The president always intended to repudiate more than George W. Bush’s foreign policy. In a 2012 presidential debate with Mitt Romney, Mr. Obama made clear that he was turning away from Ronald Reagan, too. “The 1980s are now calling to ask for their foreign policy back,†he jeered, “because the Cold War’s been over for 20 years.†Mr. Romney’s reference to Russia as “our number one geopolitical foe†now looks prescient, whereas the president’s boast, in a January 2014 New Yorker magazine interview, that he didn’t “really even need George Kennan right now†looks like hubristic rejection of foreign-policy experience itself. Two months later, Vladimir Putin annexed Crimea.
Mr. Obama also had his own plan for the Middle East. “It would be profoundly in the interest†of the region’s citizens “if Sunnis and Shias weren’t intent on killing each other,†Mr. Obama said in that same interview. “If we were able to get Iran to operate in a responsible fashion—not funding terrorist organizations, not trying to stir up sectarian discontent in other countries, and not developing a nuclear weapon—you could see an equilibrium developing between . . . predominantly Sunni Gulf states and Iran.â€
Now I see that this was the strategy—a strategy aimed at creating a new balance of power in the Middle East. The deal on Iran’s nuclear-arms program was part of Mr. Obama’s aim (as he put it to journalist Jeffrey Goldberg in May) “to find effective partners—not just in Iraq, but in Syria, and in Yemen, and in Libya.†Mr. Obama said he wanted “to create the international coalition and atmosphere in which people across sectarian lines are willing to compromise and are willing to work together in order to provide the next generation a fighting chance for a better future.â€
I think it’s simpler than that. I think it’s “Don’t blame me”, a policy always doomed to failure. I do take exception with these remarks from Dr. Ferguson:
Some things you can learn on the job, like tending bar or being a community organizer. National-security strategy is different. “High office teaches decision making, not substance,†Mr. Kissinger once wrote. “It consumes intellectual capital; it does not create it.†The next president may have cause to regret that Barack Obama didn’t heed those words. In making up his strategy as he has gone along, this president has sown the wind. His successor will reap the whirlwind. He or she had better bring some serious intellectual capital to the White House.
IMO the last thing we need in the White House is someone who brings “serious intellectual capital”. That’s the view from the Ivory Tower. What we need is someone who trusts his staff and attracts a staff worthy of trust. And I don’t mean a close circle of cronies he’s known for twenty years.
In the United Kingdom newspapers tend to be associated with particular political parties. The Telegraph is so closely associated with the Conservative Party that it’s waggishly called the “Torygraph”. The Daily Mirror and the Financial Times have tended to support Labour. Recently, The Independent has oxymoronically tended to support the Lib-Dems.
Here in the United States we have notionally had a non-partisan press but that has become increasingly frayed over the years. The New York Times is pretty clearly the voice of the Democratic Party. The Wall Street Journal performs a similar function for Republicans. MSNBC and Fox News are notoriously pro-Democrat and pro-Republican, respectively.
The problem with that is illustrated in this Wall Street Journal editorial on the authoritarian impulse among some progressives, something that’s becoming increasingly worrying:
Elizabeth Warren recently drove out a think-tank scholar for having the nerve to report that a new federal regulation could cost billions, but the progressive censor movement is broad and growing. Advocates of climate regulation are urging the Obama Administration to investigate people who don’t share their views.
Last month George Mason Professor Jagadish Shukla and 19 others signed a letter to President Obama, Attorney General Loretta Lynch and White House science adviser John Holdren urging punishment for climate dissenters. “One additional tool—recently proposed by Senator Sheldon Whitehouse—is a RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) investigation of corporations and other organizations that have knowingly deceived the American people about the risks of climate change, as a means to forestall America’s response to climate change,†they wrote.
In other words, they want the feds to use a law created to prosecute the mafia against lawful businesses and scientists. In a May op-ed in the Washington Post, Mr. Whitehouse specifically cited Willie Soon of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, who has published politically inconvenient research on changes in solar radiation.
These abuses of power are things that a genuinely non-partisan press would be trumpeting. That the stories are relegated to the Wall Street Journal or Fox News impels half the population to dismiss them, regardless of their merits. As Jefferson wrote “…whenever the people are well-informed, they can be trusted with their own government; that, whenever things get so far wrong as to attract their notice, they may be relied on to set them right.” There are times when I fear for the republic.
I wonder how long it will take columnists like Ruth Marcus that Hillary Clinton doesn’t care about workers? Any expressed concern is merely instrumental in her getting into the Oval Office. My offhand guess is that they already know but won’t dare say anything about it until the last year of her second term.
Moscow recently began bombing rebel-held areas in strikes that appeared designed to cripple the opposition groups that pose the gravest threat to the Syrian government. That approach will almost certainly prove to be self-defeating even if the Assad regime, after gassing and slaughtering thousands of Syrians, were to stay in power in the short run.
They may be right but there’s precedent for questioning that assessment. Saddam Hussein remained in power a full 15 years after gassing thousands of Kurds at Halabja. And after killing many thousands of “marsh Arabs”, the Shi’ite Arabs native to the south of Iraq. Sometimes tyrants are removed by spontaneous revolts of the people but it wasn’t true in Iraq and there’s reason to question that it would occur in Syria. IMO Syria’s revolt has been fomented and fueled by outsiders, among whom are the United States and Gulf Arabs, intent on spreading their own Salafist version of Islam.
If there’s any reason to prefer that over the Alawite regime that presently rules Syria, I certainly don’t see it. Quite to the contrary, why don’t we stop supplying the rebels entirely and start putting pressure on our notional allies in the region to do the same.
When you’ve lost the New York Times… Here’s what the editors of the New York Times have to say about the Obama Administration’s new policy with respect to Syria:
The initial plan was dubious. The new one is hallucinatory…
characterizing the president’s plan as “incoherent”. Which is what quite a few people many of whom are not warmongers have been saying for several years. The president given his limited rhetorical repertory has routinely called those who disagreed with him vicious, fools, or insane, something that’s beginning to look like projection.
What if those who’ve criticized the president’s policies from time to time have been right? What if some of them are Democrats? Hillary Clinton has recently entered the lists as one of them. That’s a risky move but not for the reasons usually given. It’s risky because it threatens to divide Democrats into those who are loyal to Obama, those who are loyal to Clinton, and those who don’t care who the messenger is but recognize bad policies when they see them.
One thing I learned in a theory of negotiations class I took many years ago is that a lack of options is a position of strength. That’s what occurred to me when I read Stephen Walt’s comparison in Foreign Policy of Vladimir Putin’s and Barack Obama’s policies in the Middle East. Here’s the passage that caught my attention:
But Putin has also done one thing right: He has pursued simple objectives that were fairly easy to achieve and that played to Russia’s modest strengths. In Ukraine, he had one overriding goal: to prevent that country from moving closer to the EU, eventually becoming a full member, and then joining NATO. He wasn’t interested in trying to reincorporate all of Ukraine or turn it into a clone of Russia, and the “frozen conflict†that now exists there is sufficient to achieve his core goal. This essentially negative objective was not that hard to accomplish because Ukraine was corrupt, internally divided, and right next door to Russia. These features made it easy for Putin to use a modest degree of force and hard for anyone else to respond without starting a cycle of escalation they could not win.
Putin’s goals in Syria are equally simple, realistic, and aligned with Russia’s limited means. He wants to preserve the Assad regime as a meaningful political entity so that it remains an avenue of Russian influence and a part of any future political settlement. He’s not trying to conquer Syria, restore the Alawites to full control over the entire country, defeat the Islamic State, or eliminate all Iranian influence. And he’s certainly not pursuing some sort of quixotic dream of building democracy there. A limited deployment of Russian airpower and a handful of “volunteers†may suffice to keep Assad from being defeated, especially if the United States and others eventually adopt a more realistic approach to the conflict as well.
I don’t think Dr. Walt is giving President Putin enough credit and is giving President Obama far too much. Not only are Mr. Putin’s actions in Syria in Russia’s interests and within Russia’s abilities, they’re overwhelmingly popular in Russia. Putin is not only staking out a position for himself as the defender of Russian interests but as the hero of Orthodoxy—something that will bolster Russia’s and Putin’s reputation far beyond Russia or Syria.
Fortunately for the United States, U. S. foreign policy is an emergent phenomenon and extends far beyond the decisions of the president. The president is command in chief and orders the U. S. military into battle. Or doesn’t. And he directs the actions of the diplomats who work for the State Department. The president’s actions are constrained not only by his own ideological views but by political considerations. And he doesn’t direct the thousands of companies and other organizations and the millions of individuals that are creating U. S. foreign policy in their day to day actions in ways over which the president has very little control.
When I read reports like this one about Paul Ryan’s thinking about throwing his hat into the ring for Speaker of the House, it puts me in mind of a wisecrack I once heard, attributed to Mark Twain but that actually sounds more like Josh Billings to me. In reaction to the prospect of being tarred and feathered and run out of town on a rail he said that if it weren’t for the honor he’d just as soon have walked.
The JPL is now predicting that the El Niño phenomenon is very likely to be quite strong this season. From the LA Times:
An El Niño that is among the strongest on record is gaining strength in the Pacific Ocean, and climate scientists say California is likely to face a wet winter.
“There’s no longer a possibility that El Niño wimps out at this point. It’s too big to fail,†said Bill Patzert, climatologist for NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in La Cañada Flintridge.
“And the winter over North America is definitely not going to be normal,†he said.
What that means for Chicago is that the winter of 2015-2016 is likely to be warmer and drier than usual.
I’m glad for California, of course. They’re in desperate need of the rainy winter that a strong El Niño is likely to bring to them. I hope they’re ready for it. Rain that just runs off won’t be any good to them.
But it also means that we’re unlikely to have a good sledding season here. Damn. I thought we might actually have a team to run.
A prime example of the intelligence shortfall is the train-and-equip program that was derailed so quickly this summer by Jabhat al-Nusra, the al-Qaeda affiliate, in northern Syria. The Pentagon needs to assess immediately why this overt, U.S.-backed program failed so badly, and whether it can be rebuilt. A better bet may be the CIA’s covert training program, whose fighters can make tactical battlefield deals with Jabhat al-Nusra without publicly allying with it.
What about safe zones in northern and southern Syria? That still seems like a good idea, so long as they’re established as corridors for humanitarian assistance and revived public services, rather than an armed U.S. or Turkish military intervention to help the rebels. Here, again, the United States needs better information. Scores of Syrians travel across the border from Turkey and Jordan every day to deliver basic supplies and keep water and other essential services operating. Talk to them! Maybe these zones could be the start of a managed transition to a post-Assad government.
The United States has lost its chance to make Assad’s departure a precondition for negotiations. But Washington should continue to insist that he must go eventually. Otherwise, no political deal can work. President Obama should be urging Putin right now to resume the Geneva negotiating process.
Here’s my equally unsolicited and probably much less welcome advice: identify your priorities and pursue them unflinchingly. Rather than getting lost in the weeds as Mr. Ignatius does, think of what kind of Syria we want and the policies most likely to encourage that kind of Syria.
In Syria there are the Assad government, Al Qaeda, and DAESH. There are probably hundreds of militias and various groups but they boil down to just those three alternatives. The idea that either Al Qaeda or DAESH have any interest in a liberal democratic government in Syria is fatuous. If that’s what we want there or even if we just want stability there, the road in that direction runs through the Assad government. The Russians, consummate realists, understand that.