Status Report

I think I mentioned a month or so ago that my real income in 2013 was the lowest it had been in my adult life. My nominal income was lower than it’s been in decades.

A year ago I started putting out some feelers and I’ve added a few clients. It’s better than nothing but none of my new clients has much potential. Once I’ve started working with a client, I tend to retain the client, well, forever which is something.

At the beginning of the year I thought I’d secured a new client with substantial potential but for one reason or another that hasn’t materialized. It may eventually. We’ll see.

Over the last month I’ve put out more feelers and am beginning to get some nibbles. Last week I received roughly one inquiry or offer a day which is encouraging. It fully supports my belief that my skills remain saleable.

One of the problems I’ve encountered is that I’m not looking for a job. Based on what I’ve been seeing I could get a fulltime permanent job just about any time I wanted one but I don’t want one. I’m looking for work which is a slightly different proposition. My ideal solution would be for some combination of new clients who would give me ten hours of billable work a week over time. That really isn’t much and I would think it would be doable.

My least preferred alternative would be taking a fulltime job. That would leave me unable to serve my present clients towards whom I still feel responsibility.

2 comments

Why Is the LFPR Declining?

Evan Soltas has a very interesting post that examines why the labor force participation rate is declining. After some math and pseudo-math, here’s what he finds:

The headline result is that 1.7 percentage points of the decline in the labor force participation rate are explained by changes in the demographic composition of the population, and that 1.1 percentage points are left unexplained. The 95-percent confidence intervals on those figures are that between 1.4 and 1.9 percentage points are explained and between 0.8 and 1.4 percentage points are unexplained.

Note that “demographic composition” has more than one component. It includes both Baby Boomers who he presumes are retiring and young workers who are seeking more education.

He mentions one shortcoming of the analysis in his concluding observations: he only examines a very small period. Commenters point out several technical issues with his analysis. I’ll point out some others. Although he recognizes the endogeneity of young workers seeking more education as a factor:

Another concern is the obvious endogeneity problem with education. That is, if the economy’s terrible, that affects your decision of whether to work now or to go back to school. But note that this problem is insoluble without a model of how the economy affects education decisions, something well beyond the scope of my work here. What my work suggests, though, is that this exercise is worthwhile. Since you get a year older every year, there’s not a lot of mystery to the aging-working link. But, since we know now that education decisions were actually important to driving down overall labor force participation, maybe we should go back and think about it carefully.

i.e. conditions other than age, e.g. the state of the economy, affect whether young workers seek more education or not. However, he fails to recognize that the same is true of older workers leaving the workforce: that, too, is not strictly exogenous.

Another issue is that although lives births and people who live to turn 65 are frequently thought of as smooth and continuous they aren’t. That wouldn’t be an issue if he were considering a longer timeframe but, since he’s only considering a couple of months, noise in the underlying data could be significant.

That aside note that the amount he attributes to older workers leaving the workforce is just about the same as the amount he considers unexplained. In other words Baby Boomers retiring doesn’t explain the decline in the LFPR. It probably explains less than half of it.

Here are probably his most important findings:

And what just straight up doesn’t matter? Changes in the share of people on welfare, disability aside. Changes in health, after accounting for disability and age. Changes in the sex and race composition of the labor force.

Overall it makes for interesting reading, especially if you’re math-oriented.

In the final analysis I believe that wondering too much about why the LFPR is declining is misdirection. Whatever the reason, it’s declining and that has implications. Among those implications are lowered tax revenues, reduced income for many people, and less economic activity in general.

10 comments

Grand Theft Avocado

Here’s a headline that caught my eye—”Man arrested in Santa Paula avocado theft”:

A man was arrested Saturday on suspicion of stealing avocados in Santa Paula, police said.

Officers responded about 3 p.m. to the area of East Telegraph Road and Texas Lane regarding two people stealing avocados, authorities said.

When police arrived, both people tried to flee, authorities said.

An officer caught one suspect, who was found to have 53 pounds of avocados, police said. The other person dropped 54 pounds of avocados before fleeing, officials said.

Apparently, avocados are a prime target for drug addicts. They can be sold pretty easily on the street for a buck a piece, don’t attract much attention in Southern California, and aren’t easy to trace.

They weigh about a half pound each so a hundred pounds of avocados is a lot of avocados.

1 comment

The Laboratory of Economics

Justice Louis Brandeis once characterized the states as “laboratories of democracy”. At Slate Jordan Weissmann writes about Seattle’s experiement in raising the local minimum wage to $15 an hour:

Economists everywhere may soon be thanking Seattle Mayor Ed Murray. Not because of his inspired policymaking, but because Murray seems ready to turn his city into a gigantic laboratory for one of the most ambitious, and quite possibly misbegotten, labor market experiments in recent memory.

The entire article is interesting and I commend it to your attention.

As I see things the real minimum wage peaked around 1970 and, well, conditions were very different then than they are now. The labor market was different. The global economy was different. It was a lot easier to get a job that paid more than minimum wage then that it s now. I think the primary effect of the high minimum wage was to incentivize the mass immigration we’ve seen since then, something only paralleled in our history by the immigration at the end of the 19th century.

It may be that a $15 minimum wage in Seattle will work out just fine. The experiment will soon be under way. Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn wants to raise Illinois’s minimum wage to $10 an hour, something I suspect will be disastrous. Illinois already has the third-highest unemployment rate in the country and a higher minimum wage than Wisconsin, Iowa, Indiana, or Missouri. I don’t think that Illinois is healthy enough to make a good experimental subject.

2 comments

Fixing Europe

Rock star French economist Thomas Piketty has an op-ed in The Guardian you might want to take a look at. He proposes radical changes to European Union governance guided by what is to my eye and, presumably, the eyes of most Americans something pretty obvious: for a common currency to work there must also be a common fiscal policy. And a common fiscal policy requires a democratic European legislature:

It is time to recognise that Europe’s existing institutions are dysfunctional and need to be rebuilt. The central issue is simple: democracy and the public authorities must be enabled to regain control of and effectively regulate 21st century globalised financial capitalism. A single currency with 18 different public debts on which the markets can freely speculate, and 18 tax and benefit systems in unbridled rivalry with each other, is not working, and will never work. The eurozone countries have chosen to share their monetary sovereignty, and hence to give up the weapon of unilateral devaluation, but without developing new common economic, fiscal and budgetary instruments. This no man’s land is the worst of all worlds.

I think this brings something into relief that appears to be lost on the progressive Americans who lionize Dr. Piketty. His main interest is Europe and his assumptions and prescriptions are targeted at a European audience intent on fixing European problems.

0 comments

Eliminate the Corporate Income Tax!

Erstwhile Obama Administration “auto czar” Steve Rattner takes to the opinion page of the New York Times to argue that it’s time to end the corporate income tax. Reacting to the same news I commented on earlier he writes:

A more ambitious, and therefore more politically difficult idea, would be to scrap our unworkable corporate tax system altogether and instead tax shareholders, first by eliminating low tax rates on capital gains and dividends.

That would offset only a small portion of the loss of corporate tax revenue (a projected $350 billion in 2015), so we should raise the balance by eliminating loopholes enjoyed by wealthy Americans, increasing rates on their earned income and potentially introducing new concepts, such as taxing gains on investments as stock prices rise rather than when they are sold.

The wealthy need not fear; eliminating corporate taxes would lead to a jump in business earnings and, consequently, stock prices. That would encourage similar actions by other countries. Otherwise, their companies might move here to enjoy a zero corporate tax rate.

Higher stock prices would also help pension funds, foundations and other tax-exempt institutions focused on social betterment.

While eliminating corporate taxation would be branded a giveaway, properly engineered reforms would provide a huge uplift to ordinary Americans.

It’s heartening to see a Democratic Party apparatchik like Mr. Rattner getting behind eliminating the corporate income tax. As best as I can tell, it presently serves mostly to give large corporations that can afford armies of tax attorneys and accounts and are able to engineer exemptions for themselves a competitive advantage over small and medium companies that don’t have the resources to do the same thing.

Just as a reminder, the U. S. has the highest marginal effective tax rate on corporate investment of any OECD country.

14 comments

Point of Information: the Origination Clause

I have a question. Has any federal law ever been declared unconstitutional on the technical procedural grounds of violation of the Constitutional requirements of the origination clause, as George Will demands is the case with the PPACA?

So you don’t have to look it up, here’s the origination clause to which he refers from Article I, Section 8:

All bills for raising revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with amendments as on other Bills.

The emphasis is mine. Mr. Will’s claim is that since the PPACA originated in the Senate it’s in violation of the origination clause which, since the Supreme Court has already held that its mandatory provisions are based on the Congress’s tax powers.

I seriously doubt that the Supreme Court would declare the PPACA unconstitutional on the grounds Mr. Will suggests unless it was already predisposed to strike the law down and there’s very little evidence that’s the case.

Could somebody help me out here?

7 comments

Boosting the Economy

Diana Furchtgott-Roth proposes some measures that could produce more economic growth:

  • Fix the Affordable Care Act.
  • Allow exports of natural gas.
  • Reform taxes.
  • Overhaul immigration.

She characterizes these reforms as “easy”, presumably meaning that they need not require federal spending. Quite to the contrary, I think these problems are extraordinarily difficult. If they weren’t, they’d’ve already been done by now.

Clearly, her priorities are different from mine. Allowing more flexibility in the plans offered under the PPACA might make sense but it’s probably politically quite difficult and, frankly, it will do almost nothing to spur economic growth. Her most convincing argument is for allowing exports of natural gas:

Most non-marketed natural gas is wasted, flared into the atmosphere like an open burner on a gas stove. Flaring gas releases CO2 as a byproduct of combustion, so it would be environmentally preferable for the gas to be sold. A third of North Dakota’s total production is flared, or burned. North Dakota’s goal is to reduce its percentage of non-marketed gas to 10% by the fourth quarter of 2020. Allowing more exports would help North Dakota’s economy as well as increase U.S. GDP.

As I’ve mentioned before, I’m neutral on increasing GDP. Under present circumstances I see too much daylight between increasing GDP and improving the fortunes of most Americans for me to get very exercised about it. I think what we really need to do is not to sell more of what’s already being produced but produce more. To whatever extent selling more natural gas incentivizes additional production of natural gas I’m in favor of it. Otherwise, I’m indifferent to it.

I agree that tax reform would be helpful. However, I think reform should be more narrowly tailored than this

A better solution would be to lower taxes on capital to encourage more investment. Spending on equipment declined by 5.5% in the first quarter, the largest one-quarter decline since the second quarter of 2009.

The portion of immigration she emphasizes is probably the smallest component:

Immigrants have a higher propensity to start businesses than do native-born Americans, according to a 2012 study by the Kauffman Foundation , which champions entrepreneurship. The author, Duke University professor Vivek Wadhwa, reported that immigrant founders of engineering and technology companies started between 2006 and 2012 employed approximately 560,000 workers and generated $63 billion in sales in 2012. In California’s high-tech Silicon Valley, 44% of businesses had at least one immigrant founder.

I suspect that 90% or more of our immigration consists of unskilled workers from Mexico, other parts of Latin America, and the Caribbean. Offhand I doubt that many of them are coming here to start engineering and technology companies. A more direct way of spurring growth in the number of engineering and technology companies would be federal spending that encouraged engineering and technology companies. The epitome of that kind of spending was the space program which not only caused more money to be devoted to engineering and technology but did so in an area of technology that wasn’t already filled with giant companies that were mobilized to suck up every available dollar as is the case now. I’m not sure what kind of federal spending would encourage that today.

IMO the most immediate effect of expanding the number of H-1B visas would be to push wages down for the engineering and technology workers already here.

As the old wisecrack has it “Lord, send us a cure! The disease is already here.” We need more economic growth now rather in five or ten years and the growth we need will cause more investment and business spending in the United States. I don’t think that any of Ms. Furchtgott-Roth’s proposals would have those effects.

4 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Whither Tablets?

John Dvorak has a kind of interesting gripe about the future of tablets:

With sales of tablets falling, the so-called “experts” are now re-evaluating predictions about tablets taking over the computing market. It never made sense in the first place.

All eyes are on the market share leader, Apple, whose iPad sales fell 16 percent during the first quarter. Some of this has to do with customers moving to Android tablets, but a downward trend is clear. The Microsoft Surface also took a beating.

The rationale is that, whatever a tablet is good for, it’s never going to be replaced. Once the market saturates, the replacement cycle is long and slow. Unlike on PCs, there are no tablet apps that are so powerful they need more horsepower. Most users simply use them to read content or play games.

Insofar as a fashion item, there is not much you can do design-wise to a tablet to encourage an upgrade. There are no real design elements. It’s just a slab of glass.

My own view is that tablets, like mainframe computers and notebook computers, are a niche product. There’s a viable niche for them and will be for the foreseeable future. So far I don’t we’ve scratched the surface (to use a wildly inappropriate metaphor) of the potential for smartphones or tablets in the business environment. Interestingly, smartphones and tablets are unlike mainframes and personal computers whether desktop or notebook in that they’re primarily a consumer product rather than spreading from business use into personal use.

I’ve been thinking of starting an online magazine devoted to add-ons for smartphones and tablets for a while now. There doesn’t seem to be anything like that out there or, if there is, it’s certainly keeping its existence hidden pretty well. There’s plenty of material and I would think with and with 150 million smartphones and 100 million tablets out there, you’d think that there might be at least a little interest.

9 comments