It’s Death for Tsarnaev

The trial of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the surviving “Boston Marathon bomber”, has not resulted in the outcome that some of us might have hoped for. He has been sentenced to death. The editors of the Wall Street Journal declaim:

Had Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev been sentenced to life at a federal Supermax prison, his remaining years would have been spent in a tiny concrete cell, 23 hours a day, constantly alone, with barely a sight of the sky and none of the country. As punishment for crime goes, that might have been enough.

But more than punishment was at stake in the case of Tsarnaev, who was sentenced to death Friday by a Boston jury after 14 hours of deliberation for the 2013 bombing that killed three and injured some 300, many maimed for life. The bombing was no mere criminal act carried out on an especially large scale. Tsarnaev and his brother Tamerlan, who died trying to escape arrest, carried out an act of war aimed at the institutions and values of American civic life.

The victims were unsuspecting and defenseless, and the damage done will be felt for decades. Think of the Richard family: Bill Richard, the father, eardrums blown and wounded with shrapnel; his wife Denise, who lost an eye; daughter Jane, who lost a leg; son Henry, unwounded but traumatized; son Martin, murdered at the age of eight.

No society serious about its self-defense and preservation can tolerate this. There are strong arguments for and against the death penalty, and there is no doubt that innocent men have been killed by the state. But there is no doubt of guilt in this case. And whatever else one believes about the death penalty, it sends an unmistakable message that even a society as tolerant as ours still believes that some acts deserve the ultimate penalty.

I think that most of us would agree that Mr. Tsarnaev does not make a particularly attractive case for opposing the death penalty. As I have mentioned before my view is that proportionality requires that for some degree of offense the death penalty should be available. Even in Mr. Tsarnaev’s case I’m not extremely comfortable with the death penalty.

Those who take principled stances against the death penalty should take some solace in the reality that Mr. Tsarnaev may never face it. The period of years required for appeals is a long time, as I have pointed out before. He may die. He may be murdered. The death penalty may be abolished in the United States.

4 comments

Hersh’s Version and Who Knew What and When?

Over at Bloomberg Noah Feldman has some interesting observations about Seymour Hersh’s account of the assassination of Osama bin Laden:

Hersh’s account — which cites both named and unnamed sources — differs in three important ways, raising new legal questions. First, Hersh says that the U.S. knew bin Laden was being held in the Abbottabad compound as a prisoner of the Pakistani ISI, that country’s intelligence service. The U.S. knew that his ISI guards would be gone from the compound — and as a result, Hersh implies, the U.S. knew with a high degree of likelihood that there would be no guns in the compound and no resistance.

If the U.S. in fact knew that bin Laden was effectively a prisoner -– not to mention that he was unarmed and unprotected — then killing him would almost certainly have violated the laws of war. A former combatant who is “hors de combat” — rendered incapable of fighting — isn’t a lawful target for killing. A prisoner is a perfect example. (To make matters worse, Hersh also reports that bin Laden was known to be an invalid.) Of course, Seal Team Six couldn’t be 100 percent certain that bin Laden was unarmed and without a kamikaze device — and who knows what orders they received. But according to Hersh, the chain of command knew bin Laden was effectively an unarmed, unprotected prisoner.

Read the whole thing. The key point is that killing an enemy is lawful under the laws of war but murdering one is not. Also, it’s possible that the White House committed a war crime but Seal Team Six did not. It all depends on the details, who knew what and when.

12 comments

Knowing What We Knew Then

BTW, I don’t have a problem answering the question that Jeb Bush bungled. Not only do I think that knowing what we know now we should not have invaded Iraq, I thought that knowing what we knew then we should not have invaded and everything that has happened since has supported the views I expressed at the time. It’s not a difficult question to answer, requiring fine discrimination and careful judgment.

Why is it that in mitigating risks we always take the most violent of available strategies? I don’t think it’s for pragmatic reasons but for political ones.

3 comments

Junked 2

The sequel! Better than Sharknado 2! Moody’s has reduced now reduced the Chicago Public Schools’s and the Chicago Park District’s bond to junk status as well. That means that they, too, will need to come up with substantial payments to the banks. editors of the Wall Street Journal put in their two cents:

Illinois’s domination by public unions has the state dancing on the edge of fiscal freefall. The state Supreme Court ruled last week that Springfield can’t alter pension benefits, prompting Moody’s this week to downgrade the debt of the city, its public schools and park district all to junk status. Now the Chicago Teachers Union wants to make another contribution to the collapse.

In May the union filed an unfair labor practice complaint with the Illinois Educational Labor Relations Board, accusing the school district of failing to bargain in good faith and rejecting mediation to reach a new contract. The union’s complaint? The school district wants teachers to chip in more for their pensions. The horror.

The dispute goes back to 1981, when in lieu of larger pay raises the district agreed to pick up seven percentage points of the teachers’ contribution of 9% of their salaries to their pensions. This is on top of the district’s own contribution. Teachers have since become accustomed to paying only 2% of their salaries for pensions, about $1,496 a year on average.

Many current teachers weren’t in the school system in 1981, but they like the perk of paying a fraction of their pension cost. Who wouldn’t? The 2% contribution is far less than the 9% contributions made by many other public employees in Illinois, let alone the 6.2% payroll tax for Social Security or what private workers pay into 401(k)s.

Teachers are also comparatively well compensated. The Illinois State Board of Education says the average Chicago teacher salary is about $71,000 a year. That compares to Chicago’s median salary of $47,270 in 2009-2013, according to the Census Bureau. The average starting pension for a Chicago teacher retiring in 2011 after a public-school career was $77,496, according to the Illinois Policy Institute. The city will pay a teacher who retired in 2011 some $2.4 million during retirement, up from $1.35 million a decade earlier.

The starting wage for a ten month position with bachelors only for a Chicago school teacher is around $50,000. Much of the foregoing is territory I covered during the teachers’ strike a couple of years ago. To one of my posts a commenter who was very favorably disposed to the CTU admitted that their cause was not a particularly sympathetic one.

If anyone has ideas for solving CPS’s problems without cuts, I’m all ears. I think the best we’re going to come up with is a list along the lines of the one I proposed yesterday, i.e. shared sacrifice. There does come a point at which Chicago will realize a Detroit-like degenerative spiral. That last step is a long one and you don’t necessarily know when it will come.

11 comments

A Trade Agreement With Japan

Charles Lane is upset that anyone should disagree with the administration about the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement:

In Greek mythology, Sisyphus paid for his sins by being compelled to push a boulder up a steep hill, only to have it roll back down, over and over again.

If the gods had really wanted to frustrate him, though, they would have assigned Sisyphus to fact-check the misinformation opponents of the Trans-Pacific Partnership are spreading in their desperate effort to block that manifestly beneficial free-trade agreement between the United States and 11 other countries.

I, on the other hand, think that we should be wary about a trade agreement with countries that have a policy of currency manipulation. I also think that any partnership with countries whose economies are closely tied with that of China probably aren’t worth the paper they’re printed on (or the disk storage they’re recorded on).

However, let’s get down to the nitty gritty. This isn’t a free trade agreement but a managed trade agreement. We already have managed trade agreements with Canada, Mexico, Australia, and Singapore, generally referred to as “free trade agreements”, which with the exception of Japan constitute the largest economies among the countries with which we’re negotiating. That raises a question that I think needs answering: what will we secure in a trade agreement with Japan that we don’t already have? Be specific. The essence of this agreement is an agreement with Japan.

4 comments

In Regards to David

I think it must have been a decade since I’ve watched David Letterman’s program. I thought it was amusing in its day. I need an honest opinion. Are the lionizations of him on his departure deserved for what he’s been doing lately or are they mostly nostalgic?

3 comments

Who Is Our Greatest Living President?

I’m surprised that anyone would have a problem answering this question in any other way: George H. W. Bush. He is a decent and honorable man. He did what he thought was right even thought it ultimately cost him re-election. When he took us to war, he did so very much by the standards that a consensus of Americans apparently support.

I am not a Republican and I never voted for him. I don’t like dynasties.

Jimmy Carter’s policies lead directly to a collapse of the American foreign policy edifice we had been building for 30 years and have labored to find a substitute for ever since. Bill Clinton was lucky and IMO is not a good man. George W. Bush is a dope. Barack Obama doubled down on too many of George W. Bush’s policies and added a dollop of catering to favored constituencies.

3 comments

Junked

Moody’s has cut Chicago’s credit rating by two notches to junk status. The editors of the Chicago Tribune remark:

That means Chicagoans likely must pay much higher interest to borrow money for the city’s many needs. And the spreading awareness that Illinois governments can’t control their pension crises casts new suspicion on the creditworthiness of cities, suburbs, towns and school districts statewide — that is, on many of the 7,000 local governments here in what we’ve called The Government State.

Chicago’s corporate counsel has said that he doesn’t think that the Illinois Supreme Court’s decision will have any effect on Chicago’s plan to deal with its public employee pension problems. If I can find the link I’ll post it. I’m skeptical. Just because he’s a lawyer it doesn’t mean he’s a good one.

In the interests of thinking positive, here’s my plan for digging Chicago out of the hole it’s dug for itself. Remember: it’s an imperfect world and the best we can hope for at this late stage in the game is a plan in which the pain is shared.

  1. Get a reprieve from the state on bringing our pension fund up to snuff. This is a sine qua non. It doesn’t solve anything but it does provide some head room.
  2. Eliminate any new city hiring that has been scheduled and any new city projects that don’t have a pay-off in reduced operating costs by the end of 2017.
  3. Increase taxes. I think that some small tax increases are inescapable. My first step would be a small increase in the residential property tax and a change in the property tax multiplier so that Loop properties are taxed a little higher than they are now. I think that an increase in the sales tax should be avoided.
  4. Cut the wages of city employees. I realize that this is the Third Rail but I don’t see how it can be avoided, either. If there are to be shared sacrifices, city employees need to put something on the table, too. It would also have the benefit of reducing future liabilities.
  5. Reduce police overtime where possible and tighten the rules on how firefighters spend their off-duty time.
  6. Most importantly, more economic growth. For this to be anything than an Underpants Gnome proposal, the federal government needs to take some affirmative steps to spur economic growth.
  7. Reduction in city services. These should be avoided if possible.

I’m open to other suggestions. The mayor’s proposal is to pay down the principle on our debt which strikes me as an Underpants Gnome proposal. Keep in mind that increasing the sales tax just drives retail out of the city, that the city doesn’t have the power to impose an income tax, and that higher taxes and fees for businesses will reduce economic activity. So will a higher property tax but we’ve got to do something.

There’s one final point I’d like to make on this. For Chicago to overcome its problems, it’s going to need to become a very different city from the one it’s been for the last 60 years. Business as usual won’t solve anything.

Update

It may be that some readers don’t recognize how serious this downgrade is for Chicago. The downgrade triggers about $2.2 billion in additional payments to banks. To place that in perspective, Chicago’s total corporate fund budget for 2015, most of the city’s project spending, is $3.5 billion. This is a big deal.

3 comments

Policy Prescriptions I Agree With

It doesn’t happen very often but I think I may agree with all four of William Handke’s policy prescriptions in his post at RealClearPolicy:

The American economy is not what it once was. Picture it as a building: Its foundations were once thick, strengthened by a large middle class and a realistic minimum wage. Its breadth was considerable, with plenty of room for everyone and then some. Its reach was high, but not dangerously so. Its penthouse was well adorned, but not decadent. Surely, some Americans struggled, but most moved upward and many more had the chance to do so.

Now, the economy has grown hollow, its base and woodwork worn through, as middle-class wages have stagnated. Many of its rooms are now poorly kept and packed full, even as its penthouse suites grow roomier and climb higher and higher, their soaring windows accruing rosier and rosier tints, their few and fortuned denizens elevated to such a level that they forget those on whom their wealth was built and ultimately relies. Today, many struggle, some move forward, and fewer have the chance to do so.

To be sure I do have some quibbles. For example, I’d increase the minimum wage more gradually than he proposes with more conditions for increasing it written into the statute. The consensus of economists seems to be that a modest increase in the minimum wage is unlikely to have a serious impact on the number of minimum wage jobs on offer. I’d raise the wage gradually so we could be more sure of that.

I also think we need a tighter labor market so I’d put in some robust workplace enforcement.

I think I would be cautious about “reducing welfare”, too. At this point SSDI is the unemployment insurance of last resort and until we get much more robust job growth than we’ve seen for the last seven years I wouldn’t want to kick the legs out from under it.

That I like his proposals is virtually a guarantee that none of them will be implemented.

3 comments

Lowering the Water

There’s more than one way to reduce the crime rate, as this article in Chicago Magazine explains. Want fewer murders? Just re-classify ’em!

3 comments