Who’s to Blame for DAESH? (updated)

In an op-ed at the New York Times Middle East analyst Kyle Orton presents what is to me a counter-intuitive argument: that Saddam Hussein is the primary culprit to blame for the rise of DAESH. Here’s the meat of his argument:

The campaign of Islamization intensified further after Iraq’s devastating defeat in Kuwait in 1991 and the subsequent Shiite revolt, culminating in 1993 with Mr. Hussein’s abandonment of the last vestiges of Baath secularism when he initiated the Faith Campaign. In some respects, Mr. Hussein’s government was following rather than leading public opinion, as Iraqis fell back on their faith for solace under the harsh international sanctions. But what began as a cynical attempt to shore up support, as the regime retreated to its Sunni tribal base, took on a life of its own, transforming Iraq into an Islamist state and imposing lasting changes on Iraqi society.

The government imposed a version of Shariah law: Thieves had their hands cut off, homosexuals were thrown from rooftops and prostitutes were beheaded in public squares. Numerous mosques were built, Quran study became a national focus and midlevel clerics acquired new roles as community leaders.

The Faith Campaign claimed to be ecumenical, but its clear pro-Sunni tilt led to a final collapse of relations between the state and the Shiite population and heightened sectarian tensions. In the Sunni areas, however, the campaign was effective, creating a religious movement I call Baathi-Salafism, under Mr. Hussein’s leadership. It also eased strains between the regime and independent religious movements like the “pure” Salafists, whose long opposition to the regime gave way to some of its members serving in its administration, even though Mr. Hussein was warned by his intelligence chief that if the alliance continued, the Salafists would eventually supplant the regime.

Alongside the Faith Campaign, Mr. Hussein’s regime constructed a system of cross-border smuggling networks designed to evade the sanctions. This funded a system of patronage, much of it distributed through mosques, that maintained a series of militias directly loyal to the ruler, like the Fedayeen Saddam and the Sunni tribes, as a hedge against any repeat of the 1991 Shiite revolt. These networks, which are deeply entrenched in the local populations, especially the tribes of western Iraq, are now run by the Islamic State, adding to the difficulty of uprooting the “caliphate.”

One of the less advertised aspects of the Faith Campaign was the infiltration of mosques by military intelligence officers. There was a trapdoor in this policy: With Baathism a spent force by the late 1990s, many of them slid into Salafism. The security sector had been profoundly influenced by Salafism by the time Mr. Hussein’s government fell.

It’s true that disbanding the Iraqi Army after 2003 put professional soldiers at the service of the Sunni insurgency. It’s also true that Al Qaeda in Iraq — the small, foreign-led nucleus of what became the Islamic State — used poorly run American prisons like Camp Bucca to recruit former regime elements. But the significant fact is that those who assumed leadership roles in the Islamic State’s military council had been radicalized earlier, under Mr. Hussein’s regime.

I find that somewhat self-refuting, cf. the second sentence of the quoted passage: “In some respects, Mr. Hussein’s government was following rather than leading public opinion, as Iraqis fell back on their faith for solace under the harsh international sanctions.” If you agree with his stated causality, the cause was the international sanctions.

I wish he dwelt a little more on the factors that drove Ba’athism from its secular roots through Neo-Ba’athism and ultimately (in Iraq) to Islamization. Why wasn’t there a similar transition to Islamization in Syria? Or was there?

I have tended to view Ba’athism as a Middle Eastern variant of fascism that was impelled for populist reasons to move from pan-Arabism to nationalism to Islamization. That would imply that the fault wasn’t Saddam Hussein’s but the social and political conditions prevailing in Iraq.

At any rate I think I would say that the blame for the rise of DAESH can’t just be laid at the feet of one, solitary culprit but has many fathers. Among them I would include (in no particular order):

  • The U. S. intervention in the Middle East 1990 known as the “Gulf War”, the subsequent sanctions, and the eventual invasion of Iraq and overthrow of Saddam Hussein by the U. S. in 2003.
  • Saddam Hussein
  • The colonial powers (mostly the United Kingdom and France)
  • The post-revolution Iranian regime.
  • The social and political factors prevailing in Iraq (and Syria, the other Ba’athist state)
  • The strategy of the elite in the Gulf states (particularly the Saudis) to promote their own power by spreading their own version of Islam and exporting disaffected young men to promote their extremism at the point of a gun.
  • The textual violence and supremacism in Islam (greater than in other Abrahamic religions) coupled with the lack of a magisterium which lends Islam to misinterpretation by the poorly educated or the unscrupulous.

In the final analysis I would dispute any attempt to hold the U. S. blameless in the rise of DAESH. It may not be all our fault but we weren’t innocent bystanders.

9 comments

What’s the Point?

Demonstrators are planning to disrupt shopping on Michigan Avenue today:

CHICAGO — Demonstrators protesting Laquan McDonald’s shooting death are hoping to disrupt shopping on the Mag Mile Thursday, like they did on Black Friday.

The march, which organizers are calling “Black Christmas” will kick off at noon.

Community activists are calling on elected officials to join them.

They are demanding Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s resignation for his handling of the case.

McDonald, 17, was shot by Chicago police office 16 times. That officer, Jason Van Dyke, has been charged with first degree murder.

The release of dash cam video of the shooting sparked protests throughout the city.

That’s a variety of secondary boycott and secondary boycotts are immoral. It’s hard for me to discern what their point is. I doubt that Mag Mile retailers have a lot of influence over what Mayor Emanuel does or does not do. If they do and he’s been doing their bidding, what they’ve wanted, e.g. higher taxes, teachers’ strikes, are pretty strange and not what I might have expected.

In fact, I suspect Chicago would be better off if retailers had a lot more pull than they do.

4 comments

Syria at the End of 2015

I’ve been looking for a map like this for some time and this one was helpfully provided by Understanding War (hat tip: Pat Lang). It benefits by comparing it with this image from UW’s September assessment:

As you can see the regime has made good progress in moving to retake areas in the northwest of Syria. Here’s UW’s assessment:

The direct intervention of Russia into the Syrian Civil War has shifted battlefield momentum in favor of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad since ISW published its last Control of Terrain in Syria Map in mid-September. Russia began its air campaign in Syria on September 30, enabling the regime to mount renewed offensives against opposition-held terrain throughout Western Syria. In Aleppo Province, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and associated proxy forces launched a multipronged offensive on October 15 that has seized large swaths of rebel-held terrain in the southern countryside of Aleppo City, threatening to sever the strategic M5 Highway. Meanwhile, pro-regime forces relieved the besieged Kuweires Airbase in Eastern Aleppo Province on November 10 in a key symbolic victory that positioned the regime to exploit future U.S.-led coalition operations against ISIS along the Syrian-Turkish border. The regime also achieved tactical gains against the opposition in Northeastern Latakia Province and parts of Northern Hama Province as well as the Eastern Ghouta suburbs of Damascus.

Pat thinks that we will see a “sudden collapse of rebel activity in NW Syria”.

Note, too, the extension of the area controlled by DAESH in northeast Syria, towards areas controlled by the Kurds.

Both of these areas of activity contradict the Obama Administration’s account of what’s happening in Syria and with DAESH. Perhaps they’re privy to information not available to us.

8 comments

Who Loses From Chicago’s Property Tax Hike?

This post was inspired by a post by Mike Shedlock, linked in comments by a regular commenter. In his post Mish gives a beginner’s introduction to Chicago’s distinctive style of corruption, pointing out a few big winners from Rahm Emanuel’s recent recordbreaking property tax hike. As should be surprising to practically no one the list includes some very highly placed Illinois politicians.

Mish has pointed out some of the winners. I thought I’d reflect on who the losers might be. Consider the graphic above, thoughtfully provided by Zillow. The zip code I’ve highlighted, 60647, is the Logan Square neighborhood and parts of adjoining Buck Town. As you can see as of 2014 36% of properties in that zip code had negative equity and property values averaging $271,000. The owners of those properties lose. They can’t sell without taking a bath and their property taxes will rise.

Homeowners in my zip code have nothing to worry about. About 12% of us are underwater and we can afford the tax hike.

Now look at where most of the properties with negative equity are. They’re on the West Side and the South Side. Renters in those areas lose, particularly if they live in multi-family residences because a) the tax will hit those properties and b) the tax hike will be passed on to them by their landlords.

0 comments

Well, He’s Not the Worst

He’s not even the worst Illinoisan on the list. Rahm Emanuel has placed #26 on GQ’s list of “Worst People of 2015”.

3 comments

How Can New York and California Do It?

Over at Forbes William Baldwin calculates a “FeedMe index” for each of the 50 states (illustrated above) and deduces from it that New York, California, New Mexico, West Virginia, Mississippi, and Arkansas are circling the drain:

The hazard with overburdened states is that the departure of jobs could someday turn into a rout. Just this is happening in Puerto Rico. Its productive citizens are leaving for the mainland. They are sticking a dwindling population of private-sector workers with the burdens of supporting the government’s clients and paying off the government’s debt.

Sunny, silicon-rich California is a long way from Puerto Rico’s fate, but the costs of keeping the government fed are on an ominous upward trend. A decade ago the top individual income tax bracket decreed by the solons of Sacramento was 9.3%; today, it’s 13.3%. The nice pensions for state and local workers in California are $189 billion short of adequate funding, according to an analysis by Moody’s. That pension debt comes to $13,500 for every private-sector job.

I have a number of issues with Mr. Baldwin’s hypothesis, the gravest is that his formulation assumes that Elon Musk is not a client of the state.

I’ll offer an alternative hypothesis: as long as states can a) attract subsidies from the federal government and b) are destinations, particularly for the wealthy, they can maintain lifestyles that would sink other states. California is a destination in my terms because of its climate and its Silicon Valley remains a mecca for high tech developers. New York is a destination because of the attractions of New York City and because of Wall Street.

As long as those remain the case I think the Golden State and the Empire State have little to fear.

It also explains why Illinois, despite its much lower “FeedMe index” will continue to struggle. Illinois is not a destination for reasons other than work and forcing employers to flee is not a winning strategy for the Prairie State.

19 comments

How to Get Rid of Rahm

There’s presently a plan for a large protest on Christmas Eve with the intention of disrupting Christmas shopping:

CHICAGO (WLS) — A protest and march is planned for Christmas Eve, aiming to disrupt shopping on Michigan Avenue while calling for changes at City Hall.

Protesters are urging people to shop elsewhere as they try to get Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s attention and ultimately force him to resign. Protesters held a “die-in” Tuesday night outside the office of Mayor Rahm Emanuel, then they left City Hall and marched downtown.

Demonstrations have been ongoing and unrelenting and as they continue the group calling for change has become more diverse.

Does Mayor Emanuel really care about the retailers? Are the retailers in a position to press him to resign?

If they really wanted to get rid of Rahm, they’d start demonstrating against Hillary Clinton. He’d be gone in 60 seconds.

6 comments

Here’s What I’m Ignoring Today

As I’ve mentioned before blogging is a reactive activity and a lot of what’s been in the news just doesn’t interest me. Here’s what I’m not caring about today:

  • Hillary Clinton’s latest lies.
  • Donald Trump
  • Bowe Bergdahl’s trial
  • The Miss Universe pageant
  • The juiced-up numbers on U. S. economic growth

Is there something I should be caring about?

4 comments

Why Is It Always China?

I don’t know whether you’ve been following this story. Last Sunday a huge manmade mountain of soil and waste collapsed in the Chinese industrial city of Shenzhen, taking out more than three dozen apartment buildings. At least 81 people are dead or missing.

After the port explosions in Tianjin earlier this year, a lot of people, especially Chinese people must be wondering why these things are happening. Let me speculate with some answers.

  • China is a very big country. Its mere size means that this stuff will seem to happen more frequently there. China’s increased openness (and the omnipresence of cellphones with cameras) means that the news gets out. That’s the change.
  • China has grown very quickly and the growth has come at the expense of caution.
  • China’s construction standards are poor. Anywhere else might’ve had less damage.
  • China isn’t a democratic country. In a more democratic country the people would be less likely to stand for these kinds of disasters.
  • China’s system is incredibly corrupt. That means that even when you improve the building standards there’s no way to enforce it.
  • China doesn’t have a robust system of civil law. You can’t just sue somebody the way you would if something like this happened here.
1 comment

Paying for the Refugees

It’s estimated that Germany has now accepted about one million refugees in 2015 alone. Germany’s total population is about 80 million so that means that the population of the country has increased by 1.5% in a single year.

Something that isn’t mentioned frequently enough is the cost the Germans are assuming. It costs Germany about 10,000 euro to support each refugee. 1,000,000 X 10,000 = 10 billion euro. Germany’s total budget is around 250 billion euro. That means that just maintaining the refugees they’ve accepted will add about 4% to the German budget.

Considering what sticklers the Germans have been in fiscal matters that means either they’ve got to cut something else or tax the German people more. I expect the latter.

Germany’s GDP growth rate for 2015 will have been around .4% for 2015. Expect it to slip into negative territory in 2016.

24 comments