Controlling Healthcare Prices

Writing in the New Yorker, Atul Gawande points out (in reference to the study I mentioned last week):

When your grocery store is the only one in town, it can jack up prices without losing customers. The same goes for hospitals. The study found that hospital prices in monopoly markets are fifteen per cent higher than in those with four or more hospitals.

It’s the Cost Conundrum Squared. The bigger the hospital, the more it can adopt systems that deliver better-organized, higher-quality, less-wasteful care. But the bigger the hospital, the more power it has to raise prices.

We have a few ways out of the conundrum. We can regulate the prices hospitals charge insurers—this is what Maryland does. We can break up big hospitals. We can encourage hospitals to become the insurers. (That’s what Kaiser Permanente in California has done. It provides members with prepaid care at its hospitals and clinics.) Or we can expand Medicare to more and more people until we’re single payer.

We’re going to have to do something. The healthcare sector is already more than a sixth of the total economy. With something between half and two-thirds of that coming in the form of tax dollars one way or another, that’s a drag on the economy. I also don’t see elected officials regardless of their political party eager to pony up the additional jack the additional healthcare spending requires. That spending continues to grow at a multiple of other costs in the economy and faster than revenues.

4 comments

The Once and Future Syria

The editors of the Wall Street Journal aren’t happy with the Obama Administration’s apparent decision to accept the Russians’ strategy, prioritizing the defeat of DAESH over the removal of Assad in Syria:

Mr. Lavrov can still take satisfaction in the concessions he extracted from the U.S. Mr. Kerry has effectively given up the Administration’s longstanding insistence that Mr. Assad leave office, saying after a Kremlin meeting with Vladimir Putin last week that “the United States and our partners are not seeking so-called regime change as it is known in Syria.”

The current U.S. position is that Mr. Assad is not a fit leader for Syria, but that’s now a political opinion more than a demand. In theory the Syrian people—including its refugees—will get to decide the matter in an election, as if the Alawite Mr. Assad would honor the result if the Sunni majority won.

if that is, indeed, the position of the Obama Administration. Quite a bit of ambiguity remains.

The Joint Chiefs have reportedly affirmed what many Syria experts have warned and what the Russians have been saying all along: the choice is between Assad and DAESH or Al Qaeda. If there is to be a multi-confessional state in the territory that has been Syria, it will be controlled by the present Alawite regime.

The administration has been saying all along that to defeat DAESH somebody has to put boots on the ground. Right now that somebody is the Assad regime and the Iranians allied with it. Even though half of Americans support sending troops to fight DAESH the Obama Administration continues to oppose the idea.

Who else is there? The Saudis? It is to laugh. Not only won’t they field troops, they can’t persuade the Egyptians or the Pakistanis to do it for them. there is no one else.

4 comments

Staying Under the Radar

When I first heard the news reports that Martin Shreli had been arrested for various offenses, my reaction like, presumably many of my fellow Americans was that it couldn’t happen to a nicer guy. If you’re not up to speed on this story, here’s how the editors of the Wall Street Journal summarize things:

Mr. Shkreli is a former hedge-fund manager who until Friday was the CEO of Turing Pharmaceuticals. He had made himself a political target earlier this year by raising the price of a generic drug through the roof after buying its rights. The Obama Justice Department isn’t above targeting unsympathetic figures on Wall Street. But the criminal charges, as well as civil charges brought by the Securities and Exchange Commission, are detailed and extend to Mr. Shkreli’s behavior as far back as 2009.

The alleged deceptions include misappropriating funds and misleading his hedge-fund investors about how much he had raised, the success of their investments and his past performance. He also allegedly failed to disclose the millions he owed to Merrill Lynch after a short sale gone wrong.

The most serious charge is that Mr. Shkreli looted the pharmaceutical firm he used to lead, Retrophin, and then disguised payments from Retrophin as consulting deals for the hedge-fund investors he had mistreated. In other words, he allegedly stole from one group of investors to make up for losses to another.

I won’t prejudge this case and I don’t want to dwell on Mr. Shkreli’s misfortunes or take joy in them. I do think the case illustrates a point I’ve been wanting to make for some time.

There are reasons that people do or don’t raise prices that aren’t strictly speaking economic in nature. In other words although supply and demand are important they aren’t the only things. One of those other considerations is will raising your prices bring unwanted scrutiny?

The question you should ask is whether Mr. Shkreli would have drawn the attention of the feds if he hadn’t raised the price of that generic by thousands of percent? I don’t think he would.

Although I have no particular sympathy with Mr. Shkreli, I do think that’s something we should be concerned about. It’s a form of tyranny.

We have so many laws nowadays that you really have no way to know whether you’re breaking one or not and, frankly, the higher a flier you are the more likely it is that you’re breaking the law or, at least, skirting it.

My preferred solution to this problem is to decentralize, make things smaller. Have as many laws and regulations as are necessary but no more than are necessary and as you are willing and able to enforce. Everything should be sunsetted.

0 comments

Ledger Book War

I don’t have a lengthy point to make in this post. Just one quick insight.

We might entertain the possibility that the amount of territory controlled by DAESH doesn’t make much difference (as long as it’s not zero and maybe even then) because what matters is their business model. They will keep going and keep on inspiring young Muslims who must be in desperate need of inspiration if that’s what they turn to as long as their finances last.

DAESH’s revenues come from a number of sources: loot, taxes from the territories they’ve conquered, oil revenues, revenues from other contraband (drugs, weapons, human trafficking, and probably others), and donations (mostly from wealthy Gulf Arabs). Cutting them off from the international banking system as the UN Security Council has been debating is just wishful thinking. It won’t have much impact.

They’ll keep going as long as they can finance their operations. Just a thought.

1 comment

The Predicament

My predicament is that I really don’t want either Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton to be elected president. The country’s predicament is that unless something changes one of them will be.

I don’t have much truck with Ted Cruz but a one-liner of his from the the debate that was quoted in the media was relevant: “Nobody on this stage is a socialist and nobody on this stage is being investigated by the FBI”. I think he was wrong about the first part. Except possibly for Rand Paul they’re all socialists. Unless the only tax you find acceptable is a head tax, at the very least you’re a Fabian socialist and a large standing army of the sort that all Republicans apparently demand can’t be supported on the basis of a head tax.

How nobody seems to appreciate what low characters both of them are really sticks in my craw.

18 comments

The Old Grind

I have a regular routine. I rise around 5:30am, eat my breakfast, floss and brush my teeth, shave, shower, and dress. I then walk dogs. In between all of those activities I check what’s going on in the world by checking in on a dozen or so blogs and the opinion pages of the New York Times, the Washington Post, and the Wall Street Journal. I write a couple of posts if something piques my interest.

I depart for work at 7:30am—a trip of about 8 miles which takes me anything from 45 minutes to an hour and a half depending on conditions. As I drive I listen to NPR.

This morning as I listened to NPR I was absolutely deluged with pro-immigration propaganda. That’s apparently the party line of what Pat Lang refers to as “the Borg”—we should be accepting a lot more immigrants.

As I think I should have made clear by now, I’m skeptical of that view for a number of reasons. First, immigrants already are as high a percentage of the total population as they’ve been in a century:

Second, real median personal income is about where it was 20 years ago.

Third, U. S. immigration policy favors those who choose to come here rather than those whom we would choose to come. IMO that’s clearly a perverse policy, at least from the standpoint of those already here.

Fourth, personal empowerment. A very small number of people can do more damage than at any time in human history if they’re so inclined.

Finally, I think that the meaning of immigration is different than it was 30 years ago or 50 years ago or a century ago. I personally any number of recent immigrants who call Mama every day and go to visit her once a year. With such a large immigrant population it’s easier to remain within an immigrant community than at any time in American history. So what? (I hear somebody say) It means that opinion among immigrants is more likely to mirror that of people in the Old Country that at any previous time in American history. Again, so what? According to Pew Research:

While a dislike of the U. S. isn’t a mainstream position in Canada, France, or the Philippines, it’s a completely mainstream view in, say, Pakistan. Under the circumstances do you really think we should be accepting a lot more Pakistani immigrants?

19 comments

Star Wars: a New Fiscal Year

Thirty-nine years ago I stood in line all day with a couple of friends at one of the few theaters in Chicago where Star Wars opened for its very first showing. There were no numbers or “A New Hope” or any of that jazz. Just Star Wars

The book (which was ghastly) and the previews had given us a pretty fair notion of what it was going to be like. I thought it was a good movie despite the execrable acting and, more significantly, I recognized that it was an important movie.

I find all of the hooplah over the chapter in the franchise that opens this Christmas amusing. I have every confidence that J. J. Abrams will work his magic and breathe new life into a franchise that George Lucas has done his level best to kill dead. It might even end up being better than the original. It isn’t that high a hurdle.

And that’s my point. It was good but it just wasn’t that great a movie.

20 comments

Unsurprising

While I found this study a bit disquieting, I didn’t find it at all surprising:

Most states provide less support per student for elementary and secondary schools — in some cases, much less — than before the Great Recession, our survey of state budget documents over the last three months finds. Worse, some states are still cutting eight years after the recession took hold.

Most states have balanced budget requirements. As a rule they depend on three things for income: personal income, retail sales, and real estate values. None of those are booming so increasing spending on anything is increasingly difficult. When states don’t spend on K-12 education, any increases must come from local governments:

In at least 18 states, local government funding per student fell over the same period. In at least 27 states, local funding rose, but those increases rarely made up for cuts in state support. Total local funding nationally ― for the states where comparable data exist ― declined between 2008 and 2014, adding to the damage from state funding cuts.

There’s one thing I wonder about: how are they calculating state spending? They should be combining education spending as such with the amount spent on teachers’ pensions. Pensions are deferred income. Just because the states kicked the can down the road doesn’t mean that it’s not education spending.

As the proportion of state revenues committed to Medicaid and public employee pensions rises, expect a lot more of this.

Hat tip: RealClearPolicy

1 comment

And the Hits Just Keep On Comin’

The editors of The Nation have called for Rahm Emanuel to resign as mayor of Chicago:

In the coming months, a jury will consider the fate of Chicago police officer Jason Van Dyke, who has been charged with first-degree murder for shooting 17-year-old Laquan McDonald 16 times at close range. Police originally claimed that McDonald had lunged at officers with a knife, but the dash-cam footage released last month showed no such dangerous move. Instead, the tape showed Van Dyke pumping bullets into the teenager as he lay on the ground.

As the case advances through the legal system, Chicagoans are left to consider the political future of Mayor Rahm Emanuel, who appears to have done everything in his power to prevent this case from reaching a courtroom. That verdict may already be in: A recent poll showed that a majority of Chicagoans want Emanuel to resign, while less than 30 percent support his remaining in office. We agree with Chicago: Rahm Emanuel must go.

While not good for the mayor, I don’t see The Nation’s reaction as particularly bad for him, either. They’re no friends of the DLC, of which Mayor Emanuel was a member. More than anything else the call is another indication of the fight for control of the Democratic Party between its progressive and centrist wings.

5 comments

Not Clear on the Concept

The editors of the Wall Street Journal remark on the Obama Administration’s decision to maintain a lower profile in the South China Sea that I noted yesterday:

It didn’t take long for the Obama Administration to muddy the message it sent in October by sending a warship to challenge China’s aggressive territorial claims in the South China Sea. At the time U.S. officials promised regular follow-up “freedom of navigation” operations—two every three months, according to leaks to the press, including another this year. Now comes word that the next mission won’t come before January, if then.

Citing three U.S. defense officials, Reuters reports that the Administration is stalling while “weighing the risks of raising tensions with Beijing at a time when the United States is focused on the fight against Islamic State.” There’s always an excuse for indecision.

Ensuring freedom of navigation has been a mission of the U. S. Navy for 200 years. It’s a vital component of the American grand strategy. The Obama Administration’s actions really make me wonder if they’re not clear on the concept.

Turning to more immediate concerns, the People’s Liberation Army Navy will not stand still. They’ve been moving very rapidly to turn the South China Sea into a Chinese lake, very nearly literally by building out geographical features that by nature are only above water at low tide. Our allies with territorial stakes in the South China Sea are probably becoming even more nervous right about now.

3 comments