All Is Well

I recommend that you read Oliver Sacks’s announcement of his impending death. As you are probably aware Dr. Sacks is a well-known neurologist. Among his many best-selling books is Awakenings which was adapted into the movie of the same name starring Robin Williams and Robert De Niro. Here’s a snippet of the op-ed:

I have been increasingly conscious, for the last 10 years or so, of deaths among my contemporaries. My generation is on the way out, and each death I have felt as an abruption, a tearing away of part of myself. There will be no one like us when we are gone, but then there is no one like anyone else, ever. When people die, they cannot be replaced. They leave holes that cannot be filled, for it is the fate — the genetic and neural fate — of every human being to be a unique individual, to find his own path, to live his own life, to die his own death.

I cannot pretend I am without fear. But my predominant feeling is one of gratitude. I have loved and been loved; I have been given much and I have given something in return; I have read and traveled and thought and written. I have had an intercourse with the world, the special intercourse of writers and readers.

I was reminded of a passage from Camus’s The Myth of Sisyphus:

If the descent is thus sometimes performed in sorrow, it can also take place in joy. This word is not too much. Again I fancy Sisyphus returning toward his rock, and th sorrow was in the beginning. When the images of earth cling too tightly to memory, when the call of happiness becomes too insistent, it happens that melancholy rises in man’s heart: this is the rock’s victory, this is the rock itself. The boundless grief is too heavy to bear. These are our nights of Gethsemane. But crushing truths perish from being acknowledged. Thus, Oedipus at the outset obeys fate without knowing it. But from the moment he knows, his tragedy begins. Yet at the same time, blind and desperate, he realizes that the only bond linking him to the world is the cool hand of a girl. Then a tremendous remark rings out: “Despite so many ordeals, my advanced age and the nobility of my soul make me conclude that all is well.” Sophocles’ Oedipus, like Dostoevsky’s Kirilov, thus gives the recipe for the absurd victory. Ancient wisdom confirms modern heroism.

Don’t be put off by the subject matter. It may be the most optimistic and life-affirming thing you read all day.

4 comments

21st Century Electroplating

For all of you metallurgists out there, a new nanotechnology approach to fabrication with metals that’s being placed in operation now could have far-reaching implications:

An inexpensive new process can increase the strength of metals such as steel by as much as 10 times, and make them much more resistant to corrosion. If the modified metals pass field testing, the new process could go on to make bridges and other infrastructure last far longer; it could also make cars lighter and therefore more fuel-efficient.

The Seattle-based startup that developed the process, Modumetal, is commercializing it in part with collaboration with the oil companies Chevron, Conoco-Philips, and Hess.

Parts made using the technology are being tested in oil fields now. Some oil contains highly corrosive chemicals such as hydrogen sulfide that quickly damage production equipment. The new technology could make those parts last much longer and thus lower the cost of pursuing unconventional sources of oil. That could be just the first of a wide range of applications.

Basically, the approach is that a metal part is placed in a chemical bath that contains ions of multiple different metals. Then the current that’s applied is varied to create a designed, layered structure.

This is really sexy stuff, folks. It means that things could be made with a lot less actual metal or with controlled and very interesting properties. Not only could that make them lighter and possibly less expensive but, depending on the metals used and the structure that’s created, they could be corrosion-resistant and significantly stronger. Think of the aircraft, land and ocean-going vehicles, and buildings that could be built. Think of the tanks or weaponry. Lots of possibilities here.

Hat tip: Instapundit

7 comments

Annals of Marketing

Who could possibly have known that calling their promotional club for kids the “Krispy Kreme Klub” would have provoked some outrage? I mean other than literate people or people who’ve been alive for more than ten years. I guess that’s outside the company’s demographic.

0 comments

How Illinois Could Declare Bankruptcy

In what I would take as the first (but not the last!) article to examine the issue of whether Illinois will be able to evade its responsibility for paying public employees the pensions they’ve been promised by declaring bankruptcy, Michael S. Greve, writing at Library of Law and Liberty, remarks:

A committee of the U.S. House of Representatives is considering a bill that would make Chapter 9 available to Puerto Rico’s public agencies. Those agencies carry upwards of $70 billion in debt; their bonds trade at something like 60 cents on the dollar. Existing bankruptcy law doesn’t cover them. The pending bill would change that, but it has little chance of enactment. (Some Republicans are opposed.) I don’t know the details but I’m inclined to favor the bill. The real question here is who is not going to get paid, and how and when. The sooner that gets resolved, the better.

Meanwhile up north in Illinois (politically and economically a kind of Puerto Rico without surf but, huzzah, with statehood) the legislature is considering proposals that would make it easier for municipal governments (including large-ish Chicago) to avail themselves of Chapter 9. Here, too, the question is who will not get paid. That includes not only creditors but also, and foremost, current and former public employees, whose pension and other post-employment benefits are wreaking havoc on local finances. The move to restructure—i.e., partially abrogate—those debts in Chapter 9 proceedings is prompted in no small measure by Stockton’s experience: earlier this month, the city obtained judicial approval for its bankruptcy plan. Creditors took a small hit; the unions, a very large one. Like, a cool half-billion.

That’s just about all there is to the post.

IMO bankruptcy protection should be extended to the states but the need for it would be rare which explains why no state, even the poorest, a characterization which certainly doesn’t include Illinois, at least not yet, has never needed to declare bankruptcy even in the bleakest of economic circumstances, as for example Mississippi after the American Civil War. I do not believe that extending the possibility of bankruptcy protection to states would help Illinois.

Illinois’s problem is political not fiscal and bankruptcy protection is not the tool that will protect Illinois’s legislators from the consequences of their own folly. There are all sorts of measures they could take

  • They could amend the state’s constitution. In Illinois for practical purpose only the legislature can do that.
  • They could cut other spending. Admittedly, as the pension obligations rise that is becoming harder to do.
  • They could raise taxes. My opinion is that raising rates is unlikely to result in enough revenue to plug the hole but it’s at least theoretically possible.
  • They could take much more serious steps to curtail the pension benefits of future public employees. Its name is legion.

and that’s just off the top of my head. Why don’t the legislators do any of those? The answer is simple: because it might cost them their jobs. Bankruptcy is not the right tool to insure legislators against needing to make difficult, unpopular decisions. That’s what they’re elected to do and sometimes you’ve just got to grasp the nettle as me auld mither used to say.

2 comments

The Opinion on Immigration

Can someone express an informed opinion about the Texas judge’s decision to enjoin the president’s actions on immigration that hit the news yesterday? Do the state’s have standing? Does the judge have a reasonable point? I think he’s pretty much definitionally engaging in “activism from the bench” (using the definition that an activist judge is one who decides a politically-wrought question in a way you don’t like).

I really don’t know what to think. I do think that a difference in degree is a difference in kind which is something that doesn’t seem to have occurred either to the president or those who support him.

Update

The editors of the Washington Post express their opinions:

TO THINK, as we do, that President Obama overstepped his authority by shielding more than 4 million illegal immigrants from deportation, with no assent from Congress, does not mean that a federal judge should have license to invalidate the president’s order on the basis of tendentious logic.

Yet that’s the effect of a ruling Monday by U.S. District Judge Andrew S. Hanen in Brownsville, Tex., whose well documented distaste for the Obama administration’s immigration policies explains why similarly predisposed Republican-led states turned to him for relief.

The judge, in issuing an injunction blocking the president’s order from taking effect, reached no conclusion on the constitutionality of Mr. Obama’s executive order — although there’s little doubt where he would come out on that question.

[…]

Putting aside the slapdash guesswork involved at arriving at the dollar cost of issuing driver’s licenses to an unknown number of prospective applicants — or the “harm” it would inflict on Texas and its $100 billion annual budget — the logic falls flat. By the judge’s reasoning, practically every immigration action by the federal government could be said to impose a cost of some sort on the states, and could therefore provide a basis for a lawsuit.

I’m no lawyer but I do think that the states should have the right to challenge federal actions that impose financial burdens on them, especially when the burdens are as high as those the president’s November proclamation are likely to impose. I’d be interested in the case law but, again, a difference in degree can be a difference in kind.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal put their opinions this way:

Our own view is that under dual federal-state sovereignty, states consent to such pre-emption via their representation in Congress, but the executive isn’t allowed to change the terms of this bargain except through duly enacted legislation under Article I.

Keep in mind that the editors of the WSJ in effect support open borders between Mexico and the United States. Under the circumstances that’s actually a pretty strong statement from them.

12 comments

The Difference Between Fear and Concern

On a subject related to my last post, see this post at the Daily Beast titled “Italy Fears ISIS Invasion From Libya”:

ROME — Last weekend in Italy, as the threat of ISIS in Libya hit home with a new video addressed to “the nation signed with the blood of the cross” and the warning, “we are south of Rome,” Italian prime minister Matteo Renzi shuttered up the Italian embassy in Tripoli and raised his fist with the threat of impending military action. Never mind that Italy has only 5,000 troops available that are even close to deployable, according to the defense ministry. Or that the military budget was cut by 40 percent two years ago, which has kept the acquisition of 90 F-35 fighter jets hanging in the balance and left the country combat-challenged to lead any mission—especially one against an enemy like the Islamic State.

Italian officials might be afraid or “panicking” but they’re exhibiting a puzzling lack of concern. When you’re concerned about your house catching fire, you could have your wiring checked, replace flammable items with flame retardant ones, or even purchase insurance. When you’re terrified, you tell people how frightened you are rather than taking prudent measures.

Italy, like Germany, Belgium, and Denmark, hasn’t lived up to its NATO commitments in decades. If it had, it would have more than 5,000 deployable troops. Times a’wastin’.

Hat tip: memeorandum

1 comment

Responses to Graeme Woods’s Article

There’s a vibrant dialogue going on in the blogosphere about the Atlantic article I linked to yesterday. The views being expressed cover a whole range of reactions from “he’s wrong” to “he’s right but” to “he’s right and”. On the rejection end of the spectrum is this article from Raw Story:

In September, Nihad Awad, the executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), held a press conference in Washington and, flanked by other Muslim figures, announced that 120 Muslim scholars had produced an 18-page open letter, written in Arabic, to ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.

An English translation of the document is a tough slog. As Awad said at the time, “This letter is not meant for a liberal audience.” He even admitted that mainstream Muslims might find it difficult to read.

The letter is an extended exegesis, heavily salted with quotes from the Koran and the Hadith, arguing point by point about the nature of jihad, the slaughtering of innocents, the taking of slaves, and other not-so-savory elements of the distant past — and in the past they should remain, the text argues. It makes the case not only that ISIS was wrong to commit horrific acts of violence in modern times, but that it was interpreting Islamic law incorrectly to justify such acts.

[…]

I was curious, however, what Nihad Awad might make of Wood’s article, since he had gone to so much trouble last year to argue the exact opposite.

[…]

When I reached Awad yesterday, he hadn’t seen the article yet. When I described it over the phone, he reacted immediately by saying, “This is an outrageous statement, an ignorant statement.”

He then asked for some time to read the article in its entirety, and then we spoke again later last night.

“This piece is misleading because it’s full of factual mistakes,” Awad said. “Mistakes are all over it.”

He blamed Graeme Wood for trying to grasp things he wasn’t qualified to understand.

I’m in no position to affirm or deny Mr. Awad’s remarks but consider them carefully. Note that he doesn’t say that the article is wrong. What he’s doing is something very lawyerly that might be thought of as “mau-mauing in detail”. He’s attacking the entire article on the basis of individual factual or textual errors that may or may not refute the article’s thesis and, in true post-modernist style, denying Mr. Woods’s authenticity. In terms of classic rhetoric that’s an argumentum ad hominem which does not refute the veracity of the article.

Next in the apologetics spectrum is this post at The Moderate Voice from front page poster “Prairie Weather”:

Take a look — even if it’s just a quick glance –at Graeme Wood’s article on “What Isis really wants.” Not so much difference between Isis and Christian fundamentalists there within.

[…]

I think we helped to create ISIS. We would almost certainly be responsible for making things worse, not better, if we were to rush in there and start sawing on their necks. We’d surely be setting up a situation in which a new generation of young Muslims, radicalized, would aim their wrath and resentment at our grandchildren. Already they know more about us than we know about them.

This is all about bigotry and racism on both sides. Let’s not kid ourselves about that.

tu quoque fallacy. It says nothing about the true or falsehood of Mr. Graeme’s article. It’s irrelevant.

And with respect to the Lord’s Army I have no problem in saying they’re not Christians. In my tradition it takes more than saying that you’re a Christian to be a Christian. To be a Christian you must imitate Christ and whatever Jesus of Nazareth did he certainly didn’t lead an army that committed atrocities.

Although Juan Cole doesn’t mention Mr. Woods’s article or link to it he certainly must have it in mind in his most recent post in which he denies seven “myths” about Islam. Dr. Cole’s post is worth reading but, ultimately, I think that his political views overwhelm his thesis. His thesis is that DAESH is a criminal gang, its power and influence are “smoke and mirrors”, and it will soon collapse. He does provide some good advice for the administration, however:

Politicians should just stop promising to extirpate the group. Brands can’t be destroyed, and Daesh is just a brand for the most part.

IMO DAESH is a bit more than a brand; it’s a network organization and a pretty effective one that we’re just not prepared to cope with.

Also, I’m troubled by Dr. Cole’s reliance on proportions as an important consideration:

Actually, the numbers are quite small proportionally. British PM David Cameron ominously warned that 400 British Muslim youth had gone off to fight in Syria. But there are like 3.7 million Muslims in the UK now! So .01 percent of the community volunteered.

I’m troubled by it for two reasons. First, .01 of the 1.6 billion Muslims is 160,000 people. That’s a lot of people whatever their proportion might be. Second, in the present age of super-empowerment 160,000 people can wreak a lot of havoc. It’s not comforting, it’s dismaying.

On the affirming side of the spectrum is James Joyner’s post at OTB:

Unlike al Qaeda or even the Soviet Union, whose leadership mostly manipulated religious or secular ideology to gain support for secular, political goals, Bagdadi and company are true believers. They literally can’t compromise. So, short of killing every last one of them—which is perhaps a futile exercise, given the nature of martyrdom, the best we can hope for is to help them fail at their own game while keeping the lightest footprint possible.

There’s the usual heated discussion going on in comments there. In comments Lounsbury remarks:

Rubbish. The sheer messianic lunacy of DAESH is widely alienating.

As usual his comments are well worth reading. At one point Lounsbury was a frequent commenter here and his blog, now dormant, is in my thrifty blogroll. If I’m not mistaken, he’s an Anglo-American financier living in Morocco, fluent in Arabic and pretty well informed on issues relating to the Middle East and North Africa and especially those affecting finance.

The best reaction piece I’ve read so far was by Adam Silverman and posted at Balloon Juice:

John asked me for my take on Graeme Woods’ article “What ISIS Really Wants.” Before I start I want to make it clear that my understanding of Islam is that of an informed outsider. I have been studying Islam, or portions of it, since I was an undergraduate and conducted fieldwork for the US Army in Iraq that dealt with both religious and tribal identity. I have published articles dealing with jihad and shahadat, as well as the tribal and religious identity and its effects on US operations in Iraq.** I was even fortunate enough to have a counterpart cultural advisor who was both Muslim and had an advanced degree in Islamic Law and Jurisprudence that I could rely on as a resource to verify if I was correct in my understanding and interpretation of his religion. As I liked to say when I would brief on these, and related subjects, everything I am telling you is true and verifiable, except where it isn’t because I’m an outsider trying to make sense of someone else’s religion.

Overall I think Woods’ article is quite good and I highly recommend you click over and read it before proceeding. It is thought provoking and makes a number of points explicit that have rarely ever been made implicit regarding ISIS. For example, the millennial and apocalyptic components to ISIS’s theology. Woods also has an excellent section dealing with ISIS’s refreshing and recontextualizing long dormant components of Islamic theology and dogma. I was also impressed that Woods took the time to make it clear that al Qaeda was a logistic, support, and training network much more than it was structured like a company. One of the biggest errors in understanding al Qaeda over the past decade came out of the attempts to understand al Qaeda as a corporation or conglomerate.

He goes on to expand on the concept, important among Sunni Muslims, of ijma, usually translated “consensus”, to make the point that you can’t really say that there’s one, monolithic Islamic theology but that dogma, doctrine, and practice all vary from community to community and that Mr. Woods’s neglect of that point is a deficiency in his article. What’s the “Muslim mainstream”? Does the very idea have any meaning? Where does DAESH fit into Muslim thought? Read the whole thing. It’s very enlightening.

10 comments

The Word on DAESH

I’d like to commend a pair of articles on the “Islamic State”, DAESH to your attention. The first is an article in Atlantic by Graeme Wood on DAESH’s objectives:

Ideological tools may convince some potential converts that the group’s message is false, and military tools can limit its horrors. But for an organization as impervious to persuasion as the Islamic State, few measures short of these will matter, and the war may be a long one, even if it doesn’t last until the end of time.

It seems to me that one of the problems that Western secularists have in understanding DAESH is that they refuse to believe that it’s possible for people to be genuinely sincere about religious conviction. I think that points to a serious defect in Western secularists, a strategic weakness.

The present prevailing wisdom seems to be that DAESH will burn itself out because it can’t govern. Neither could the Ottoman, the last caliphate. That only troubled the West for the better part of a millennium. Only a few million people lost their lives in the wars that ensued from the 15th to the 19th centuries. With modern technology I’m sure DAESH can improve on that.

The other is from USA Today:

WASHINGTON – Since exploding onto the world stage as a conquering force in Iraq a year ago, the Islamic State has expanded its reach across the Middle East despite a U.S.-led bombing campaign that has killed thousands of militants and destroyed tons of their equipment.

Monday, Egypt launched an airstrike against Islamic State targets in neighboring Libya after the terrorist group posted a video of militants beheading a group of Egyptian Christians.

This month, U.S. forces killed a former Taliban leader in southern Afghanistan who had sworn allegiance to the Islamic State weeks earlier. The Pentagon said the group’s presence in Afghanistan was nascent but demonstrated its global aspirations.

Signs of the Islamic State have emerged throughout the Middle East. Some extremists in the Sinai, where militants battle the Egyptian government, have sworn allegiance to the Islamic State. Groups affiliated with the militant organization have popped up in Algeria and Tunisia.

The beheadings and burnings that have shocked the West and rallied some Middle Eastern governments to oppose the Islamic extremists have appealed to young Muslims willing to fight the West or what they perceive as corrupt Arab governments.

My view is that DAESH is likely to be a nuisance to the United States, dangerous to Europe, and an existential threat to a number of our notional allies in the Middle East and North Africa. I wouldn’t equate DAESH with Islam but I do think it represents a disease that is endemic in Islam.

11 comments

It’s Still There

Despite its absence from the newspapers and the nightly news report the ebola outbreak in West Africa is still ongoing. It’s been more than a week since the last situation report from the World Health Organization but to my eye the trend suggested by the last several situation reports suggests a disease that has gone from epidemic to endemic. The total number of cases is still mounting and the total number of deaths is still mounting.

It’s better than when the cases and deaths were rising exponentially but it’s still not good news.

2 comments

It’s Their Business

In reaction to the terrorist attack in Copenhagen over the weekend, the editors of the Wall Street Journal declaim:

Stopping terrorism from becoming normal will also require describing accurately the jihadist threat. The Obama Administration in the U.S. has refused to identify Islamism—or even “Islamic extremism”—as the ideology behind the recent attacks on the Continent and the horrors in Syria and Iraq. Such obfuscation doesn’t help moderate and reformist Muslims, whose cooperation is essential to defeating jihadists. Copenhagen can set a counterterror example by calling the enemy by its name.

It’s not just terrorism our European cousins need worry about. violent crime, generally, has risen rapidly there over the last forty years even as it has declined here.

I’ll repeat what I’ve said before: the traditionally ethnic states of Europe need to decide what sort of countries they wish to be and take the steps to insure that’s what they become. One size won’t fit all and the various countries will need to make their own decisions. It’s up to them. It’s none of my business.

8 comments