Why Is Business Investment So Low?

Robert Samuelson remarks on an IMF study of worldwide business investment:

We now have a new study from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that suggests some not very encouraging answers. For starters, it confirms that the investment bust is a global phenomenon. It’s not just the United States but also Europe, Japan and most advanced countries. As important, the main cause of the investment slump is clear-cut: Businesses aren’t expanding because they can already meet most demand with existing capacity.

Compared with what had been expected, the shortfall is huge. The IMF looked at predictions in 2007 of future investment and then examined what had actually occurred. For advanced countries, the difference averaged about 20 percent from 2007 to 2013. Investment was about one-fifth less than had been anticipated.

They’re looking at too short a horizon. Investment hasn’t just been low for the last seven years. With the exception of housing construction and related things, business investment has been low for fifteen years.

I think a change has taken place in the understanding of risk. Investors are willing to buy quarters for a nickel a piece in quite literally any quantity. Much riskier than that and they pick up their marbles and go home.

What the IMF and Mr. Samuelson are missing is that personal consumption expenditures as a percentage of GDP haven’t been north of 67% forever. Just for the last fifteen years.

Federal government spending is also high relative to historic norms. The only component of GDP that isn’t bearing the weight it used to is business investment. The “shortfall in demand” argument doesn’t wash unless you narrow your examination to the last eight years. It doesn’t explain why business investment has been low for so long.

2 comments

Playing Dragon Age: Inquisition

I’ve just finished the final battle of Dragon Age: Inquisition, Bioware’s latest entry in its Dragon Age franchise, and I thought I’d comment on the experience. I have now played the game from beginning to end three times at the “Hard” level of difficulty, first as a Rogue, then as a Warrior, and this last time as a Mage.

My style of play isn’t really suited for a multiplayer environment so I play solo. I probe into just about every nook and cranny, try different strategies to see how it changes gameplay, and so on.

You can play the game using the old Dungeons & Dragons character types (Rogue, Warrior, Mage), male or female, as a human, elf, dwarf, or Qunari (sort of a minotaur-type character) for a dizzying number of combinations. There are a similarly dizzying number of armor and weapon styles for you to find, buy, or make. The best armor and weapons are made not bought. I don’t think I can count the number of different ways you can customize your armor. You can customize the look of Skyhold, your stronghold. You can get lost just in the mechanics of the game. I didn’t figure some of these things out until my second time through.

I think that Bioware may expect you to play the game as a mage. There are certain options that make a lot more sense as a mage than with the other character types. Playing as a mage has better cut scenes, too.

I can’t remember where I read the review where this was said but it’s about right. Dragon Age: Inquisition is the most beautiful dull game that has ever been created. It’s engaging enough that I’ve played it more than once but it just doesn’t have the enthralling, emersive character of a really great role-playing game. Ultimately, I just don’t care about the characters or their problems that much. It plays well enough and it doesn’t crash any more frequently than is typical of PC-based games in the genre.

To date the best role-playing game I’ve ever played has been Baldur’s Gate II. It was just transporting. The technology has come a long way since then but even with the improved technology the more recent games have just not achieved that level of experience.

So, if you’d like to kill some time exploring (and fighting your way through) a world in which, unlike ours, dragons can be slain, Dragon Age: Inquisition is a pretty good choice. I’m going to try something else. I may even go back to Skyrim.

7 comments

Kissinger and Shultz on the Iran Framework Agreement

If you have access to it, I strongly recommend you read Henry Kissinger and George Shultz’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal on the incipient deal with Iran and its likely consequences. I think it does so in a fair and balanced way without taking an editorial position. But for the copyright restrictions, I’d quote it in its entirety. Here are a few snippets to give you the flavor:

Mixing shrewd diplomacy with open defiance of U.N. resolutions, Iran has gradually turned the negotiation on its head. Iran’s centrifuges have multiplied from about 100 at the beginning of the negotiation to almost 20,000 today. The threat of war now constrains the West more than Iran. While Iran treated the mere fact of its willingness to negotiate as a concession, the West has felt compelled to break every deadlock with a new proposal. In the process, the Iranian program has reached a point officially described as being within two to three months of building a nuclear weapon. Under the proposed agreement, for 10 years Iran will never be further than one year from a nuclear weapon and, after a decade, will be significantly closer.

[…]

Negotiating the final agreement will be extremely challenging. For one thing, no official text has yet been published. The so-called framework represents a unilateral American interpretation. Some of its clauses have been dismissed by the principal Iranian negotiator as “spin.” A joint EU-Iran statement differs in important respects, especially with regard to the lifting of sanctions and permitted research and development.

[…]

Under the new approach, Iran permanently gives up none of its equipment, facilities or fissile product to achieve the proposed constraints. It only places them under temporary restriction and safeguard—amounting in many cases to a seal at the door of a depot or periodic visits by inspectors to declared sites. The physical magnitude of the effort is daunting. Is the International Atomic Energy Agency technically, and in terms of human resources, up to so complex and vast an assignment?

[…]

The agreement’s primary enforcement mechanism, the threat of renewed sanctions, emphasizes a broad-based asymmetry, which provides Iran permanent relief from sanctions in exchange for temporary restraints on Iranian conduct. Undertaking the “snap-back” of sanctions is unlikely to be as clear or as automatic as the phrase implies. Iran is in a position to violate the agreement by executive decision. Restoring the most effective sanctions will require coordinated international action. In countries that had reluctantly joined in previous rounds, the demands of public and commercial opinion will militate against automatic or even prompt “snap-back.” If the follow-on process does not unambiguously define the term, an attempt to reimpose sanctions risks primarily isolating America, not Iran.

[…]

Traditional theories of deterrence assumed a series of bilateral equations. Do we now envision an interlocking series of rivalries, with each new nuclear program counterbalancing others in the region?

Previous thinking on nuclear strategy also assumed the existence of stable state actors. Among the original nuclear powers, geographic distances and the relatively large size of programs combined with moral revulsion to make surprise attack all but inconceivable. How will these doctrines translate into a region where sponsorship of nonstate proxies is common, the state structure is under assault, and death on behalf of jihad is a kind of fulfillment?

For some, the greatest value in an agreement lies in the prospect of an end, or at least a moderation, of Iran’s 3½ decades of militant hostility to the West and established international institutions, and an opportunity to draw Iran into an effort to stabilize the Middle East. Having both served in government during a period of American-Iranian strategic alignment and experienced its benefits for both countries as well as the Middle East, we would greatly welcome such an outcome. Iran is a significant national state with a historic culture, a fierce national identity, and a relatively youthful, educated population; its re-emergence as a partner would be a consequential event.

But partnership in what task? Cooperation is not an exercise in good feeling; it presupposes congruent definitions of stability. There exists no current evidence that Iran and the U.S. are remotely near such an understanding.

[…]

Some advocates have suggested that the agreement can serve as a way to dissociate America from Middle East conflicts, culminating in the military retreat from the region initiated by the current administration. As Sunni states gear up to resist a new Shiite empire, the opposite is likely to be the case. The Middle East will not stabilize itself, nor will a balance of power naturally assert itself out of Iranian-Sunni competition. (Even if that were our aim, traditional balance of power theory suggests the need to bolster the weaker side, not the rising or expanding power.)

Until clarity on an American strategic political concept is reached, the projected nuclear agreement will reinforce, not resolve, the world’s challenges in the region. Rather than enabling American disengagement from the Middle East, the nuclear framework is more likely to necessitate deepening involvement there—on complex new terms. History will not do our work for us; it helps only those who seek to help themselves.

That’s less than a quarter of the lengthy, intelligent, informed commentary. There is also praise for the president and Secretary of State from two former consequential Secretaries of State.

14 comments

Party Affiliation in the U. S., 2015

You might want to take a look at this analysis from Pew Research of political party affiliation by gender, race, age, and educational attainment. Superficially, it looks pretty bad for the Republicans and it would be if party affiliation were as rigid for the Millennials as it is for, say, African Americans.

It used to be believed that once young people had settled on a political party they rarely budged but that seems to be an oversimplification. What is now believed is that certain life milestones, e.g. getting a job (or failing to), having children, buying a first home, etc., motivates people to re-evaluate the views they’ve held.

It still looks pretty obvious that Republicans can’t be successful at the national level and be the old white guys’ party.

3 comments

The Devil You Know

Yesterday the voters of Chicago or, at least, a few of them went to the polls and instead of electing a challenger who relied on doubletalk and handwaving in answer to the tough questions facing Chicago, re-elected an incumbent who relies on handwaving and doubletalk in answer to the tough questions facing Chicago:

Washington (CNN)Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel thanked voters Tuesday night for giving him a “second term and a second chance” as he declared victory over challenger Jesus “Chuy” Garcia.

Still, Emanuel, whose tough political persona is legendary, appeared humble in the wake of a fierce six-week runoff battle that served as a proxy war between the ascendant progressive wing of the Democratic party and the more traditional centrist bloc.

“I want to thank you for putting me through my paces. I will be a better mayor because of that,” Emanuel told the crowd during his victory speech.

President Barack Obama’s notoriously prickly former chief of staff also promised to do things differently in his second term.

“Chicago, I hear you,” he said. “I’m proud of what we have accomplished, but I understand the challenges that we face will require me to approach them differently.”

Emanuel was viewed skeptically by the left during the campaign. But in victory, he rattled off a list of progressive priorities, including a hike in the minimum wage, and pledged to unite the city

But he warned that “in an era of hard choices, I can’t promise that everyone will be pleased with every decision.”

It’s an era of significant financial challenges for the city, including a $20 billion pension crisis and $300 million operating budget shortfall that have resulted in multiple downgrades in the city’s bond rating. The city’s financial woes, and the reforms Emanuel undertook to try to address them, produced widespread backlash from Chicago’s teachers, working class and minority communities that ultimately drove Emanuel to a runoff in February.

How bad is Chicago’s fiscal situation? This bad:

In a friend of the court brief filed in the state pension case, Corporation Counsel Stephen Patton warned that Chicago faces a $300 million deficit in 2016 with shortfalls continuing “for the foreseeable future”— even before piling on the pension liabilities that have dropped the city’s bond rating to just two levels above junk status.

And if state legislation that saved two of four city employee pension funds is overturned, Patton warned that a “catastrophic outcome” awaits retirees and taxpayers alike.

“The city’s liabilities will increase by $2.5 million a day. The city will suffer further downgrades that could materially increase the cost of borrowing money essential to funding basic operations. And it could make the city immediately liable to pay hundreds of millions of dollars as a result of default and early termination of debt-related obligations,” Patton wrote.

To place that in some context Chicago’s total annual revenues from all sources are around $2.1 billion. The city already has the highest sales tax in the country and it’s bumping up against the limit at which it can set property taxes without turning to the voters for approval. The mayor has already relied heavily on increasing city fees to balance the budget. Pushback against that was one of the reasons Emanuel faced such strong opposition.

Either Chicago needs to increase its revenue by 50% this year and every year thereafter or it needs to borrow an extra $1 billion this year and every year thereafter or some combination. Chuy Garcia had the right idea:

“Yes, we have a debt crisis and a pension crisis. But that’s because of the one thing: We have a growth crisis,” he said, noting Chicago’s decline in population, which fell 6.9 percent to 2.7 million from 2000 to 2010. “We can’t tax our way out of this crisis. We can’t keep borrowing our way out of this crisis.”

Some investors in the $3.5 trillion municipal market now treat Chicago’s debt as speculative grade. The burden weighing down the city totals $32.6 billion when liabilities of its park district, water agency and school board are included.

It’s hard to see how to reconcile that with the policies Rahm Emanuel must adopt and with the Big Business, zero sum orientation he has displayed so far.

I see no way the city can solve its fiscal problems without relief from the state legislature, something they have shown little inclination to grant, signed into law by Gov. Rauner, something there’s no guarantee he will do, or with the governor’s veto overridden by the legislature, something it seems impossible to believe.

That’s the problem that Mayor Emanuel was re-elected to solve. He didn’t even mention the balloon payment Chicago is required to put into its public employees’ pension fund in his State of the City message early this year.

6 comments

Lost in Translation

This passage from the editors of the Washington Post:

Mr. Obama conceded that some vital “details” have not yet been worked out, including how the lifting of sanctions on Iran would be tied to its implementation of steps such as reducing its stockpile of enriched uranium and its base of installed centrifuges. Worryingly, the fact sheets issued by the U.S. and Iranian governments differ sharply on this point: While the U.S. version says that “sanctions will be suspended after” the International Atomic Energy Agency “has verified that Iran has taken all of its key nuclear-related steps,” Tehran’s account is that “at the same time as the start of Iran’s nuclear-related implementation work, all of the sanctions will be automatically annulled on a single specified day.”

suggests that the remaining work to secure an agreement with Iran is more than just a few details. Or else somebody is lying. Maybe everybody.

8 comments

Ebola Update

Based on the data for the most recent reporting week ending April 5 which was published today and which in turn is derived from the country reports of Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone, over 300 new cases were reported in that week. If past experience is any gauge 40-50% of those who contract the disease will die of it. It is also estimated that the actual figures are probably two or three times as high as the verified reported figures.

Or, in other words, if the outbreak has ended it’s because the disease has now become endemic in West Africa. The little downturn that was reported so breathlessly last month has not continued.

0 comments

“The system is rigged for the insiders against the interests of taxpayers.”

The quote that forms the title of this post was said by Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner and comes from this editorial from the Chicago Tribune. What are the priorities in the new governor’s “turnaround agenda”?

Hence his mission to rivet all of us on repairing Illinois’ competitiveness for jobs (via such issues as tort reform, worker’s compensation, unemployment taxes). He enthused not about a long list of popular issues but about … fixing the architecture of governance. If lawmakers and citizens don’t go for these big fixes but instead get sidetracked debating one construction project or one budget provision, he said, “then we’ve lost.”

A top priority: pension reforms that would protect benefits earned to date, move all future work by current employees into the state’s existing and less generous Tier 2 plan, and offer an optional lump-sum pension buyout for workers who then would enroll in a 401(k)-style plan on top of their newly reduced defined benefit plan.

His Job One for pensions is a constitutional amendment specifying that only currently earned benefits — not those earned in the future — can’t be, in the words of the Illinois Constitution, “diminished or impaired.” Many Illinois pols await a state Supreme Court ruling on the meaning of that provision. Not Rauner. He says it’s “critical” that his proposed amendment be on the 2016 ballot. Nor is he daunted by the likelihood that public employees will try to block any pension changes in court. “If we do anything other than increase benefits,” he told us with a smile and a shrug, “we’ll be sued.”

Let me follow up on the passage above with a pair of cynical predictions. The court will rule that reducing benefits for the state’s public employees is beyond the legislature’s powers. And at the end of his first and, likely, last term the governor will have accomplished none of the priority items listed in the editorial.

0 comments

How the Other Half Lives

I strongly recommend you take a look at this post from the Wall Street Journal. It’s chock-full of interesting information about how people earn and spending their incomes at different income levels. Would you find it shocking that 40% of all Americans spend more than half of their income on just two necessities: food and housing. Or that the highest 10% of income earners derive 83% of their income from wages and salary? The top 10% are not spats-wearing coupon-clippers. For that you’ve got to go up to the top .1%.

That household spending on education is distributed in a U?

Lots of interesting stuff here. I think we’d learn something from an age distribution, too.

0 comments

A Decision Without Choices

Tomorrow Chicago’s polls open yet again to select the man who will be Chicago’s mayor for the next four years. I am faced with the unhappy choices of voting for Rahm Emanuel, voting for Chuy Garcia, or not voting at all.

I don’t think that Chicago is working out the way Emanuel thought it would. For some unfathomable reason he seems to have thought Chicago would be a sinecure, paving his way for higher office and giving him plenty of time to devote to raising money and getting Democratic presidential candidates elected. Obviously, that hasn’t worked out. If he’s re-elected I fully expect him to devote most of 2016 to the Clinton campaign or, on the off chance that Hillary isn’t the candidate, on the campaign of whichever Democrat is running.

On the (I think) six different opportunities I’ve had to vote for Emanuel I have never done so and I see no reason to break my streak now. That leaves Garcia or not voting. I find the idea of not voting very sad. I may well vote for Garcia.

7 comments