Heading for the Nearest Airport

In my experience in life the simplest explanation for something that doesn’t require alien abduction, divine intervention, or a huge conspiracy that would be impossible to keep secret (but somehow is) is frequently the best. Experienced pilot Chris Goodfellow offers an explanation for why the wreckage of Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 should be sought between its last known location and Pulau Langkawi.

Update

Jeff Wise argues against Goodfellow’s theory:

Goodfellow’s theory fails further when one remembers the electronic ping detected by the Inmarsat satellite at 8:11 on the morning of March 8. According to analysis provided by the Malaysian and United States governments, the pings narrowed the location of MH370 at that moment to one of two arcs, one in Central Asia and the other in the southern Indian Ocean. As MH370 flew from its original course toward Langkawi, it was headed toward neither. Without human intervention—which would go against Goodfellow’s theory—it simply could not have reached the position we know it attained at 8:11 a.m.

To make a good theory, Einstein is said to have asserted, “everything should be kept as simple as possible, but no simpler.” Unfortunately, Christopher Goodfellow’s wildly popular theory errs on the side of too much elegance.

3 comments

How Low?

Just as one measure of how low the turnout was in the precinct where I worked, at one point in the day pollwatchers outnumbered voters eight to one.

1 comment

Too Many Conclusions from Too Little Data

I think that the analysts who are drawing conclusions from yesterday’s Illinois primary elections are drawing a pound of conclusions from an ounce of data. Writing at Washington Post Sean Sullivan makes comments about the governor’s race, the conundrum that will face organized labor in the fall, the absence of backlash against the Republican legislators who voted for same-sex marriage, and the yawn in House races in Illinois. Nowhere does he mention the single, critical, inescapable fact of yesterday’s primaries here: the turnout was incredibly low. It was under 10% in the city of Chicago.

I could try to explain the low turnout away any number of ways. It was a primary. It was a mid-term. In the prior three mid-term primaries turnout was 27.3% in 2010, 32.1% in 2006, and 39.8% in 2002. Whatever the reason that’s terribly, depressingly low.

I also think that it’s possible that the number of registered voters has become completely disassociated from the number of people who can be expected to vote in a primary mid-term election.

Many people mocked North Korea’s 100% vote in favor of Kim Jong-Un not long ago. In most cases Chicago’s primaries weren’t elections but affirmations. Nearly all incumbent officeholders ran unopposed. First time officeholder (second time candidate) Will Guzzardi won his race against Maria “Toni” Berrios, daughter of Cook County Democratic Party chairman Joseph Berrios, for the seat in the 39th state house legislative district. Guzzardi a 26 year old Ivy-educated former journalist ran on a progressive platform with the support of organized labor.

But the turnout was low there, too. Rather than drawing conclusions about an anti-incumbent sentiment, an anti-machine sentiment, or the rise in progressives in Chicago politics, the only conclusion that’s really supported by the evidence is that when the turnout is low anything can happen.

I’m exhausted today. I rose at 1:00am yesterday morning (courtesy of an elderly dog with dementia), arrived at the polling place where I had my election judge assignment, and returned home around 9:00pm. Voters expressed plenty of anti-incumbent sentiment but those were only the most disaffected voters.

Why the low turnout? I mentioned some of the reasons above but IMO there are a couple of other reasons worth mentioning. It might be that the torrent of negative ads have finally discouraged voters to the point where they don’t even bother to turn out for elections. The prevailing wisdom is that negative ads don’t suppress turnout but they do produce a sense of futility.

That’s the real message, the real conclusion. In Chicago the voters think that voting is futile.

7 comments

Primary Election Day, 2014

Today is the day of the primary elections for the elections to be held in November. As usual, I’m working as an election judge in a precinct in my ward. It will be a long day: I go to the polling place no later than 5:00am and I expect to be home sometime between 8:00pm and 9:00pm this evening.

I expect the worst turnout since I began working as an election judge more than 25 years ago, a combination of it being a primary which, ironically, typically have less turnout than do general elections, it being a mid-term election, and just plain fatigue.

I’ll try to check in at some point during the day but that may not be possible. I’m sure I’ll have something to say about the elections tomorrow.

0 comments

Ain’t It the Truth

The morning briefing sheet I received from Foreign Policy this morning was captioned like this:

Crime Votes to Secede from Ukraine

From the mouths of typographical errors…

0 comments

This I Believe

There’s a very good parenthetical passage in a post at Andrew Sullivan’s site on the scandal du jour about Paul Ryan’s presumed racism which takes a side trip into Charles Murray’s scholarship. Here it is:

(It’s an old and great line that liberals believe nothing is genetic but homosexuality, while conservatives believe everything is genetic except homosexuality. For my part, it seems pretty damn obvious that almost all human behavior is a function of both – and the interaction between them.)

A great, succinct way of expressing something that I, too, believe.

11 comments

Teach Me to Number Our Days

There’s a good piece of advice in Edward Lazear’s Wall Street Journal op-ed on the most recent jobs report:

The labor market’s strength and economic activity are better measured by the number of total hours worked than by the number of people employed. An employer who replaces 100 40-hour-per-week workers with 120 20-hour-per-week workers is contracting, not expanding operations. The same is true at the national level.

Using that measure how does the jobs report fare?

The total hours worked per week is obtained by multiplying the reported average workweek hours by the number of workers employed. The decline in the average workweek for all employees on private nonfarm payrolls by 3/10ths of an hour—offset partially by the increase in the number of people working—means that real labor usage on net, taking into account hours worked, fell by the equivalent of 100,000 jobs since September.

To start adding jobs and putting the people who’ve been out of work for so long back to work we need to increase the hours worked rather than reducing them. I can’t help but wonder if the number of uncompensated hours is rising even as the number of compensated hours falls. Given the president’s recent proposal about over-time pay, I suspect that’s what he’s decided.

17 comments

Happy Birthday, ARRA!

The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 also known as “the stimulus package” is five years old. Robert Samuelson celebrates with a fair explanation and evaluation of its performance. He concludes:

All this makes for a messy verdict. When proposed, President Obama’s stimulus was desirable. (Disclosure: Though disliking details, I favored it.) Regardless of multipliers, it supported the economy. It also sent a message along with the auto-industry bailout, the Federal Reserve’s easy money and the Troubled Asset Relief Program: The government won’t let the economy collapse. This was crucial to restoring confidence. The stimulus was a justifiable emergency measure.

That was my grudging opinion as well. I thought the stimulus was poorly timed and structured even worse. For maximum impact it should have been spent as quickly as possible rather than dribbled out over years. If the economy had come roaring back, it would have provided political fuel for additional stimulus. That didn’t happen.

I think there are additional questions Mr. Samuelson doesn’t raise in his column. Is it politically possible to fabricate a timely and effective stimulus? Have the last 80 years of Keynesian and pseudo-Keynesian policies inured the economy to fiscal stimulus?

Japan’s experience with fiscal stimulus including “Abenomics”, its most recent experiment, isn’t particularly cheering.

Effective or not it will be darned hard to stamp out fiscal stimulus as a strategy for dealing with economic downturns. There is an insatiable appetite for spending money that hasn’t been earned.

2 comments

St. Patrick’s Day, 2014

I’ve written about my Irish heritage before but it bears repeating. My maternal line is entirely Irish. My mother self-identified as Irish-American which means a lot of my identity is Irish, too. Her name was Colleen. Despite her conspicuously non-Irish birth name, my mom’s mother self-identified as Irish, too—she was billed as “the Irish Nightingale” in vaudeville. Her mother was Irish. Her maiden name was Flanagan. Her mother’s mother’s name was Dunn.

The Flanagans were cattle people from Westmeath in the center of Ireland. Born in Ireland, my great-great-grandfather Flanagan came over here as an infant. I have the story in his own words and I’ll publish it some day. He joined the Union Army during the Civil War at a very young age. Twice. And thereby hangs a tale. He worked as a express mail carrier, a cowboy, and, later, a cattle grader.

The Flanagans were tall, slender, good-looking, and had reddish-blond hair. I do not look like a Flanagan.

I know nothing about the Dunns. Perhaps I’ll learn more some day which would be interesting since I think I favor them.

My mother’s father self-identified as Irish, too. His mother’s maiden name was McCoy, she was born in this country, her family emigrated here around 1840, and I have reason to believe that they were from Armagh. I suspect they were in the horse trade. One of her brothers was a teamster when that meant you drove a team. Her mother’s name was Reilly.

My wife’s maternal line is Irish, too. That’s a story I may tell some day. Her great-niece is an Irish step-dancer who competed at the international level.

My best high school buddy was 100% Irish. All four of his grandparents were born in Ireland. He celebrated St. Patrick’s Day by wearing orange.

3 comments

He’s No Jimmy Carter

There’s one good sentence in Tom Friedman’s latest column:

It can’t be easy being Pollyanna, John Wayne and Henry Kissinger all at once.

Sadly, that mild wisecrack is expanded into a column that doesn’t offer much additional insight. I won’t bother fisking it.

The one thing about which I think we can be absolutely certain about in Barack Obama’s foreign policy is that he’s no Jimmy Carter. My criticism of Carter’s foreign policy at the time and which I believe has held up since is that he thought the U. S. could maintain its position in the world on the basis of moral suasion alone.

My basic criticism of the president’s foreign policy is that I believe that domestic political considerations overwhelm our actual policy interests. That’s not unique to him but I do find a difference in degree so great that it becomes a difference in kind. I think it explains everything about his foreign policy from why he campaigned on an “Afghan surge”, why we haven’t withdrawn our forces from Afghanistan long after it was obvious that we had accomplished whatever could be accomplished there with the effort we were willing to expend, his reactions to Iran, the “Arab Spring”, you name it. It’s a Unified Field Theory of Obama foreign policy.

I think it explains why he reacted as he did to the situation in Syria. Surrounded as he was by R2P (“responsibility to protect”) advocates, he initially responded quite aggressively. However, when he realized that was a miscalculation and popular reaction wasn’t what he had supposed it was, he pulled back and Russian President V. Putin gave him the figleaf he needed for a hasty retrenchment. Haven’t heard much about Syria lately, have you? Civilians are still dying there in the thousands.

With respect to the situation in Ukraine I think the president has taken the temperature of the country (this country) pretty well. We’re not interested in intervention. We don’t like it that the Russians are intervening but, honestly, in the final analysis we don’t much care.

9 comments