The Band Wagon

I see that the editors of the Washington Post have gotten on the tax reform band wagon:

THE HOT read among policy wonks these days is “Capital in the Twenty-First Century,” by French economist Thomas Piketty. He warns of a long-term trend toward ever-concentrated wealth and urges a global wealth tax to prevent it. While that might be a bad idea even if it were politically feasible, there is merit to the broader notion that industrialized countries could better coordinate taxing wealth, corporate and otherwise, that flits around the world in search of the lowest rates. Case in point: U.S. drug maker Pfizer’s $106 billion offer for Britain’s AstraZeneca, which could enable Pfizer to flag itself as a British company and pay taxes at Britain’s 20 percent rate rather than this country’s 35 percent.

Reforming the corporate income tax without reforming the personal income tax is impractical, either from a political or fiscal standpoint. One of the things I find most troubling about support for the corporate income tax is the strong anti-business stand its supporters frequently express. I wonder how they think we’re going to produce economic growth or reduce unemployment and beat down business at the same time?

What we’re seeing on the international scene with large multi-national companies pulling up stakes to seek more felicitous tax environments in other countries is the same thing we’ve been seeing among the various states for some time. Whether international or interstate that’s a zero-sum strategy rather than a growth strategy.

The solution is obvious and I’m not really sure what alternative supporters of the corporate income tax have in mind.

3 comments

Wind Blows

While we’re on the subject of what’s green and what isn’t, Tennessee Sen. Lamar Alexandar has an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal opposing the re-introduction of the wind power tax credit:

This giveaway expired in December. Yet on April 3 the Senate Finance Committee gave it new life by approving a $13 billion, two-year renewal within a package of 55 “tax extenders.” Once again, Washington is proving Ronald Reagan’s observation that “the nearest thing to eternal life that we’ll ever see on this Earth is a government program.”

The wind-production tax credit was first enacted in 1992. At the time, wind-power was considered a kind of “infant industry,” needing help to bring its technology up to speed and lead to lower costs. The tax credit has since been reborn eight times, even though President Obama’s Energy Secretary Stephen Chu in 2011 said that wind power is a “mature technology.” A mature technology should stand on its own in the marketplace.

I suspect that this explains the large windmill farms in midstate Illinois:

The 2.3-cent tax credit for each kilowatt-hour of wind-power electricity produced is sometimes worth more than the energy it subsidizes. Sometimes in some markets, for example in Texas and Illinois, the subsidy is so large that wind producers have paid utilities to take their electricity and still make a profit.

He offers three reasons not to support the subsidy

  1. It wastes money.
  2. It gives windmill operators a competitive advantage over other power generators which in turn makes it more likely that they’ll reduce capacity.
  3. At best wind power can only supplement other power sources rather than replace them.

Certainly #2 is the intention of the subsidy. If wind power doesn’t reduce power generation from coal, oil, or gas and does it at higher cost, what good is it?

I think that #3 is the really damning issue with wind power.

Here in Chicago the preponderance of electricity is generated using nuclear power and that has been the case for well over a generation. I honestly don’t see how any serious environmentalist can not support nuclear power and recently there appears to have been some movement in that direction. Luddites, yes.

I can also see how people who live in tectonically unstable parts of the country, e.g. California (or even Memphis) could be wary of nuclear power. One size does does not fit all and a solution that works in the upper Midwest might not be as prudent in the Southwest or Southeast.

1 comment

The Dammed

Outdoorsman and outdoor equipment magnate Yvon Chouinard takes to the op-ed page of the New York Times to make a pitch for removing dams:

VENTURA, Calif. — OF the more than 80,000 dams listed by the federal government, more than 26,000 pose high or significant safety hazards. Many no longer serve any real purpose. All have limited life spans. Only about 1,750 produce hydropower, according to the National Hydropower Association.

In many cases, the benefits that dams have historically provided — for water use, flood control and electricity — can now be met more effectively without continuing to choke entire watersheds.

I think he’s on the strongest ground when opposing new dam-building:

New dams are a bad idea. We’ve glorified them for decades, but our pride in building these engineering marvels has often blinded us to the environmental damage they cause. The consequences run the length of the river and beyond. Our many complex attempts to work around these obstacles would make Rube Goldberg proud. Interventions like fish elevators and trap-and-haul programs that truck fish around impoundments don’t lead to true recovery for wild fish populations or reverse the other environmental problems caused by blocking a river’s flow.

But that’s a battle that’s already largely been won. My best efforts have failed to reveal any large new dam projects waiting for regulatory approval. We’ve been removing dams at a pretty fair pace. Some dams are being refurbished to allow them to generate hydroelectric power, generate more power, or generate it more efficiently.

I note that he doesn’t mention one of the issues with dams: they aren’t particularly green. The impound reservoirs behind large dams are substantial sources of methane, a greenhouse gas. That’s something to keep in mind the next time someone pontificates to you about how China is going green. The Chinese authorities have decided to de-emphasize wind and solar power in favor of nuclear and hydroelectric.

That highlights something I think that many Americans, especially Americans serving in Congress, have not yet come to terms with. In a developing country infrastructure spending is necessary to build new infrastructure. In a developed (or over-developed) country like the United States infrastructure spending is necessary to optimize infrastructure which is likely to include removing obsolete infrastructure. That’s a much less glamorous project than building new roads, bridges, dams, etc.

What’s the single largest impediment to dam removal? I strongly suspect it’s waiting for environmental impact assessments.

In closing this post I feel that I should reveal my immediate reaction to this op-ed. It takes a lot of chutzpah to get your message out using a medium whose server farms are probably worse for the environment than most dams. Environmentalists should oppose moving to the Cloud rather than supporting it.

5 comments

Australian Television

Lately I’ve been binge-watching Australian television. I’ve watched a couple of police procedurals, one naval drama, and a period mystery drama. Right now I’m watching a medical drama. On deck is a legal drama, Rake, which was adapted into a drama of the same name on American television.

By and large I find the writing and acting in Australian television superior to their American counterparts. I find just too much mugging among young American actors. I think the better writing might be attributable to how American television is written. In general network American television programs are written by committee. That’s something that goes back to radio days.

I learn something in practically every show I watch. There’s the local color, of course. Some of their problems are the same. For example, they have a problem with illegal immigration. However, unlike ours most of their illegal immigration is apparently from East Asia or East Timor. They have their own Vietnam veterans with many of the same problems as our Vietnam vets live with.

Their medical problems are a bit different. For example, cystic fibrosis is apparently much more prevalent in Australia than it is here. I suspect that’s because of the Irish population—about 1 in 19 Irishmen carry the trait, the highest rate in the world.

The real difference is a consequence of the difference in their healthcare system. They have a national health system somewhat similar to Britain’s which coexists with a private system. If the show is any gauge, “Do we have the funding to treat this individual?” is as important a question as “How do we treat this individual?” and hospital crowding is chronic.

I’m still looking around for a good Aussie sitcom to cut my teeth on. Maybe someone can offer some suggestions. Humor may not translate as well as drama.

One more thing: so far in my watching I’ve seen exactly one lead actor of aboriginal descent. My, but he was a good-looking guy! You can see how he made it.

2 comments

Hackable

Here’s a finding which should give us some pause. Just about every system in a hospital is insanely easy to hack:

When Scott Erven was given free rein to roam through all of the medical equipment used at a large chain of Midwest health care facilities, he knew he would find security problems–but he wasn’t prepared for just how bad it would be.

In a study spanning two years, Erven and his team found drug infusion pumps–for delivering morphine drips, chemotherapy and antibiotics–that can be remotely manipulated to change the dosage doled out to patients; Bluetooth-enabled defibrillators that can be manipulated to deliver random shocks to a patient’s heart or prevent a medically needed shock from occurring; X-rays that can be accessed by outsiders lurking on a hospital’s network; temperature settings on refrigerators storing blood and drugs that can be reset, causing spoilage; and digital medical records that can be altered to cause physicians to misdiagnose, prescribe the wrong drugs or administer unwarranted care.

Erven’s team also found that, in some cases, they could blue-screen devices and restart or reboot them to wipe out the configuration settings, allowing an attacker to take critical equipment down during emergencies or crash all of the testing equipment in a lab and reset the configuration to factory settings.

“Many hospitals are unaware of the high risk associated with these devices,” Erven says. “Even though research has been done to show the risks, health care organizations haven’t taken notice. They aren’t doing the testing they need to do and need to focus on assessing their risks.”

This highlights something I’ve cautioned my clients about from time to time. You can’t take security for granted. It’s an attitude. If you don’t insist on and maintain system security in a systematic manner, your systems won’t be secure.

That applies to every organization from a retail store to a hospital but hospitals are a particularly horrifying example. I stopped doing business with Target flat when their security problems were revealed last year. When it turned out that the breach was due to malware having been injected into their point-of-sale systems, it was clear that the organization was simply not security-minded.

1 comment

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

“Scumbag Woodstock”

How’s our intervention in Libya turning out?

2 comments

Do Americans Think We’re on a Mission?

In comments yesterday we had a discussion of Americans’ view of foreign policy. Some held the position that Americans were strongly interventionist. I hold the view that there’s a sharp divide between American public opinion and our foriegn policy positions. What I said in response to the claim that in dealing with the rest of the world Americans believe they’re on a mission was:

That is a strain of American thought but it’s not the only strain. I don’t even think it is the most numerous strain but it’s the view held by a lot of American elites.

Here’s how IR scholar Dan Drezner characterized the situation:

A recurring theme among those who study public opinion has been that there’s a foreign policy disconnect between Washington elites and the rest of the country — the former is far more enthusiastic about liberal internationalism than the latter.

Here’s the Gallup Organization’s most recent findings:

and here are Pew’s

These are not interventionist priorities, whether liberal interventionist or neoconservative. If these views represent the desire of most Americans for some sort of mission, I’m not sure what it would be. The most significant objectives I see there are defense of the country and the pursuit of economic goals. There is, clearly, a strain of American opinion that longs for broader goals. But it’s a string of opinion not the majority of American opinion.

4 comments

I ♥ Apple

I’ve heard of people loving their Macs but this is taking things a step too far:

(NEWSER) – A Florida judge has tossed out a bizarre motion from a man who claimed he wanted to marry his “porn filled Apple computer.”

It’s being claimed, probably correctly, that this is a bizarre anti-gay marriage publicity stunt.

2 comments

Race Exists. Why Does It Matter?

It seems to me that the notion that race is a social construct, a view that largely took hold among social scientists after I had already left college, is fated (as Trotsky memorably said of the Mensheviks) to the dustbin of history. I don’t believe that it can survive the combination of the mapping of the human genome and genetic testing. That the subject to which Robert VerBruggen turns at RealClearScience, reviewing a book titled A Troublesome Inheritance: Genes, Race and Human History:

It’s an important book. It should demolish the idea that race is nothing whatsoever but a “social construct” and jumpstart a conversation about human history. But unfortunately, A Troublesome Inheritance does not equip readers to deal with the broader ramifications of the claims it makes: Though such concerns are arguably outside the realm of science, these theories have the potential to inflame racial prejudices, and Wade’s attempts to address this fact leave much to be desired.

I certainly hope it doesn’t “jumpstart a conversation”. “Conversation” has become an auto-antonym, a word that means both one thing and its opposite like “inflammable”. The dictionary definition of “conversation” is an informal exchange of ideas using speech. It now also means a sermon issued by one person or group to another, very much the opposite of the dictionary definition.

What I hope it jumpstarts is reflection.

Investigations into racial differences have a bad pedigree. They’re frequently used as cudgels to beat some despised group or other with. For example, Mr. VerBruggen repeats one of them:

Wade also digs into Jewish history, relaying theories that the religion’s emphasis on literacy — a skill with little practical value in a farming society — may have driven the less intelligent to join Christianity instead, and that European Jews’ being highly concentrated in intellectually demanding professions like moneylending may have further contributed to increased IQ.

I’m skeptical of that. IMO a more productive investigation might be comparing urbanized Jews with rural Jews or middle class Jews with lower class Jews. My suspicion is that the cultural and social factors overwhelm the genetic ones.

I think that’s the case with cross-racial comparisons of intelligence, too: the variations within races are much more significant than those between races. A prudent society would promote its citizens making the best use of their gifts, regardless of gender (in the case, for example, of the Middle East) or race. That race and gender continue to matter suggests that we continue to have a long way to go.

23 comments

What Does “Self-Determination” Mean?

In the wake of the debacle that’s unfolding in Ukraine, I’m seeing an odd sort of argument being made. It goes something like this.

Various miniscule countries have a right to exist because of self-determination. They don’t have the ability to protect themselves from their neighbors. Consequently, we (the United States) have an obligation to defend them.

Note that’s what is meant by NATO these days: the obligation of the United States to protect other countries while the remainder of our NATO allies stand around, ready to hold our coat while we work. Or not as they see fit.

I think that’s the most bizarre definition of self-determination I’ve ever heard. What the heck kind of right to exist does a country that can’t or won’t defend itself have?

I completely understand why these countries want us to defend them. What I can’t figure is what’s in it for us. I don’t see that it strengthens our security, enhances our prestige, or furthers any strategic interest.

18 comments