The Greek Passion

I want to answer George Will’s question, asked in his most recent column in the Washington Post. There’s a sort of Brezhnev Doctrine embraced by the EU. Once a country has joined the eurozone it can’t be allowed to leave and you’ve got to wonder why? If Greece is as lazy and spendthrift as the Germans say, why are they so eager for it to stay in the club?

I don’t think the answer is philanthropy on the part of the Germans but that there is a group of large mostly German, Dutch, and Luxembourger banks that have made a pretty cozy business model out of extending credit to countries like Greece and Portugal that is obviously beyond those countries’ ability to pay, secure in the belief that the countries will never leave the euro and that the European central banks will always bail them out.

Most of Mr. Will’s column is devoted to the horrors of socialism but he might devote a little more time to writing some columns about crony capitalism or, maybe, state capitalism. The solution to Greece’s problem is at hand: let Greece go back to the drachma. It will renegotiate its loans on a better basis or default and you will be able to hear the sound of of collapsing European banks in Reykjavik. But Greece will have the ability to start living within its means which it does not as long as it’s on the euro.

Update

It’s gratifying to me to see that Barry Ritholtz is on my side:

Let Greece go.

Hey Greece — if anyone is listening — just default on the debt and start anew. The rest of Europe has caused the country and everyone else enough agita: just let Greece leave the euro zone in peace. Sure, it will be a long torturous process, but at least Greece — and maybe the euro region — will start moving in the right direction.

In case anyone forgot: Greece never should have been in the euro zone in the first place. Based on the formal entry requirements, it never met the membership standards. With a little help from the Wall Street magicians it lied and cheated its way in, disguising its debt levels and fiscal health. As Spiegel wrote five years ago, “Goldman Sachs helped the Greek government to mask the true extent of its deficit with the help of a derivatives deal that legally circumvented the EU Maastricht deficit rules.” Greece should have been given the treatment a teenage drinker would get after being discovered in a bar: tossed out and not allowed in until meeting the entry qualifications.

Regardless, it is now in Greece’s own best interests to show itself the door. There should be no doubt, as Martin Wolf points out in the Financial Times, that like most divorces, this one will be acrimonious. But the sooner it starts, the sooner Greece can begin the process of starting an economic recovery.

I haven’t researched it but I suspect that Goldman-Sachs did not act alone.

2 comments

Variations in Tactics

I do not generally find myself in agreement with Robert Kagan Kaplan but his recent column in The Atlantic is sound advice. Applying Sun-Tzu’s advice:

The side that knows when to fight and when not will take the victory. There are roadways not to be traveled, armies not to be attacked, walled cities not to be assaulted.

to Syria, he remarks:

The United States does not chase after war bands in Yemen as Darius did in Scythia, but occasionally it kills individuals from the air. The fact that it uses drones is proof not of American strength, but of American limitations. The Obama administration must recognize these limitations, and not allow, for example, the country to be drawn deeper into the conflict in Syria. If the U.S. helps topple the dictator Bashar al-Assad on Wednesday, then what will it do on Thursday, when it finds that it has helped midwife to power a Sunni jihadist regime, or on Friday, when ethnic cleansing of the Shia-trending Alawites commences? Perhaps this is a battle that, as Sun Tzu might conclude, should not be fought. But Assad has killed many tens of thousands, maybe more, and he is being supported by the Iranians! True, but remember that emotion, however righteous, can be the enemy of analysis.

The question that must be asked is “So, you remove Assad. What then?”

5 comments

Visualize the U. S. Economy

There’s a cool map at Fixr that illustrates the U. S. economy on a state-by-state basis, depicting gross state product and GSP per capita. If the map also illustrated the state’s Gini factor (a measure of inequality), I think it would be even more informative.

8 comments

Security By Design

However predisposed I might be to agree with these remarks from James Taranto:

One might argue that the federal government has become so big and complex that there is no way the president or members of Congress could have known precisely what OPM spending was essential and would result in catastrophe if cut. One would thereby issue a more powerful rejoinder to Krugman: Big government is antithetical to effective government, for the bigger the government, the harder it is for anyone to manage effectively.

in reference to the massive, damaging, unforgiveable and avoidable security breach at the Office of Personnel Management, I think his kneejerk reaction only carries you so far as well. There are some things that cannot be done securely.

Why were the data in question retained in digital form at all? Why were they retained for so long? The data in question should never have been digitized in the first place but they also should not be retained indefinitely.

1 comment

These Things Happen

You want to know why these things happen? I’ll tell you why these things happen. Whenever these things happen people just say ‘These things happen’ and that’s why they happen.

The quote above, spoken by the estimable Ethel Merman is from the movie It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World and there is wisdom in them. When you combine enormous and increasing personal empowerment, more people, and a predisposition not to get involved, events of increasing horror and destructiveness will inevitably take place.

The solution is not greater police powers. The solution is intervention at an earlier point in the process. And that in turn means a greater predisposition to take responsibility.

2 comments

The Amazing Coincidence

Here’s another non-obvious case. One of the implications of the PPACA is that it favors large companies over small ones which in turn will lead to slower growth in the number of new jobs than might otherwise be the case. I presume the counter-argument is that the PPACA makes free-lancing less risky than it otherwise might be.

Still, it’s an amazing coincidence that the strategy that the Congressional Democratic leadership came up with favors their preferred path for the economy: a smaller number of companies overall but companies that are larger. Big Government has always preferred Big Business.

5 comments

The Cost of Countering the Business Cycle

This post at Zerohedge poses the counter-intuitive hypothesis that the Federal Reserve’s strategy for reducing the frequency and depth of recessions hasn’t functioned exactly as advertised:

Not too long ago, in a land not so far away, the business cycle was declared to be defeated. Policymakers at the Federal Reserve were credited with slaying the pesky beast that featured recessions as part of its nature. Such was the faith in the permanence of business cycle’s demise that the era was given its own label, The Great Moderation, a perfect world in which inflation ran not too hot or too cold and profit growth was accepted as the steady state.

As is so often the case, reality rudely disturbed nirvana’s prospects. The Great Moderation devolved into the Great Recession precipitated by one of the most devastating financial crises in U.S. history. The veneer of calm advertised over the prior years was stripped away. In its stead, economists had to concede that an era of benign monetary policy had encouraged malinvestment, the scourge that Austrian Ludwig von Mises warned of in the early 20th century. An overabundance of debt, if left unchecked, inevitably leads to the misallocation of resources. In the case of the first years of the 2000s, the target was, of course, the housing market.

The costs of the Fed’s strategy are obvious but, sadly, largely unacknowledged. For one thing they have practically made my case in favor of the Social Security program for me: it is now impossible for most people to save for their own retirements without reducing their level of consumption to one that would in turn reduce economic activity to a dire extent and without assuming much higher levels of risk. That in turn implies that there will be many, many more losers than would otherwise be the case.

6 comments

He Reshaped the World

Very few men have reshaped the world within their lifetimes. Alexander. Mohammed. Napoleon. You might want to take a look at this article on Napoleon. The author’s thesis is that the world would have been better off if Napoleon had won at Waterloo. I wish he had devoted more time to that idea rather than to why Napoleon lost at Waterloo but the article is still interesting.

3 comments

The Joys of Median Income

As I read Matt O’Brien’s post at the Washington Post on how much greater it is to be middle class now than it was 30 years ago:

But even though median households are only making 9 percent more in inflation-adjusted terms than they were in 1980, there’s not a hint of any kind of civil strife, unless you count a few bongo drums in Zuccotti Park. Why not? Well, maybe because that 9 percent number understates how much better off the middle class is today than it was a generation ago. That, at least, is what a majority of economists at the ideologically-diverse IGM Panel think.

The first was that its title should have been “Shut Up! He Explained”. The second was that he was using the wrong dates for comparison. Rather than using 1980 he should be using 1970 or 1960. 1980 was a different point in the business cycle than we are now which renders the comparison facetious.

The third was that the things he cites as great advantages we have now that we didn’t have then:

But even if we have less money, you know what we do have that we didn’t 15 years ago? Smartphones and social networks, Netflix and HD TVs, apps and whatever other technology you prefer to waste time on. Now, it’s true, you can’t eat an iPad, but it’s also true that these things make our lives better in ways that are hard to measure.

really don’t mean as much to me as they apparently do to him. He’d be better off picking healthcare (something else that doesn’t mean as much to me as it does to most people) for which I think there’s at least a reasonable argument.

It seems to me that he’s using meaningless ways of analyzing the differences presumably to bolster his case. Let’s try something else.

Every year Forbes publishes their “Cost of Living Extremely Well Index”, a shopping list of what it takes to life the lifestyle of the rich and famous and how much it costs. Here’s the article for 2014. Unsurprisingly, it takes a lot more money (in real terms) to be rich than it used to.

I propose that we develop a shopping list of what constituted a middle class lifestyle in 1960, what that shopping list is now, and the costs of each. My intuition is that a middle class lifestyle in 1960 was a lot more within the reach of most Americans that the presumed middle class lifestyle is today but I’m willing to be pleasantly surprised.

So, what did it take to lead a middle class lifestyle in 1960? Now? Divide it (as Forbes does) into entertainment, fashion, household, services, travel, and food and drink.

8 comments

China Gushing

I think that Clive Crook is gushing a bit too much in his column at Bloomberg cautioning us to beware of the China bubble’s inevitable collapse:

Singapore, which I’m visiting at the moment, opens your mind to the highly improbable. Rich, ethnically diverse, cheerfully efficient, globalized in the extreme, it’s a man-made economic miracle — astonishing proof of what market forces combined with superb top-down direction can achieve.

Even in Singapore, though, there are limits to what you can believe. I struggle to imagine, for instance, that China’s stock market isn’t a bubble.

China’s leadership has long been impressed with the Singapore model. Since Deng Xiaoping, its government has been much more interested in capitalism in the style of Lee Kuan Yew than class struggle in the style of Karl Marx. In China, the mix of markets and smart management has indisputably worked another miracle, and on a vastly larger scale than Lee’s.

There must be a good word for this particular style of journalism, made notorious by Tom Friedman in which you lavish praise on the Chinese leadership for all of the wrong things.

It’s not completely surprising that after abandoning its official policy of autarky China has grown quite a bit. High single digit or even double digit annual growth is easier than it sounds when starting from the base of an economy that’s almost completely supine. Whether “top-down direction” can continue the growth is another question entirely.

1 comment