The editors of the Wall Street Journal seize on the riots in Baltimore as an opportunity to criticize Democratic Party domination of cities:
Nothing excuses the violence of rampaging students or the failure of city officials to stop it before Maryland’s Governor called in the National Guard. But as order starts to return to the streets, and the usual political suspects lament the lack of economic prospects for the young men who rioted, let’s not forget who has run Baltimore and Maryland for nearly all of the last 40 years.
The men and women in charge have been Democrats, and their governing ideas are “progressive.†This model, with its reliance on government and public unions, has dominated urban America as once-vibrant cities such as Baltimore became shells of their former selves. In 1960 Baltimore was America’s sixth largest city with 940,000 people. It has since shed nearly a third of its population and today isn’t in the top 25.
The dysfunctions of the blue-city model are many, but the main failures are three: high crime, low economic growth and failing public schools that serve primarily as jobs programs for teachers and administrators rather than places of learning.
While I think their identification of the problems is fair, I disagree with some of their other interpretations. Their prescriptions:
It’s time for a new urban renewal, this time built on the ideas of private economic development, personal responsibility, “broken windows†policing, and education choice.
won’t solve our cities problems. I reject their view that Rudy Giuliani’s “broken windows” policing was the linchpin of New York’s recovery. I think that can be attributed to two reasons: New York’s unique cultural position in the United States and the massive federal subsidies that have been heaped on the city over the last several decades. “Broken windows” policing did help but the Disney company among others was instrumental in New York’s revival. Restoring the city’s position as a major tourist destination just isn’t a strategy open to Baltimore, Cleveland, or even Chicago. And if we stop subsidizing the financial sector I strongly suspect that New York will falter.
I don’t know if there’s a single magic bullet for our cities. I can point to some of the things that need to happen, for example we should stop subsidizing oil production, home building, and the highways that ease travel between the urban centers and the suburbs. It’s not that we shouldn’t do any of those things but that we should let them stand on their own two feet and let their actual merits determine what gets done.
Single party rule is obviously a problem but it’s not a problem with a ready solution. Educational choice is a policy that will benefit children with engaged parents and the children of the upper middle class disproportionately. Sadly, many parent just aren’t engaged.
I think that what will make our cities prosper is to stop subsidizing the growth of suburbs and a restoration of economic dynamism but I just don’t know how we get there from here.