Being a Totalitarian State Ain’t What It Used to Be

The editors of the Washington Post note the problems the Chinese authorities have had keeping wraps on the tour boat accident in the Yangtze River this week and remark:

The stirrings showed that Mr. Xi’s attempt to impose Stalinist-style information controls may not work in 21st-century China. His regime would foster more trust were it to follow the examples of neighbors such as South Korea and Taiwan, which live-streamed video of rescue efforts after recent disasters and encouraged debate about what went wrong. In attempting to shield the regime from criticism, Beijing’s censors are only adding to public embitterment.

I don’t think they’ve realized the half of it. The Chinese authorities are in a bind. They just can’t control information the way they used to. They can either choose to be a part of the rest of the world or not. They could keep cellphones, computer technology, and Internet technology out of the hands of their citizens and remain permanently in the 1970s with the same GDP and poverty problems they had in the 1970s or join the rest of the world and lose control. Loss of control inevitably signs the CCP’s death warrant. It’s just a matter of time.

That also points to a gaping security hole of which the Chinese authorities are undoubtedly aware but which I doubt most Americans are. China has, I believe, two physical connections to the Internet. Cut those (something well within our power) and China’s manufacturing companies lose their connections to their overseas corporate customers all of which use just-in-time inventory systems. No Internet means that having your manufacturing in China suddenly becomes a lot less attractive. Companies like Apple (or Walmart) that are dependent on Chinese suppliers would find things pretty difficult, too, but most companies aren’t quite as dependent on lines of communication to China as those two are.

Prudent companies have second sources.

0 comments

What If the Triple Entente Hadn’t Won World War I?

David Frum has an interesting alternative history speculation over at Atlantic you might wish to look at it. As should be almost needless to say I disagree strongly with his conclusions.

I believe that, if the U. S. had not entered WWI on the side of the TE, the TE would not have won the war outright. On that much we’re in agreement. However, I think that if the TE had not won outright that doesn’t mean that the Central Powers would have won. I think it means the TE would have sued for peace and that, in turn, means that there would have been no Treaty of Versailles and no Treaty of Sèvres. The Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman Empires would have remained intact, at least for a while. Germany would not have been saddled with war reparations.

That means less struggle in Germany to cope with the debts it had incurred during the war, a reduced likelihood that Hitler would have risen to power, and a possbility that, if the Austro-Hungarian Empire went to war again a generation later, it would have been with Soviet Russia rather than Western Europe.

The problems of the Middle East would have taken on a very different cast with a continuing rump Ottoman Empire. What form? It’s open to debate.

My general take is that our entry into the Great War despite its notionally favorable outcome may have been just as boneheaded as our invasion of Iraq.

3 comments

Iran’s Unknown Unknowns

Over the last few days there’s been a bit of a kerfuffle about a New York Times story claiming that Iran had been cheating on its previous nuclear agreements. As it turns out the NYT isn’t the only source for the claim:

Since Iran agreed in late 2013 to negotiate limits on its nuclear ambitions, the Obama Administration has boasted that its diplomacy has “frozen” Iran’s progress, particularly the regime’s stockpile of enriched uranium. Turns out this isn’t true.

That’s the conclusion of a report Tuesday by the Institute for Science and International Security (the other ISIS), a clearinghouse for technical analysis on Iran’s nuclear programs. Under the 2013 interim nuclear agreement, Iran was not prevented from running its centrifuges to enrich uranium. And enrich it has, producing some four tons of low-enriched uranium since the agreement came into effect in January 2014.

The agreement did require Iran to convert the enriched uranium into an oxide form that cannot be easily turned into weaponizable material. And here is where Iran has failed to comply. As the ISIS report notes, Iran has produced only 150 kilograms of uranium oxide, “a mere five percent of what was expected.” Since last November Iran hasn’t even bothered to convert any enriched uranium into oxide.

Iran has until the end of June to convert the remaining 3,800 kilos into oxide if it’s to honor the terms of the deal. Don’t hold your breath. The Iranians claim that their efforts to oxidize the uranium have been slowed by technical snafus and fouled by sabotage. Sabotage by whom? It makes no sense for the West to stymie an attempt to reduce Iran’s stockpile of weapons-usable uranium.

A likelier explanation is that Iran never intended to honor the interim agreement. Now it can use its additional uranium stockpile either to drive a harder bargain as nuclear negotiations approach their June 30 deadline—or drive harder toward a bomb.

Remember the memorable phrase about known knowns, known unknowns, and unknown unknowns? The known knowns about Iran is that it had a nuclear weapons development program, it has a nuclear development program, and it has cheated on previous agreements. The known unknown is that we don’t know the extent of Iran’s cheating which could potentially extend to ongoing nuclear weapons development. What are the unknown unknowns? By definition we don’t know but it seems to me that we should at least want to know.

I don’t think that those who are in favor of an agreement on nuclear development with Iran have made a strong enough case. The burden of proof is on them rather than on those who oppose such an agreement. The very least we should expect from proponents is a convincing case that the U. S. benefits from the proposed agreement and their proposed strategy for mitigating the risks the agreement will expose us to.

5 comments

Testimonials

Testimonials are generally considered a very weak form of evidence. Complaints that one scientific study or another did not take testimonials into account are even weaker. One of the purposes of scientific studies is to determine the truth without relying on testimony.

If you take testimonials as unassailable evidence, you must necessarily believe in God, demons and angels, alien abduction, and the validity of astrology because there are testimonials to all of them. Those beliefs in turn have implications of their own.

1 comment

Answering the Questions That Need Answering

The science is now settled:

In the guys’ experiment, they each filled a kiddie pool with water. They didn’t want to just go off tubs and toilets—there are too many variables there. Toilets have jets in them that influence water flow, and no matter where you are on Earth, there will be toilets and sinks that drain clockwise, and others that flow counterclockwise.

Each kiddie pool was filled and allowed to sit for 24 hours. Then the guys pulled plugs from underneath each tub, dropped in some food coloring for visual aid, and waited with bated breath.

The results? Water did indeed drain counterclockwise in Alabama, and clockwise in Australia. As the Earth spins on its axis, it pulls water in different directions depending on where you are. We can see this in nature with the Coriolis Effect: hurricanes in the northern hemisphere spin counterclockwise, while the south’s cyclones whip clockwise.

So, yes, when you flush a toilet, the water rotates in the opposite direction in the southern hemisphere than in the northern.

7 comments

Hillary’s Favorabililty

I liked the comment I left on Doug Mataconis’s post on the recent decline in Hillary Clinton’s favorability rating enough that I think I’ll resurrect it and expand on it a bit here.

I’m actually surprised at this. She has 100% name recognition (within the margin of error). That means that some people are changing their minds about her. Who?

There are many possibilities as to what might happen. She might already have seen her highest favorable rating. She could bounce back. Her favorability rating could drift ever lower right now through election day. She could push back through her previous high favorability rating. I doubt it but anything could happen. Which of those is the most likely? BTSOM.

If I had to put money on it, I think I would bet that her highest favorability rating is already behind her and that it will go somewhat lower over time. However, don’t construe that as her being in free fall. I think she pretty clearly has a cadre of supporters who will buoy her favorability rating come what may, regardless of revelations, scandals, or self-mutilation. I’d estimate that her favorability rating will never go below right around 40%.

Whether that’s enough to whisk her into a White House coronation or not is beyond me. It depends on distribution. One thing is for sure: she can’t be elected president just by taking California, New York, and Massachusetts.

18 comments

Our Wacky Political and Legal Systems

Most of the world uses a system of called the “civil code” system, informed by the principles of the Code civil des Français. The United States and the countries of the British Commonwealth use a “common law” system in which written law is only the tip of our legal iceberg. Most of our law was never enacted by any legislature but has been devised by judges and other lawyers. As you might expect in such a disorganized system, our law is filled with illogic and inconsistencies.

Nowhere are the illogic and inconsistencies more plain than in our laws governing voting, apportionment, and citizenship. In his remarks on Evenwel v. Abbott, the Texas case recently taken up by the Supreme Court and which he terms “the most important redistricting case in 50 years”, Sean Trende notes:

By ruling that states had to ensure an equal number of eligible voters in districts — rather than persons — the court would force even Democratic map makers to push districts out of heavily Democratic areas and into Republican areas. Just 78 percent of the residents of heavily Democratic Queens County are citizens, and 83 percent of similarly Democratic Kings County residents are citizens. In neighboring Nassau County, however, 91 percent of residents are citizens. In other words, 20 percent of the population in districts in Queens and Brooklyn would no longer count. To populate these districts, line drawers would be forced to push districts into Nassau County. Democrats would have a choice between weakening the Queens/Brooklyn districts, or making the remaining Nassau County districts more Republican.

To see how this plays out in practice, consider the lawsuit brought in 2012 challenging the apportionment of the New York State Senate. The current map places nine senate districts on Long Island, 26 districts in New York City, and 28 districts upstate. These districts are of similar populations.

But if we look at citizens of voting age (or CVAP), we see some pretty wide disparities. The average CVAP for the Long Island districts is 215,436 persons. The average CVAP for the New York districts is 191,133 persons. The average CVAP for the upstate districts is 217, 759 persons. There are other ways to look at the data, but the upshot is that a successful lawsuit would probably move two senate seats out of reliably Democratic New York City and into upstate New York. New York’s congressional districts are similarly apportioned between New York City, Long Island, and Upstate, so adopting CVAP would likely move a congressional district out of the city and into the swing areas upstate.

There are other examples here: Harry Enten and Dave Wasserman note that only 41 percent of the residents of California’s 34th District (downtown Los Angeles) are adult citizens; this district would probably have to be combined with most of a neighboring district (probably the 40th, where only about 40 percent of the population is adult citizens) to generate a full Hispanic-majority district. This would probably result in a new district placed in swingier areas of the state. Republican David Valadao’s Central Valley district is majority non-adult citizen; Democrats would love to weaken him but would have a hard time doing so while also protecting Jim Costa’s Fresno-based district. Weakening Loretta Sanchez’s district would be almost unavoidable. The five districts that abut the Rio Grande River in Texas have high non-citizen populations; one would likely be eliminated and, if Republicans have their way, transferred to the heavily Republicans suburbs of one of the major cities.

Although this case doesn’t address the point directly, it leads inevitably to the question of who should be considered for purposes of federal apportionment and who should not? Should corporations be considered for reasons of apportionment and why or why not?

These are all questions that would never arise under a civil code system and I’m sure our European cousins find us a source of puzzlement and endless amusement.

9 comments

Quote of the Day

My pick for quote of the day comes from Paul McHugh, formerly chief of psychiatry at Johns Hopkins Hospital:

At the heart of the problem is confusion over the nature of the transgendered. “Sex change” is biologically impossible. People who undergo sex-reassignment surgery do not change from men to women or vice versa. Rather, they become feminized men or masculinized women. Claiming that this is civil-rights matter and encouraging surgical intervention is in reality to collaborate with and promote a mental disorder.

from his op-ed in the Wall Street Journal.

14 comments

Is This What They’re Up To?

Here’s a theory of what the overwhelmingly Democratically-controlled Illinois legislature is up to. Dennis Byrne, writing at the Tribune, claims:

As the Tribune recently noted, the Democratic strategy, now that Democrats refused to pass a balanced budget, will be to “force (Gov. Bruce) Rauner to wear the jacket for billions in budget cuts that would hit social service programs in the hopes that he’ll feel enough heat to eventually sign on to a tax increase …” As if the heartless governor, who didn’t bring on this crisis, is the one who is depriving the poor, elderly, young and others dependent on state aid and programs. How droll. What brass.

Mostly blame House Speaker Michael Madigan and Senate President John Cullerton (both Democrats) and their deep-pocket contributors, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees and other public employee unions. Their incessant and greedy demands for more, more and more have forced government to borrow more, more and more to a point approaching bankruptcy.

Champions of the middle class, downtrodden and huddled masses? Hardly. These very Democrats are hypocritically robbing the schools, hospitals and social service providers of billions and billions of dollars that must instead go into pensions and debt service.

As a famous Ilinoisan once said, you can fool some of the people all of the time, all of the people some of the time, but you can’t fool all of the people all of the time. Fortunately for Illinois’s legislators, they don’t have to fool all of the people all of the time. They just have to fool enough of the people in their districts all of the time to re-elect them term after term after term.

If that’s their strategy, it will probably work. But working isn’t enough. There are actual problems facing Chicago and Illinois and fooling just enough voters to get re-elected just prolongs the agony.

8 comments

With Defenses Like This…

Bill Wheelhouse of WUIS rejects the idea of a flight from Illinois:

Last year, Illinois was one of a handful of states that lost population. The out migration became a campaign issue in the governor’s race last year and has some throwing up caution flags. But the numbers don’t mean there is a crisis, or even a real clamor, to leave the state.

It is true Illinois lost population overall last year. More than 90,000 people moved elsewhere. In his State of the State Address, Gov. Bruce Rauner mentioned that over the past dozen years 250,000 people picked up and moved out of Illinois. That is correct. However, people also moved into the state and were born here. With the exception of last year, population has generally grown in Illinois at a small rate.

Illinois has experienced net out-migration every year for more than 20 years:
residents_lost
Unless every single one of those people is elderly or a child, that strongly suggests that Illinois’s dependency ratio, the ratio of those 14 years of age or under plus those 65 years of age or older to those between 14 and 65, has been increasing for the least two decades. Not only is that not good news, it’s a disaster from the point-of-view of the state’s tax base.

2 comments