It’s Not Easy Being This Wrong

This morning’s Wall Street Journal editorial stuck in my craw right from the subheading: “The Paris attacks signal a new Islamist terror strategy.” There’s nothing new about it. In a position of strength the radical Islamists fight wars in conventional ways. In a position of weakness they disappear into the cities and fight terror wars with suicide bombers, roadside bombs, and so on. It’s so typical it’s been called “the Arab way of war”. The only thing that’s new is Angela Merkel’s “come one, come all” invitation which, along with the Schengen accords, has allowed the cities the terrorists disappear into to be Brussels, Paris, and Berlin.

The Paris massacre should mark the end of that self-deception. Jimmy Carter shed his illusions about the Soviet Union after its invasion of Afghanistan in 1979, and Mr. Obama needs a comparable rendezvous with reality. This will be harder for Mr. Obama, a man of great ideological vanity, but perhaps the prospect of defeat for his party in 2016 will force him to see the world more clearly.

There are no signs of this. The inability of the three Democratic candidates for the presidency to say that our enemies are radical Islamists suggests to me that they value what passes to inclusiveness today beyond all else.

Mr. Obama also deposed Moammar Gadhafi in Libya but then did almost nothing to help Libyans restore order. Americans saw a glimpse of the gathering storm in the terror attack on the U.S. consulate in Benghazi, but the White House blamed it on an obscure video.

The Qaddafi regime was synonymous with the state in Libya. Once it had been deposed there was no state to maintain. See above.

Now Americans can see clearly the spreading infection from Islamic State and a resurgent al Qaeda. It isn’t merely a regional threat, as Mr. Obama once claimed. Its offshoots have spread into North Africa across the Middle East to Afghanistan. The civil war in Syria has spawned a refugee crisis that has descended on Europe and may have provided cover for at least one of the Paris jihadists.

That is the region. The Middle East and North Africa. The refugee crisis began with Iraqis fleeing into Syria and Jordan. DAESH is a direct outcome of our invasion of Iraq. I continue to believe it was an unintended outcome (although there are some Internet crackpots who claim that DAESH is a CIA construct).

The Paris attack is in some ways even more alarming than 9/11. Airplane hijackings have largely been stopped through enhanced security. Paris suggests that Islamic State has embarked on a strategy of urban unconventional warfare wherever it is able across the West. And it is far harder to track and prevent suicidal jihadists with assault rifles and grenades who want to blow up a restaurant district or concert hall.

I think this is nonsense. 9/11 resulted directly in thousands of deaths (indirectly in hundred of thousands) and trillions of dollars in losses. The only sense in which the Paris attacks, first in January and now in November, are more alarming is that they call into question France’s official policy of one, secular France. There are some French people who simply won’t be included, won’t go along with the plan, won’t be French. I think that will be France’s greatest challenge going forward.

The question now is what America’s President is going to do to prevent more Paris-like carnage, including attacks on U.S. soil. He can start by taking the political restraints off the U.S. military’s campaign against Islamic State.

To what end? We have next to no intelligence on the ground. DAESH captures pick-up trucks and mortars faster than we can attack them.

Turkey and the Sunni Arabs haven’t committed more to the fight because they don’t believe Mr. Obama is committed.

Turkey and the Sunni Arabs haven’t committed more to the fight because they support DAESH. Turkey’s unleashing of Syrian refugees on Europe is a sign of a new, demographic strategy against the West. If the U. S. “redoubles its efforts” will the Turks continue to allow the U. S. to use Incirlik Air Base? It would be a good gauge of their intentions.

Mr. Obama should order the Pentagon to roll back Islamic State from all of its territory in Iraq and Syria as rapidly as possible, which means months not years. Kurds and Sunni Arabs will provide most of the fighters if the U.S. supplies the firepower, intelligence and political leadership.

See above on the Kurds. And the Sunni Arabs are on the other side.

This ought to include taking up the Turks and Jordan on their desire for safe zones in Syria to protect Sunnis who are fighting the Bashar Assad regime but aren’t radical jihadists.

There are no such. The anti-Assad Sunni Arab Syrian rebels aren’t taking prisoners. That’s a pretty good proxy for radicalism in my book. Besides, as noted above, the Assad regime is the state. Without it there will only be chaos in what used to be Syria. And chaos is the friend of DAESH.

11 comments

The Kurds Fight to Defend Their Homes

I’m glad that somebody other than me sees that the Kurds are fighting to defend their homes rather for Syria or Iraq and that encouraging them to fight for Syria or Iraq will prove futile. In this case it’s Dexter Filkins, writing in the New Yorker:

For the Kurds, the new reality has amounted to a paradox: leaders in both Baghdad and Washington want the Kurds to fight ISIS, but the Kurds themselves mostly just want to secure Iraq’s Kurdish areas.

That means that the Kurds had every reason to want to liberate Sinjar. The Yazidis may be a religious minority—most Kurds are Sunni Muslims—but the majority of them are Kurdish-speaking. The Kurdish Regional Government, based in the city of Erbil, isn’t likely to stop battling ISIS until Sinjar is completely reunited with the Kurdish region. Peshmerga fighters have been preparing for this operation for months, having re-conquered nearby Mount Sinjar late last year.

If the peshmerga have indeed cut off the main highway that leads from the Syrian border, then Mosul is now quite isolated. Still, the evidence suggests that, once the Kurds fully retake Sinjar, they’ll stop fighting. Mosul, at least the parts held by ISIS, has a largely Arab population, and if Kurdish leaders sent their fighters in, they would likely face stiff, even popular, resistance. Retaking Mosul is most likely being reserved for the Iraqi Army, which, if it recovers, is likely to remain largely Arab. “We are happy to support an offensive to retake Mosul, but we won’t lead it,” the Kurdish official told me.

1 comment

The Middle East: the Land of Strong Regimes and Weak States

As I read this interview with Joshua Landis, one passage in particular leapt out at me:

The West falsely believes that it can separate the regime from the state. It argues that it can pursue regime-change while simultaneously preserving the state and its institutions. Washington believes it can avoid the chaos it sewed in Iraq. I don’t believe it can. It wasn’t only Bremer that criminalized the Baath Party and disbanded the army. The Shiite politicians he empowered insisted on it. In most Middle Eastern countries, the regimes, for better or worse, have transformed the states into reflections of themselves. They have cannibalized the state. They have crammed their loyalists into every nook and cranny of the national institutions. They had to in order to coup-proof their regimes. They justified it in the name of bringing stability. State institutions are not autonomous. Westerners believe that because their own state institutions are run by professional civil servants, Middle Eastern states are too. But they aren’t. Political appointees make up the entire edifice. They cannot simply be swapped out. Regime-change for an Arab country is not like administration change in a Western country. Destroying the regime means destroying the state. The price of regime-change is chaos.

That the countries of the Middle East and North Africa have, by and large, been dominated by autocratic regimes may not be an accident. It could be the foreseeable outcome of social institutions of family, clan, village, and tribe are not only more compelling than loyalty to the state but overwhelm it. I don’t know enough about Arab culture or Arab society to comment but I’ll appeal to those who do. Is that a characteristic of Arab societies?

If it is, it puts things in a new light. The condition of strong regimes and weak states may not be a result of post-colonialism; rather having been colonized may be a result of failure to unify beyond family, clan, or tribe.

And if that’s the case, the prospects for liberal democracy with the rule of law and protections for speech, the press, and the rights of minorities may be bleak. It would take generations of fostering of institutions, something I don’t think that we have the patience to do. As to whether liberal democracy can grow endogenously in the region, we’ll soon see. If democracy can’t survive in Tunisia, it probably can’t survive anywhere in the Middle East or North Africa.

Undermining states, something we have persistently done, certainly doesn’t help.

10 comments

No Lack of French Decisiveness

Well, don’t fault the French for a lack of decisiveness:

(CNN)The French air force carried out bombing missions on ISIS targets in Raqqa, Syria, for a second day in a row in the wake of deadly Islamist extremist terror attacks in Paris.

On Monday, it targeted a command center, recruitment center, ammunition storage base and a training camp, the French military said.

Also on Monday, French Interior Minister Bernard Cazaneuve said “war” had been declared on France, and that “anybody who attacks the Republic, the Republic will fight back.”

“It is not they who will destroy the Republic. The Republic will destroy them,” he said.

France has been part of the U.S.-led coalition of nations fighting ISIS from the air, but after Friday’s attacks that killed 129 people and wounded more than 350 more, France has flown an increased number of sorties — re-inserting itself into the battle.

ISIS has claimed responsibility for the attacks, which France’s President described as “an act of war.”

There are multiple schools of thought on what will or should happen next. Some think that the French will bomb a few targets in Syria and leave it at that. Some, like the editors of the New York Times, call for unspecified action. It’s unclear to me why they would be so vague. Perhaps they’re outraged but simply don’t know what to do. Perhaps they’re waiting to see what the president (or Hillary Clinton) supports so they can come down on the side of that whatever it is.

By and large the Republican presidential candidates favor a more muscular response—Mitt Romney’s WP op-ed is pretty typical:

Only the United States can lead this war, and that leadership means being willing to devote whatever resources are required to win — even boots on the ground. We have the best-equipped and most dedicated military for good reason. The president must stop trying to placate his political base by saying what he won’t do and tell Americans what he will do.

We must do what it takes.

My position, as it has been for some time, is that we need to change sides. The only “boots on the ground” in Syria capable of destroying DAESH are those of the Syrian Army and the Iranians. Rather than jumping through our rear ends trying to distinguish between “good” radical Islamists and “bad” ones we should decide that all radical Islamists are bad.

If we can’t bring ourselves to join with the Russians, Syrian government, and the Iranians, we should butt out. If that’s unpalatable, we should keep doing what we’ve been doing—go after targets of opportunity, mostly the stray pickup truck, pursuing our strategic objectives without a strategic plan that can accomplish them.

Clear thinking, to paraphrase President Hollande, is called for. Refugees are not tourists who select their destinations and itinerary. When Syrians reach Turkey, fleeing for their lives, they are refugees. When they set out from Turkey for the fleshpots of Berlin or Stockholm, they are economic migrants, welfare tourists, or, as we have seen in the attacks on Paris, terrorists. We shouldn’t ignore the degree to which Turkey and Saudi Arabia are the problem rather than the solution.

12 comments

Face DAESH With Sang-Froid

I wanted to draw you attention to this editorial from Le Monde, hepfully translated by World Crunch. The original editorial is here and I found the translation pretty fair. I’d’ve translated a few words differently but it’s reasonably faithful.

I think the editorial hits the right notes. It minces no words:

France is at war. At war against a terrorism that is totalitarian, blind and horribly murderous. We’ve known it since the attacks against Charlie Hebdo and the kosher supermarket in Paris in January.

And yet, despite the French population’s exceptional show of unity four days after those attacks, despite the shows of solidarity from the leaders of all the world’s democracies, President François Hollande, Prime Minister Manuel Valls and France’s top security officials had warned repeatedly: the threat still exists. It wasn’t a matter of whether there’d be more attacks in France, but when.

So it happened this Friday, November 13. More bloodshed in and around Paris. And this tragedy demonstrates that these terrorists who have decided to target France have set no limits to their deadly endeavour.

which is better than our leaders and most of our media. The terrorist attack didn’t exactly come as a surprise:

President François Hollande, Prime Minister Manuel Valls and France’s top security officials had warned repeatedly: the threat still exists. It wasn’t a matter of whether there’d be more attacks in France, but when.

Echoing Hollande, it calls for sang-froid, i.e. composure, is dealing with the threat:

This folly calls for only one response. To show dignity in the face of panic. To show resolution against the sowers of death. To show lucidity in the face of chaos. And as the President of the Republic rightly said during the night, to show sang-froid the “cold blood” of steely calm and determination in the face of terror. And above all, to again show the nation’s unity in the face of our ordeal.

Stratfor observes:

In the wake of these attacks, Marine Le Pen and her far-right National Front party could see their popularity rise. Le Pen kept a low profile after the Charlie Hebdo shooting in January and still saw an increase in her party’s popularity because of its longstanding anti-immigration message. Hollande also saw a brief uptick in popularity after the Charlie Hebdo attack because of his reaction to the events, but a repeat of this trend is not expected because people will now question whether the anti-terrorism measures that were approved this year actually worked. The leader of the center-right Republicans Party, Nicolas Sarkozy, also has a history of taking a strong stance on security issues; he was campaigning on the subject only last week. He is expected to battle the milder Alain Juppe for his party’s nomination in the 2017 elections, and voters may swing to his side in the wake of the attacks.

The ball is clearly in M. Hollande’s court and his next steps are crucial. Will he invoke Article 5 of the NATO agreement? If so, we will either go to war or NATO is finished.

The calls for unity are essential. France is believed to have about three times as many Muslims per capita as the United States, most French citizens. No one really knows because keeping records on religion or ethnicity is illegal.

1 comment

The Economist‘s Take

The editors of the Economist put in their two cents on the “horror in Paris” going from the sublime:

A broader question will be what, if anything, Europe can do to reduce the risk of such attacks becoming a recurring horror. A more concerted attempt to end the war in Syria and destroy the IS caliphate might help reduce the flow of refugees but it is not likely to eradicate the threat. Indeed, IS might become much more focused on taking the fight to the “far enemy”.

to the ridiculous:

One major concern must be the easy availability of automatic weapons in Europe (although not, mercifully, in Britain with its strict gun laws) and the way in which they can be moved from one country to another. If large-scale terrorist attacks start to take place more or less anywhere that people gather in large numbers, from sports stadia to rail stations to entertainment venues and political events, will it mean introducing Israeli-style security screening and checks across Europe’s cities? That would seem politically inconceivable and economically disastrous, the clearest manifestation that the terrorists had won.

The editorial is mostly notable for the infographic on Islamist terrorist attacks in Europe which I’ve helpfully sampled above.

35 comments

The Responsible Opposing View

Eric Fehrnstrom supplies the counter-point to the point made in my previous post. Writing in the Boston Globe:

Likewise, there are two statistical measurements that, more than anything else, will determine whether the White House changes parties in 2016: Obama’s job approval and the direction of the country, measured by whether voters think we’re on the right track or the wrong track.

In terms of job approval, Obama has been under 50 percent for most of his presidency. The most recent Real Clear Politics monthly polling average says just 45 percent of Americans approve of the job Obama has been doing, while 52 percent disapprove. If the president remains net negative, voters should expect to hear a lot from Republicans on how the Democratic nominee is really running for Obama’s third term.

The Real Clear Politics average also says 64 percent of all voters think the country is on the wrong track. Only 27 percent believe we are headed in the right direction. As with job approval, if this number stays inverted, it’s going to be difficult for a Democrat to win no matter what.

The only question is which Republican will reap the benefits.

Those are some of the “fundamentals” I mentioned in that earlier post. Another is just plain fatigue. Electing candidates of the same party to the White House three times in a row is the exception rather than the rule and I just don’t think that the economy is strong enough to buoy Democrats to a wave.

Intervening events matter. If we’re in recession in the third quarter of 2016 and there are terrorist attacks being carried out in Europe once a week (or, heavens forfend, here) the rhetoric that some of the Republican candidates are dishing out won’t seem quite so nutty.

3 comments

My Gripe

My gripe about the “microaggressions” and “safe space” stuff is that it’s completely post hoc. There is no behavior or statement that is so banal and harmless that it can faithfully be determined in advance that absolutely nobody will be offended by it. What’s missing from the formulation is the intention of the speaker or actor.

Consequently, both constructions serve primarily as cudgels used to beat up people you don’t like.

10 comments

A Democratic Wave in 2016?

Writing in the Washington Post Democratic pollster Stanley Greenberg predicts sweeping victories for Democrats in the 2016 elections:

The United States is being transformed by revolutions remaking the country at an accelerating and surprising pace. Witness the revolutions in technology, the Internet, big data and energy, though just as important are the tremendous changes taking place in immigration, racial and ethnic diversity, the family, religious observance and gender roles. These are reaching their apexes in the booming metropolitan centers and among millennials.

As the revolutions interact, they are accelerating the emergence of a new America. Consider that nearly 40 percent of New York City’s residents are foreign-born, with Chinese the second-largest group behind Dominicans. The foreign-born make up nearly 40 percent of Los Angeles’s residents and 58 percent of Miami’s. A majority of U.S. households are headed by unmarried people, and, in cities, 40 percent of households include only a single person. Church attendance is in decline, and non-religious seculars now outnumber mainline Protestants. Three-quarters of working-age women are in the labor force, and two-thirds of women are the breadwinners or co-breadwinners of their households. The proportion of racial minorities is approaching 40 percent, but blowing up all projections are the 15 percent of new marriages that are interracial. People are moving from the suburbs to the cities. And in the past five years, two-thirds of millennial college graduates have settled in the 50 largest cities, transforming them.

Shifting attitudes were underscored in this year’s Gallup Poll when 60 to 70 percent of the country said gay and lesbian relations, having a baby outside of marriage, sex between an unmarried man and woman, and divorce are all “morally acceptable.”

The United States is emerging out of its revolutions as racially blended, immigrant, multinational and multilingual — and diversity is becoming more central to our multicultural identity.

Further, these revolutionary transformations have accelerated the growth of a new majority coalition of racial minorities, single women, millennials and seculars. Together, these groups formed 51 percent of the electorate in 2012, but our analysis of census survey data and exit poll projections indicates that they will comprise fully 63 percent in 2016. With these growing groups each supporting Hillary Clinton by more than 2 to 1 in today’s polls, it is fair to say that the United States has reached an electoral tipping point.

The Republican Party’s battle to defeat this new majority has reached a tipping point, too. The brand of the Republican Party today has probably not been as tarnished since the Watergate era.

He may be right but, frankly, I doubt it. Many of the trends he points to are real but I think they’ll mean more for the 2020 elections than they do for the 2016. The results don’t depend on opinion polls take of all Americans, eligible voters, registered voters, or even likely voters but upon the people who actually show up at the polls and vote. This seems to be my day for multiple choice. Will the 2016 elections be

  1. a wave election for Democrats in which Democrats take the White House, the Senate, and the House.
  2. an election in which the Democrats take the White House and, narrowly, the Senate.
  3. an election in which the Democrats take the White House, leaving the Senate and the House with Republican majorities.
  4. an election in which Republicans take the White House, lose the Senate, and retain the House.
  5. an election in which the Republicans take the White House and strengthen their majorities in both houses of Congress.
  6. remarkable only in their banality.

I’m tempted to weasel out by saying that it’s too early to tell the outcome of the 2016 elections at this point—come back and ask me when there’s an actual Republican candidate.

If forced to choose, I’d say that even with the billions in in-kind contributions she’s likely to receive, Hillary Clinton, the Democratic candidate presumptive, will be unable to achieve the turnout that Barack Obama did in 2008 or even that President Obama did in 2012. I think that B-D are more likely than A or E. The fundamentals of presidential elections disfavor the Democratic candidate; the fundamentals of Senate elections favor the Democrats. That leaves B or D. I’ll reluctantly go with B but only because right now it looks as though whoever the Republican candidate will be, he will be ghastly.

Keep in mind that 80% of life is showing up.

17 comments

Attaques à Paris

Le Monde is reporting that

  • Six simultaneous attacks took place in Paris yesterday.
  • 128 people are dead and many more are wounded, some seriously. The attackers are all dead.
  • A state of emergency has been declared and the borders have been closed.
  • A national day of mourning has been declared.
  • DAESH is being blamed for the attacks.
  • A Syrian passport was found on the body of one of the attackers.

French President François Hollande has addressed the nation, vowing that France will be pitiless against “the barbarians”.

I want to take a poll. What will the French do in response to the attacks in Paris?

  1. Domestic crackdown against Middle Eastern refugees and other immigrants from the Middle East.
  2. Domestic crackdown against Muslims more generally, including some who are French citizens.
  3. Take an active role in fighting Islamist terrorists in Syria, on the side of the Syrian government.
  4. Take an active role in fighting Islamist terrorists in Syria and Iraq, siding with the Americans.
  5. Seek a Security Council resolution condemning DAESH for the attacks and, possibly, authorizing the use of force against DAESH.
  6. Nothing.
5 comments