Thinking About Francis’s Message

I suppose I ought to express my thoughts on Pope Francis’s visits to Washington and New York. I’ll start with what to me was the most nonsensical headline for an article on Francis’s address to Congress from the New York Post: “Pope Francis is big on ideals — but small on solutions”. They’re saying that as though it were a bad thing. Francis has doctorates in philosophy and theology. The more closely he hews to the ends rather than the means, the stronger the ground on which he stands. I celebrate Francis’s humility, simplicity, and his call for us to heed what Abraham Lincoln called “the better angels of our nature”.

In concluding his First Inaugural Address with that phrase, Lincoln was elaborating on Charles Dickens:

The thoughts of worldly men are for ever regulated by a moral law of gravitation, which, like the physical one, holds them down to earth. The bright glory of day, and the silent wonders of a starlit night, appeal to their minds in vain. There are no signs in the sun, or in the moon, or in the stars, for their reading. They are like some wise men, who, learning to know each planet by its Latin name, have quite forgotten such small heavenly constellations as Charity, Forbearance, Universal Love, and Mercy, although they shine by night and day so brightly that the blind may see them; and who, looking upward at the spangled sky, see nothing there but the reflection of their own great wisdom and book-learning…

“It is curious to imagine these people of the world, busy in thought, turning their eyes towards the countless spheres that shine above us, and making them reflect the only images their minds contain…So do the shadows of our own desires stand between us and our better angels, and thus their brightness is eclipsed.

(from Barnaby Rudge) who in turn was quoting Shakespeare (Othello).

I agree wholeheartedly with Francis that we should shelter refugees, be better stewards of the environment, be more frugal in our use of the earth’s resources than we are, and take better care of the poor. But I also agree somewhat with this passage from Rich Lowry’s article cited above:

The questions are usually one of means, rather than ends, and of practicalities. The pope says we should respond to immigrants humanely and justly. OK. The United States welcomes more than a million legal immigrants here annually, and they are treated so humanely and justly that tens of millions more would be happy to come. But the United States doesn’t have an open-ended obligation to import foreigners without reference to the interests of the people already living here.

Also, don’t forget the wellbeing of the people left behind in the countries that are producing large numbers of migrants (eliding over the distinctions among refugees, economic migrants, and just plain rent-seekers).

I think that Peggy Noonan has the pope about right here:

The Francis I love is against materialism because he knows it is hollow and soul-crushing. He knows wealth and power are a moral hazard. He does not want man reduced to a commodity. He is for the little guy. He opposes the throwaway culture in which the old and the vulnerable are expendable. He wants you to be a saint, not a Scrooge.

He wades into the great spiritual questions.

That pope has captured the imagination of the world.

Is what he does merely symbolic? Nothing at his level is merely symbolic. He is acting in a Christlike way: His actions are lessons, reminders, intimations. Inspirations.

The less lovable pope is—well, and I say this still with love, Uncle Frank in the attic. This is the one who endorses secular political agendas, who castigates capitalism in language that is both imprecise and heavily loaded. He doesn’t, actually, seem to know a lot about capitalism or markets, or even what economic freedom has given—and is giving—his own church. For one small example, the other day Stephen Schwarzman of the Blackstone Group gave $40 million to the Catholic schools of New York, meaning he is giving his personal wealth to pay for the education of children, many of whom are recent immigrants and some of whom sleep in cars. Last I looked Mr. Schwarzman was not a monk or a mystic but a businessman in private equity. This is not abusing, ignoring or dehumanizing the poor. This is lifting them up, helping them in a concrete way that will change their lives.

and I welcome this from the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

In the Americas “thousands of persons are led to travel north in search of a better life for themselves and for their loved ones, in search of greater opportunities,” the pope said. “Is this not what we want for our own children? We must not be taken aback by their numbers, but rather view them as persons, seeing their faces and listening to their stories, trying to respond as best we can to their situation. To respond in a way which is always humane, just and fraternal.”

The pope’s call to a common humanity is much-needed, but to our ears the most striking word in that passage is “north.” Here is the Latin American pope acknowledging that the migrants are moving north to the United States, not the other way around. This is the same United States that practices the capitalist economics the pope has excoriated on so many other occasions. There must be something moral to free-market economics if it creates so much opportunity that attracts so many of the world’s poor.

The first sentence in the second paragraph is fine; I think the balance of the paragraph goes well beyond anything that Francis has said or intends because his focus is on the ends rather than the means. Identifying the most appropriate and efficient means for accomplishing those ends is a task left to secular leaders, leaders who I might add are not stepping up to their responsibilities.

There is also a conundrum with which Francis has yet to come to terms. Why isn’t there a responsibility reciprocal to the responsibility to provide shelter to refugees to work towards changing the countries from which they are fleeing? How about economic migrants? That 10% of Mexico’s population has left Mexico for the United States isn’t an indictment of our system but of theirs. Where are Mexico’s responsibilities in his thinking?

I also think that those American politicians who see Francis as a political ally should guess again. He isn’t a fool. I seriously doubt that his idea of helping the poor means income redistribution from the rich in America to the middle class in America (most of what current policy does) but from America to poorer countries. If they think that’s a viable platform, they should try running on it. Two-thirds of the poorest people in the world live in just five countries: India, China, Nigeria, Bangladesh, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. India isn’t poor because America is rich and making Americans poorer will do little to help poor Indians. That so many of the people in those five countries are desperately poor points to serious economic and social dysfunction (if not malfunction) in those countries.

As it turns out (and as I have documented before) Americans give more to the poor overseas both overall and per capita than all but a very few countries. Unlike our European cousins we don’t do it solely through the government but in a manner consistent with our society: through a combination of government aid, aid from various private social services organization, and person-to-person assistance. We can and should do more but we should also maintain better stewardship of the aid we give. There’s truth in the wisecrack that foreign aid is poor people in rich countries contributing to rich people in poor countries. Means are important as well as ends.

Finally, there is something of which I think many lose track. Francis’s views are a seamless garment. If you pick and choose among them to find those you like, you’re creating a parody of his message. As Paul Kengor notes:

What does this mean? It means you shouldn’t cherry-pick this pope. You can’t grab this or that statement that fits your personal political-ideological preferences and think you have the full picture. The Francis picture has many shades.

This pope is neither liberal nor conservative. This pope is Catholic.

5 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Après Boehner le déluge

I don’t really have much to say about House Speaker John Boehner’s announcement that he would be resigning not just his office as Speaker but his seat in the House as of the end of October. The question that I guess is on most minds is what next? Does anyone really think that Kevin McCarthy (California 23rd District) will pacify the more fractious members of the Republican caucus? I don’t think they’d be satisfied with anyone but one of their own. Maybe not even then.

I say that because my take on today’s Congressional politics is that there are a lot of Republicans who are under the misapprehension that there’s a hidden groundswell of conservative voters out there just waiting for a Republican caucus that will pass their agenda. Quite to the contrary I think that what you see is what you get. About a quarter to the country is conservative; about 30% is progressive; the other 40 some-odd percent is not particularly ideological. Eclectic, maybe, because I don’t think that “centrist” quite covers it.

6 comments

Oh, Dear

BMW is now receiving scrutiny over the test results of its own diesel engines:

Germany’s motor vehicle administration “will concentrate its investigations not only on the Volkswagen models in question but will also do spot checks of other car manufacturers,” Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt told reporters in Berlin.
Emissions measured in road tests of 15 new diesel cars were an average of about seven times higher than European limits, according to a study published last October by the International Council on Clean Transportation, the same group whose tipoff led U.S. regulators to investigate a gap between VW diesels’ emissions in tests and on the road.
ICCT also found a gap between real-world and lab performance in BMW’s X3, Germany’s Autobild magazine reported. BMW said that there’s no system in its cars that responds to tests differently than it would operate on the road.
“The BMW Group does not manipulate or rig any emissions tests,” the Munich-based company said in a statement in response to the report. “We observe the legal requirements in each country.”

It’s practically the perfect storm for the German automotive industry. If every time any German company comes up with good test results on emissions, they’re subjected to increased scrutiny because of suspected cheating, it’s going to be a problem.

3 comments

Help Wanted, Superpower

Joseph Nye, the chap who coined the term “soft power”, reiterates a point I’ve made from time to time in an op-ed at National Interest. Like it or not we’re stuck with the job of “indispensable nation” because nobody else wants the job:

Contrary to those who proclaim this the “Chinese century,” we have not entered a “post-American world.” Of course, the continuation of the American century will not look like the 20th century. Our share of the world economy will be less than it was in the middle of the past century, and the complexity represented by the rise of other countries—as well as the increased role of nonstate actors—will make it more difficult for anyone to wield influence and organize action. But no other country—including China—is about to replace us. Europe lacks unity; Russia is in decline; India and Brazil remain developing countries. Americans should stop talking and worrying about “decline,” a fear that mixes many different trends and leads to mistaken policy conclusions. Instead, we should face the fact that we will be the largest country and will have to lead for decades to come.

If only we would use our powers for good!

Actually, I think that we do but our government has much to answer for. When did the government stop being answerable to the people?

13 comments

Don’t Just Take My Word For It

You don’t need to just take my word for how bad persistent low interest rates will be for the economy. “Bond King” in exile Bill Gross makes arguments very similar to those I’ve made:

But models aside, there should be space in an economic textbook or the minutes of a central bank meeting to acknowledge the destructive influence of 0% interest rates over the intermediate and longer term.

How so? Because zero bound interest rates destroy the savings function of capitalism, which is a necessary and in fact synchronous component of investment. Why that is true is not immediately apparent. If companies can borrow close to zero, why wouldn’t they invest the proceeds in the real economy? The evidence of recent years is that they have not. Instead they have plowed trillions into the financial economy as they buy back their own stock with a seemingly safe tax advantaged arbitrage. But more importantly, zero destroys existing business models such as life insurance company balance sheets and pension funds, which in turn are expected to use the proceeds to pay benefits for an aging boomer society. These assumed liabilities were based on the assumption that a balanced portfolio of stocks and bonds would return 7-8% over the long term. Now with corporate bonds at 2-3%, it is obvious that to pay for future health, retirement and insurance related benefits, stocks must appreciate by 10% a year to meet the targeted assumption. That, of course, is a stretch of some accountant’s or actuary’s imagination.

It’s his continuation that I find interesting:

Do central bankers not observe that Detroit, Puerto Rico, and soon Chicago, Illinois cannot meet their promised liabilities? Do they simply chalk it up to bad management and inept governance and then return to their Phillips Curves for policy guidance? Do they not know that if zero were to become the long-term norm, that any economic participant that couldn’t print its own money (like they can), would soon “run on empty” as Blackstone’s Pete Peterson once expressed it in describing our likely future scenario? The developed world is beginning to run on empty because investments discounted at near zero over the intermediate future cannot provide cash flow or necessary capital gains to pay for past promises in an aging society. And don’t think that those poor insurance companies and gargantuan pension funds in the hundreds of billions are the only losers. Mainstream America with their 401Ks are in a similar pickle. Expecting 8-10% to pay for education, healthcare, retirement or simply taking an accustomed vacation, they won’t be doing much of it as long as short term yields are at zero. They are not so much in a pickle barrel as they are on a revolving spit, being slowly cooked alive while central bankers focus on their Taylor models and fight non-existent inflation.

There’s actually quite a bit of subtext in his remarks. Some of it is the complaint of the applied practitioner about theoreticians. It wasn’t always that way. Once upon a time Fed governors were actual bankers and investors.

7 comments

Time to Recalibrate the Models

It seems to me that it’s pretty hard to read this post at Watts Up With That? and not come away with the impression that the climate change models need some work.

Just to recap my views on the subject, I think the idea that humans affect the climate is obvious, I don’t know what proportion of climate change is effected by human activity, I think that climate change (whether anthropogenic or not) is a serious matter, and I think that it deserves serious attention. None of the plans put forward to date do that. When somebody presents a draconian plan that they say addresses .1% of the problem, it makes me wonder what’s next?

The steps that I think we should take first here all involve our ending our subsidies for carbon production. For example, why do subsidize urban sprawl?

One of the things we’ve learned in the last week is that some of the measures put in place by us and our European cousins have not been nearly as effective as we might have hoped. Good news! If VW re-flashes the memories on all of those 11 million control modules, it should reduce emissions measurably without any other actions taking place. Now to the hard part: obtaining compliance.

10 comments

Trying to Tax Their Way Out of the City’s Decline

The editors of the Wall Street Journal have noticed the whopping tax increases that Mayor Emanuel has proposed:

At Chicago’s City Hall, Mr. Emanuel proposed what he says are some $600 million in annual tax and fee increases, including $588 million in property tax increases phased in over four years. The Illinois Policy Institute says the real total in new property tax revenue over four years will be $1.768 billion in a fiscal 2016 budget of $9.3 billion.

All that cash will do little or nothing to improve city services. Mr. Emanuel says $543 million will fund pensions for firemen and police. The remaining $45 million by his calculation will go to cover capital improvements for public-school buildings.

The tax increase isn’t intended to improve city services. It’s intended to pay for the mayor’s and his predecessors’ promises to city workers. Whether those promises have resulted in improved city services you can judge for yourself. I’m skeptical to say the least.

What the promises have paid for is the re-election of the mayor and his predecessors again and again. I don’t think we’re better off for that but I’m admittedly in a minority.

Something else the tax increases will pay for: the increased interest the city will pay on its loans, the direct product of the mayor’s incompetence.

3 comments

The Other Shoe On VW’s Recall (Updated)

As I anticipated, the fix to VW’s emissions problems may be very difficult to sell:

Once the sting of the lie fades, the US customers who bought 482,000 of those cars will feel the real pain. Because Volkswagen will be forced to recall those vehicles and somehow make them to meet federal standards. There are two apparent ways to do that, and owners who value performance, fuel economy, and trunk space won’t like either.

The first way is to reflash the engine control module so the vehicles stay in test mode all of the time. They’ll lose power and their mileage will drop. They just won’t be the vehicles that were advertised. Can you spell “class action lawsuit”? I knew you could.

The other way is to slap a urea tank onto those suckers just like the big boys use. That would be even more expensive for VW and the only likely place to put it is in the trunk. No trunk space? Once again the customers won’t have the vehicles they thought they were buying. IMO VW will need to sweeten the deal to keep from facing billions in legal fees.

Update

As widely expected, VW’s CEO has resigned. They’re drawing straws to see who succeeds him. Short straw wins loses becomes the next CEO.

4 comments

Ganging Agley in Syria

As should be surprising to no one other than those who either a) are completely in thrall to the Obama Administration or b) just fell off the turnip truck, supporting the “moderate rebels” in Syria is not working out quite the way the Administration has billed it:

US-trained rebels in Syria have defied their Pentagon-funded programme by pledging to fight against Assad regime troops.
Division 30, the first rebel faction to incorporate graduates of a US-led training programme, released a statement on Tuesday in which it promised to fight Syrian president Bashar al-Assad – something Washington had tried to prevent.
“The Division was formed from the honourable sons of Syria to help rid their country of Assad gangs and Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (Isil),” read the statement.

unless, of course, the entire thing isn’t a cover story for arming Al Qaeda. I don’t think the Obama Administration is feckless enough to do that. Let’s summarize what happened:

  1. We train and arm “moderate Syrian rebels”.
  2. As soon as they’re turned loose they surrender their arms to Jabhat al-Nusra.

There’s lots of commentary on this story over at Pat Lang’s place.


But Mousie, thou art no thy lane,
In proving foresight may be vain:
The best-laid schemes o’ mice an’ men
Gang aft agley,
An’ lea’e us nought but grief an’ pain,
For promis’d joy!

5 comments