Failure Has Few Fathers

Writing at The New Yorker Rick Perlstein presents what I think might be thought of as the progressive’s case against Rahm Emanuel:

Start with the 1992 Presidential campaign. Emanuel persuaded Clinton to prioritize raising money. This, to put it lightly, caught up with him. And while Emanuel was never tied to the fund-raising chicanery involving forgotten names like James Riady, Yah-Lin Trie, and John Huang, it was that zeal for cash that provided Clinton’s Presidency its original taint of scandal. Obsessive fund-raising is also the foundation of Emanuel’s political operation in Chicago. When two reporters for the Chicago Reader filed a Freedom of Information Act request for the Mayor’s private schedule in 2011 (unlike previous mayors, his public schedule was pretty much blank), they discovered that he almost never met with community leaders. He did, though, spend enormous blocs of time with the rich businessmen, including Republicans, who had showered him with cash.

There are moral complaints to be made about this, to be sure. But it has also failed Emanuel on political grounds: when he found himself in trouble, he was left without a broad base of political support, unlike the previous mayor, Richard M. Daley, who in similar straights fell back on his close relationships in all fifty city wards. When one of those rich Republicans donors—Bruce Rauner, with whom Rahm has vacationed—became Illinois’s governor last year, at least the scolds could comfort themselves that their mayor would enjoy privileged access to lobby for the city’s needs. But that hasn’t worked, either: instead, Rauner has given Rahm the cold shoulder.

or, said another way, he’s a primary architect of many of the worst aspects of today’s political system. But it doesn’t stop there:

After Washington, Emanuel made eighteen million dollars in two and a half years as an investment banker. (His buddy Rauner helped get him his job.) He came back home—although diehards will insist that Emanuel isn’t really a Chicagoan, having grown up in suburban Wilmette—and won a congressional seat in 2004. His next step was chairing the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, in charge of recruiting House candidates. In 2006, he got credit when Democrats took back the lower chamber. One Democratic strategist from California who saw him working a room of worshipful admirers shortly afterward marvelled, “Inside the Beltway, Rahm is like … well, not Dylan or Madonna but maybe Britney or Paris.”

or, again said another way, he’s an exemplar of the unavoidably corrupt relationship between finance and politics that is the root of Rubinomics.

But rising from Democratic Party rainmaker from sinecure to sinecure does not mean you have political accomplishments, a base of support, or the skills of a politician. Raising money is important but it’s not enough.

Are we to believe that it’s all a coincidene?

By then Emanuel had became the mayor of Chicago, elected with fifty-five per cent of the vote in the spring of 2011. Since then, there have been so many scandals in Emanuel’s administration which have failed to gain traction that it’s hard to single them out. One signature idea was lengthening Chicago’s school day by thirty per cent—controversial because he proposed to compensate teachers only two per cent more for the extra work. The Chicago public schools’ inspector general was soon investigating allegations that a local pastor linked to Emanuel was arranging buses to pack public hearings with supporters of the idea, paying at least two “protesters” twenty-five to fifty dollars each.

The city also rolled out a new “smart card” system for customers to pay transit fares, a product of the San Diego-based defense contractor Cubic. The system, known as Ventra, worked about as well as Lucille Ball on a factory production line: some people would get on the bus for free, while others would be charged several times. The cards were supposed to double as debit cards for Chicago’s “unbanked” poor. But buried deep within the thousand-page contract with Cubic were nice little Easter eggs, like the seven-dollar fee for customers who didn’t use the card for eighteen months, and another five dollars tacked on for each dormant month after that.

The article goes on to catalogue the frauds in school improvement and crime statistics under Emanuel. Read it and weep. Weep for Chicago.

8 comments

How Long Can You Tread Water?

The El Niño event we’re experiencing right now has a clear parallel. The El Niño of 1998 which bore remarkable similarities to our present one:

The comparisons between the ‘97-’98 El Niño and the 2015-16 El Niños has been steadily stacking up for awhile now. The first lookalike comparison that drew attention was ‘97 and 2015, but researchers were still cautious about reading too much in to the comparison. This latest data of sea surface heights from NASA JPL, however, shows even more similarities setting up between right around the beginnings of ‘98 and 2016.

This is particularly important because in the 1997-98 El Niño, which the 2015-16 El Niño seems to be mirroring closely, early ‘98 was when we saw the worst and most powerful El Niño weather patterns: intense ice and snow storms, flooding, even some unlikely tornado landings.

Here’s what the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has to say about the “El Niño Winter of ’97-’98” (PDF):

The first two months of 1998 were the warmest and wettest in the 104-year record of temperatures and precipitation measurements for the contiguous 48 states. During the period January – February, the national average temperature was 37.5 degrees F compared with a normal of 32.1 degrees F. The previous record was 37.0 degrees F in 1990. For precipitation, 6.01 inches fell, compared with a normal of 4.05 inches. The previous record was 5.7 inches in 1979.

For the winter (December through February) as a whole, however, temperatures and precipitation were not as extreme, due to December being somewhat cooler and drier (as a national average) than January and February. The winter of ‘97-’98 was the second warmest on record and the seventh wettest. The normal national average temperature for the winter months of December, January, and February is 32.3 degrees F. This winter’s figure was 36.4 degrees F. The record was 36.6 degrees F set in 1991-1992. For the three-month period, the normal precipitation value for the country is 6.35 inches. This winter’s figure was 7.96 inches, compared with the record 8.5 inches in 1932-1933.

California and North Dakota had their wettest February on record. Florida, Maryland, Nevada, Rhode Island, and Virginia had their second wettest February since records began in 1895. The warmest February on record took place in much of the upper midwest and parts of the east including Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut. Nationwide energy savings were estimated at 10% (i.e., 10% lower heating costs as compared to normal winter).

4 comments

You Ain’t Seen Nothin’ Yet

You know I think this may end up being the nastiest, angriest, down and dirtiest election since Andrew Jackson ran for president.

5 comments

Dance of the Uncertainty Fairy

During 2009 and 2010 Paul Krugman did a lot of complaining about the “uncertainty fairy”—criticizing the idea that uncertainty played a role in the slow recovery of the economy after the Great Recession. As it turns out he was both right and wrong, depending on what is meant by “uncertainty”, as this column at Bloomberg by Noah Smith points out:

A team of empirical macroeconomists recently set out to investigate the uncertainty issue more deeply. Sydney Ludvigson and Sai Ma of New York University and Serena Ng of Columbia University have a new paper in which they investigate whether uncertainty is exogenous or endogenous — that is, whether it is the cause of economic disruption, or the effect. Their statistical technique requires some bold assumptions, but allows for interpretation of cause and effect.

Ludvigson, Ma and Ng find that financial uncertainty seems to cause every other type of economic uncertainty — in other words, that financial uncertainty looks exogenous while other types of uncertainty seem to be endogenous. This reinforces what many other macroeconomists have found since the crisis — finance often seems to drive the real economy.

So what does this result mean for the policy uncertainty hypothesis? On one hand, it reinforces the notion that uncertainty, in the general sense, is very bad for the economy. But it implies that for policy to be the cause of this uncertainty, it would have to do so through its impact on financial markets. Legal challenges to Obamacare or increased regulation of aircraft manufacturing would be unlikely causes of recessions.

In summary uncertainty is bad for the economy but uncertainty in the financial markets induces other forms of uncertainty rather than the other way around. Or, said another way, the Masters of the Universe screwed up big time.

2 comments

What Our Justice System Does and Does Not Do

As I’ve mentioned before, I don’t usually dig into stories from jurisdictions other than those in which I vote. However, there are some larger issues in the grand jury’s decision not to pursue charges in the case of the shooting of Tamir Rice in Ohio and, particularly, the commentary on that outcome that I wanted to remark on.

First, the background. On November 22, 2014 911 in Cleveland, Ohio received a call reporting that somebody was pointing what looked like a firearm at people in a city park. There were other details but they’re not relevant to this post. Shortly thereafter members of the Cleveland Police arrived at the park in a squad car and within seconds had shot and killed the person whose activities had been reported. As it turns out he was 12 year old Tamir Rice and he had a pellet gun (without the orange tip indicating it was not a live firearm) made up to look like a real firearm.

Now consider the comments in this thread on the story at Outside the Beltway. I think there’s a widespread difference of opinion.

It seems to me that many people believe that when somebody is killed, somebody should be punished for it. That may be true under Divine Justice but our justice system isn’t in the Divine Justice business. It’s barely in the justice business. The job of our justice system is to determine if a law has been broken and if so to prosecute those accused of the offense and, if they are found guilty beyond reasonable doubt, punish them. That’s it.

It’s terribly sad when a kid is killed regardless of the circumstances. Nothing should detract from that. But it’s not necessarily true that someone should be punished for killing him. The grand jury arrived at the determination that no crime had been committed.

None of the rest of us were there or have seen the full body of evidence and/or testimony available to the grand jury. Rendering Divine Justice is beyond the grand jury’s scope. They were supposed to arrive at their findings based on the evidence presented to them and the law as interpreted by the judge honestly and to the best of their abilities. Do we have reason to believe they did not do that?

I think we should be very reluctant to change our system to one that administer’s Divine Justice.

21 comments

The Stranded Christmas Guests

One of our Christmas guests managed to finally catch a flight to LA last night and the other found a flight this morning. As it turns out, as WGN reports, they weren’t the only ones who had problems:

CHICAGO (WLS) — Thousands of airline passengers who were stranded overnight at Chicago’s airports are still scrambling to find flights the day after a winter storm struck.

Airlines are playing catchup after about a thousand flights were canceled Monday. On Tuesday, 245 flights at O’Hare International Airport and 24 flights at Midway International Airport were also canceled. Both airports are also experiencing minor delays.

Since it’s the holiday season and flights were already packed to begin with, many travelers are left wondering when they’ll be able to get onto a plane. The stranded passengers O’Hare and Midway have snatched up nearly every available seat on the flights that are making it out of town.

My guess is that the mess won’t be untangled until Monday.

0 comments

What Would a Depression in China Mean for the World?

If Gordon Chang’s analysis at The National Interest holds true, China is in for some rough sledding:

As an initial matter, China’s current situation is far worse than the official National Bureau of Statistics reports. The NBS maintains that the country’s gross domestic product rose 6.9 percent during the third calendar quarter of this year after increases of 7.0 percent during each of the first two quarters.

Willem Buiter, Citigroup’s chief economist, a few months ago suggested the rate was closer to 4 percent, and growth could be as low as the 2.2 percent that people in Beijing were privately talking about mid-year. The most reliable indicator of Chinese economic activity remains the consumption of electricity, and for the first eleven months of the year electricity consumption increased by only 0.7 percent according to China’s National Energy Administration.

Other statistics confirm extremely slow growth. For instance, imports, a sign of both manufacturing and consumption trends, fell 8.7 percent in November in dollar terms, marking a record thirteen straight months of decline. Exports were down 6.8 percent, the fifth straight month in the red.

Especially disturbing is price data. In Q3, nominal GDP growth of 6.2 percent was less than the officially reported real growth of 6.9 percent. China, therefore, looks like it is now caught in the deflationary trap of falling prices. Deflation, in turn, suggests a 1930s-style crash is increasingly possible. China has too much debt—perhaps as much as 350 percent of GDP at the moment—which becomes impossible to service in an era of rapidly declining prices. The country over the last year has seen a number of “first” defaults. So far, the central and provincial authorities have managed rescues for many of the obligors, but at some point they will have no choice but to let failing borrowers go under in far greater numbers.

You might think that the Chinese authorities might try a different tack to address their country’s economic slowdown but so far that doesn’t seem to be the case. They’re continuing to wield the hammer they’ve been using so far: stimulus. If they pound long enough it might work eventually.

If the Chinese authorities’ ability to change the course of China’s economic ship is limited, ours is nonexistent. Although it might be difficult to credit, I doubt even a major downturn in the Chinese economy would have much direct bearing on the U. S. At $130 billion our exports to China account for less than 1% of U. S. GDP.

Not so for countries from which China imports a lot more, notably Taiwan, South Korea, and Japan but also Germany, Australia, and Brazil. Germany exports $87 billion a year to China, accounting for 2% of the German economy—they’re one of the few countries that maintains a small trade surplus with China. Australia’s exports to China account for a whopping 6% of their economy. Both Germany’s and Australia’s economic growth have been pretty flat this year and China’s slowing economy is a big part of that.

I’ve long been a China skeptic. I opposed China’s admission to the WTO. It’s too big, it’s too authoritarian and mercantilist, it lacks an exchangeable currency or a robust system of civil law. The world is simply incapable of integrating that China into the world system. And that was when China was expecting double digit growth as far as the eye could see. What will things be like when China has slow or no growth?

The Chinese authorities have long maintained that 7% annual GDP growth was necessary to avoid civil unrest. Maybe they were wrong or maybe things have changed.

Interesting times.

0 comments

Can Hillary Maintain a Low Profile and Still Win?

While I agree with those who think that Hillary Clinton is overwhelmingly likely to secure the Democratic nomination for the presidency handily, even the most tenacious of her supporters will ultimately be forced to acknowledge what a lousy candidate she is. Not only does she face the conundrum of her strongest prospective assets, Bill Clinton and Barack Obama, also being among her greatest liabilities as I’ve mentioned before, she’s an awful campaigner.

Writing a Politico Annie Karni lists six “moments that could haunt” Secretary Clinton:

  1. “We now finally are where we need to be” on ISIL
  2. Republicans are my enemies
  3. “What, like with a cloth or something?”
  4. Guns
  5. Charter schools
  6. Not My Abuela

Read the whole thing. And that’s just for 2015. There are dozens, possibly hundreds of others. Add to those that’s she’s made a hash of every major job she’s undertaken in her entire life, she’s under investigation by the FBI, and that everybody’s already made their minds up about her—she has near-100% name recognition—and begin to grasp the extent of her problems. Her greatest advantage is that she’s will be running against a Republican opponent with serious deficiencies of his own.

Given her gifts, maintaining a low profile might be her best campaign strategy. Can she drum up enthusiasm among prospective Hillary voters while doing that?

17 comments

O’Hare’s Perfect Storm

It was a madhouse at Chicago’s O’Hare Airport yesterday with more than a thousand flights cancelled and thousands of passengers stranded by the winter storms affecting the country. And the misery continues today reports NBC Chicago:

Hundreds of frustrated fliers could be seen staring at the arrival and departure screens Tuesday morning hoping to not see red, but many still were as cancellations continued hours after Monday’s winter storm wreaked havoc on travel plans.
More than 1,600 flights were canceled Monday amid an icy storm system, creating a massive backlog of passengers trying to get out of the city.

Stranded travelers spend the night sleeping on cots in Chicago’s O’Hare and Midway Airports, on chairs, the floor or anywhere they could find space after yesterday’s storm grounded thousands of Chicago flights after the holidays.
Airlines worked to de-ice planes quickly enough to get as many planes as they could onto their destinations, but with more than 300 flights canceled at O’Hare and 1,300 flights canceled at O’Hare, by the day’s end more than half of the city’s slated air schedule had been cleared for re-booking.

215 flights have already been cancelled today. And the day ain’t over yet.

The reasons for the mess include:

  • the Christmas holiday and its timing
  • the weather
  • the hub system still used by many airlines
  • where the weather struck. Chicago is a hub for multiple airlines. When Chicago is socked in with bad weather as happened yesterday, the effects ripple across the country. But Texas was affected by the bad weather, too, and there are hubs in Texas as well.

Flights weren’t just cancelled because you couldn’t get in or out of Chicago but also because of a lack of equipment. Planes stranded elsewhere couldn’t continue on to Chicago.

Things probably won’t get back to normal for a week.

8 comments

Multiple Police Killings in Chicago Over Christmas Weekend

Another day, another call for the resignation of Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel. Over Christmas weekends two Chicagoans were shot and killed by Chicago police officers, one a young man reportedly brandishing a baseball bat, the other a woman who is said to have been shot by accident. USA Today reports:

Embattled Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel will cut short his family vacation in Cuba and head home Tuesday after a police shooting Saturday that claimed two lives, one of them a woman who law enforcement admits was killed accidentally by an officer.

The 56-year-old mayor serving his second term has seen his approval rating fall to 18% and demonstrators calling for his resignation after he was forced to release a police dashboard camera that showed 17-year-old Laquan McDonald shot 16 times by a police officer in 2014. Tensions have only increased in the last 48 hours after the latest police shooting that left a 19-year-old engineering student and 55-year-old mother of four dead.

Emanuel’s spokeswoman Kelley Quinn said in a statement Monday that the mayor would cut short a family vacation with his wife and three children to Cuba in order to “continue the ongoing work of restoring accountability and trust in the Chicago Police Department.” She said he had been in constant contact with his staff and the acting police superintendent John Escalante.

Among those calling for Mayor Emanuel’s resignation is Al Sharpton:

Rahm Emanuel is headed back to Chicago following a family trip in Cuba, as a prominent voice called for the mayor to resign.

Rev. Al Sharpton — the National Action Network founder and MSNBC host — called for the Chicago mayor to step down Monday, after a city police officer fatally shot two people, one of them accidentally.

Emanuel was vacationing in Cuba during Saturday’s shooting, the latest circumstance of a Chicago police officer gunning down black residents. The mayor’s spokesperson later confirmed that Emanuel was “cutting his family trip short” to return to Chicago on Tuesday, but declined to identify when his trip was originally scheduled to end.

“We have not seen this kind of physical disparity by a mayor in the middle of this crisis,” Sharpton told the Daily News, discussing national circumstances of police violence. “It’s stunning to me … they’re outraged in the community.”

I don’t know how much that hurts the mayor but it certainly doesn’t help.

Besides the deteriorating political condition of Chicago’s mayor what I think the latest shooting illustrate is what I think will be an accelerating pattern, an increasing tendency to second guess the police not just in Chicago but everywhere. When the police are actually facing weapons (unlike in the case of Laquan McDonald), I don’t think that’s appropriate. We weren’t there. We can’t evaluate the situation.

But that’s what police officers are likely to face going forward and, sadly, they’ve brought it on themselves.

4 comments