Being Jewish in America

I think that Jonathan Tobin misses two points in his post on the “demographic collapse” of non-Orthodox Jewry in the United States. In his concentration on the effects of American Jewry’s success and acceptance in the United States and consequent intermarriage with non-Jews he misses a couple of things. First, most American Jews are Ashkenazic, i.e. descended from Northern and Central European Jews rather than from Southern European, North African, or Middle Eastern Sephardic Jews, and the murder of millions of Ashkenazic Jews by the Germans during the 1930s and 1940s tore the heart out of Ashkenazic Jewry.

When you couple that with the widespread notion that the real place for Jews is Israel, it’s pretty hard to preserve non-Orthodox Judaism in the United States. On the other hand Orthodox Jews have more kids and are much more likely to rear their children in the Jewish faith than non-Orthodox Jews are.

3 comments

What Was World War I About?

Noah Rothman presents a thought-provoking theory of World War I. He explores the idea that WWI was over how the Ottoman Empire would be dismembered and who the beneficiaries of that process would be. Turning to the present day he touches on the potential for accidental great power war over Syria.

IMO connecting that conflict with the present day is somewhat farfetched. The only real candidate for dismemberee this time around is Russia and I don’t think matters have quite gotten to that point for the Russian Republic. I think that we’re still fighting over how the Ottoman Empire will be dismembered and who the beneficiaries of the process will be.

9 comments

Two Important Points About Economic Policy

In their editorial in reaction to the recent employment situation report, the editors of the Wall Street Journal made two points that I wish more people understood. The first is that the global economic turmoil of the last couple of months is at the very least in part and possibly largely our own chickens coming home to roost:

In a blog post, the White House Council of Economic Advisers attributed the jobs miss to “slowing growth abroad and global financial turmoil,” which is true as far as it goes. What they didn’t say is that some of that turmoil and slow growth has been caused by the whipsaw effect in emerging markets from Federal Reserve policy.

Capital that rushed into those markets during the Fed’s bond-buying heyday is now flowing back into dollar assets as the Fed considers raising interest rates. Commodity markets have also deflated as the dollar has risen, with considerable damage to the U.S. oil and gas boom that had been a rare bright spot.

That’s right. Developing economies have been exporting deflation back to us and it’s having an effect.

Here’s the other one:

If the economy is slowing down, don’t expect much help from the rest of Washington. In their blog post on Friday, the White House economists said “we must take steps to continue the domestic momentum that the U.S. economy has enjoyed in the last several years. That includes passing a budget that reverses the sequester and makes critical investments that help our economy continue to grow, reauthorizing the Ex-Im Bank so that our businesses can compete on a level-playing field abroad, and increasing investments in infrastructure.”

Is that all there is? Revive a loan-guarantee bank and spend more on roads and bridges? Really? This White House is either intellectually tapped out, or too partisan even to consider Republican growth ideas such as tax and regulatory reform. This week the Administration piled another costly rule on the economy to limit ozone in the atmosphere, even though only parts of California are in serious breach of current U.S. standards.

That’s been my complaint about the Obama Administration over the period of the last four or five years. They’ve never produced an economic plan or proposal that would do anything but nibble at the margins of our problems. The Republicans might oppose such plans but that doesn’t mean that the president’s economic advisors should just sit on their ash heaps, scraping their sores with a potsherd.

6 comments

Perspective

PolitiFact throws a little cold water on President Obama’s claim about the U. S.’s alleged high rate of mass killings. As it happens both Finland and Norway have much higher incidences of mass killings than we do per 100,000 population. Our rate is about the same as Switzerland’s. Given Switzerland’s very high rate of gun possession I’m surprised Switzerland’s isn’t higher.

In a country of 310 million people you’re going to have a lot of just about everything, including crazy people. Or people who are just plain evil. In a country of 310 million people that has wall-to-wall television news coverage it will seem as though a lot more horrible things happen.

16 comments

When the Conventional Wisdom Is Wrong

In my last post I mentioned that I’d get back to Eugene Volokh’s “modest proposal” and I’m doing that now. Here’s the passage that follows the one I quoted before:

Well, we tried, and the conventional wisdom is that the cure was worse than the disease — which is why we went back to a system where alcohol is pretty freely available, despite the harm it causes (of which the deaths are only part).

I think that the conventional wisdom is wrong or, at least, unproven. I’ve already produced the facts and figures. The reality of Prohibition is that it substantially decreased the rate of alcohol abuse (which has never returned to its pre-Prohibition level) and there’s no proof that the violence and organized crime that rose during the Prohibition era wouldn’t have risen anyway. There was more than one factor behind the rise of organized crime in the 1920s and 1930s among which are technological change, increasing urbanization, and the immigration of the late 19th and earliest part of the 20th centuries. Al Capone, Meyer Lansky, and Lucky Luciano were all immigrants or the children of immigrants. I’m not claiming that all criminals are immigrants merely suggesting that anomie and loss of social cohesion may be contributing factors to crime.

I think that the better argument against a return to Prohibition is that in the case of alcohol consumption the ratio of abusers to users is quite low. Nearly 60% of American adults are regular consumers of alcohol; about 7% are abusers. The comparable figures for marijuana are 25/2, for cocaine 1.5/.3, and for heroin .3/.17.

Indeed, that might be a good way to think about the rationale behind prohibiting the use of some substances while merely restricting the use of others. There is some likelihood of abuse attendant on use that is just too high a risk.

1 comment

Ways and Means

Ruth Marcus demands that we take some action to reduce the likelihood of future incidents like the shootings in Oregon last week:

The Second Amendment protects a right to gun ownership. It does not forestall reasonable regulation. The sorts of small steps that now appear unachievable would not interfere with the needs of responsible gun owners.

It is too soon to know how the Roseburg killer obtained his weapon or weapons; how evident was his mental illness; whether he could have been stopped. It is not too soon for all of us, myself included, to feel ashamed by our willingness to accept the status quo as bloody but immutable.

There are, however, several questions she leaves unanswered. What “reasonable reforms” would have that effect? Chicago has or had regulations or restrictions that were among the toughest in the nation, so tough they didn’t make constitutional muster. It also has one of the highest rates of gun violence in the country. Just last weekend we had a spate of violence that left six dead and eight more wounded. What reforms, specifically, would have changed that? Mayor Emanuel says there are too many guns but doesn’t have any proposals in mind that would both reduce the number of guns and meet constitutional muster.

Eugene Volokh points out the close association between gun violence and the consumption of alcohol:

Now I generally don’t support the “don’t just stand there, do something” school of criminal law. When all the proposals seem likely not to work, or do more harm than good, implementing one of them for the sake of “doing something” strikes me as a mistake.

But let me offer a concrete analogy (recognizing that, as with all analogies, it’s analogous and not identical).

Every day, about 30 people are killed in the U.S. in gun homicides or gun accidents (not counting gun suicides or self-inflicted accidental shootings). And every day, likely about 30 people are killed in homicides where the killer was under the influence of alcohol, plus alcohol-related drunk driving accidents and alcohol-related accidents where the driver wasn’t drunk but the alcohol was likely a factor (again not including those who died in accidents caused by their own alcohol consumption). If you added in gun suicides on one side and those people whose alcohol consumption killed themselves on the other, the deaths would tilt much more on the side of alcohol use, but I generally like to segregate deaths of the user from deaths of others.

So what are we going to do about it? When are we going to ban alcohol? When are we going to institute more common-sense alcohol-control measures?

I recognize that Mr. Volokh means this as a “modest proposal”. More about that later. The point is that in addition to the presence of lots of guns there are other factors involved. Among these are inadequate treatment of mental health problems, substance abuse, and low social cohesion. Rather than one grand (but ineffectual) gesture in gun control why not try some smaller moves in all of those directions?

Over the last few days I’ve heard praise for President Obama’s words as an attempt at moving the Overton window. What I believe they are missing is that there is no barrier to engaging in symbolic action aimed at redirecting the national discourse while proposing concrete steps that will effect your intended objective. If President Obama is trying to change hearts it’s not working. If anything, public opinion has moved in the direction of believing that we have gun control laws that are strict enough.

One more thing. I own two long guns, family heirlooms, neither of which has been discharged in living memory. I’m no “gun nut” but I understand where they’re coming from. There are many people in the United States who are absolutely as dedicated to the Second Amendment just as there are people who are dedicated to the First Amendment. I suspect that’s why few Democratic politicians other than a few backbenchers and no Republicans have staked any political capital on gun control. I’m not advocating despair—merely pointing out that when you hear a politician declaiming gun violence it may well be cynical and that goes for the president of the United States, too. Verbal advocacy for gun control while being unwilling to sacrifice anything for it may just be a form of signalling.

1 comment

Who Gets the Blame?

If President Obama makes good on his threat and refuses to sign a temporary spending bill if one comes across his desk, who will get the blame for “shutting down the government”? The prevailing wisdom is that Republicans will get the blame (presumably due to their majorities in both houses of Congress) if no spending bill is passed but does the same apply if reason the government “shuts down” is that the president refuses to sign a temporary bill? Does President Obama’s 45% approval rating factor into the equation?

We’re facing a similar situation here in Illinois. For the last several months the state of Illinois has been operating without a budget under various court orders because Gov. Bruce Rauner won’t sign an unbalanced budget. The difference is that the Illinois constitution requires a balanced budget while there’s nothing unconstitutional about a temporary spending bill.

I think that blame would fall on the president in the case of the federal budget and the Illinois legislature in the case of Illinois because Democrats have super-majorities in both houses of the Illinois legislature. Am I being unfair to Democrats? I see it as expecting more from them.

13 comments

Adjustments to the Jobs Reports

In the comments to Doug Mataconis’s post at OTB on the September labor situation report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which see here, our old friend Michael Reynolds remarks:

Why are we still responding to the early reports? Have we not been through one revision after another?

which, as it turns out, is a very good question.

Every month the BLS issues a report on the employment situation for the previous month which includes a first revision for the second previous month and a second revision for the third previous month. So, for example, the employment situation report issued in October contains the first estimate for September, a first revision for August, and a second revision for July. Whether you think the revisions are better than the original estimate is in the eye of the beholder.

Here’s a summary of the results for the last twelve months:

Month First estimate First revision Second revision Direction of first Direction of second
September 142,000        
August 173,000 136,000   Down  
July 215,000 245,000 223,000 Up Down
June 223,000 231,000 245,000 Up Up
May 280,000 254,000 260,000 Down Up
April 223,000 221,000 187,000 Down Down
March 126,000 85,000 119,000 Down Up
February 295,000 264,000 266,000 Down Up
January 257,000 239,000 201,000 Down Down
December 252,000 252,000 329,000   Up
November 321,000 353,000 423,000 Up Up
October 214,000 243,000 261,000 Up Up

The data are noisy, of course, but there are clearly a lot fewer jobs being created now than at the end of last year. My first order approximation suggests that revisions tend to be in the direction of trend but that may be a trick of the eye.

As to why we pay so much attention to data that are being revised, what fun would it be to ignore them? More importantly, revision is the way that science progresses and being subject to revision is actually more important than being measurable at all.

My conclusion is that we should be treating the present employment situation much more seriously than we are and that we need some policy revisions, something unlikely to occur with all of the hoopla about the 2016 presidential election. However, I’m glad to see the data and even happier that the BLS revises their data over time.

2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Signs of a Slowing Economy

The most recent employment situation report has not brought good news:

U.S. employers slammed the brakes on hiring over the last two months, raising new doubts the economy is strong enough for the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates by the end of this year.

Payrolls outside of farming rose by 142,000 last month and August figures were revised sharply lower to show only 136,000 jobs added that month, the Labor Department said on Friday.

That marked the smallest two-month gain in employment in over a year and could fuel fears that the China-led global economic slowdown is sapping America’s strength.

“You can’t throw lipstick on this pig of a report,” said Brian Jacobsen, a portfolio strategist at Wells Fargo Funds Management in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin.

Not only is the change in the number of jobs less than was expected but last month’s job figures have been revised to sharply downward. Job growth in both months was below the “natural increase”. Zerohedge has noticed that and points to the sharp decrease in the labor force participation rate, now the lowest it’s been in almost 40 years:

While the September jobs number was an absolute disaster, here is the real punchline: in September, the people not in the labor force soared by a whopping 579,000 to a record 94.6 million, up from the previous record 94.0, even as number of people employed – according to the household survey used to calculate the “5.1%” unemployment rate – tumbled by 236,000 to 148.8 million.

And as a result of this latest surge in people who aren’t working, nor want to work, the participation rate crashed yet again, and sliding from 62.6% to 62.4%, it was the lowest since October 1977.

Basically, things are moving the wrong way. We want less slack in the labor market not more.

12 comments