A Plan of Action for Syria

Pat Lang presents his plan of action for the U. S. in Syria:

* Accept the truth that we destroyed the Iraqi state and from that act of vandalism all present chaos in that country derives.

* Don’t do it again in Syria.

* Stop saying that no “Assad cronies” can be in or head the government. They ARE the government. Assad himself is dispensable, but not the government of Syria.

* Act like Russia, China and Iran matter as something other than rivals and adversaries.

* Ignore Erdogan’s Turkey. It is a manifestation of the jihadi enemy. They will deny us use of Incirlik and the other bases? Fine, that would clarify the situation. Move onto Syrian bases or the big, unused NATO built base north of Tripoli in Lebanon.

* Ignore Saudi Arabia’s wishes with regard to Syria. They are jihadi supporters.

* Ignore Israel’s wishes with regard to Syria. Natanyahu’s government is pursuing a mistaken and short sighted policy of eliminating coherent government in Syria for the purpose of crippling their Lebanese Hizbullah adversaries whom they think exist because of Syrian and Iranian help. The Likud’s imagined interest in Syria is not America’s interest.

* Accept Russian and Iranian co-belligerence in the war against the jihadis, ALL JIHADIS.

* Fully coordinate operations, intelligence analysis sharing and logistics with the co-belligerent partners.

* FIGHT THE JIHADIS, NOT THE SYRIAN GOVERNMENT.

Not only is it materially correct, it’s what the Russians have been saying for several years. Someday maybe we’ll stop thinking that we should oppose everything the Russians support.

Another way of saying it would be “Don’t do stupid s**t”. Somebody said that once. Did it not pertain to Syria?

6 comments

Why the Populist Mood Is Abroad in the Land

For what might be the first time, I find myself in material agreement with Robert Reich. In his recent op-ed at The Boston Globe he writes:

Despite the recovery that began in 2009, confidence in economic institutions has fallen precipitously. In 2002, a Gallup poll found 77 percent of Americans satisfied with opportunities to get ahead by working hard, and only 22 percent were dissatisfied. By 2014, only 54 percent of Americans were satisfied and 45 percent dissatisfied.

Perhaps that’s because people have started to notice. Millions are still out of work six years after the recession ended. The jobs that have replaced the jobs that were lost pay less and, frequently, carry no benefits. All or practically all of the jobs gained can be attributed to immigrants being hired. Those aren’t things from which great satisfaction are born.

Confidence in political institutions has followed the same downward trajectory. In 1964, just 29 percent of voters believed that government was “run by a few big interests looking out for themselves.” By 2012, that opinion predominated, with 79 percent of Americans agreeing.

I wonder why that could possibly be? Could it be because trust among Congress and between Congress and the White House has eroded to the point that nothing can get done?

The erosion in public trust has been particularly steep in the past few years. In 2006, 59 percent of Americans felt that government corruption was widespread; by 2013, 79 percent of Americans felt that way. In Rasmussen polls undertaken in the fall of 2014, 63 percent thought most members of Congress were willing to sell their vote for either cash or a campaign contribution, and 59 percent thought it likely their own representative already had.

You can fool all of the people some of the time, etc. When the Senate is primarily composed of multi-millionaires, representatives are elected to Congress with barely a sou to their name and emerge after having been serially re-elected 40 years later as multi-millinoaires, people may talk. See also the Clinton Foundation which gives the impression of corruption even if corruption can not be proven to have taken place. As Dan Rostenkowski once put it, never take a bribe. Just hand ’em your business card.

Many Americans have expressed their mounting frustrations by not voting. The largest political party in America is neither the Republican party nor the Democratic party; it’s the party of nonvoters. Only 58.2 percent of eligible voters cast their ballots in the 2012 presidential election.

Only the most optimistic or the most interested can possibly believe that the challengers are much better than the incumbents.

The antiestablishment backlash can be heard in populist rhetoric coming even from the Republican Party. “[We] cannot be the party of fat cats, rich people, and Wall Street,” said Republican senator Rand Paul, in seeking to position himself for a 2016 presidential run.

It probably doesn’t help that the explicit objective of the Federal Reserve’s policy of quantitative easing was to help “fat cats, rich people, and Wall Street” and that we no longer have a fiscal policy in this country only a monetary policy. Very little of that money has landed in the pockets of people who aren’t “fat cats, rich people, and Wall Street”, at least not in this country. The Forbes Index of Living Extremely Well has soared, however.

Polls show, for example, support among self-described Republicans as well as Democrats for cutting the biggest Wall Street banks down to a size where they are no longer too big to fail. In 2014, Republican Representative David Camp, House Ways and Means Committee chairman, proposed a quarterly tax on the assets of the biggest Wall Street banks in order to give them an incentive to trim down. “There is nothing conservative about bailing out Wall Street,” said Rand Paul.

As it worked out “bailing out Wall Street” was a bipartisan policy, supported both by the George W. Bush Administration and the succeeding Obama Administration. For an administration that had a primary strategy of doing the opposite of what Bush did, bailing out Wall Street stands out as a notable exception.

In 2013, when Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren introduced legislation to recreate such an act, Republican Senator John McCain cosponsored it. Tea Party Republicans expressed strong support of the measure, even criticizing establishment Republicans for not getting more fully behind it.

There is also growing bipartisan support for ending “corporate welfare,” including subsidies to big oil, big agribusiness, big pharma, Wall Street, and the Export-Import Bank. Progressives on the left have long been urging this, but by 2014 many on the right were joining in. David Camp’s proposed tax reforms would have eliminated dozens of targeted tax breaks. Ted Cruz urged that Congress “eliminate corporate welfare and crony capitalism.”

Everyone supports eliminating crony capitalism except when it’s their cronies.

Finally, grass-roots antipathy has grown toward trade agreements crafted by big corporations. In the 1990s, Republicans joined with Democrats to enact the North American Free Trade Agreement, join the World Trade Organization, and support China’s membership in the WTO.

But more recently, rank-and-file Republicans as well as Democrats turned against such agreements. “The Tea Party movement does not support the Trans-Pacific Partnership,” stated Judson Phillips, president of Tea Party Nation. “Special interests and big corporations are being given a seat at the table,” he said, while average Americans are excluded.

Negotiating agreements in secret and forbidding the disclosure of the terms of agreements could conceivably have something to do with that. Has any administration ever kept something they thought would be popular a secret? I can’t think of any.

It is likely that in coming years the major fault line in American politics will shift from Democrat versus Republican to antiestablishment versus establishment.

In a typical campaign year suppressing your opponent’s base is a routine strategy for achieving electoral success. This cycle suppressing your own base may emerge as the new strategy.

1 comment

Disconcerting

Last night I saw Ann Cusack in a guest appearance on Castle. Her sister and brother, Joan and John Cusack, have frequently said they thought she was the best actor of the three of them. I either sang at John’s or Ann’s baptism. It was a long time ago and I don’t honestly remember which it was.

Ann did a good job without a great deal to do.

It’s always a bit disconcerting to see people you’ve known since they were infants on television with gray hair and their faces lined with experience.

0 comments

No STEM Shortage

As I’ve been saying for the last decade there is no shortage of science, technology, engineering, and math workers in the U. S. economy and here’s more evidence that supports that conclusion:

This wage data suggest that there is not a shortage of STEM workers broadly, or for commonly discussed computer occupations. (Data on all detailed STEM occupations is available here.) One reason employers might think they can’t find workers is that they may have inflexible requirements for vacant positions. For example, a company might require that workers work for low wages and long hours, or that they have particular certifications or unreasonably specific skills, or vague cultural attributes that favor certain types of people. There might also be an unwillingness to train new workers on-the-job, which was very common in the past.

Or, alternatively, employers are writing job descriptions specifically to fit an H1-B workers they’d like to bring in for substantially lower wages than the prevailing wage for the job. I know this happens because I’ve actually seen it. As I’ve said before that presents a problem to which the solution is a centralized clearing house for positions for which employers wish to bring in a workers on an H1-B visa along with a requirement for paying the prevailing wage (yes, it’s difficult to determine but not impossible—the job sites do it every day) and accepting qualified domestic applicants.

5 comments

Questions and Answers About Hillary Clinton’s Emails

The never-ending saga of Hillary Clinton’s emails continues and it is guaranteed to be continue because of the regularly scheduled document drops the State Department is making under court order. Let’s put the matter into question and answer format.

What did Hillary Clinton do?

From the very beginning (January 2009) of her term as Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton exclusively used a private email server, either hosted on her own premises or those of others, commingling private emails, the emails in which she conducted State Department business, and business related to the Clinton Foundation. This was brought to light as a consequence of a Freedom of Information Act request.

Why did she do that?

She said she did it for convenience. That’s absurd and I assume that she along with everyone else knows it’s absurd. IMO the most likely explanation and the one explanation that does not presume that she’s an idiot is that she maintained a private email server to avoid the scrutiny of her communications that she knew her political enemies would inevitably conduct.

Well, so what?

Not only were her actions in violation of State Department policy (policy she was not at liberty to ignore even as Secretary of State) but the server was not secured. We know that the security of the private email server was breached by at least one hacker—that came out early in the investigations. We do not know whether its security was also breached by foreign governments.

It is also quite likely that she violated the law multiple times.

What laws?

According to Ken Cuccinelli:

Instead of turning his journals — so-called “black books” — over to the Defense Department or CIA when he left either of those organizations, Petraeus kept them at his home — an unsecure location — and provided them to his paramour/biographer, Paula Broadwell, at another private residence. (None of the classified information in the black books was used in his biography.)
On April 23, Petraeus pled guilty to a single misdemeanor charge of unauthorized removal and retention of classified documents or materials under 18 USC §1924. Many in the intelligence community were outraged at the perceived “slap on the wrist” he received, at a time when the Justice Department was seeking very strong penalties against lesser officials for leaks to the media.
According to the law, there are five elements that must be met for a violation of the statute, and they can all be found in section (a) of the statute: “(1) Whoever, being an officer, employee, contractor, or consultant of the United States, and, (2) by virtue of his office, employment, position, or contract, becomes possessed of documents or materials containing classified information of the United States, (3) knowingly removes such documents or materials (4) without authority and (5) with the intent to retain such documents or materials at an unauthorized location [shall be guilty of this offense].”

Mr. Cuccinelli goes on to explain how Sec. Clinton’s actions satisfies each of those conditions. I also think there’s a pretty good case that she engaged in a conspiracy to evade the Freedom of Information Act. That’s a felony.

Isn’t she exonerated by virtue of having been Secretary of State at the time and empowered to determine what was or was not classified?

No. Some of the emails on her private server were what is called “classified at birth”. That means they were inherently and automatically classified. Declassifying them would have left a paper trail. Since no such paper trail has come to light, it’s a reasonable inference that never happened.

Isn’t this all just politically motivated?

No. There are certainly political motivations involved and the investigations may have started out with political motivations but it’s gone far beyond that now. It genuinely appears that Sec. Clinton engaged in illegal activities and has persistently lied about them.

21 comments

The Question About Chicago

There is an interesting question contained in the slug (the subtitle) of this post at City Journal on the circumstances that face Chicago: “How it is possible for a city this booming to be this broke?” The author points to multiple developments:

Chicago’s Loop hums with life and commerce today. A parade of companies, including Kraft and Motorola, has moved from the suburbs into the central business district. The greater downtown apartment market is booming, with thousands of new units being constructed. Chicago hotels will add 2,200 new hotel rooms this year to accommodate throngs of tourists. The city has rolled out new amenities and attractions, including an enhanced Riverwalk along the once-polluted Chicago River, and Maggie Daley Park, a fantasy-like playground that replaced the forlorn Daley Bicentennial Plaza section of Grant Park. Also opening this year: a long-anticipated elevated rail trail and a new nature preserve on Northerly Island.

The question is actually pretty easy to answer. These amenities are being built with borrowed money—borrowed from the federal government or financed by issuing bonds. Those will need to be paid back eventually. Meanwhile, while they add to the prestige of the city and, more importantly, the politicians who borrowed the money to build them they don’t bring a lot of revenue into the city.

What does bringing Boeing, Kraft, or Motorola into the city do to enhance revenues? Not a heckuva lot. In fact just about all it does is make the morning commute tougher. Relatively few of the people who work in these headquarters offices live in the city. They may work in Chicago but they live in the suburbs and that’s where they do their buying and that’s where they pay the real estate taxes on their homes. The city doesn’t have a city earnings tax (an income tax paid by people who work in the city but don’t live there) and doesn’t have the power to impose one.

Meanwhile, Mayor Emanuel and the City Council are running our credit rating into the ground (making it that much more expense to borrow) and raising every tax and fee they can to the point where no one will want to live here. Heckuva job.

1 comment

Get Your Scorecards Here!

For those of you who have lost track of what’s going on in Syria, the Russians are supporting the Assad government (the official, internationally recognized government of Syria) and we’re supporting the “moderate rebels” (which translates into Al Qaeda) which the Russians correctly say is illegal. Saudi Arabia and Turkey are supporting Al Qaeda. Now the French are attacking DAESH. Meanwhile, the Assad government is fighting the “moderate rebels”, Al Qaeda, and DAESH. Is all that straight now?

Scorecards, get your scorecards here! You can’t tell the players without a scorecard.

5 comments

It’s Always Different When It’s Your Ox Being Gored

I think it’s been nearly a decade since I more than glanced at an article in National Review Online without rolling my eyes but this article at NRO by Reihan Salam is a notable exception. This passage in particular caught my eye:

More than one Dumbo parent has tried to explain to me how they’re totally different from other people who fight against integration. They explain that what they really want is a better world in which we spend far more on our public schools, not mentioning, or perhaps not knowing, that New York city spends $20,331 per pupil, almost twice as much as the national average of $10,700, and that much of this money is spent very inefficiently. Of course they want integration, they’ll tell you, but only if it entails no sacrifice on their part. “It’s more complicated when it’s about your own children,” says one Dumbo parent. Well, yes, it is more complicated, and that is exactly what every parent believes, whether they are in Brooklyn or South Boston or Kansas City.

Is there an area other than education in which the NIMBY (“not in my backyard”) phenomenon is more pronounced than in education. I can’t tell you how many conversations I’ve had with people explaining their choices in 1,000 different ways, all of which are different ways of saying “racism”. And yet they would deny that they’re racists.

11 comments

Seeing Free Markets Under Every Bed

One of the very first posts I wrote here at The Glittering Eye was an explanation of the business that large pharmaceutical companies are in, something that remains widely misunderstood more than ten years later. They are not in the business of developing new drugs. They’re in the business of selling drugs and retaining the rights to an exclusive market for their products. As evidence I produced the figures from the companies’ very own annual reports over the period of a decade showing that research and development increased with inflation while sales, marketing, and lobbying expenses increased with revenues which by itself is enough to prove the point. To increase revenues a farmer plants more land. To increase revenues pharmaceutical companies do more promotion and lobby harder. R&D is basically an overhead expense for them, like the phones.

I also have a vague recollection that the post sparked the first email exchange I had over one of my posts (I think it was with Megan McArdle). My correspondent said I just didn’t understand the length of time that it takes a pharmaceutical company to bring a product to market (an irrelevancy). Since by that point in my career I’d had big pharmaceutical companies and medical equipment manufactures as clients for decades and not only did I know how their businesses worked I knew how their managers thought, I was confident of my ground.

At any rate you might want to take a look at this article in Quartz on drug prices. The graph above is from that article and I beamed when I saw it. Familiar territory.

However, I laughed out loud when I read the final sentence of this passage:

Americans pay far more than any other country for prescription drugs. In fact, Americans overpay for every aspect of healthcare: procedures and services are the most expensive in the world, because efficiency plays no role in rewarding the healthcare providers. As Dr. Stephen Ondra—who works as chief medical officer for customer-owned health insurance company Health Care Service Corporation—told Quartz, “right now inefficiency is rewarded, the more you do to get an outcome, the more you make.”

There is a common denominator behind all of this: the free, unregulated market.

Talk about not understanding the industry you’re writing about! I fully endorse the second sentence of the first paragraphy above. I’m told that’s changing under the PPACA but I’ll believe it when I see it. However, healthcare in general and the pharmaceutical industry in particular are among the most heavily regulated sectors in the economy. There is no “free, unregulated market” in pharmaceuticals. If there were Martin Shkreli’s decision to increase the price of Daraprim from $13.50 per tablet to $750 per tablet over which they are rightly outraged would have presented no problem because there would have been a legion of companies (many of them in India) that would have been eager to produce the drug themselves and undercut the $750. I don’t know the manufacturing processes required for Daraprim but I suspect it would come in at a price substantially below $13.50 per tablet. No, the reason it presented a problem is because of patents and trademarks, neither of which have anything to do with a free market.

Like most other heavily regulated industries, e.g. banking, pharmaceutical companies are doing very well, indeed. Whatever problems free markets create, high pharmaceutical prices aren’t among them. The real problem in this case is that a 62 year old drug is being extended patent protection at all. Heck, I’m skeptical about extending trademark protection for that long let alone patent protection. We don’t pay Xerox a royalty when xeroxing a document or Kleenex a royalty when blowing our noses. I don’t think that Daraprim should be any different.

9 comments

Welcome to the Consequences

I could go into all of the various issues I have this article on poverty at The American Prospect. For example, in this sentence:

The official poverty measure is an important metric, one that tells us what share of people live in extreme economic deprivation in one of the wealthiest countries in the world. Since it’s been in place for nearly 50 years and has been measured fairly consistently, the official poverty measure paints a picture of poverty over time.

they conflate two very different things: “extreme economic deprivation” and “official poverty”. Official poverty is a statistical measure of relative poverty based on the CPI. There are actually two different definitions—one from the OMB and one from HHS. The OMB figure is the 14% they quote in the article.

“Extreme economic deprivation” has a definition, too: in the United States it’s trying to live on $2 per person per day and that’s true of about 1% of the population.

However, the quibble with the article I wanted to highlight is in this paragraph:

Finally, one of the most critical factors in suppressing wages is the erosion of collective bargaining and the decrease in job quality for working people. Enacting modern labor standards, such as paid family leave and paid sick days, as well as continuing advancements in and enforcement of labor laws, such as greater employer responsibility to franchise and contract workers, and making it easier for workers to form unions and new alliances will improve working conditions, wages, and benefits.

I think they should be specific. What “erosion of collective bargaining” are they referring to? I don’t see any. What I see is deindustrialization of the United States under the pressure of globalization and falling wages for jobs with few entry requirements driven by effectively open borders, both neoliberal policies that have been strenuously promoted by American progressives over the period of the last half century.

Welcome to the consequences of the policies you’ve favored.

0 comments