The Floppy Ears

Here’s an interesting article on why so many breeds of domesticated dogs have floppy ears. It covers territory I’ve covered here before.

It’s pretty simple, actually. Floppy ears are a neotenous characteristic (neoteny is when immature chaacteristics are preserved in adulthood). Dogs have been selectively bred from wild canines for reduced cortisol production and reduced cortisol production is associated with increased neoteny.

My breed, Samoyeds, have “prick ears”, i.e. they’re not floppy. However, they’re also white and white in the coat is also a neotenous characteristic.

0 comments

The Rates

Health Affairs Blog considers the factors that will determine the 2015 healthcare insurance rates:

The rates are coming, the rates are coming.

While there seem to be fewer “latest verdicts on the ACA,” breathlessly reported in the popular press, as we move through the second half of 2014, the filing of 2015 rate requests for individual and small group products on the health insurance exchanges offer one more piece of catnip for pundits.

Who is up? Who is down? How much? Is this the dreaded death spiral for the ACA? Or its vindication?

They point to the paucity of data that insurance companies use to make their determinations as one of the key factors in what will eventually happen. I think it’s worth keeping in mind that the paucity of data is a feature rather than a bug.

2 comments

The Question

Bart Hinkle asks what I think is a pretty good question:

If insurance companies can’t turn people away, then why should physicians be allowed to?

4.4% of physicians accept no new private patients. 14% accept no new Medicare patients. Almost 30% accept no new Medicaid patients.

40% of physicians provide no care free or at reduced rates, generally considered an ethical obligation.

The answer that physicians generally give to the question is that they must turn away some patients to be able to provide adequate care to the rest. That the patients turned away are those for whom they receive less compensation is just one of life’s mysteries.

I don’t think that the answer to the question resides in something as abstract as self-determination or speculative as the ability to provide adequate care. I think that it was easier to persuade insurance companies that they would benefit from a larger pool of subscribers than it was to persuade physicians that they should do more work for lower pay.

7 comments

Arguing Against a DREAM

In arguing in favor of it Albert Hunt provides a pretty fair argument against any version of the DREAM Act, the proposed law that would allow individuals who came to the United States as children illegally to remain here legally. He addresses the president:

By all means, use an executive order to give work permits to, and avoid deportation of, the parents of those young undocumented “Dreamers.” Call it family values. The Republicans will go berserk, but the more vitriolic they get, the greater the probable voter backlash in November.

In other words, he sees the DREAM Act as a stalking horse for a general amnesty. I strongly suspect he’s misreading public opinion on this subject, including the opinion of legal immigrants.

0 comments

The Changing Nature of Employment

I found this article from the LA Times interesting:

A short gig doing security for the True Blood television show. A stint driving for a rental car company. A week as a customer service representative at a retail store.

This is how Delvontaie Antwine, 34, makes do in California’s economic recovery — earning a few scattered paychecks a month from odd temp jobs while living with relatives in Silver Lake.

Each week, he goes to a career center, where recently he was looking into positions transporting patients for Kaiser Permanente.

“I just need something consistent; otherwise, I’m like a puppy chasing its tail,” he said. “I’m at the bottom of the totem pole right now.”

It’s a purgatory sometimes called the gray economy. Although the official state unemployment rate dropped to 7.4% in June, 16.2% of Californians — or about 6.2 million — were either jobless, too discouraged to seek work, working less than they’d like or in off-the-books jobs.

The unemployment rate isn’t measured. It’s polled. What you read in the newspapers is determined by an arcane combination of the establishment survey (polling businesses), the household survey (polling households), and guesstimation. I have complained many times in the past that the fudge factors introduced in the guesstimation process are so much larger than the numbers actually polled that they strain credulity.

This article highlights how the nature of employment today may have rendered the establishment survey incredible if not irrelevant.

47 comments

It Can’t Happen Here

The Wall Street Journal op-ed by Ian Lipkin is a good illustration of what I meant:

An infected individual could board a flight in West Africa, become symptomatic in the air or after landing and then expose others to the virus. At worst, this might result in a few other people becoming infected and possibly dying. But sustained outbreaks would not occur in the U.S. because cultural factors in the developing world that spread Ebola—such as intimate contact while family and friends are caring for the sick and during the preparation of bodies for burial—aren’t common in the developed world. Health authorities would also rapidly identify and isolate infected individuals.

Am I wrong to detect notes of arrogance and patronization in that statement? That’s not a rhetorical question. I genuinely want to know. It seems to me that Dr. Lipkin is assuming things that are not in evidence and failing to take into account the much higher number of deaths and, presumably, infection rate in this most current outbreak compared to others. I see nothing in his profile that suggests firsthand knowledge which implicitly means he’s just repeating what he’s been told.

18 comments

My Questions About the Ebola Outbreak

The Ebola outbreak in West Africa is continuing unabated:

The death toll from the outbreak of Ebola virus in west Africa has climbed to 826, nearly double the number of fatalities of the previous worst-ever epidemic, according to figures released by the World Health Organisation.

The update suggests the outbreak is spinning out of control, with more than 50 deaths reported in three days from 28-30 July, as the spread of the virus outpaces efforts to contain it in Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone.

“The surge in the number of new cases . . . calls for concentrated efforts by all to address the identified problems such as health facility transmission and effective contact tracing,” the WHO said.

The rapid increase in the death toll comes after the three west African nations announced over the weekend extra measures to combat the outbreak, including calling in the army to enforce quarantines in several villages.

In a statement the trio said the new measures would focus on the “cross-border regions that have more than 70 per cent [of the cases] of the epidemic”. They added that the “border areas will be isolated by policy and the military”.

By my reckoning that means that there have been about four times as many deaths in this outbreak as in any previous one. And the outbreak hasn’t subsided. That strongly suggests to me that something has changed. What?

Additionally, I have read reports that the American healthcare workers who have been brought back to the States for treatment after contracting the disease were using the CDC’s containment protocols including containment suits. Assume that they were. How much confidence should we have that the containment protocols are effective?

Finally, many of the remarks I have read about the spread of the disease in Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone have been incredibly patronizing. I’m sure they were well-intentioned. Patronizing people frequently have good intentions. Is it warranted?

I’m not advocating panic. I’m advocating skepticism. It seems to me that we may not know as much as we think we do and that isn’t much.

24 comments

More Things in Heaven and Earth

There’s an interesting pair of articles that might interest you. In the first from Wired David Hambling reports on an apparently successful test by NASA of an impossible space drive:

The Nasa team based at the Johnson Space Centre gave its paper the title “Anomalous Thrust Production from an RF [radio frequency] Test Device Measured on a Low-Thrust Torsion Pendulum”. The five researchers spent six days setting up test equipment followed by two days of experiments with various configurations. These tests included using a “null drive” similar to the live version but modified so it would not work, and using a device which would produce the same load on the apparatus to establish whether the effect might be produced by some effect unrelated to the actual drive. They also turned the drive around the other way to check whether that had any effect.

Back in the 90s, Nasa tested what was claimed to be an antigravity device based on spinning superconducting discs. That was reported to give good test results, until researchers realised that interference from the device was affecting their measuring instruments. They have probably learned a lot since then.

The torsion balance they used to test the thrust was sensitive enough to detect a thrust of less than ten micronewtons, but the drive actually produced 30 to 50 micronewtons — less than a thousandth of the Chinese results, but emphatically a positive result, in spite of the law of conservation of momentum:

“Test results indicate that the RF resonant cavity thruster design, which is unique as an electric propulsion device, is producing a force that is not attributable to any classical electromagnetic phenomenon and therefore is potentially demonstrating an interaction with the quantum vacuum virtual plasma.”

Not so fast says Steven Novella of NeuroLogica:

The bottom line is that I just don’t believe it. I could be wrong. I hope I’m wrong. I don’t necessarily think the results of NASA’s test are untrue, just that I don’t think they have “validated” that the propellantless drive is what proponents say it is.

My reaction is identical to the claim made in 2011 that a team of researchers found that neutrinos travel faster than light. I didn’t believe those results either. The researchers were very careful, they rigorously reviewed every aspect of their experiment, and only announced the results when they were confident they ruled out all error. The physics community didn’t believe it, but they did their due diligence. After further analysis, it was found that the results were an error – an artifact introduced in the experimental setup. Initial skepticism was vindicated.

The claims made for a machine that can provide thrust without propellant is as unlikely and at variance with the laws of physics as neutrinos traveling faster than light or free energy machines. Sure, it’s always possible that our understanding of the universe is incomplete in a way that allows for one of these phenomena to be true, but our current understanding calls for extreme initial skepticism. Such a stance has a very good history to support it.

I find the whole thing a very fun idea. If it’s true and this impossible drive actually works, not only will it revolutionize satellite and space station design, it could have a major impact on deep space exploration with ripples into our basic understanding of the universe. If it isn’t true and it doesn’t work, it will certainly impel some re-thinking of how we go about designing experiments.

117 comments

Stragglers

Amazing as it may be there are still primaries for Senate seats yet to be held: Kansas, Tennessee, Hawaii, and Alaska. RealClearPolitics handicaps the outcomes.

0 comments

Remarkable Restraint

When I saw the slug on this historical article, “Did First Lady Kill President Harding?”, my immediate reaction was the follow-up question: “And if not why not?” If she didn’t have a hand in his death, it certainly showed remarkable restraint on her part. An interesting story about our worst president.

0 comments