I can’t help but wonder in reading Robert Samuelson’s lament for the small returns to consumers from investments in information technology:
In a recent essay, economic historian John Komlos of the University of Munich argues that the economic value of new technologies has declined over time. A century or so ago, “the incandescent bulb replaced the kerosene lamp, and the value added [to national income] as well as to welfare in terms of reliability, convenience, health and safety [was] humongous,†he writes.
Similar transformations stemmed from many 19th- and 20th-century technologies: steel-making, the telephone, automobiles, airplanes, antibiotics, and radio and television.
The same is not true of much information technology, Komlos argues. Consider Facebook. “While social networking facilitated by Facebook is a popular feature of the Internet, basically it merely replaces older ways of socializing without adding much to our feeling of well-being,†he writes. “It monetized activities that were for the most part left previously outside of the market’s purview.â€
why he’s selected information technology as his whipping boy? I agree with the general proposition: consumers aren’t realizing the surplus from technological innovation the way they did a century ago. Producers are. The entire question might be summed up as where are our flying cars? Or, alternatively, the future ain’t what it used to be.
However, the real place to look isn’t at information technology but at healthcare. It would take some convincing before I believed that the aggregate amount (in real dollars) that the federal government has spent on information technology research over the last 50 years amounts to what it pays to support the NIH each year ($26 billion). The Internet itself was invented on a government investment of less than $1 million. And I suspect that if you took the aggregate public and private amount that’s been spent on information technology research over the last forty years it’s dwarfed by what is spent on healthcare every single year. Are we that much healthier than we were in 1970? Life expectancy has only gone up by about 10% over the period and I’d attribute a lot of that to the reduction in smoking which is not healthcare. Said another way the return on investment in information technology has been pretty darned good while the ROI on healthcare is extremely small.
So, where are our flying cars? We’ve decided to spend the money on a few extra days or weeks of vegetative life for the elderly instead (that’s where a good chunk of the healthcare dough is spent—the last weeks of life).
However, the explanation I’d provide fits information technology and healthcare equally well. What we’re seeing is exactly what you’d expect when the government protects and subsidizes providers and relies on the providers to look out for the interests of consumers from the goodness of their hearts, for ethical reasons, and so on. Producers capture most of the surplus.






