I wanted to take note of a single sentence in David Ignatius’s Washington Post column on Russia’s increasing involvement in Syria:
Putin embodies a kind of muscular diplomacy the United States disdained over the past three years of halfhearted attempts to train and equip the Syrian opposition. Obama’s failure to develop a coherent strategy left the field open for Putin.
because it illustrates everything that’s wrong with the Washington prevailing wisdom, of which Mr. Ignatius is the haruspex. There are several assumptions bundled into the sentence, first, that there is a coherent interventionist policy for the U. S. in Syria. It also assumes something else: that Russia has entered the lists in Syria solely because of a vacuum produced by U. S. inaction. Neither of those is true.
The first is not true because the choice in Syria is between the Assad government and radical Islamists. However much the Administration might wish there were liberal democrats in Syria just waiting for their opportunity to form a a government there isn’t one. There’s the more-or-less secularist Alawite government of Assad and his regime, there’s Al Qaeda and groups affiliated with them, and there’s DAESH and groups affiliated with them. That’s it. All are bad choices, inconsistent with American interests or values but, sadly, the Assad government is probably the best of the lot. Given how awful that regime is that’s not something any American president is likely to admit.
But as we have seen in Iraq DAESH would be even worse. Iraq was ethnically and religiously diverse with Arabs, Kurds, Chaldeans, Assyrians, Muslims, Christians, and Yezidis, just to name a few of the many groups that have called the country “home”. DAESH is changing that in the areas it controls. No one other than Sunni Arabs is safe in those areas and those are only safe as long as they adhere to a particularly harsh and antiquated form of Islam.
And do I really need to remind anyone that Al Qaeda was responsible for the most deadly terrorist attack on U. S. soil in history? I see no circumstances under which supporting Al Qaeda is in our interests.
But the second is even more absurd. Syria is in Russia’s neighborhood. Sevastopol is about 750 miles from Damascus—roughly the distance between New York City and Atlanta. The travel time is 33 hours overland. Russia is much more threatened by violent radical Islamism than we are. It has about three times as many Muslims as we do and some are very radicalized. Indeed, the Boston Marathon bombers were Chechens and there are many Chechens fighting the Assad government in Syria. They have good reason to believe that what happens in Syria won’t stay in Syria.
Far from needing a more muscular or interventionist policy in Syria, the U. S. needs a less interventionist policy in Syria. We shouldn’t be supporting radical Islamists under any circumstances. Actual U. S> military intervention means risking a direct confrontation between the United States and Russia. Do I really need to remind anyone that Russia is the only country other than the United States able to bring life on earth to an end? Direct confrontation with Russia would be foolhardy in the extreme.
The best thing we can do right now in Syria is maintain a low profile.