Digging into the BEA’s 1st Quarter GDP Report

I’ve been digging into the Bureau of Economic Analysis’s report on 1st quarter GDP for 2015. Most people are commenting on the phlegmatic growth—two-tenths of one percent is nothing to write home about.

However, I think there’s more to chew on than that. A couple of things occur to me. First, I wonder when they’re going to figure out that healthcare spending is a drag on the economy. I think that’s the obvious conclusion from the spending numbers.

And the savings numbers are almost undoubtedly due to rising incomes among the highest income earners and stagnant incomes for everybody else. If we’re going to have an economy that depends on consumer spending and income gains are concentrated among the highest earners, they’ve got to start spending, darn it. Something’s gotta give.

2 comments

What Ricardo Didn’t Say

Once again Tom Friedman justifies his position as dean of American idiots with newspaper columns:

BERLIN — I strongly support President Obama’s efforts to conclude big, new trade-opening agreements with our Pacific allies, including Japan and Singapore, and with the whole European Union. But I don’t support them just for economic reasons.

While I’m certain they would benefit America as a whole economically, I’ll leave it to the president to explain why (and how any workers who are harmed can be cushioned).

Repeatedly Mr. Friedman has praised elitism. That’s the obvious source of his fondness for what’s happening in China. Someday the scales will fall from the world’s eyes and they’ll realize that what has happened there is a disaster of world historical proportions that has largely gone to benefit a handful of elites. I guess it’s all worth it if Beijing has a shiny new airport.

In his writings on trade, the foundation of modern views on the benefits of trade, David Ricardo never said there were no losers. There will be losers as a result of the trade pact being negotiated and they will be ordinary American workers. There is no way to “cushion” them without goring an entire herd of sacred cows which means it won’t happen.

15 comments

Ending Energy Subsidies

Now here’s an idea at Washington Monthly I can get behind, ending energy subsidies:

Energy subsidies are the sordid legacy of more than sixty years of politics as usual in Washington, and they cost us somewhere around $20 billion a year. To put that sum in perspective, that’s more than the State Department’s entire budget. It’s also enough to send half a million Americans to college each year with all expenses paid. Energy subsidies undermine the working of the free market, and they make rational approaches to long-term energy challenges and climate change impossible. They are not an aid to energy independence or environmental stewardship. They are an impediment.

Energy subsidies take many forms. Some of them are direct outlays of taxpayer dollars, like payments to corn producers for ethanol. Most are in the form of tax benefits, such as the deduction for “intangible drilling costs” (labor, repairs, hauling, you name it) in oil exploration—a notoriously abused provision of the tax code. The sheer number of subsidies is part of what makes them so hard to track.

but then the author goes off the rails in the mistaken belief that ending energy subsidies will help solar, wind, and other so-called “green” energy strategies. That’s mistaken. The subsidy for solar energy is 96 cents per kilowatt-hour compared to one cent per kilowatt-hour for fossil fuels.

However, let the competing strategies compete on their own merits. Stop subsidizing energy production. If you must subsidize something energy-related subsidize energy transmission. The incentives for the industry to improve the transmission grid on its own are terribly low.

5 comments

Violence As a First Resort

I am continuing to read misguided op-eds in major news outlets and posts on blogs in support of the rioters in Baltimore. In some cases it’s being characterized as a last resort.

That is nonsense. It’s a first resort. They’ve been trying the same thing over and over again for the last 80 years and expecting different results. Don’t rob a convenience store. Organize politically.

Here’s a wild idea. Vote for somebody other than a regular Democrat. There are other alternatives out there after all including Greens, reform Democrats, and (gasp!) Republicans. The perfect is the enemy of the good.

15 comments

Supporting Anarchist-Hooligans

Do you recall yesterday when I pointed out that supporting the rioters and looters in Baltimore wasn’t standing up for progressivism but for anarchism and hooliganism? As it turns out there’s some empirical support for my hipshot assessment:

An analysis of social media traffic in downtown Baltimore Monday has unearthed striking connections to the protests in Ferguson, Mo. last year, according to a leading data mining firm that shared its findings exclusively with Fox News.

The firm, which asked to remain anonymous because of its government work, found between 20 and 50 social media accounts in Baltimore that were also tied to the peak period of violence in Ferguson. While further analysis is being conducted on the data, it suggests the presence of “professional protesters” or anarchists taking advantage of Freddie Gray’s death to incite more violence.

The worst part of supporting the rioters even obliquely is that it will hurt rather than help poor urban blacks.

3 comments

Healing the Cities

The editors of the Wall Street Journal seize on the riots in Baltimore as an opportunity to criticize Democratic Party domination of cities:

Nothing excuses the violence of rampaging students or the failure of city officials to stop it before Maryland’s Governor called in the National Guard. But as order starts to return to the streets, and the usual political suspects lament the lack of economic prospects for the young men who rioted, let’s not forget who has run Baltimore and Maryland for nearly all of the last 40 years.

The men and women in charge have been Democrats, and their governing ideas are “progressive.” This model, with its reliance on government and public unions, has dominated urban America as once-vibrant cities such as Baltimore became shells of their former selves. In 1960 Baltimore was America’s sixth largest city with 940,000 people. It has since shed nearly a third of its population and today isn’t in the top 25.

The dysfunctions of the blue-city model are many, but the main failures are three: high crime, low economic growth and failing public schools that serve primarily as jobs programs for teachers and administrators rather than places of learning.

While I think their identification of the problems is fair, I disagree with some of their other interpretations. Their prescriptions:

It’s time for a new urban renewal, this time built on the ideas of private economic development, personal responsibility, “broken windows” policing, and education choice.

won’t solve our cities problems. I reject their view that Rudy Giuliani’s “broken windows” policing was the linchpin of New York’s recovery. I think that can be attributed to two reasons: New York’s unique cultural position in the United States and the massive federal subsidies that have been heaped on the city over the last several decades. “Broken windows” policing did help but the Disney company among others was instrumental in New York’s revival. Restoring the city’s position as a major tourist destination just isn’t a strategy open to Baltimore, Cleveland, or even Chicago. And if we stop subsidizing the financial sector I strongly suspect that New York will falter.

I don’t know if there’s a single magic bullet for our cities. I can point to some of the things that need to happen, for example we should stop subsidizing oil production, home building, and the highways that ease travel between the urban centers and the suburbs. It’s not that we shouldn’t do any of those things but that we should let them stand on their own two feet and let their actual merits determine what gets done.

Single party rule is obviously a problem but it’s not a problem with a ready solution. Educational choice is a policy that will benefit children with engaged parents and the children of the upper middle class disproportionately. Sadly, many parent just aren’t engaged.

I think that what will make our cities prosper is to stop subsidizing the growth of suburbs and a restoration of economic dynamism but I just don’t know how we get there from here.

9 comments

Time-Shifting

Apparently, quite a lot of the money spent last year was clawed back this year:

Most filers who received government subsidies to buy Obamacare plans had to pay money back to the IRS this year, according to an H&R Block analysis released Monday that looks at the health law’s first full tax season.

The tax-prep giant studied its own massive customer base and concluded that two-thirds of its filers who got subsidies from Obamacare were overpaid during the course of the year, and owed money back to the IRS on the April 15 deadline.

They repaid $729 on average, cutting the average refund by about a third.

I hope the economic implications of that aren’t lost. It means that a significant amount of money was pumped into the economy last year and withdrawn from it this year. In econspeak that’s called “time-shifting”—consumption was transferred from this year to last year.

Sometimes that makes sense, for example, in the early stages of a recovery when you expect substantial growth for years ahead. The present recovery is now, what, 71 months old? Does time-shifting from this year to last year sound like a good idea to you? Oh, well. There were midterm elections to consider.

2 comments

The Sort of Thing

I’m concerned that this incident is the sort of thing that could plunge us into war willy-nilly, especially since the channels of communications between the U. S. and Iran aren’t particularly good:

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — Iranian forces fired warning shots across the bridge of a Marshall Islands-flagged cargo vessel as it was traversing the Strait of Hormuz, boarded the ship and directed it toward the Iranian mainland, a Pentagon official said Tuesday.

The incident with the MV Maersk Tigris, which prompted the U.S. Navy to dispatch a destroyer and a plane in response, comes at a critical time in Iran’s relations with its neighbors and the United States.

Somebody lets off a stray shot or thinks the other guy shot at him and suddenly it’s a real shootin’ war. There’s a lot of ship traffic in the Gulf and a significant number of naval vessels.

0 comments

Legal Question

I have a question for someone with a more informed legal opinion than I have. How does the Supreme Court craft a decision in Obergefell v. Hodges that doesn’t reverse United States v. Windsor so isn’t that something they have to do?

7 comments

Bipartisanship and Red Shoes

Michael Barone takes note of the sudden outbreak of bipartisanship in Washington:

Like spring, bipartisanship is busting out all over. Even more so maybe: Washington in a time of alleged global warming is suffering through a chilly, wet springtime, but bipartisanship is sprouting up like gangbusters.

Exhibit A is the Corker-Cardin legislation, passed unanimously in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, providing for limited congressional review of negotiations with Iran over its nuclear weapons program. Exhibit B is the legislation combating human trafficking, passed unanimously by the Senate last Wednesday. Exhibit C is the elimination of the annual “doc fix,” engineered by Speaker John Boehner and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi.

He goes on to list other deals in the making in the greatest spurt of activity we’ve seen from the Congress in years. Mr. Barone, mistakenly I think, attributes the difference to the president’s lack of involvement in the proceedings.

The great movie, The Red Shoes, ends with the suicide of the prima ballerina. In her absence her ballet slippers are carried around the stage at the performance of the ballet on which she was working. The difference in Congress isn’t the absence of the president. It’s the change in Senate majority leadership.

When will it be recognized that Harry Reid was the worst Senate majority leader in living memory?

10 comments