posts are entirely written for my own satisfaction—practically no one reads them. As ideas come to me I’ll probably write such posts in the future but don’t be surprised if they become less common with the passing years—I just don’t have the energy.

My most-read post is a joke: “The four types of dog vomit”. Many people don’t get it and many aren’t in a mood to get it. They’ve gone there looking for help with a vomiting dog. One of these days I should write a serious, follow-up post to that which actually provides some resources for people whose dogs are vomiting.

My next most-read post is a recipe: “How to poach a chicken breast”, a method I learned in a Chinese cooking class I took.

Over the years my blog’s traffic has waxed and waned. Right now it’s in a waning phase. I can’t honestly tell how much of that is due to the audience for my work actually dwindling and how much an illusion due to bots and comment spam once having been treated as legitimate readers that no longer are. 90% of the notional hits I get are either bots or comment spam. I use various methods of blocking or slowing them but the constant battle is very frustrating to me. I’d rather be writing substantive posts than blocking comment spam but it’s part of the cost of blogging these days. I consider comment spam a crime, stealing space and bandwidth that I pay for.

Do I wish my blog had more traffic? Of course I do. Do I want crude and thoughtless readers? Not particularly. All in all I guess I’m satisfied with how things are. I’ve accomplished every goal I set for myself with this blog, albeit at a very small scale.

I intend to continue posting at The Glittering Eye as long as I live which, if family history is any gauge, will be for decades into the future. And I’ll continue to post about what interests me: current events, politics, history, opera, food, dogs, geneaology, and anything else that strikes my fancy. That hasn’t changed since the very earliest days. Recently, I’ve toyed with the idea of starting a second more commercial blog that’s tangentially related to my area of professional expertise. At this point it’s in the research stage.

In closing, I’d like to express my profound gratitude for all of my readers, whether frequent commenters, family, friends, occasional silent visitors, or those who arrive here by accident never to return. Thank you all!

16 comments

Can Atheists Be Moral?

I do not think that a belief in God is necessary for a person to be moral. However, if this survey from Pew Research is to be believed, that puts me and many people in the richest countries in the world in a distinct minority from a global standpoint:

Many people around the world think it is necessary to believe in God to be a moral person, according to surveys in 40 countries by the Pew Research Center. However, this view is more common in poorer countries than in wealthier ones.

In 22 of the 40 countries surveyed, clear majorities say it is necessary to believe in God to be moral and have good values. This position is highly prevalent, if not universal, in Africa and the Middle East. At least three-quarters in all six countries surveyed in Africa say that faith in God is essential to morality. In the Middle East, roughly seven-in-ten or more agree in Egypt, Jordan, Turkey, the Palestinian territories, Tunisia and Lebanon. Across the two regions, only in Israel does a majority think it is not necessary to believe in God to be an upright person.

Many people in Asia and Latin America also link faith and morality. For example, Indonesians, Pakistanis, Filipinos and Malaysians almost unanimously think that belief in God is central to having good values. People in El Salvador, Brazil, Bolivia and Venezuela overwhelmingly agree. However, most Chinese take the opposite position – that it is not necessary to be a believer to be a moral person. And in Latin America, the Chileans and Argentines are divided.

The linked source has lot of interesting charts and graphs.

While I don’t think it’s necessary, I think that whether you believe in God or not it’s very difficult to be a moral person with the level of moral education that most Americans possess. Most of our moral educations are what we learned at our mothers’ knees. If that.

I don’t believe that moral conduct is natural to human beings (the Roman Catholic belief is that it’s natural but our present condition is unnatural) and it requires some work to gain an understanding of right conduct, work that most of us are unwilling to do.

59 comments

Making the Enemies List

For the first time the United States has earned a place on Reporters Without Borders’s “Enemies of the Internet” list:

This is the first time the US has made it onto RSF’s list. While the US government doesn’t censor online content, and pours money into promoting Internet freedom worldwide, the National Security Agency’s unapologetic dragnet surveillance and the government’s treatment of whistleblowers have earned it a spot on the index.

When you get a place on a list that includes Cuba, North Korea, Belarus, and Syria, I think that some reflection is called for. At the very least.

1 comment