The Vermont Initiative

I think this article on Vermont’s inching its way towards a single-payer system is an interesting one.

3 comments

Fear Itself

After getting off to a shaky start in her piece on the U. S. reaction to the Ebola outbreak (and bringing sick Americans home for treatment), Heather Wilhelm echoes a point I’ve made:

No matter your feelings on crazed grocery runs, a definite strangeness surrounds America’s leading Ebola narrative. There is, for instance, a whole lot of condescension going on. On Monday, online magazine Slate ran a “myth-busting” piece on Ebola, explaining why you’re pretty much a moron to worry even a little bit about a contagious virus that can melt your insides. The article included an alarming-looking photo, featuring three individuals in hazmat suits, with the following caption: “Members of Doctors Without Borders wear protective gear on July 23, 2014, in Conakry, Guinea, in a scene that’s not coming to the U.S. anytime soon.”

Ah, the smugness. Can you feel it? America is rich, you see. Africa, meanwhile, is The Other. This sentiment, explicit or not, is echoed repeatedly in much of the “don’t panic” press. Slate’s caption, when you think about it, isn’t too far from a recent headline from the satirical news site The Onion: “Experts: Ebola Vaccine at Least 50 White People Away.”

It’s a relief that I’m not the only one who sees it.

6 comments

Lack of Outrage

I guess I’m not as outraged as James Taranto about Jonathan Alter’s modest proposal for corporate loyalty oaths:

Before we settled on today’s topic, we weighed the question: Is Jonathan Alter joking? The question arose not on the basis of Alter’s character–we’ve met him, and he strikes us as very earnest, an unlikely prankster–but because his latest Daily Beast piece is so outlandish. The headline is “The United States Needs Corporate ‘Loyalty Oaths.’ ”

Although as a matter of pure logic one cannot rule out the possibility of a very elaborate deadpan charade, the balance of evidence–namely his Twitter feed–suggests he’s serious. Taken at face value, every Alter tweet about the piece is entirely unironic, especially this one: “I’m afraid headline made people react viscerally rather than read piece.”

We read piece and piece even more outlandish than headline. The term “loyalty oath” has a certain implication to those familiar with 20th-century U.S. history. Alter explicates it, which is to say he names names: “If Republicans cared about this issue, which most don’t, they would revive McCarthy-era loyalty oaths, where people were forced to swear that they weren’t communists.”

That might be because I doubt the proposal will go any farther than Mr. Alter’s column. I also think it’s more emblematic of a lack of understanding of the problem and a lack of imagination that it is of a mindset.

1 comment

Ditch the Coup-Counting

For once I find myself in agreement with E. J. Dionne:

Do Republicans really want to be known as a purely negative party? The GOP’s establishment was pleased that it again beat back the tea party with Sen. Pat Roberts’s victory in Tuesday’s Kansas primary. Might this not give the party a little more room to work with Democrats on something?

That’s where the plain vanilla agenda comes in. Yes, the label risks dooming the enterprise. The phrase comes from President Obama — last week, he scolded House Republicans for blocking “even basic, common-sense, plain vanilla legislation” — and many conservatives presume anything associated with Obama is toxic.

Still, it’s an instructive concept to encourage a search for policy ideas that ought not to be terribly controversial. To construct such an agenda, I sat down this week with Heather Boushey and Elisabeth Jacobs of the Washington Center for Equitable Growth. We put together two lists. The as-plain-as-possible-vanilla list included proposals that already have a lot of Republican support. The ought-to-be-plain-vanilla ideas either once won GOP backing or should have appeal, given other things to which conservatives are committed.

On the first list: extending the earned-income tax credit (EITC) for single, childless people; a refundable child tax credit; and a big infrastructure bill, perhaps including an infrastructure bank.

[…]

And here’s the ought-to-be-plainvanilla list: a minimum-wage increase (many Republicans used to vote for it); pre-kindergarten expansion (many of the most ambitious pre-K programs are in Republican-led states such as Oklahoma and Georgia); paid family leave (financed as an insurance program so employers don’t carry the whole load); and the right not to be fired just for requesting a flexible work schedule.

There ought to be more areas of agreement between the two parties and there should be areas in which they would agree to work together for the good of all of us. To do that there would need to be an end to “poison pills”, comprehensive or omnibus legislation in which unacceptable aspects are intermingled with things that should be acceptable to both parties, a general swallowing of their pride on the part of the Republicans, and a general abandoning of the rejectionist stance they’ve held for the last six year.

Since I don’t believe that any of those things will happen, regardless of the outcome in November the next two years are likely to bring more of the same.

6 comments

Comparing a Hypothetical Obama with an Actual Lincoln

I think there’s some merit in Charles Lane’s comparison of a hypothetical executive order from President Obama

offering up to 5 million undocumented parents of U.S. citizens and others the same two-year renewable reprieves from deportation plus work permits that Obama already ordered for undocumented residents who arrived as children

with Abraham Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation. It would simultaneously be an act of mercy and politically expedient; he would be exceeding his powers and, consequently, courting impeachment.

However, the analogy fails if the actual circumstances of each are taken into account. There is no comparison between illegal economic migrants and slaves. The economic migrants are free to return to their countries of origin, mostly Mexico. Additionally, the analogy fails to take into account the Emancipation Proclamation’s function as a tactic to end the American Civil War.

It would be a much closer analogy if, rather than a civil war, the Emancipation Proclamation had been issued to quell a slave rebellion. What do you think would have happened if there had been no civil war and President Lincoln had issued the Emancipation Proclamation during a slave rebellion?

5 comments

Running the Gauntlet

After cataloging the gauntlet that the PPACA must run over the next two years, Shikha Dalmia remarks:

No doubt Democrats are going to berate Republicans as obstructionists. President Obama lectured Republicans to “stop hating all the time” after they voted this week to challenge the legality of his executive actions in court.

But the reality is that unless public opinion swings dramatically in Obamacare’s favor, Republicans have no skin in the game and no reason to cooperate.

All of this means that Halbig was just the beginning. For the foreseeable future, the country will remain embroiled in Obamacare battles—instead of actually fixing the myriad problems with American health care.

What I think that many supporters of the PPACA miss is that the unpopularity of the PPACA was designed in from the start. The number of people that it hurts was designed to outnumber of people it helps. Presumably, the idea was that it would hurt the people it hurt only a little and it would help the people it helped a lot. I don’t think that’s quite worked out as expected. For whatever reason the president and Congressional leaders thought that the law would be more popular than it has turned out to be and that its popularity would grow in the near term.

That hasn’t happened and if anything it has become less popular over time. The attitude now seems to be that public opinion is bound to turn around eventually. Un bel di.

13 comments

New York’s Pension Problem

Megan McArdle notes:

In New York, reports the Times, the unions don’t want to move to more conservative pension accounting, because if they do, the city will be required to put more money into the pot . . . and the taxpaying public might mobilize against the union workers who put them in this spot.

Of course, putting it off will ultimately just make the problem worse; the inexorable logic of compounding is just not very forgiving. Over the next few decades, we are going to come face to face with more problems like Detroit’s: pensions that must be paid, legally and morally, but cannot be paid while still offering an acceptable level of government services. Taxpayers’ wallets are not an inexhaustible resource, and cities and states that demand too much will see their citizenry depart for more fiscally responsible climes.

The problem is that at any given time, it always looks better to delay — and the worse a crisis gets, the more attractive a delay looks, because the reckoning is already very painful. New York’s new mayor has so far said little about the city’s pensions, and it’s probably in his best political interest to keep mum. It’s too bad that the interests of future pensioners — and the city’s — are so different.

The title of her post asks a question: will New York be the next Detroit? My answer would be “No”. I think that honor belongs to Chicago for three reasons:

  • Chicago has all of the same problems New York does
  • Chicago is in worse fiscal shape than New York
  • Absent a stay of execution from the state, Chicago must put a billion dollars that it doesn’t have into its public pension fund

The state legislature is barely able to commit to what its members want to eat for lunch let alone bailing Chicago out of the fix they put it in. I think Chicago will walk the plank before New York.

2 comments

Government for a Digital Age

In the middle of a lot of partisan twaddle Michael Barone hints at the kernel of a good idea:

Government was reasonably good at replicating the bureaucratic processes of large corporations in the industrial age. But it’s not very good — it’s often downright incompetent — at replicating the IT processes of firms such as Walmart and Amazon.

I wish there were more there about why Amazon’s systems work better but there isn’t.

I can only speculate. Amazon wasn’t an enormous giant when it started. It started fairly small and its systems have evolved over time. They have been subjected to continuing, ongoing change.

The way that federal projects are funded and let precludes such a process.

I think there’s probably room for a lot more analysis of how modern system development could be managed in the context of 21st century government but, unfortunately, you won’t find that in Mr. Barone’s article.

Again, I can only speculate. I think a network model rather than the hierarchical model would be more effective. I think that bringing the development closer to the stakeholders rather than removing it to the confines of Washington, DC would also help. Agile development just won’t work in the severely top-down federal government and today’s environment in which every failure is trumpeted from the rooftops isn’t helpful, either.

I’m reminded of Churchill’s remark that success consists of going from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm. That’s as good a definition of agile development strategies as any I’ve heard but I’m skeptical that our government could work that way.

10 comments

Animal Spirits

The most recent Wall Street Journal/NBC poll finds Americans in a foul mood over the economy:

Still scarred by a recession that ended five years ago, Americans are registering record levels of anxiety about the opportunities available to younger generations and are pessimistic about the nation’s long-term prospects, directing their blame at elected leaders in Washington.

A new Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll found that despite the steady pace of hiring in recent months, 76% of adults lack confidence that their children’s generation will have a better life than they do—an all-time high. Some 71% of adults think the country is on the wrong track, a leap of 8 points from a June survey, and 60% believe the U.S. is in a state of decline.

What’s more, seven in 10 adults blamed the malaise more on Washington leaders than on any deeper economic trends, and 79% expressed some level of dissatisfaction with the American political system.

“The American public is telling its elected representatives that the economic distress that a significant proportion of them are feeling is directly their fault,” said Democratic pollster Fred Yang, who conducts the Journal poll with Republican Bill McInturff. “The public seems to have moved beyond the plaintive cry of ‘feel our pain’ to the more angry pronouncement of ‘you are causing our pain.’ ”

The economy is an area in which belief equals reality or, at least, belief has an important effect on behavior which produces the reality. That’s what John Maynard Keynes referred to as “animal spirits”, an important force in pulling economies out of recessions.

In comments recently it was remarked that things would be no different today if Bill Clinton were president. I disagree. Whatever his failing, Bill Clinton was a relentless and indefatigable cheerleader for the economy. His confidence built confidence in others.

George W. Bush didn’t have that same quality and neither does Barack Obama.

10 comments

The Summary

Josh Zumbrun of the Wall Street Journal provides a fair summary of how economic indicators have fared during the Obama presidency. Here’s the Reader’s Digest version.

The stock market, home prices, GDP, the total number of jobs, and industrial production are up.

Real median household incomes and the labor force participation rate are down. Real average incomes are down, too, which means that even the continuingly increasing share of income by the wealthy doesn’t make up for the loss of income.

Food stamp use is up. Job growth has been phlegmatic by comparison with post-war presidents other than George W. Bush with whom it’s pretty comparable.

Whether you think it’s a good record or a bad one largely depends on your point-of-view. As usual where you sit is where you stand. President Obama clearly thinks it’s a good record.

My view is that it’s not good enough.

36 comments