The Trib Demurs

Well, this is interesting. The editors of the Chicago Tribune disagree with those of the Washington Post:

Mosby [ed. the Baltimore state’s attorney] bypassed a grand jury, declaring unflinchingly that she had found probable cause to file the charges herself. She batted away a call for her to step aside and let a special prosecutor handle the case because her husband is a Baltimore city councilman.

She owned the decision. She projected a sense of urgency. We pray that her confidence is well founded, that she did not act in haste in the midst of a political and social firestorm.

These are serious charges, and rare. Six officers are accused of arresting Gray for no good reason, roughing him up and ignoring his pleas for medical attention as he bounced around, unrestrained, in the back of a police wagon that made four stops on its way to the station.

[…]

This case needs to be about what happened between Freddie Gray and the six police officers who interacted with him on April 12, not about righting the entire criminal justice system. The stakes are high enough already.

Again, let’s not rush to judgment. Justice will emerge from the trial not from op-ed pages, tweets, or Facebook posts.

6 comments

How Easy We Are to Identify

Well, this is encouraging. It turns out that just four pieces of information are required to identify individuals in 90% of cases: the dates and locations of four purchases. That’s true in datasets that don’t include what we think of as “personally identifiable information”, i.e. names, addresses, telephone numbers, credit card numbers.

European laws are much stricter about the information governments are allowed to possess and the information companies are allowed to retain. Land of the free, indeed.

0 comments

A Step Towards…What?

The editors of the Washington Post proclaim the indictment of six police officers on crimes related to the death of a man in their custody that have sparked demonstrations, riots, and looting in Baltimore “a step toward justice”:

The decision to prosecute the six officers involved in Mr. Gray’s death therefore affords an opening for justice. That justice would be first and foremost for Mr. Gray and — if it provides an impetus for enacting more sensible rules for dealing with police misconduct — for future victims of abuse by police.

I am content to let the case work its way through the courts. I don’t know what happened in Baltimore. I don’t know what caused the death of Freddie Gray. That will emerge in the trial and we can only hope that justice will be done, whatever that might be.

So far things are promising. Baltimore had a relatively peaceful night last night. Whether it will remain so we can only speculate.

I hope those calling for justice are not disappointed if a future trial leads to acquittals of all of the police officers. Indictments of police officers for the deaths of individuals in their custody are rare but convictions are almost unheard of. Particularly in the case of the most serious charge I can see any number of ways that a jury might have reasonable doubt. Based on my personal experience with Chicago juries I will be greatly surprised if the police officers are convicted of anything.

Meanwhile, let justice be done. And let’s not leap to a judgment of what that might require.

0 comments

Another Part of the Forest

Writing at Daily Beast John McWhorter has an interesting take on the inner city black social dysfunction that has lead to the situation in St. Louis and Baltimore:

First, the Black Power ideology that proliferated in the 1960s and ’70s discouraged black communities from maintaining the old-time mantra that adversity meant that blacks have to try twice as hard. The wise insight was that after centuries in the United States, the persistent double standard was demeaning, and while that made basic sense, it changed black America’s orientation towards individual initiative. That helps explain, for example, why only in the ’60s did it become common for poor blacks to burn their own neighborhoods in protest. Even amidst Jim Crow, black people did not do this.

Second, in the late ’60s, partly in response to the riots of the Long Hot Summers, welfare was transformed from a time-limited program intended for widows to an open-ended program that didn’t care whether recipients ever got jobs. This had the unintended consequence of discouraging marriage, and made it easier for women to raise kids without the father around. This, a story too little told (read it here), decisively impacted the black experience nationwide.

Finally, the War on Drugs created a black market alternative to legal work for poor black men underserved by bad schools. Frankly, The Wire explained this dynamic better than any academic analysis.

There’s an aspect of this whole thing that I haven’t seen pointed out by anyone. St. Louis (of which Ferguson is a close-in suburb) and Baltimore have something in common. Each city is its own county. That means that whites were able to flee the increasingly black city centers by stepping across the city line.

26 comments

Turning on Turnout

I think there’s a kernel of truth in Sean Trende’s musings over why Hillary Clinton is running to the left:

I tend to think overall that the 2016 election will be decided much more by the state of the economy than Hillary Clinton’s positioning on marriage equality or ability to increase youth participation rates. In that respect, Wednesday’s GDP report was much worse news for Democrats than anything we might discern about youth turnout in 2016 (though it remains to be seen if there is a summer “bounce-back” for the economy, as there was last year).

But I do think party coalitions matter, however, at least on the margins. In that respect, I think Beutler identifies the most important issue, by several orders of magnitude, for 2016: Is Obama’s coalition transferrable to Clinton (or other Democrats)? I think we need to flesh out this question a bit before we can turn to Beutler’s second question, which actually asks what Hillary Clinton’s positioning tells us about the answer to the first question.

I think the answer is pretty obvious: she’s doing what she needs to do to prevent serious primary competition and that’s run to the left. What she does after the primaries is anybody’s guess.

The kernel of truth is this: the 2016 general election will be about turnout. It will turn on which candidate is better able to draw out his or her voters or demotivate her or his opponent’s voters.

That’s why I think that Democrats should be running from Hillary Clinton. Presuming she remains the candidate, between now and November 2016 there will be a Chinese water torture of scandals and tone-deaf statements with surrogates fanning out to perform damage control with increasing lame and incredible excuses. That won’t convince a single Democrat to vote for her Republican opponent whomever that might be but it will discourage them from turning out to vote at all. Conversely, Republicans will be increasingly motivated to vote against Hillary.

0 comments

Give and Take

I wonder if former Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke is enjoying blogging?

It’s nice to know we’re being read, and Thursday’s editorial on “The Slow-Growth Fed” sure got a rise out of Ben Bernanke. The former Federal Reserve Chairman turned blogger turned Pimco adviser wrote to defend the central bank and by implication his policies as innocent of responsibility for subpar economic growth.

This is fun, so let’s parse the Revered One’s arguments. First, Mr. Bernanke accuses us of “forecasting a breakout in inflation” at least since 2006. The central banker is getting into the polemical swing, but he’s wild with that one. We’re not always right. But we’ve been careful not to join some of our friends in predicting inflation from the Fed’s post-crisis policies. We’ve written that we are in uncharted monetary territory with risks and outcomes we lack the foresight to predict.

[…]

Mr. Bernanke defends the Fed’s over-optimistic economic growth forecasts by saying the central bank has been overly pessimistic about unemployment. “The relatively rapid decline in unemployment in recent years shows that the critical objective of putting people back to work is being met,” Mr. Bernanke writes.

Now, that’s over-optimism. One reason the jobless rate has fallen to 5.5% is because so many people have left the workforce. The labor participation rate has plunged to 1978 levels during this supposedly splendid expansion. Most economists acknowledge that if the participation rate had stayed constant, the jobless rate would still be close to 8%. The failure to attract the long-term unemployed into the job market is one reason the Fed continues to hold interest rates so low.

Mr. Bernanke’s other defense is the counterfactual that it could have been worse: “It seems clear that the Fed’s aggressive actions are an important reason that job creation in the United States has outstripped that of other industrial countries by a wide margin.”

That’s conveniently unprovable, not least because it doesn’t correct for non-monetary variables. The structural policy impediments to growth in Europe and Japan are far worse than in the U.S., yet Mr. Bernanke implies that the main policy difference is that they waited too long to try QE.

There’s a lot more in the Wall Street Journal’s counter-rebuttal of Dr. Bernanke’s retort. What’s amazing to me is that Dr. Bernanke appears to believe in what he’s saying. The simpler explanation would be that the results of quantitative easing, boosting asset prices with few other effects, was what was intended.

The whole thing reminds me of a physician who continues to prescribe a test that has been proven to be useless because it’s the standard of care. At some point you’d think you’d revisit your assumptions.

7 comments

The STEM Shortage

When you hear stories about the shortage of science and technology workers think about this:

From the perspective of five laid-off Disney IT workers, all of whom agreed to speak on the condition of anonymity, Disney cut well-paid and longtime staff members, some who had been previously singled out for excellence, as it shifted work to contractors. These contractors used foreign labor, mostly from India. The laid-off workers believe the primary motivation behind Disney’s action was cost-cutting.

“Some of these folks were literally flown in the day before to take over the exact same job I was doing,” said one of the IT workers who lost his job. He trained his replacement and is angry over the fact he had to train someone from India “on site, in our country.”

The total number of workers who were replaced was something between 120 and 200. IMO this is an abuse of the H-1B or L-1 visa and the law should be amended accordingly.

Meanwhile, why should an American kid study hard subjects like science or technology? They’d be better off spending their time on easier courses. Their earnings will be capped by whatever a foreign worker is willing to accept.

9 comments

Race Matters

I just heard an interesting report on NPR on the racial aspects of the rioting and looting and what’s going on may not be as simple as the white-black narrative we’ve been hearing. Apparently, in some parts of Baltimore stores owned by Asians are being especially targeted.

That parallels what happened in the 1960s except that 50 years ago it was stores owned by Jews that were being targeted. After the destruction the Jews moved out, leaving empty storefronts or hollow shells. Don’t be surprised if the Asians do the same thing.

As far as the police are concerned I strongly suspect it’s not a white-black issue but a black-blue one.

6 comments

Lots of Problems But No Solutions

While Karl Rove points, correctly, to “the messes Obama left behind”:

Slow economic growth will be at the top of the list of problems. The pattern of American history has been that the more severe the recession, the stronger the recovery. Until now. In Mr. Obama’s recovery, average annual growth has been the slowest since the U.S. began compiling reliable economic statistics near the 20th century’s beginning—a feeble 2.9%. This year is off to an even slower start, with GDP growing 0.2% in the first three months.

The number of jobs also will be on that list. It took from June 2009 to April 2014—nearly five full years—to get back to having the same number of people working as when the recession began in December 2007. That’s a longer period of time to return to the starting point than in any recession in U.S. history. Meantime, roughly 14.7 million people came of age without a job available. The last time the job participation rate was this low was 1978. A third of Americans between 18 and 31 last year were living with their parents, the highest percentage in at least four decades.

The quality of jobs available will be another topic on that list. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says 4.5 million Americans were working part time for economic reasons in December 2007, meaning they could not find full-time work. Last month the number was 6.6 million—a 46% increase. More part-time workers are getting fewer than 30 hours a week, in part probably because of ObamaCare.

Then there is the size of Americans’ paychecks. Inflation-adjusted median household income has dropped, from $54,059 in 2009 to $51,939 in 2013 (the latest year available), the only time this has happened during an economic recovery. The president who harps on inequality as a “defining issue of our time” has demonstrated that the middle class fares badly under progressive economic policies.

his remarks suffer from the same problems that afflict most of the punditry. He points out the problems but not to the solutions.

The modern Republican Party has only one domestic policy: tax cuts. There are members who espouse other policies but it’s the single point of consensus. Tax cuts of themselves will not increase the number of jobs, the quality of jobs, or income stagnation for most Americans. What other policies should be put into place? There is only silence.

There is a Congressional consensus favoring increased immigration. That is inconsistent with wage growth.

There are solutions to these problems but no one in a position to effectuate them is proposing them because they don’t bring in campaign contributions or put money into the Clintons’ foundation. If there is any justification whatever for political violence, the molotov cocktails are being thrown in the wrong direction.

6 comments

A House Divided

I continue to be appalled at the number of columnists who are justifying the riots and looting going on in Baltimore. The issues of poverty and injustice should not be conjoined with crime and vandalism. They are not meeting their burden of proof. They are assuming that the protesters and the rioters are the same people. As I pointed out yesterday there is evidence that they are different if not distinct groups. Those justifying the rioters need to produce evidence that they’re one and the same.

Keep in mind that even given the assumptions of those justifying violence, the rioters and looters are in rebellion against the democratically elected and duly constituted authorities in Baltimore. If the salt shall lose its savor, with what shall it be salted? What do they want instead of democracy? Autocracy? Is that something that should be justified for any reason whatever?

President Obama erred when he laid the problem at the feet of all of us. The cities have been petri dishes for Democratic Party government for most of the last 80 years. Democrats need a change of heart. They should stop justifying their own politicians on the fallacious grounds that two wrongs make a right. They need to do better. They need to do something different.

17 comments