Meeting the Qualifications

When I read commentary like Ruth Marcus’s column on how Carly Fiorina is unqualified to be president, I am immediately struck with the recognition that Ms. Marcus has no idea what CEOs of Fortune 500 companies do. I have known quite a few over the years and I’ll tell you: they’re politicians. The same is true of generals. You don’t make it to general without being a politician.

I don’t care for Carly Fiorina and wouldn’t vote for her but it’s not because she’s unqualified. She meets the constitutional requirements of age and being a native-born citizen. Those are the only requirements.

For those who think there are other requirements, explain to me again how a one-term senator who’s only been elected in one statewide election in what’s generally considered a “safe” state is qualified to be president.

Just for the record I think that Barack Obama was qualified to be president in 2008 just as I think Carly Fiorina is now. I honestly don’t think you can make Ruth Marcus’s qualifications argument without deciding that Hillary Clinton isn’t qualified to be president but I guess that where you sit is where you stand.

1 comment

Disproving a Theory Is Easy

I am heterodox when it comes to my environmental policy views. I believe that anthropogenic climate is real but I’m an agnostic about the role of carbon dioxide. I believe that we should change our policies to be more environment-friendly but I think that most of the changes that we’ve made over the last 30 years have been futile if not counterproductive. I don’t believe that one size will fit all in environmental policy and I don’t believe that developing economies have a right to follow a path identical to the ones that developed economies did because we know more now than we did then. When conditions are different, you hold to different standards. I also hold the very non-conformist view that an individual’s carbon emissions tend to increase geometrically with his or her income or, said more simply, if you want to reduce worldwide carbon emissions you need to figure out a way to motivate the richest people to reduce theirs which means that most policies make people feel better but don’t have a great deal of effect.

One thing that I do know is that anecdotes can’t prove a theory and that the minimum standard for proving the truth of a theory is that the theory be predictive. Anecdotes can, however, disprove theories and lists like this one should at the very least cause people to re-examine their beliefs.

In the interest of balance here’s the flipside of that coin.

Unfortunately, at this we have divided into two angry camps neither of which pays any attention to the other’s pronouncements. The articles I’ve linked to won’t convince anybody of anything because most of the people have already made up their minds.

3 comments

The Power of Trade Unions

If in your readings about the outcome of the recent British elections, you see something about Labour’s problem with being beholden to trade unions, keep in mind that 25% of Britons are members of trade unions compared with 10% of Americans. American union membership as a percentage peaked in 1954 at 35%.

2 comments

The Poorest in the United States

There’s a reason the ad hominem fallacy is a fallacy. It’s been summed up as “even a stopped clock is right twice a day”. Regardless of intent, track record, or any other factor even people you dislike may occasionally be right. Concentrate on the arguments not the individuals. While it may be fun to mock Darrell Issa for being a dope, what’s the reality of poverty in the U. S.?

By world standards the poverty threshold of $11,170 for an individual isn’t poor at all. By IMF and World Bank standards it’s middle income.

However, we do have very poor people in the United States, not just people who meet the official U. S. definition of poverty but those who are poor by world standards. Much of the information in the rest of this post is derived from here.

Based on information from the 2000 Census (the comparable info from the 2010 census isn’t available yet), the poorest community in the U. S. is Allen, South Dakota. The per capita income there is $1,539. It is small, very remote, and 94% of the people who live there are Lakota. That income is roughly $4 a day—that’s not only poor by U. S. standards, it’s poor by Chinese or Indian standards.

When you look at the poorest of poor communities in the United States, you see a pattern. They are small; they are rural; they are in North Dakota, South Dakota, Texas, Oklahoma, California, New Mexico, Arizona, or Montana. A substantial percentage of their populations is Native American, black, or, particularly in Texas, Mexican.

These people are barely reached by the support systems we have in place which are mostly targeted to the urban poor who, as mentioned above, aren’t poor at all. They’re just relatively poor. They have cars, refrigerators, televisions, DVD players, and cable.

The main problem in the poorest communities isn’t income inequality. It’s just plain poverty. It wouldn’t take much to help a lot in these communities. It’s a scandal and an outrage that we don’t devote more of our resources in time, attention, and money to them. But as long as anti-poverty programs are actually “get out the vote” campaigns that won’t happen.

22 comments

Why Should They Behave That Way?

I have only one question for the editors of the Washington Post about their reaction piece to the Illinois Supreme Court’s decision that the legislature’s strategy for dealing with the state’s pension problem was unconstitutional:

We don’t have any good advice for Mr. Rauner, but the lessons are clear enough: No state should ever get into such a financial trap in the first place. Elected officials should make only promises their states can afford to keep.

Why? Why should they behave that way? The guy who makes unfulfillable promises gets elected and re-elected, again and again and again. The guy who doesn’t won’t make it through the front gate.

The clear problem here is that, just as with the financial crisis, everybody is operating based on their incentives and it will culminate in disaster. During the housing bubble there was a cynical slogan: IBGYBG. “I’ll be gone; you’ll be gone”. We’ll make a lot of money and by the time the nickel drops we’ll both have left town. It’s the same here.

The only way to change this is to change the incentives. I can think of a dozen ways to do that and every single one of them would be opposed by powerful constituencies for which they are a matter of life and death.

0 comments

Treating Democrats Like Republicans

Dana Milbank cautions the president that his approach to persuading his fellow Democrats might well cost him the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade deal he’s been trying to secure:

Let’s suppose you are trying to bring a friend around to your point of view.

Would you tell her she’s emotional, illogical, outdated and not very smart? Would you complain that he’s being dishonest, fabricating falsehoods and denying reality with his knee-jerk response?

Such a method of a persuasion is likelier to get you a black eye than a convert. Yet this is how President Obama treats his fellow Democrats on trade — and why he’s in danger of losing.

The vast majority of lawmakers in his own party oppose him on trade legislation. Yet rather than accept that they have a legitimate beef, he shows public contempt for them…

Welcome to the show, Democrats. That’s how President Obama has been treating the Republicans for the last six years. Is it any wonder they’re hostile to him? When you pile that attitude on top of ordinary partisan opposition you get, well, what we’ve been getting for the last six years. It’s a sad commentary when your president would rather be right than president.

Every single Congressman is a mature successful individual each of whom has won his or her own election and in some cases has been winning them since President Obama was in grammar school. Not only do they deserve better treatment, it’s a more effective way of doing the people’s business.

7 comments

Tips for Self-Checkout

Here’s a tip I wanted to pass along for using a self-checkout lane at the supermarket. When using a public touchscreen don’t press the center of the button. Press closer to the edge. The center is more likely to be worn and won’t register the touch as well.

7 comments

Mother’s Day Movies

It’s getting a bit late on Mother’s Day but it occurred to me I had never made a list of movies for Mother’s Day. Quite a few of the “women’s pictures” from the 1930s and 40s fit the bill as would anything based on a novel by Edna Ferber. I’ll just spew out a list:

I Remember Mama
Stella Dallas
Imitation of Life (the 1934 version not the 1959 one)
The Sin of Madelon Claudet
Fanny
Two Women (a bit grim but there you are)
Auntie Mame
Penny Serenade
Mrs. Miniver
Min and Bill

There’s another interesting list to be made—pictures peculiarly unsuited for Mother’s Day. Here goes.

Psycho
The Bad Seed
Mommie Dearest
Flowers in the Attic

Now here’s a question for you. Which list does Mildred Pierce belong on? I think I might put the 1945 version on the first list and the recent miniseries version on the second.

9 comments

Post-Apocalyptic Novels

I was a little saddened by this list of post-apocalyptic fiction at The Guardian. Was anything in the list written before 1970? I think the oldest book in her list is The Stand (1978). I was saddened because I’m a collector of 19th and early 20th century science fiction, the end of the world has been a popular theme in science fiction for 150 years, and most of the themes you’ll find in more recent books are just elaborations of things that were explored a century ago.

As it turns out, I’ve produced a list of older post-apocalyptic novels before, “The Beginning of the End”, and a list of older movies with a post-apocalyptic theme, “Apocalypse…Now and Then”. One of the neat things about the older novels is that a lot of them are available for free on Project Gutenberg.

There’s no dirth of post-apocalyptic novels written between 1950 and 1970, either. Brian Aldiss’s Greybeard, Richard Matheson’s I Am Legend, Nevil Shute’s On the Beach, Piers Anthony’s Sos the Rope, Poul Anderson’s Maurai series, and Andre Norton’s Star Man’s Son, 2250 A.D. immediately leap to mind.

12 comments

A Radical Solution for Over-Regulation

I disapprove of the strategy for dealing with over-regulation being proposed by Charles Murray in his WSJ op-ed on principle:

Let’s just ignore them and go on about our lives as if they didn’t exist.

The risk in doing so, of course, is that one of the 70-odd regulatory agencies will find out what you’re doing and come after you. But there’s a way around that as well: Let’s treat government as an insurable hazard, like tornadoes.
People don’t build tornado-proof houses; they buy house insurance. In the case of the regulatory state, let’s buy insurance that reimburses us for any fine that the government levies and that automatically triggers a proactive, tenacious legal defense against the government’s allegation even if—and this is crucial—we are technically guilty.

Why litigate an allegation even if we are technically guilty? To create a disincentive for overzealous regulators. The goal is to empower citizens to say, “If you come after me, it’s going to cost your office a lot of time and trouble, and probably some bad publicity.” If even one citizen says that, in a case where the violation didn’t harm anything or anyone, the bureaucrat has to ask, “Do I really want to take this on?” If it’s the 10th citizen in the past month who says it and the office is struggling with a backlog of cases, it’s unlikely that the bureaucrat’s supervisor will even permit him take it on.

I propose two frameworks for implementing this strategy. The first would be a legal foundation functioning much as the Legal Services Corporation does for the poor, except that its money will come from private donors, not the government. It would be an altruistic endeavor, operating exclusively on behalf of the homeowner or small business being harassed by the regulators. The foundation would pick up all the legal costs of the defense and pay the fines when possible.

The other framework would be occupational defense funds. Let’s take advantage of professional expertise and pride of vocation to drive standards of best practice. For example, the American Dental Association could form Dental Shield, with dentists across America paying a small annual fee. The bargain: Dentists whose practices meet the ADA’s professional standards will be defended when accused of violating a regulation that the ADA has deemed to be pointless, stupid or tyrannical. The same kind of defense fund could be started by truckers, crafts unions, accountants, physicians, farmers or almost any other occupation.

because I believe that widespread law-breaking weakens the law and the general fabric of the society. It’s why I disapprove of violent rebellion as well as passive resistance in all but the most extreme of circumstances. It’s also why I disapprove of the ridiculously large number of laws and regulations heaped on us. They, too, weaken the fabric of our society by incentivizing exactly the sort of measures that Mr. Murray proposes.

However, I recognize the strategy. It is Rule #4 of Saul Alinsky’s Rules for Radicals:

Make the enemy live up to its own book of rules.

It is a sad state of affairs indeed when a society is strained between leftwing radicals and rightwing radicals. Are there no more conservatives or liberals worthy of the names?

If I were going to use Mr. Alinsky’s rules, I think I’d use Rule #4 somewhat differently. I would routinely, consistently, and systematically point out how a) the Congress and b) federal agencies fail to follow their own laws and regulations even if those laws and regulations expressly exclude them. Regulators have plenty of incentives. They need some disincentives, too.

I would also suggest Rule #12. Target individuals not just agencies.

9 comments