Reminder About Foreign Policy

I’ve told this anecdote often enough but it bears repeating. When I was in college I had a year-long argument with my professor of American Diplomatic History about whether the United States had a foreign policy or not. He said it didn’t; I said it did.

I didn’t have the vocabulary to express it succinctly then but I do now. U. S. foreign policy, unlike that of many other countries, is an emergent phenomenon arrived at through the individual decisions of presidents, American politicians, diplomats, businessmen, and American consumers. We have a foreign policy. It’s just not a top-down policy.

To whatever extent we have a foreign policy one of its components is to keep the governments of neighboring countries weak. Our pilot project for that was Mexico and even the most generous reading of the interrelationship between our two countries reveals how hard we’ve worked on that project over the years.

We are now extending that policy throughout the world, something understandable in a world in which technology has brought nearly every country in the world closer in practice than Mexico was to us 50 years ago. We want weak governments everywhere. Except for here, of course.

Remember that when you read about the collapse of the Westphalian system. It didn’t jump. It’s being pushed and we’re the main pushers.

And just for reference we don’t make war with the Mafia. We don’t enter into negotiations or declare truces with them. There’s a real danger in starting to treat NGOs the way we would states.

11 comments

Economic Ex-Lax

In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal George P. Schultz proposes four steps “to get America moving again”. They are:

  • A resest on the personal income tax system with fewer, lower deductions, i.e. “loopholes”, and lower marginal rates.
  • Bringing the corporate income tax into line with prevailing international practices.
  • Streamlining the regulatory system.
  • Putting the Federal Reserve on a rules-based regime.

His proposals remind me strongly of the column I wrote about a couple of days ago. You’d think his proposals were commonsensical and would attract bipartisan support but, alas, no.

As a group they are proposals that might attract Republican support, indeed might even be a Republican wish-list, but would be castigated by many Democrats as helping the rich, corporations, unleashing poisons on the American people, and snake oil.

We are long overdue for an overhaul of our personal income tax system. Tax systems are like ships. They leave the boatyard bright, shiny, and slick but after many years are covered with barnacles that slow progress to a crawl. You would think that corporate “inversions” would spur action. I mean action other than insisting on loyalty oaths as, for example, getting into line with the corporate tax laws of the United Kingdom, France, and Germany just to name a few.

I have been proposing simplification of our regulatory system for decades. Federal regulations alone run to nearly a quarter of a million pages while state and local regulations contribute probably ten times as many. The upshot of that is that nobody understands our system of regulations. Asserting that simplification is impossible or undesireable is absurd on its face.

And, of course, with a rules-based regime there would be little need for a Federal Reserve board. I can hear the howls of protest from here.

Go ahead, Congress! It’s chocolate-flavored.

20 comments

Doing Something

The editors of the Washington Post hale President Obama’s decision to bomb ISIS in Iraq:

PRESIDENT OBAMA was right to order military action to prevent a potential genocide in northern Iraq and to stop forces of the al-Qaeda-derived Islamic State from advancing on Baghdad or the Kurdish capital of Irbil.

but criticize his lack of a coherent strategy for the Middle East:

However, the steps the president authorized on Thursday amount to more of his administration’s half-measures, narrowly tailored to this week’s emergency and unconnected to any coherent strategy to address the conflagration spreading across the Middle East.

I don’t think they’re looking at the big picture. The president has a coherent strategy it’s just not a foreign policy strategy. It’s a political strategy.

The president is under intense political pressure from some quarters to do something. Bomb strikes against ISIS are something. He’s under equally intense political pressure not to do anything that might be effective, e.g. sending troops, and that pressure is coming from among others his political base.

Under the circumstances ineffectual bombing is probably his best political strategy.

2 comments

The Legal Question

Ilya Somin critiques the legal justifications for President Obama’s use of force against ISIS in Iraq:

US airstrikes ISIS in Iraq have now begun. There may well be good moral and strategic rationales for the president’s action. But there are still serious questions about his legal authority to order it. There are several possible legal justifications for the airstrikes. But none can justify more than very limited military action without additional congressional authorization.

The Obama administration has not yet put forward an official legal rationale for its actions. Cornell professor Sarah Kreps predicts that it will probably rely on the president’s inherent powers as commander in chief of the armed forces under Article II of the Constitution. If it is adopted, this theory is vulnerable to the objections I made in my last post. The commander-in-chief Clause makes the president the highest ranking general and admiral, but does not give him the power to initiate war without congressional authorization.

Perhaps the president would not need congressional authorization if all he seeks to do is protect US personnel already in Iraq from attack. But The President’s speech last night clearly indicates that he intends to go beyond this, as he also emphasized the need to prevent ISIS’ attempted genocide of the Yazidi minority. Michael Ramsey, a leading academic expert on constitutional war powers, reaches a similar conclusion (see here and here).

As I noted in my earlier post, congressional authorization might not be required for very small-scale airstrikes that are not extensive enough to qualify as a war. So far, I don’t think that threshold has yet been crossed. But there is a real chance it will be soon.

The whole post is worth reading. Reader’s Digest version: as I said in my previous post, the president is not on particularly solid legal ground here.

3 comments

Lang’s Prescription

Although I frequently disagree with Pat Lang’s prescriptions since I respect his opinion so deeply I always take his analysis of situations in the Middle East seriously. Here’s Col. Lang’s prescription for Iraq:

An insurgent force that can; wage propaganda war, has lots of money, a coherent ideology and the ability to organize and operate armored kampfgruppen (battle groups) is a very dangerous opponent. IMO that force potentially threatens the state system throughout the Sunni Middle East and is a menace that must be halted.

To build an effective local coalition of forces against IS (a concert of the Middle East?) one must stop trying to unseat the existing governments. They are the only possible basis for such a coalition; Iran, Turkey, whatever government exists in Iraq, Jordan, Syria (Bashar), Egypt, Kuwait (for the basing), Saudi Arabia (for the money and basing), Qatar (for the basing). Unfortunately, to bring these forces together, Obama’s government would have to acknowledge the folly of its college bull session foreign policy over the last six years.

6 comments

Glamorous

I think I’d want to add at least one additional woman to Virginia Postrel’s list of women who “helped to define by their example what it meant to be a ‘modern woman'” and it’s someone who might surprise you: Ethel Barrymore.

Most of us who know who she was remember Ethel Barrymore, sister of John and Lionel, as a regal dowager in movies of the 1940s like The Farmer’s Daughter, The Paradine Case, and (a favorite of mine) Portrait of Jennie. However, forty years before when she was the toast of Broadway (pictured at left) a phrase was coined to describe her: glamor girl. She was the original glamor girl. For that reason alone she’s worth a mention.

1 comment

But That Was a Good Inversion

Apparently there are inversions and inversions. As you may recall an “inversion” is when a company changes its corporate headquarters in search of a lower tax liability. Recently, President Obama condemned inversions by U. S. companies:

Here’s what the president said at a press conference yesterday: “You have accountants going to some big corporations–multinational corporations but that are clearly U.S.-based and have the bulk of their operations in the United States–and these accountants are saying, you know what, we found a great loophole–if you just flip your citizenship to another country, even though it’s just a paper transaction, we think we can get you out of paying a whole bunch of taxes.”

However, Bloomberg reported a bit of irony:

President Barack Obama says U.S. corporations that adopt foreign addresses to avoid taxes are unpatriotic. His own administration helped one $20 billion American company do just that.

As part of the bailout of the auto industry in 2009, Obama’s Treasury Department authorized spending $1.7 billion of government funds to get a bankrupt Michigan parts-maker back on its feet — as a British company. While executives continue to run Delphi Automotive Plc (DLPH) from a Detroit suburb, the paper headquarters in England potentially reduces the company’s U.S. tax bill by as much as $110 million a year.

This might be a good time to recall Ralph Waldo Emerson’s dictum that a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds. Little minds are clearly not a problem for the Obama Administration.

1 comment

The Meta-Law

When I say “meta-law” I mean the philosophical underpinnings of the law. Here in the United States the Constitution is the law of the land but the meta-law includes things like the Declaration of Independence. I’m sure you’re familiar with the opening lines of the Declaration:

When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.

The emphasis is mine.

Other countries are based on blood kinship, long history, a common religion, or even accident. The United States, as G. K. Chesterton so aptly put it, is a country founded on a creed. Part of the creed is “a decent respect to the opinions of mankind”. That’s one of the reasons that I believe we should have good reasons for the things that we do and be willing to explain them to the world. It’s part of our DNA, our creed. Our meta-law.

0 comments

The Disaster in Libya

Speaking of going to war, the editors of the Washington Post warn of the increasingly desperate situation in Libya that we are studiedly ignoring:

U.S. and Western responsibility for this mess is heavy. Having tipped the outcome of the war against the Gaddafi regime, NATO quickly exited Libya, which was left with no army or political institutions but was awash in weapons. Repeated Libyan requests for assistance in restoring security were brushed off; a small-scale NATO training program based outside the country was little more than symbolic. As in the case of Afghanistan, Congress rejected the Obama administration’s aid requests.

Libya’s attempt to establish a working democracy, meanwhile, was overtaken by infighting among militias, which slowly polarized along an Islamist-secular divide. Libyans appear to prefer secular government: Islamists fared poorly in a parliamentary election held in June. But their military forces, which include a militia from the coastal city of Misurata as well as Ansar al-Sharia, are formidable.

The Obama administration has done its best to ignore Libya’s collapse, even as Republicans in Congress obsess over conspiracy theories about the 2012 Benghazi attack. Administration officials continue to peddle the empty line that “Libya’s challenges can really only be solved by the Libyans themselves,” as Secretary of State John F. Kerry put it this week. Officials point to the newly elected parliament, which convened in the eastern city of Tobruk last weekend, as a possible vehicle for a political settlement.

It’s hard to decide which is more fanciful: the idea that there is some incipient “working democracy” in Libya struggling to get out or that we will intervene to end the chaos there. Liberal democracies are built on institutions and Libya does not possess the institutions that form the foundations for a liberal democracy and can’t develop them quickly. It would take years. Generations. The situation there has always been a contest between warring factions and the only thing that we’ve accomplished is to side temporarily with one of the factions, just long enough to produce chaos.

No one has ever built a nation or even stabilized one from an altitude of 30,000 feet. Air power can do a lot but those are things it can’t do and it’s pretty darned hard for me to imagine the U. S., NATO, or the UN intervening in Libya with a ground force powerful enough and with a mandate to bring order and stability out of the chaos we had a hand in creating.

7 comments

At War With ISIS

President Obama has authorized airstrikes against ISIS, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, the notional “caliphate”, to protect our consulate in Erbil and, if necessary, our embassy in Baghdad:

President Obama authorized airstrikes “if necessary” against Islamic militants if they move toward Erbil in northern Iraq where American military, diplomats and civilians are stationed.

During a late night statement Thursday from the White House, the president said he’s okayed “targeted airstrikes to protect our American personnel and a humanitarian effort to help save thousands of Iraqi civilians who are trapped on a mountain without food and water and facing almost certain death.”

Mr. Obama explained that the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) in recent days has “continued to move across Iraq and have neared the city of Erbil, where American diplomats and civilians serve at our consulate and American military personnel advise Iraqi forces to stop the advance on Erbil.

ISIS is presently consolidating the areas of Iraq it presently controls and slowly extending that control. At some point I strongly suspect it is likely to move on Baghdad. In the areas it controls it is exterminating Christians. The surviving members of the small Iraqi Yezidi sect are now besieged on a mountaintop. If there were ever a case for a responsibility to protect this is it.

The Security Council has not authorized military action by the United States in Iraq and, unless it does or until it threatens our consulate in Erbil directly, military action by the U. S. in Iraq will be on shaky legal ground. IIRC it wasn’t too long ago that many were urging us to stay out of the conflict in Iraq. If they change their views once the president has authorized the use of force, the will abandon any pretext of coherence.

Just to make my own views clear I think that President Bush’s decision to invade Iraq was an error, the treaty he negotiated with the Maliki government was an error, and President Obama’s adherence to that agreement was an error. Contrary to the president’s assertions of just a few years ago Iraq is clearly not stable and is not able to defend itself. The editors of the Wall Street Journal concur:

For President Obama, any decision to reinforce the Iraqis or Kurds will be painful. On Thursday night he still took credit for removing all U.S. forces from Iraq in 2011. He was at pains to reassure Americans that the U.S. will not fight another war in Iraq even as he committed U.S. air power to the war that continues in Iraq.

It’s clear now that his decision to withdraw all U.S. troops in 2011 was a strategic and increasingly a moral disaster. The President—which is to say the United States—bears responsibility now for the humanitarian catastrophe occurring in Iraq, just as it did for the mass flight of Vietnam’s boat people, some two million, after the Communist triumph in the 1970s.

Before using force in Iraq, the president should seek Congressional authorization and gain the support of the American people. Don’t be gulled into believing that ISIS’s progress can be stopped with air power alone.

45 comments