They Say It’s the Same But It Isn’t the Same

When I was in the U. K. I ran out of toothpaste so I ran down to the chemist’s and picked up another tube. Same brand, same variety. When I got home I had occasion to compare the tubes of the stuff I bought here with the stuff I bought in the U. K. and was a bit surprised to note that they were different. Here’s the list of active ingredients on my U. S. toothpaste:

  • Potassium nitrate
  • Sodium fluoride

and here’s the list from the U. K. version:

  • Arginin

My first reaction was to wonder if some of the ingredients in my U. S. toothpaste were banned by the EU. That didn’t explain it. I’ve come up with two different possible explanations, both of which might be true:

  • Consumers in the U. K. are more sensitive about chemical-y sounding things than U. S. consumers are.
  • The U. K. brand is the successor product to a product originally produced by a company that P&G acquired. The U. K. ingredients reflect the ingredients of that product and what its U. K. customers are accustomed to.

I’m open to other suggestions. Why is the same toothpaste different in two different countries?

7 comments

Drumbeats

I’m going to come right out and admit that talk of war between China and the U. S. makes me nervous. It concerns me that endlessly hashing out different war scenarios inures us to the idea of going to war.

Although I found Robert Farley’s article at The National Interest too concerned with tactical errors than with the strategic errors that I think could really lead us to war with China, it’s probably worth reading anyway. I think that strategic errors are far more likely to lead us to war than tactical blunders. These are the sorts of things that I mean:

  • China underestimates the U. S. willingness to react. I think that’s the single most likely thing to push us into war. Consider Al Qaeda. Osama Bin Laden’s dismissal of U. S. will lead to the attacks on 9/11.
  • U. S. underestimates Chinese strength.
  • There are too many people on both sides who are already committed to going to war.
20 comments

Taranto Does the Math

In his column yesterday James Taranto does the math and comes up with the point I’ve been making for quite a while now:

In treating turnout as an afterthought, Tomasky gets it exactly backward. The 2% increase in black turnout was considerably more significant than the seven-point improvement in the Democratic margin among black voters. The total number of votes cast in 2004 was 122.3 million. What if 7% of black voters had switched from Bush to Kerry? That’s 7% of 11% (the total black share of the electorate) of 122.3 million, or about 940,000 votes.

The total number of votes cast in 2008 was 131.5 million. The difference between 11% and 13% black turnout is roughly 2% of the total electorate, or 2.6 million votes. Further, the black electorate grew from 11% of 122.3 million (13.5 million) to 13% of 131.5 million (17.1 million), an increase of 3.6 million, or 27%. That is more than twice the number of blacks who voted for Bush in 2004.

That’s why the constant news of the Clinton’s scandals will be so damaging to the Democrats. It won’t affect the votes of their strongest supporters. They’ll turn out and faithfully vote the straight Democratic ticket. But it will discourage those who aren’t their strongest supporters from turning out to vote at all.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. The 2016 election will hinge on turnout. Whoever’s voters turn out will win. Not the candidate whose constituencies are sewed up most tightly.

4 comments

Blue, Red, and Green

Republican states may be red and Democratic states blue but money is green. That’s what the state of Connecticut is learning to its dismay:

The blue-state paragon’s two-year budget of $40.3 billion includes a $1.5 billion net increase in taxes and fees. The top marginal individual tax rate rises to 6.99% from 6.7%. But the biggest blow is making permanent a 20% surtax on a company’s annual tax liability—a tax on a tax—and for the first time taxing Connecticut companies on their world-wide income, rather than what they earn in the state.

General Electric, long a Connecticut fixture, protested that the state is “retroactively raising taxes again,” which “makes businesses, including our own, and citizens seriously consider whether it makes any sense to continue to be located in this state.” Aetna, the giant health insurer and pillar of Hartford, said the bill would “undermine the competitiveness” of companies and “lead to an exodus of jobs and business from the state.’’

The biggest shock came Thursday when GE CEO Jeffrey Immelt told the company’s Connecticut employees that he has “assembled an exploratory team to look into the company’s options to relocate corporate HQ to another state with a more pro-business environment.”

Mr. Immelt, usually the consummate corporate diplomat, said Connecticut had raised taxes on GE five times since 2011. “I believe we should pay our fair share and that all of us should give back to our communities,” he wrote. But he added that “we can compare Connecticut with other states where small and large businesses have a better environment to thrive and compete.”

President Obama name Mr. Immelt to head his Economic Advisors Board. I guess we know what his advice for improving the global economy is now.

GE isn’t the only company strategizing its exit from the Nutmeg State. Aetna is, too. You can raise the rates but that doesn’t guarantee you’ll receive more revenue.

GE and Aetna are two of Connecticut’s largest employers. Here’s a a list of some of the others. I’m guessing that those that are portable are considering boogying out about now, especially those that have substantial overseas earnings.

2 comments

Patching the Holes in Uncle Sam’s Security

I don’t think that the Washington Post editors really comprehend the magnitude of the federal government’s security problems:

What’s so disconcerting about the breach — other than its massive scale and possible value to Chinese espionage, of course — is that it is just one in a series of intrusions into vital computer systems of the U.S. government. The White House and the State Department last year discovered their e-mail systems had been compromised in an attack linked to Russian hackers. The OPM was the target of a smaller attack last year. Last week, the Internal Revenue Service said identity thieves had illegally obtained tax information on more than 100,000 households.

[…]

High-profile cyberattacks on such private companies as Sony Pictures Entertainment and Target prompted the White House to push the private sector to improve protections of its computer networks and share information on best methods. So there’s an unfortunate irony in the vulnerability of federal computer networks, which, as Rep. Adam B. Schiff (D-Calif.) noted, Americans expect to be “maintained with state-of-the-art defenses.”

Measures taken so far are clearly insufficient. We hope the breach at the OPM — among the largest thefts ever of government data — awakens the administration and Congress to the need for a robust strategy that puts safeguards in place and promises consequences for the people and countries who try to violate them.

The last “breach” mentioned, the exploit against the IRS, doesn’t fit the same model as the others. If the published reports are correct, nobody actually hacked anything there. They just used the system that was in place for an illegal purpose. As best as I can tell the system was inherently insecure. It should never have existed in the first place.

But let’s get to the nuts and bolts of the federal government’s lax security. Nothing can be done about it because no one can be held responsible.

If those who are notionally responsible for the security of the OPM’s systems are government employees, they’re protected by the Pendleton Act, the Civil Service Act of 1883. By the time anyone could be fired or even demoted they’d’ve retired and be living in Barbados. If they’re contractors, it’s probably a sole source. Most contracts requiring expertise are and once the company had been in place for a few years no other company would have the prerequisite knowledge or skills. The most that could happen is that they’d be yelled at. What would that accomplish? The single most important qualification for a PM on one of these contracts is a thick skin.

There are a thousand effective technical solutions to the problems. Just to name one no personally identifiable information should be retained on mass storage unencrypted. Period. If the problem is one of legacy systems, those systems should be disconnected from any possible connection to the public Internet. Would that be cumbersome? Yes. Security doesn’t mean being convenient. People might actually have to walk over to secured workstations. That’s what happens in secure environments. Horrors!

If there’s solid evidence that the exploit emanated from China, there should be more than a few cross words. There should be retaliation. As I’ve mentioned before China is not a good Internet citizen. Just on my little blog 80-90% of my unwanted traffic is from China. That’s probably true for every site in the world.

10 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

How Do We Fix Income Inequality?

I actually found the first comment in the thread on Doug Mataconis’s post on the politics of income inequality more interesting than the post so I’ll comment on the comment. In the comment the commenter, well known hereabouts, points to a broad consensus on three tactics for improving income inequality:

  • Increasing the minimum wage.
  • Higher taxes on “the rich”.
  • Limits on CEO compensation.

Those are interesting proposals but it’s not entirely clear to me how they solve the problem of income inequality. I don’t see any way of implementing the last one that will meet constitutional muster. Somehow, miraculously, regardless of the highest marginal rate “the rich” never actually pay it (or at least don’t pay it on a great deal of their income). And the third could decrease income inequality a tiny bit (do a pencil and paper exercise—you’ll see what I mean), do nothing, or even increase income inequality a little. Besides, only about a million people earn the minimum wage. You can’t do much about income inequality by raising the wages of that small a number of people by just a couple of thou a year.

My list of remedies would be somewhat different. I’d

  • Reduce the number of unskilled or low-skilled workers coming into the country.
  • Reduce our dependence on imported goods.
  • Break up the big banks.
  • Stop subsidizing the top 3% of income earners as highly as we do.

There might be a few other steps but that would be a start. For the sake of argument assume that income inequality presents a problem we should solve. How do we solve it in the most economically efficient way that doesn’t risk a collapse in our currency?

16 comments

The May Employment Situation Summary

I probably should say something about the May employment situation report:

Total nonfarm payroll employment increased by 280,000 in May, and theunemployment rate was essentially unchanged at 5.5 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Job gains occurred in professional and business services, leisure and hospitality, and health care. Mining employment continued to decline.

That’s certainly better than if the number of jobs had decreased but the economy needs to continue to add jobs at that rate for years to bring the long-term unemployed back into the labor force. Other observations:

  • Job growth continues to be in the wrong sectors. We’re adding jobs in retail, hospitality, and highly subsidized sectors. That suggests continued low wage growth in an environment of fiscal problems.
  • The slight uptick in the unemployment rate is probably a good sign—it may be that people are starting to come back into the jobs market.

I should probably check out how this breaks out by region.

0 comments

The RFK Counterfactual

It appears that people are in a counterfactual-y sort of mood. Maybe that’s related to how lousy the facts are.

Evan Thomas speculates on what might have happened if Robert Kennedy had become president in 1968 (rather than being assassinated):

It is one of history’s great “what ifs.” What if Robert Kennedy had not been assassinated 40 years ago and gone on to become president of the United States? It’s safe to say that his presidency would have followed a different course from that of Richard Nixon. And it may just be that American politics would not be endlessly refighting the 1960s. Kennedy was a less polarizing figure than Nixon, who exploited the divisions that have now hardened into Red States and Blue States. But Kennedy himself was a complex and mercurial figure, so all we can really do is speculate. It’s an intriguing guessing game—if one does not get too dreamy about the mythology of RFK.

Oddly he never really answers the question, only hinting at his answer (it would have been wonderful).

For Robert Kennedy to have become president he would have had to avoid assassination, he would have had to defeat Hubert Humphrey in the primaries, and he would have had to defeat Richard Nixon in the general election. We’re beginning to stack up a lot of “ifs” here. I actually think it’s more likely that if he had not been assassinated very little else would have changed. He might have continued to serve as senator from New York for the rest of his life which would, presumably, have left Hillary Clinton out in the cold so there’s that.

But I’ll play along. If RFK had become president, I think we clearly we would have exited Viet Nam a few years earlier than we actually did, probably before 1970 and 20,000 or so fewer Americans would have died. We’d still have had the bad taste of Viet Nam in our collective mouth but otherwise I have no idea what impact it might have had on foreign policy. We probably would not have opened up to China when we did.

I’m guessing the Democratic Party would have remained more centrist than it actually became. See if you can figure out my reasoning on that.

2 comments

Name That Smoothing Strategy

I’m really not sure what to make of this report in Science:

Much study has been devoted to the possible causes of an apparent decrease in the upward trend of global surface temperatures since 1998, a phenomenon that has been dubbed the global warming “hiatus.” Here we present an updated global surface temperature analysis that reveals that global trends are higher than reported by the IPCC, especially in recent decades, and that the central estimate for the rate of warming during the first 15 years of the 21st century is at least as great as the last half of the 20th century. These results do not support the notion of a “slowdown” in the increase of global surface temperature.

It also may tie in with something I mentioned in comments a couple of days ago. Is NOAA

  1. Improving the smoothing of its data
  2. Trying to change reality to match its data better
  3. Something else?
  4. When you make trends (or the lack of trends) appear or disappear by changing your weighting, it makes me queasy but I’m willing to give them the benefit of the doubt if there’s a good argument for it.

8 comments