The Rosenbergs, Alger Hiss, and Unappreciated Irony

You might want to take a look this old LA Times column on the Rosenbergs, Alger Hiss, and the “McCarthy witch hunt” of the 1950s. The irony is that in each of these cases the liberals were wrong. The Rosenbergs and Alger Hiss were, in fact, Soviet agents and worked against American interests. Hollywood, too, was full not just of soft-hearted pinkos but of actual Soviet agents. You could and should disagree with Joe McCarthy’s tactics but there was a genuine problem. It wasn’t so much a case of a witch hunt as of overzealous prosecution.

60 comments

What Are They Thinking?

At CityLabs Kriston Capps writes on the brouhaha over the Department of Justice’s recent criticism of Ferguson. It can be boiled down into a single sentence: the DoJ is asking Ferguson to do something that is beyond its power. Here’s the peroration:

Yesterday, I wrote that Justice’s review of Ferguson, however factually accurate and morally necessary, misses the forest for the trees. (And they are necessary: These guides will be reviewed by law-enforcement agencies far beyond the borders of St. Louis.) But it seems like the department’s recommendations for reform are designed to extinguish the flames on one tree when the whole forest is on fire.

Here is the 13th and final recommendation from Justice for reform in Ferguson:

13. Collaborate with other municipalities and the State of Missouri to implement reforms

That’s the whole ball game. But a generic guideline suggesting these municipalities “collaborate” doesn’t go far enough.

Even if Ferguson were to get it right: Could Florissant? Where a part-time judge making two appearances per month earns $50,000 per year? Where the prosecuting attorney “works roughly 4% of a fulltime job, but earns 145% of a full-time public defender’s salary”? Could Bel-Ridge? Where 83 percent of the residents are black, 42 percent are below the federal poverty level, and warrants outnumber households 2 to 1?

These are just three of the cities in the greater St. Louis area where residents are suffering. Many of the municipal courts operating across St. Louis County may be too broken to be reformed. There is at least one potential solution to these structural problems: The cities could be reconstituted through unification. But that is a step toward reform that’s beyond the Department of Justice.

The reform being demanded is beyond Ferguson’s or St. Louis County’s powers. It’s within the state pf Missouri’s powers but to accomplish it the state would need to act undemocratically and tyrannically.

Is that the Obama Administration’s view of government? An autocratic and benevolent tyrant that marches in to right wrongs? Benevolent this time, that is.

3 comments

John Tamny’s Clickbait

John Tamny’s most recent column has an eye-catching title, “What Jennifer Aniston’s Love Life Tells Us About Unemployment”. There’s a word for that: clickbait. Curious, I took the lure and found the column to be pretty obnoxious. First off, he doesn’t mean “love life”. He means marital status and unless you were raised in a cloister you know the two are not synonymous. His column can be simplified into a single sentence of econo-speak: the jobs on offer are being offered at a wage below the market-clearing price for labor. He blames this on workers:

Aniston could once again have millions of suitors were marriage her objective, and then on a smaller scale, many unmarried women and men who desire wedlock could have just that were they similarly willing to accept less in the way of a life mate than what they presently seek. Work is no different. Leaving aside the numerous flawed ways in which unemployment is calculated in the first place, that the jobless number presently stands at 5.7% doesn’t signal that there are no jobs for 5.7% of those actively seeking work; rather there are no jobs that meet the standards of roughly 5.7% of the work-interested. There’s a big difference.

His claim is a tautology; it’s true by definition but I think there’s more to it.

In my view there are many different situations. For some, Mr. Tamny’s assertion is correct. For others the blunt reality is that taking one of the jobs that are on offer doesn’t make economic sense. There are all sorts of reasons that could happen, e.g. the cost of child care is higher than the wage being offered. Here’s another example. The wage being offered for a job in another city would need to be quite high for it to make sense for my wife and me to move to take it. My wife has a good job and our combined wages in the new location would need to be greater than our present combined wages for moving to make financial sense. My point here is that voluntary and involuntary is not exactly an Aristotelian binary choice. There are gradations of being involuntary.

Finally, for some the wages for the jobs that are on offer just aren’t enough to live on and are less than they’d receive for not working. I guess that’s what Mr. Tamny means when he suggests that unemployment is a luxury. There’s a lot of blame to spread around for that: landlords may be charging rents that are too high, food is too expensive, healthcare is too expensive, taxes are too high, there are city, state, and federal minimum wages, there are lots of regulations, and so on.

The solution I’d like to see is for wages to rise and that is more likely to happen in a tighter labor market. There are several ways that might happen. Either our economy can start producing more jobs or we can reduce the number of workers we’re importing or some combination.

3 comments

He’s More Than a “Pragmatic Progressive”

The editors of the Washington Post weigh in on the Chicago mayoral run-off:

A RUNOFF election next month to determine if Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel gets a second term appears to be close. His opponent, Jesus “Chuy” Garcia, is not as well known and has far less campaign money, but recent polls show him within single digits of Mr. Emanuel. Democratic Party purists and special interest groups have reached the startling conclusion that the able and decidedly liberal incumbent is not liberal enough, and they are intent on punishing him for not toeing their line. If there is no room in the party for a pragmatic progressive like Mr. Emanuel, who was President Obama’s first chief of staff in the White House, then the party, and by extension the country, are in trouble.

Mr. Emanuel last month became the first sitting mayor in Chicago history forced into a runoff when he failed to get 50 percent of the vote in a five-way nonpartisan election. On April 7, he will face Mr. Garcia, a Democratic Cook County commissioner who got 34 percent of the vote to Mr. Emanuel’s 45 percent and is being backed by labor interests and the left-wing groups allied with them.

Fill in my usual complain about non-Chicagoans sticking their noses into Chicago’s business here. The WP editors’ description of the mayor is incomplete and inaccurate. It’s inaccurate in that he, in fact, did knuckle under to powerful interest groups. It’s just powerless interest groups that he’s gone after after alienating and aggravating powerful ones.

The mayor is a lot more than a “pragmatic progressive”. He’s a volatile, verbally abusive guy with poor impulse control who wants power. His highest and best use is as a Democratic Party rainmaker where those qualities have served him in good stead.

1 comment

Earning Respect

Is there any surer way to earn respect:

Mental Health Movement members Debbie Delgado and Matt Ginsberg-Jaeckle just confronted Rahm face-to-face about his mental health clinic closures. Rahm was about to address a small room of developers and residents at the Wicker Park field-house. 3 years after he closed half of Chicago’s public mental health clinics, he may have thought the issue had gone away. But then Debbie, sitting in the front row, a few feet from the mayor, stood up to tell her story. She told of losing her son to gun violence. She told him how her other son was holding him as he died. She told about how the city’s Northwest Mental Health Clinic in Logan Square saved their lives, helped her and her son deal with the PTSD and depression. Then she asked why he took that clinic away from her. Why he closed a clinic and now a bar sits in that space. Why he closed five other mental health clinics. Why he thought she would be able to travel an extra hour past three cemeteries to get to the clinic she was supposed to be transferred to without having an anxiety attack on the way. Why he has left her with no options. Why he has left her with her son closed in, barely leaving the house anymore, refusing to see a new therapist since Rahm Emanuel took away their clinic. After trying to keep his cool, he told us that he would speak to us after the event in a separate room. There, we saw the Real Rahm. Now off camera, Rahm’s voice raised, his demeanor changed, in no time he was shouting in Matt’s face, nose-to-nose “YOU’RE GONNA RESPECT ME!”

than yelling “You’re gonna respect me!” in people’s faces? In prospective voter’s faces? In the faces of prospective voters in fragile mental states?

I recognize that’s only one side of the story and that the mayor is in a tough position. Chicago’s fiscal situation is a mess, it was a mess when he came into office, and whatever he does somebody’s ox will get gored. He asked for the job and that’s the job. We didn’t force it on him. If he doesn’t want it, why is he seeking re-election?

I think that to earn respect you’ve got to give it. Does he appear to have been giving these voters respect?

There’s more comemnt on the reported incident at memeorandum.

1 comment

Annals of Marketing

What in the world did I search for that is causing me to get display ads for poultry supplies to be served up to me? For a while there it looked as though these ad servers were getting smarter. Now I’m not so sure.

1 comment

Who Cares About Legitimacy?

Megan, Megan, Megan. You write:

Earlier I wrote about the King v. Burwell case, which was heard before the Supreme Court today and will decide whether insurance subsidies can be offered on federally run health-care exchanges. Specifically, I wrote that the folks who are screaming that a ruling against the government would deliver a mortal blow to the legitimacy of the court are themselves the ones with a legitimacy problem. “Nice court you have there … it’d be a shame if anything happens to it” is not the tone that responsible citizens should take with one of our most important institutions.

How very non-postmodern of you. They don’t care about legitimacy. They care about authenticity and they’ve got that in abundance. They support the White House’s position, don’t they?

6 comments

Are American Kids Just Stupid and Lazy?

This article in the Washington Post caught my attention:

There was this test. And it was daunting. It was like the SAT or ACT — which many American millennials are no doubt familiar with, as they are on track to be the best educated generation in history — except this test was not about getting into college. This exam, given in 23 countries, assessed the thinking abilities and workplace skills of adults. It focused on literacy, math and technological problem-solving. The goal was to figure out how prepared people are to work in a complex, modern society.

And U.S. millennials performed horribly.

That might even be an understatement, given the extent of the American shortcomings. No matter how you sliced the data – by class, by race, by education – young Americans were laggards compared to their international peers. In every subject, U.S. millennials ranked at the bottom or very close to it, according to a new study by testing company ETS.

“We were taken aback,” said ETS researcher Anita Sands. “We tend to think millennials are really savvy in this area. But that’s not what we are seeing.”

The gap between “savvy in this area” and the ability to solve technological problems (either in the real world or in a test) is pretty large. The only surprise might be that the researchers were surprised. The ability to use a telephone does not mean that you could build one let alone invent one. Or being able to plug in an XBox, install games on it, and play them does not mean you could build one, design and implement a game, or solve problems with the game or the gadget. The ability to post on Facebook or put your picture on Instagram does not mean you could create Facebook or Instagram. The researchers, all technologically-challenged elders in fact, may just lack the smarts to know the difference.

However, let’s list some possible reasons for the outcome:

  • Students in other countries are smarter and work harder.
  • American students are stupid and lazy.
  • The tests are not being administered to representative samples of the population.
  • Other countries put their kids into educational tracks, i.e. they specialize earlier, and in those countries only the specialists are taking the test.
  • The differences among countries aren’t actually very large and random variation could account for some of the differences in outcome.
  • Who cares about results on a stupid test anyway?
  • Too high a percentage of American students live in homes where their parents are barely literate (if at all) and illiterate in science, technology, and math.
  • The U. S. education system is lousy.

and those are just off the top of my head. I’m sure there are more. Or maybe, just maybe, American parents and students are canny consumers and realize there’s no future in science, technology, and math for them. Science and math are hard, jobs in science and technology aren’t easy to get, and companies can and will always hire people from Japan and Finland for technical jobs. The only math and science worth studying are just enough to get you into med school.

12 comments

The Mulligan

When I read articles like James Taranto’s trying to divine how Chief Justice Roberts will decide in King v. Burwell, I always find them amusing. While I am fully confident that the Chief Justice will decide according to sound legal principles and the merits of the case, I also remember Mr. Dooley’s century-old wisecrack that even the justices of the Supreme Court read the election returns.

Is he willing to give the White House a mulligan on the PPACA? How strong a case do they need to have? Will his voting in support of another strained argument support his previous decision on the PPACA or discredit it and the Supreme Court along with it? There are a lot of moving parts here.

2 comments

What If the Situation Were Reversed?

The editors of the Washington Post are appalled at the revelation that Hillary Clinton as the waggish phrase has it “privatized her email”:

HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON has served as first lady, a senator from New York and secretary of state. She is no newcomer to the corridors of power. Her decision to exclusively use a private e-mail account while secretary suggests she made a deliberate decision to shield her messages from scrutiny. It was a mistake that reflects poor judgment about a public trust.

Under the rules as they existed during Ms. Clinton’s time as secretary, from 2009 to 2013, government officials were not strictly required to use official e-mail accounts. However, in 2011 the White House spokesman, Jay Carney, said, “We are definitely instructed that we need to conduct all of our work on our government accounts . . . .” He said it was “administration policy” to use government accounts. Did this not apply to Ms. Clinton at the State Department?

I wonder how the defenders of the former First Lady, senator, and Secretary of State would be reacting if she didn’t have a “D” behind her name?

I’ve made no secret of my views on Hillary Clinton. I am a small “r” republican and a small “d” democrat and I do not vote for dynasties. That was one of the reasons I did not vote for George W. Bush in 2000 and wouldn’t vote for his brother in 2016. It is a sufficient reason for me not to vote for Hillary Clinton (assuming she’s running for president) in 2016.

I wonder how many reasons it will take for her support to start flagging? For it to reduce turnout?

6 comments