Where Are Our Flying Cars?

I can’t help but wonder in reading Robert Samuelson’s lament for the small returns to consumers from investments in information technology:

In a recent essay, economic historian John Komlos of the University of Munich argues that the economic value of new technologies has declined over time. A century or so ago, “the incandescent bulb replaced the kerosene lamp, and the value added [to national income] as well as to welfare in terms of reliability, convenience, health and safety [was] humongous,” he writes.

Similar transformations stemmed from many 19th- and 20th-century technologies: steel-making, the telephone, automobiles, airplanes, antibiotics, and radio and television.

The same is not true of much information technology, Komlos argues. Consider Facebook. “While social networking facilitated by Facebook is a popular feature of the Internet, basically it merely replaces older ways of socializing without adding much to our feeling of well-being,” he writes. “It monetized activities that were for the most part left previously outside of the market’s purview.”

why he’s selected information technology as his whipping boy? I agree with the general proposition: consumers aren’t realizing the surplus from technological innovation the way they did a century ago. Producers are. The entire question might be summed up as where are our flying cars? Or, alternatively, the future ain’t what it used to be.

However, the real place to look isn’t at information technology but at healthcare. It would take some convincing before I believed that the aggregate amount (in real dollars) that the federal government has spent on information technology research over the last 50 years amounts to what it pays to support the NIH each year ($26 billion). The Internet itself was invented on a government investment of less than $1 million. And I suspect that if you took the aggregate public and private amount that’s been spent on information technology research over the last forty years it’s dwarfed by what is spent on healthcare every single year. Are we that much healthier than we were in 1970? Life expectancy has only gone up by about 10% over the period and I’d attribute a lot of that to the reduction in smoking which is not healthcare. Said another way the return on investment in information technology has been pretty darned good while the ROI on healthcare is extremely small.

So, where are our flying cars? We’ve decided to spend the money on a few extra days or weeks of vegetative life for the elderly instead (that’s where a good chunk of the healthcare dough is spent—the last weeks of life).

However, the explanation I’d provide fits information technology and healthcare equally well. What we’re seeing is exactly what you’d expect when the government protects and subsidizes providers and relies on the providers to look out for the interests of consumers from the goodness of their hearts, for ethical reasons, and so on. Producers capture most of the surplus.

13 comments

The End of the Dream

Is it my imagination or is the administration’s narrative on DAESH preparing to collapse? Consider:

Iraq’s Sunni blocs halt parliament activities after sheikh’s killing
Tribal leader: Iraqi troops in Anbar could ‘collapse within hours’
Sunnis may exit Iraq parliament after sheik’s slaying
Military and ISIS Clash Over Iraqi Town Near a Base Housing U.S. Troops

Let’s engage in a little thought experiment, purely hypothetical. That the war against DAESH in Syria is a bust is now so obvious it can hardly be denied. What are the implications for U. S. policy if the war against DAESH in Iraq is revealed to be equally ineffective? Do we arm the Kurds in the recognition that whatever arms we give them may well be captured by DAESH? I doubt the Turks will think much of our arming the Kurds since those arms could well end up being turned against them. Does the rhetoric begin the transformation from “degrade and destroy” to “contain” to something else? What happens? That’s a question. I honestly don’t know.

5 comments

The Politics of Pensions

At Reason.com Steven Greenhut presents a status report on public pensions in California:

A newly published federal court decision found the California Public Employees’ Retirement System was merely banging the legal table with its “iron fist” in the Stockton bankruptcy case.

Judge Christopher Klein rejected the pension fund’s argument that California cities could not reduce pension benefits even in bankruptcy. The decision could dramatically change the way pensions are handled in future bankruptcy proceedings, even though the judge upheld the city’s workout plan, which leaves existing pensions untouched while “impairing” creditors.

The judge was clear: When California cities go bankrupt, pensions can be cut. After Klein made that point in his verbal ruling in October,CalPERS shot back in a statement: “The ruling is not legally binding on any of the parties … or as precedent in any other bankruptcy proceeding ….” Now it seems legally binding and precedential.

California Democrats have no one to blame but themselves for the fix that state and local governments find themselves in. If Illinois’s ruling Democrats had a lick of sense they’d seize the opportunity the election of Republican Bruce Rauner has presented them to place the blame for solving Illinois’s public pension problems on Rauner while continuing to posture on it. In other words they should fight but not too hard.

4 comments

Overrated

Just in time for President’s Day, Jonathan Bernstein takes note of the most overrated and underrated presidents:

My list of overrated would include Kennedy, Reagan and Wilson, and perhaps Jackson, but I’d add Jimmy Carter and Richard Nixon. For underrated, I usually say Grant, but I’ve also sometimes added Harding and Ford. I do wonder whether those suggesting that Ike and Truman are underrated are behind the curve by a few decades about how those presidents are viewed.

While I note that these lists are heavily colored by mythology and political affiliation, I think that certainly the most overrated president of my lifetime and probably one of the most overrated overall would have to be John Kennedy. I also a president who is conspicuous by his absence from the article. Where’s Lyndon Johnson?

When the glare of the Baby Boomers’ hatred of Lyndon Johnson (and their love for Kennedy) has passed, I think that flinty-eyed scrutiny will reveal that many of the worst aspects of the Kennedy-Johnson administration will be laid squarely at Jack Kennedy’s feet while some of the best of the period will be attributed to Johnson.

I found this interesting:

Barack Obama ranks mid-pack at 18th, just behind George H.W. Bush and ahead of James Polk. His average “overall greatness” rating, on a 0 to 100 scale, comes in at 58, just a bit above average. Obama scores well on “integrity,” but only a little above average on legislative, diplomatic and military skills. He’s also rated the second-most polarizing (behind George W. Bush).

IMO Obama’s star has already passed its zenith. He’ll always have his adherents but in 75 years when his strongest supporters have passed from the scene I strongly suspect that, right with George W. Bush, he’ll be considered a poor-to-mediocre president. I might be wrong but I won’t be around to see it.

4 comments

Mutton Dressed As Lamb

In his most recent column David Ignatius points out something I wish more Americans recognized:

But Kurdistan also has some mundane problems, starting with corruption. The country is run by traditional political parties dominated by the Barzani and Talabani clans, who have historically controlled the Kurdish Democratic Party (KDP) and the PUK, respectively. Having the right connections, and greasing them with some cash, has become a way of life here.

I am puzzled by the fascination that so many Americans seem to have with the Kurds. I think they’re being misled. Sure, the Kurds aren’t Arabs—they’re Indo-Europeans as are the Iranians. I can’t help but see the Kurds’ “political parties” as tribal factions gussied up in democratic trappings. IMO there are reasonable concerns that the Kurds are presenting a democratic sideshow rather than real liberal democracy and what we’re seeing is just clans, tribalism, and autocracy promoted as the seeds of a modern society.

4 comments

Intervene in Haste, Repent at Leisure

The editors of the New York Times in 2011:

There is no perfect formula for military intervention. It must be used sparingly — not in Bahrain or Yemen, even though we condemn the violence against protesters in both countries. Libya is a specific case: Muammar el-Qaddafi is erratic, widely reviled, armed with mustard gas and has a history of supporting terrorism. If he is allowed to crush the opposition, it would chill pro-democracy movements across the Arab world.

The editors of the New York Times today:

Libyans who have been fighting since the end of the 2011 civil war must take steps to reconcile and start the arduous process of building a functioning state. Western and regional leaders have limited time to put pressure on them by offering incentives and support for those willing to chart a new course. “Libya is falling apart. Politically, financially, the economic situation is disastrous,” Mr. León said. “I don’t think the country can bear a process of months.”

The collapse of civil order in Libya and the rise of Islamist groups and other criminals there was a foregone conclusion when the United States began its bombing campaign there in 2011, a campaign supported, admittedly reluctantly, by the Times’s editors. And today in 2015 if there are any “pro-democracy movements across the Arab world” they’ve gone underground. If the Times’s editors are sincere about their concern for Libya now, they should support whatever means might be required to effect their goals, regardless of the domestic political consequences. Anything else is magical thinking.

9 comments

The Heritability of Privilege

My concerns about the alleged “hereditary meritocracy” aren’t the same as Paul Caron’s:

Intellectual capital drives the knowledge economy, so those who have lots of it get a fat slice of the pie. And it is increasingly heritable. Far more than in previous generations, clever, successful men marry clever, successful women. Such “assortative mating” increases inequality by 25%, by one estimate, since two-degree households typically enjoy two large incomes. Power couples conceive bright children and bring them up in stable homes—only 9% of college-educated mothers who give birth each year are unmarried, compared with 61% of high-school dropouts. They stimulate them relentlessly: children of professionals hear 32m more words by the age of four than those of parents on welfare. They move to pricey neighbourhoods with good schools, spend a packet on flute lessons and pull strings to get junior into a top-notch college.

I have a number of problems with that including:

  • Not all smart people are well-to-do.
  • Not all well-to-do people are smart.
  • There is a natural predisposition to want your children to be at least as successful as you’ve been and to take steps to see that happens.
  • There’s a rising body of scholarship suggesting that emotional intelligence, social and emotional capabilities, are better predictors of success than cognitive abilities.
  • Emotional intelligence tends not to be tested for.
  • Emotional intelligence while apparently somewhat heritable is not as heritable as cognitive intelligence see here.
  • After two standard deviations there’s not much correlation between Q and financial success. There may even be an inverse correlation.

My SAT scores are the same as Bill Gates’s (but reversed). My income and wealth aren’t a hundredth of his.

In ancient China jobs in the massive civil bureaucracy were predicated on passing the civil service examination. That meant that in theory the smart kid of a peasant could get a guaranteed well-paying job for life. In practice the system was corrupted so that the children of the rich, regardless of innate ability, always passed. IMO that’s the way any “merit” system will inevitably work out.

10 comments

Message to New York Times: Butt Out

I’ve mentioned before that my practice is to keep my nose out of the political issues in states other than my own and out of those in countries other than my own for that matter. Judging by the recent editorial in the New York Times opposing Illinois Gov. Rauner’s move to oppose non-union members being forced to pay “fair share” taxes, 7/8s of which go to political contributions to politicians who support public employees’ unions, the Time’s editors are not nearly as discreet:

Allowing nonmembers to get union benefits without paying fair-share fees would tempt dues-paying members to drop out. Union coffers — and bargaining power — would be weakened. Ultimately, all working people would suffer, because collectively bargained pay increases in unionized workplaces tend to lift wages in nonunionized ones, as companies compete for employees. Anti-unionism, which has become increasingly entrenched in recent decades, correlates with stagnating and declining wages. As unions have been harmed, not only by market forces but by policies that deliberately weaken them, income has flowed increasingly to those at the top of the economic ladder rather than to workers.

For now, Governor Rauner has instructed state agencies not to deduct fair-share fees from employees’ paychecks. The unions are expected to challenge the governor’s order in court. The attorney general of Illinois, Lisa Madigan, has not supported the governor’s stance. She will have the opportunity to intervene in any lawsuits to defend state law against the governor’s overreach. The end game, however, is more likely to play out in the Supreme Court.

Nowhere in the Times editorial is there any hint of Illinois’s problems or how the Times’s editors would go about solving them. That is intellectually bankrupt and morally reprehensible. Either butt out or stand up to the plate, NYT.

The New York Times has staked out a unique position for itself as local New York City newspaper, national newspaper, and guardian of left of center shibboleths everywhere. Its editors might become better informed before sticking their noses into other states’ business.

Illinois has one of the lowest levels of state contribution to education in the nation. It has the lowest credit rating of any state. It has one of the worst public pension problems in the nation. Its ROI on federal tax dollars is the second to lowest of any state—lower than New York or California. It has the highest rate of outmigration of any state. When Illinois raised its income tax, revenues did not increase proportionally to the increase but flight from the state increased, suggesting that tax increases were not a solution to Illinois’s problems.

Public employees’ unions present a thorny issue with a number of competing rights including the right of association, the right to representation, the public’s right to fair and honest services, and the right to honest government. Political contributions from public employees’ unions from dues and “fair share” taxes collected through the power of the government effectively recycle tax dollars into political contributions and are inherently corrupt.

Gov. Rauner has thrown himself on the grenade and it will be up to the courts to sort it out. Unless they’re willing to propose a workable solution to Illinois’s public pension problems, the fruit of decades of political mis-, mal-, and nonfeasance in Illinois, the editors of the New York Times should stick to New York.

6 comments

The Unkindest Cut

Of all of the criticisms of President Obama’s 2015 National Security Strategy (and most reviews of it are negative, as I noted yesterday) perhaps the harshest comes from James Jeffrey in an op-ed in the Washington Post, not because of its invective (that prize would go to Larry Johnson which is why I included his remarks in my round-up) but because to my eye it is the most damaging.

There are two reasons for that. First, Mr. Jeffrey was an Obama appointee, the U. S. ambassador to Iraq from 2010 to 2012. And second because his op-ed argues that the intellectual underpinnings of the NSS are badly mistaken. He summarizes these as the president’s view that

  1. “those who use military force are destined for the ash heap of history because force is inherently counterproductive”.
  2. “if the United States acts militarily, it inevitably runs a serious risk of overcommitment and disaster”.
  3. “there is “no military solution” to anything”.
  4. “when required, and absent the most compelling security need, military action should be employed through coalitions and after applying diplomatic, economic and other tools, with legality and legitimacy as the guiding principles.”

Here are his retorts to these four “themes”:

The first theme violates a precept that all diplomats must learn: Don’t project your worldview onto others. Assumptions that military force is self-defeating have tragically been proved wrong time and again the world over.

Equally open to question are the linked themes of “no military solution” and “escalation into a morass.” The United States has used or threatened military force frequently since the 1940s. Only three times did we fail with significant costs: in North Korea, Vietnam and Iraq. Those conflicts demonstrated the folly of regime change and social engineering under fire but not the folly of military action per se. Most U.S. military operations during that time were successful, and completed at low cost, from Berlin to the Cuban embargo, the first Gulf War, Kosovo and Bosnia. Obama’s incessant warnings notwithstanding, the United States has generally been able to achieve its military aims without getting bogged down in costly conflicts.

Finally, “no military solution” is simply empty rhetoric. It’s true that any military action ultimately must adhere to political logic. But military action can reinforce political objectives in multiple ways. Its mere threat has political effects on friends and foes, and the impact of combat operations — inflicting pain, seizing territory, threatening to disarm an opponent — also generates political outcomes. This has been made clear recently with Iran on nuclear proliferation and with the Islamic State in Iraq, but the president glosses over the effective use of U.S. military strength even under his own leadership. In this world, the military does solve problems.

I’d like to suggest that the only really permanent solutions in this sad world are military ones. We haven’t heard much about Carthaginian pirates in the Mediterranean lately, have we? Additionally, the German Empire, the Third Reich, and Japan’s Co-Prosperity Sphere might be interested in discussing the effectiveness of military solutions.

The more relevant question is whether we can solve the problems we have today with the force we’re willing to apply and my assessment would be that we can’t. That’s different than force in the abstract.

Then there are the problems that are simply not solvable full stop. Those are the “wicked problems” I’ve written about in the past and most of the thorniest problems we face fall into that category.

14 comments

On Borrowed Time

There is no need to worry about the decline of the middle class in America, advises Ruchir Sharma in the Wall Street Journal:

In June, the Fed clearly signaled an end to its quantitative-easing program, spelling the end of easy money and with it the forces favoring the rich at the expense of the rest. Since June, the dollar has risen by about 17%, undermining corporate earnings and stock prices.

While there are many reasons behind the decline in the price of oil, one of them is the end of QE, which has reduced speculation in commodities and strengthened the dollar. The price of oil and the dollar have long been known to move in opposite directions. Now, the sharp decline in the price of oil and other commodities like food is putting more money in the pockets of the middle class.

The domestic side of the U.S. economy is showing signs of greater strength: Consumer spending grew at a pace of more than 4% last quarter, even as manufacturing and exports lagged and kept the economy from accelerating beyond a 2.5% rate.

It really doesn’t take long for the myrmidons of the .1% to start sprouting from the dragon’s teeth, does it? A couple of mildly favorable economic reports and it’s off to the races!

However, two can play at that game. The car and light truck sales the author touts as indicators of new middle class prosperity were largely financed with subprime loans. And we’re due for even this phlegmatic economic expansion to end. Do you think that the richest or middle income people will be more squeezed when it does? I’d bet a shiny new dime it won’t be the .1%.

2 comments