Most of the world uses a system of called the “civil code” system, informed by the principles of the Code civil des Français. The United States and the countries of the British Commonwealth use a “common law” system in which written law is only the tip of our legal iceberg. Most of our law was never enacted by any legislature but has been devised by judges and other lawyers. As you might expect in such a disorganized system, our law is filled with illogic and inconsistencies.
Nowhere are the illogic and inconsistencies more plain than in our laws governing voting, apportionment, and citizenship. In his remarks on Evenwel v. Abbott, the Texas case recently taken up by the Supreme Court and which he terms “the most important redistricting case in 50 years”, Sean Trende notes:
By ruling that states had to ensure an equal number of eligible voters in districts — rather than persons — the court would force even Democratic map makers to push districts out of heavily Democratic areas and into Republican areas. Just 78 percent of the residents of heavily Democratic Queens County are citizens, and 83 percent of similarly Democratic Kings County residents are citizens. In neighboring Nassau County, however, 91 percent of residents are citizens. In other words, 20 percent of the population in districts in Queens and Brooklyn would no longer count. To populate these districts, line drawers would be forced to push districts into Nassau County. Democrats would have a choice between weakening the Queens/Brooklyn districts, or making the remaining Nassau County districts more Republican.
To see how this plays out in practice, consider the lawsuit brought in 2012 challenging the apportionment of the New York State Senate. The current map places nine senate districts on Long Island, 26 districts in New York City, and 28 districts upstate. These districts are of similar populations.
But if we look at citizens of voting age (or CVAP), we see some pretty wide disparities. The average CVAP for the Long Island districts is 215,436 persons. The average CVAP for the New York districts is 191,133 persons. The average CVAP for the upstate districts is 217, 759 persons. There are other ways to look at the data, but the upshot is that a successful lawsuit would probably move two senate seats out of reliably Democratic New York City and into upstate New York. New York’s congressional districts are similarly apportioned between New York City, Long Island, and Upstate, so adopting CVAP would likely move a congressional district out of the city and into the swing areas upstate.
There are other examples here: Harry Enten and Dave Wasserman note that only 41 percent of the residents of California’s 34th District (downtown Los Angeles) are adult citizens; this district would probably have to be combined with most of a neighboring district (probably the 40th, where only about 40 percent of the population is adult citizens) to generate a full Hispanic-majority district. This would probably result in a new district placed in swingier areas of the state. Republican David Valadao’s Central Valley district is majority non-adult citizen; Democrats would love to weaken him but would have a hard time doing so while also protecting Jim Costa’s Fresno-based district. Weakening Loretta Sanchez’s district would be almost unavoidable. The five districts that abut the Rio Grande River in Texas have high non-citizen populations; one would likely be eliminated and, if Republicans have their way, transferred to the heavily Republicans suburbs of one of the major cities.
Although this case doesn’t address the point directly, it leads inevitably to the question of who should be considered for purposes of federal apportionment and who should not? Should corporations be considered for reasons of apportionment and why or why not?
These are all questions that would never arise under a civil code system and I’m sure our European cousins find us a source of puzzlement and endless amusement.