Is It Soup Yet?

I’m still waiting to see if the “Hillary Clinton/email” story has legs or not. It’s still much in the news but I think it’s too early to tell.

5 comments

Compare and Contrast

There are some different points of view out there about last week Unemployment Situation Report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Paul Krugman writes:

The Fed has a so-called dual mandate — it’s supposed to achieve both price stability and full employment. At this point price stability is conventionally taken to mean low but positive inflation, at around 2 percent a year. What does it mean to achieve full employment? For the Fed, it means reaching the Nairu — the nonaccelerating inflation rate of unemployment, which is consistent with that inflation target.

The Fed currently estimates the Nairu at between 5.2 percent and 5.5 percent, and the latest report puts the actual unemployment rate at 5.5 percent. So we’re there — time to raise interest rates!

Or maybe not. The Nairu is supposed to be the unemployment rate at which the economy overheats and an inflationary spiral starts to kick in. But there is no sign of inflationary pressure. In particular, if the job market really were tight, wages would be rising quickly, whereas they are in fact going nowhere.

Continue reading the main storyContinue reading the main storyContinue reading the main story
The thing is, we’ve been here before. In the early-to-mid 1990s, the Fed generally estimated the Nairu as being between 5.5 percent and 6 percent, and by 1995, unemployment had already fallen to that level. But inflation wasn’t actually rising. So Fed officials made what turned out to be a very good choice: They held their fire, waiting for clear signs of inflationary pressure. And it turned out that the United States’ economy was capable of generating millions more jobs, without inflation, than it would have if the Fed had reined in the boom too soon.

Are we in a similar situation now? Actually, I don’t know — but neither does the Fed. The question, then, is what to do in the face of that uncertainty, with no inflation problem yet in sight.

To me, as to a number of economists — perhaps most notably Lawrence Summers, the former Treasury secretary — the answer seems painfully obvious: Don’t yank away that punch bowl, don’t pull that rate-hike trigger, until you see the whites of inflation’s eyes. If it turns out that the Fed has waited a bit too long, inflation might overshoot 2 percent for a while, but that wouldn’t be a great tragedy. But if the Fed moves too soon, we might end up losing millions of jobs we could have had — and in the worst case, we might end up sliding into a Japanese-style deflationary trap, which has already happened in Sweden and possibly in the eurozone.

What’s worrisome is that it’s not clear whether Fed officials see it that way. They need to heed the lessons of history — and the relevant history here is the 1990s, not the 1970s. Let’s party like it’s 1995; let the good, or at least better, times keep rolling, and hold off on those rate hikes.

Are times actually better? Or are the numbers just better? Louis Woodhill writes:

Government agencies can only report on the past. For example, Friday’s “Employment Situation” report represented the BLS’ best effort to describe labor market conditions as of mid-February. The financial markets operate in real time, and they process price signals, which communicate everything that matters economically about everything going on in the world. This includes how many people in the U.S. have jobs, what kinds of jobs they have, and what they are being paid.

Accordingly, the closing prices of equities, bonds, and commodities on Thursday, March 5, already reflected actual labor market conditions, not just as of three weeks earlier, but all the way up to the closing bell. So, why would a government report on the job environment in mid-February cause the Dow to dive by 1.54%, interest rates on 10-year Treasuries to soar by 6.17%, and the price of gold to plunge by 1.47% on Friday, March 6?

Answer: In the markets’ judgment, the BLS report raised the probability that the “experts” at the Fed will use their discretionary power over money to do something economically destructive. But what?

[…]

Analysts fixated on the reported 295,000 rise in payroll employment, which was considerably higher than the consensus was expecting. However, this number comes from the “Establishment Survey,” which includes a lot of jobs that are assumed into existence via the BLS’ “Birth/Death Model.” The BLS’ “Household Survey” numbers did not support the notion that happy days are here again.

According to the BLS “Household Survey,” total employment increased by only 96,000 during February. The rest of the 274,000 reduction in unemployment was the result of 178,000 working-age people dropping out of the labor force. This brought labor force participation (LFP) back down to 62.83%, which was the level of June 2014-and only slightly above that of November 1977.

Economics is not mathematics and it’s not a physical science. It’s a social science and a social science whose practitioners, because it deals with money, production, consumption, and employment, are very susceptible to letting their social preferences outrun the available data.

In economics behavior is the first thing that should be observed not the last and when people start behaving as though, as Dr. Krugman puts it, “the good, or at least better”, times are rolling, I’ll be more predisposed to believe that they are.

2 comments

What Are Romantic Movies?

Earlier today my wife asked me what movies I thought were romantic. The question was occasioned by TCM’s airing The Ghost and Mrs. Muir (it’s playing right now) which my wife and I agreed was a very romantic movie. Coming a bit closer to a recent movie, we also agreed that Murphy’s Romance was a romantic movie.

Here are some other movies I think are romantic:

Love Letters
A Portrait of Jennie
Random Harvest
Strictly Ballroom
Mr. Lucky
Now Voyager

just to name a few.

Romantic? Not romantic? What movies do you think are romantic? I think romance is sort of out of fashion. I don’t find most rom-coms romantic in the slightest and most aren’t even funny. The Notebook?

Update

I’ve thought of a picture I need to add to the list:

I Know Where I’m Going

which to me is one of the most romantic pictures ever made.

28 comments

What Do You Know About Iran’s Nuclear Development Program?

Speaking of negotiating a treaty with Iran, there’s an op-ed by William Broad and David Sanger at the New York Times that should at the very least make you uneasy:

While those talks have dragged on for 18 months, Iran has let inspectors deep inside its production facilities and observed every commitment on cutting back its production of nuclear fuel. But it has continued to stiff-arm the inspectors on the question of suspected “military dimensions,” despite agreeing to another work plan. The Obama administration has said little about that silence.

Last month, the inspectors reported that “Iran has not provided any explanations” for two of the three design questions now on the table. The other nine remain in limbo.

So will Iran have to come clean before the economic sanctions are lifted? American officials won’t say. “It’s the most sensitive topic for the Iranians,” said one former American negotiator. “Is it worth blowing up a potential agreement in the name of forcing a confession?”

I think the answer to that question is not only “yes”, it’s fundamental. If you don’t have a trustworthy interlocutor, you have nothing.

Take a look at the diagram of issues that haven’t even been addressed (at least as far as the writers know). It’s pretty disquieting.

4 comments

Concluding a Treaty With Iran

On the talking heads programs this morning there’s been quite a bit of loose talk about concluding a treaty with Iran. It might be appropriate to remind people of Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the U. S. Constitution:

The President] shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur…

In other words for a treaty to become law it must be approved by two third of the Senators voting. That’s not susceptible to a presidential veto.

The president has no obligation to put a treaty up for for vote by “the Congress” but a treaty isn’t a treaty unless it’s approved by the Senate. It’s just a statement of executive opinion.

The Congress has other recourses available to it to prevent treaties from becoming effective as well. For example, it can refuse to fund the implementation or enforcement measures in the treaty. It can also make negotiating very difficult, say, by stripping travel budgets including forcing approval of every trip specifically and seriatim. The Congress’s authority in budget matters is extremely great, that of the House in particular.

0 comments

The Morality of First Strikes

In the light of the Israeli prime minister’s address to Congress this week and the incipient diplomatic agreement with Iran, Patrick Callahan’s post at RealClearReligion on the moral dimensions of an agreement with Iran on its nuclear development program. It provides food for thought.

I think that care must be taken in distinguishing between Iran’s nuclear development program and Iran’s possession of nuclear weapons. This statement:

One alternative would be the use of force. Any such use might be beyond moral justification. It may violate any number of the criteria in the just war framework. A full moral evaluation using the just war framework is beyond the limits of this contribution. Suffice it to say that it would fail the two most pragmatic. It would not have a reasonable chance of success in attaining its just ends. It would set back Iranian capabilities for only a year or two and it may even increase the regime’s will to acquire nuclear weapons.

fully conflates the two and I think Mr. Callahan makes a basic error. There is no moral obligation for any country to absorb mass casualties because of uncertainty.

I think there are other moral considerations which in the interests of clarity he should have at least touched on. For example, American leaders have more responsibility for the lives of Americans than they do for the lives of Iranians. That’s something that has been recognized in the treatment of just war theory for more than a millennium. That the Iranians have located many of their nuclear development facilities in their population centers was their moral decision not ours.

The preoccupation with precluding civilian casualties is a modern one; Augustine, the author of just war theory, did not have such illusions. Our greater abilities places a higher obligation on us to avoid unnecessary civilian casualties but they do not mean we must preclude them. When the only effective means that can ensure a just end could be expected to inflict mass civilian casualties does not render the means unjust. In this context “proportional” means proportional to the risk.

Let me give a hypothetical example. Let’s say that we have credible information that Iran is about to attack the United States with a nuclear weapon. Under those circumstances American leaders have not only a right but an obligation to preempt such an attack by any effective means including attacking all of Iran’s nuclear development and command and control facilities with nuclear weapons, if those are the only effective means, regardless of the civilian casualties that might be inflicted. There are a lot of “ifs” in that statement but the points I’m trying to emphasize are that:

  1. The use of powerful weapons is not inherently morally wrong. There’s nothing particularly special about nuclear weapons other than they’re very powerful.
  2. Civilian casualties are not inherently morally wrong.
  3. Preemptive war is not immoral. Preventive war, on the other hand, is almost always immoral.
  4. Political leaders have responsibilities that go beyond yours and mine.
8 comments

The Death of 1,000 Cuts

I haven’t commented on the Hillary Clinton email brouhaha and don’t plan to until we see if the story has legs. We should know that within a week or two.

Meanwhile for entertainment value you might want to read John Kass’s column on it. He’s in rare form.

12 comments

WSJ Profile of Bruce Rauner

This morning the Wall Street Journal profiles Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner. After a lengthy build-up here’s the meat of the WSJ’s interview:

We meet on a Sunday morning in the state’s downtown Chicago offices, a sprawling red and gray modernist complex called the Thompson Center. The building is locked and dark, but Mr. Rauner, sitting in a government-issue barrel back chair, is smartly dressed in a business suit and striped tie.

His confidence that his agenda will not stall in the legislature comes in many parts. “I’ve got a very good working relationship with Democratic leaders in the state,” he says. “Number one, I’ve worked very hard on personal relationship-building. There’s mutual respect. There’s mutual trust that has not existed from prior governors.” Unlike his predecessors, Mr. Rauner, a Chicagoan born on the city’s north side, near Wrigley Field, is living in downstate Springfield.

Second, though Illinois is a deep-blue state, Mr. Rauner feels he has a mandate. He won every area of the state except urban Cook County, and he says even liberals see the need to cut spending and reform the bloated pension system. “Everywhere I go, people run up to me and say, ‘I’m a Democrat. You’re saying stuff that needs to be said. Hang in there,’ ” he says. “See, my wife is a Democrat. She’s troubled . . . because every dollar that gets spent beyond what’s really necessary—and it’s in a special insider deal—every dollar is a dollar that can’t go to help a truly disadvantaged person.”

Third, the budget mess is so acute, Mr. Rauner says, that the legislature simply must act. Here the governor does something that might surprise: He quotes Rahm Emanuel, Chicago’s Democratic mayor and President Obama ’s former chief of staff. “Who was it that said, ‘Never let a crisis go to waste’?” Mr. Rauner asks. “It creates the opportunity to bring people together to do things that they might otherwise not be inclined to do.”

That doesn’t mean the governor’s proposals have landed without controversy. One involves changing the future pensions of government employees, who would very much like to keep the generous current terms. Under Mr. Rauner’s plan, benefits for current retirees would be maintained, but today’s workers would be given the option of a buyout—a lump sum that the state would deposit into a new 401(k)-style account. Employees who don’t take the buyout would have future benefits modestly reduced, though the portion of their pensions that has already been earned would be protected.

Democrats and unions say the proposal violates language in the Illinois Constitution that ensures public pensions “shall not be diminished or impaired.” But the governor says that the restriction doesn’t prevent creating a new additional pension system for the future. “I love the pressure I’m putting on them. We’re going to pass that,” he says. “It’s common sense and it’s totally constitutional.”

The state Supreme Court might decide otherwise. This month justices will hear arguments on whether a 2013 law cutting retirees’ annual cost-of-living adjustments passes constitutional muster. Whatever the justices decide, Mr. Rauner says, his plan will go forward, even if he has to pass a constitutional amendment by referendum to allow the changes. “I don’t have a Plan B,” he says. “I have a Plan A.”

Equally controversial have been the governor’s plans to reform government-union rules. A full 93% of the state’s government workers are unionized (the highest rate in the country, Mr. Rauner notes), guaranteeing a stream of dues money to Democratic politicians. “Everywhere I look inside state government, the unions have been running the process, dictating the terms, setting the work rules and setting the agenda inside government,” Mr. Rauner says. “The taxpayers, school children, businesses, homeowners, small business owners have been abused and left out of the process.”

One of his first moves was signing an executive order banning public unions from collecting mandatory fees from workers who don’t want to join the union. Federal courts will ultimately determine the constitutionality of the move, so the governor then filed a lawsuit arguing that the fees violate workers’ First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and association. The suit will probably take years to wend through the legal system, but it is aimed squarely at overturning the U.S. Supreme Court’s precedent in the 1977 case Abood v. Detroit Board of Education.

Mr. Rauner has also proposed banning campaign contributions from government unions. “It’s already illegal today in Illinois for businesses or individuals who contract with the state to make campaign contributions to state politicians,” he says, but “it’s perfectly legal for government union leaders. Why?” Given that the proposal might spook legislators who rely on union contributions to get elected, Mr. Rauner wants to offer an alternative source of money. He has set up a $20 million political-action committee—funded by Mr. Rauner, businessman Dick Ulein and Citadel CEO Ken Griffin —to back politicians who side with the governor when his budget reforms head to the Statehouse. The implied threat is that legislators who don’t may face well-funded challengers.

His reform proposals have earned Mr. Rauner comparison to Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, who in 2011 pushed through limits on public-union collective bargaining. Mr. Rauner hasn’t gone that far for state workers, but he has offered a plan to let local voters determine what the workers they employ can and can’t bargain for. “I want them to decide if they want forced unionization in their government entities and their schools,” he says.

Mr. Rauner also wants to let local governments decide on what would essentially be local right-to-work zones. Illinois is surrounded by right-to-work states, including Indiana, Michigan and Iowa. Wisconsin passed its own right-to-work law on Friday and Mr. Walker’s office has said he will sign it on Monday. Mr. Rauner says Illinois needs to take comparable action to remain competitive.

“Illinois, we’re the heart of the Midwest, we’re the economic muscle of the Midwest, and we’re sitting here with closed-shop restrictions,” he says. “If DuPage County wants to have closed shop in their county, keep it—terrific, no problem. But why should DuPage force Effingham County to be closed shop? If Effingham wants to compete with Indiana for a new business, and be on the list where companies will look for employment flexibility, why shouldn’t they be able to choose to do that?”

As the state’s annual budget debate gets under way, Democrats are pushing for tax hikes. Some of the legislators want higher fuel taxes. Michael Madigan, speaker of the state House of Representatives, is pushing for a 3% surcharge on millionaires. “Talk about a flow of job creators leaving the state if they put that in,” Mr. Rauner says.

The governor’s budget included no new taxes, but Mr. Rauner has said he would be open to broadening the state sales tax to include services such as haircuts and auto repairs that are now exempt. But the biggest—and first—priority, he insists, must be to change the way Illinois does business. “We’ve got massive debt, massive deficits, high unemployment,” he says. “People think, ‘just raise the income-tax rate.’ Guys, that is not going to fix our problem. We’ve gotta grow.”

I think I’ve told the story before about the prominent Chicago tax attorney, the father of a parishioner and member of the church council, who, after looking at the books of the church I was attending at the time, gave a one sentence pronouncement: “You’ve got to sell more.” That’s essentially Bruce Rauner’s prescription for Illinois.

If I were a betting man, I’d bet against Gov. Rauner’s succeeding in his plans. That’s not to say that I think that Illinois is beyond reform or that fighting Rauner for every inch is what the Illinois legislature should do. I think that if Illinois is to recover from its present funk it must reform and it must reform in the directions in which Gov. Rauner is pointing. I think that Mike Madigan and John Cullerton should put up some show of opposition but largely cooperate with the governor, then blame him for the choices that are made. This is a great time for Illinois to have a one-term reform governor.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Historical Inevitability

I’ve mentioned “Whig history” here before. A little bit ago it occurred to me that there are any number of drastically different ways of looking at the ways in which events unfold. One of the ways is historical inevitability. There are all sorts of phrases that people use to describe that (besides “Whig history” and “historic inevitability”) like “the wrong side of history”, “the tide of history”, or “the arc of the moral universe”. It leads you to believe that because things happened in a certain way it is the only way they could have happened and thinking anything else is either stupid or self-serving.

Another way is to think that people do things for reasons. They may understand the reasons or they may not. They may be right or they may be mistaken. But they do what they do for reasons. There’s nothing inevitable about what they do because a tiny change in how they felt that morning or arriving at their destinations that evening five minutes earlier or later and the reasons might have changed.

1 comment