What Should We Be Worried About?

What should we be worried about? I’ll skip right to the conclusion. In my opinion we don’t have a lot to be worried about. However, the few things we should be worried about will be very difficult to deal with.

First, we shouldn’t be worried about violent crime.

Hat tip: New Geography

But what about the homicide rate in Chicago (I hear somebody ask)?

Both of the graphs above were derived using statistics from the FBI.

I don’t think we should be worried about either mass shootings or Islamist terrorist attacks in the United States. Fortunately, per Gallup a majority of us aren’t:

WASHINGTON, D.C. — More Americans are “very” or “somewhat” worried that they or a family member will become a victim of an Islamic State-inspired terrorist attack (47%) than they are about becoming a victim of a mass shooting (38%). But a majority of Americans say they are not worried about either potential event.

Why the enormous flurry of news reports? I believe it’s because politicians are very risk averse. If our leaders weren’t responding like infants, IMO even fewer Americans would be concerned about mass shootings or terrorist attacks than are.

IMO we shouldn’t be overly concerned about DAESH’s operations in Syria or Iraq, international terrorism, Iranian nuclear weapons development, North Korean military power, Russian military power, the conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians, the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, or China’s economic power.

I think that Syria, Iraq, Turkey, and the Gulf States should be very concerned about DAESH. Unfortunately, they’re divided with Turkey and Saudi Arabia actually supporting DAESH while Syria, Iraq, and Iran oppose it. Fortunately for us, we are not Syria, Iraq, Turkey, etc. Why are we supporting Turkey and Saudi Arabia? It’s a mystery to me.

Europe, particularly Germany, is the natural destination for immigrants from the Middle East whether refugees or economic migrants so the countries of Europe have substantial reasons to worry about DAESH and international terrorism. We are not the European countries. As long as we resist the temptation to create problems for ourselves by importing DAESH and international terrorism, they pose less of a threat to us than they do to the European countries or, obviously to Syria and Iraq and we should behave accordingly.

Why are our leaders so hysterical on these subjects? See above. They’re risk averse. They would rather spend trillions of dollars that could be used for any number of more worthy objects than take the risk they’ll be voted out of office for not acting.

As Gallup documents I am out of step with most Americans on the subject of these threats. Why do American politicians insist on strategies that have no hope of accomplishing the objectives they even more vehemently insist are vitally necessary? That’s another mystery to me.

What do I think are legitimate concerns? With most Americans, as Gallup notes, I think that the growth of government is a grave threat. I’m astonished, however, that so many Americans distinguish between Big Government, Big Labor, and Big Business. They’re all the same thing.

I think that we should be concerned about an economic downturn. As the historical review at the National Bureau of Economic Research shows, the last peak in the business cycle was in 2007. That we have not already passed the peak in the present cycle nine years later is simply incredible. Basically, we’re due.

Why should we be concerned? Because it’s highly likely that Europe and China are already in recession and will be looking to the U. S. to drag them out. They want to pull themselves up by our bootstraps. And the recovery from the Great Recession has been phlegmatic by practically any standard. We still haven’t created enough jobs to bring those who were thrown out of work during the Great Recession back. We can only speculate on what an economic downturn at this point would look like.

I think that we should be concerned that immigration is making the rich richer and keeping the poor poor. We have imported millions of mostly Mexican workers and, coincidentally, our society is coming to resemble Mexico’s than at any time during our history. Don’t blame Obama for the poor state of race relations. If you want an explanation look up “All you Americans are fired“.

I think that we should be concerned that trade is also making the rich richer and keeping the poor poor. Do we really care if trade increases GDP if the increases in income and wealth that result are all going to a very small cohort of wealthy Americans while other, poorer Americans are losing their jobs? I don’t think so.

Religion is no longer the opiate of the masses. War is.

24 comments

Why Party Politics Is No Solution

Something I’d intended to work into my last post (on the mess in Chicago) but neglected to was a preemptive retort to Republicans, like the guys at PowerLineBlog, whose answer to Chicago’s problems is that’s what they get for voting Democratic. How, precisely, do they think that’s going to happen? No Republicans ran in the 2014 Chicago mayoral election. And lest you think that’s an exception in Illinois 60% of candidates run unopposed, many more in some offices, e.g. the 90% of candidates who run unopposed for the state senate.

As I’ve pointed out before Illinois’s Republican and Democratic Parties have divvied the state up into safe Democratic seats and safe Republican seats. Gerrymandering is one explanation for it. Modern American politicians select their voters rather than the voters selecting their office-holders. But that’s not the only explanation. Mayoral candidates run unopposed, too. Tribune columnist John Kass calls this peaceful coexistence “the Combine”.

I think that the answer is that the operational differences between the two parties, i.e. their differences as manifest in conduct, are few. The rhetorical differences are huge but that’s an artifact, an illusion. You speak differently when you’re preaching to the choir.

At the national level both parties are interventionist in foreign policy, bestow tax benefits and lucrative contracts on their donors, knuckle under to the civil bureaucracy, have no real answers (or even beliefs) about the racial issues that continue to plague America, and support borders that are open in effect but look formidable. The primary purpose for both our political parties is incumbents remaining in office, receiving substantial compensation while in office, collecting large pensions when they leave office, and moving on to lucrative jobs lobbying their former colleagues.

Nearly every day I encounter editorials, op-eds, or blog posts characterizing Democrats as socialists and Republicans as racist fascists. Eliding over the fact that the actual fascists were socialists, if Democrats are all socialists why don’t they support more redistributive policies? If Republicans aren’t socialists, why do they continue to support policies in which the means of production, e.g. money, are controlled by the state?

If you care to look for a source for the anger that’s so much a part of the American political scene today, you need look no farther than the chasm between political rhetoric and political action.

I agree with Chesterton. It is terrible to contemplate how few politicians are hanged in this country.

6 comments

Chicago As Synecdoche

A synecdoche is the rhetorical device by which a part of something is made to represent the whole. Those of you who’ve read this blog for some time and are aware of these things may have noticed that synecdoche is one of my preferred tropes. Keep synecdoche in the back of your mind; I’ll return to it later in the post.

I’d thought of trying to work this into my earlier post today on the unfolding political/police scandal in Chicago but decided to give it its own post. I frequently chafe when someone who doesn’t live here tries to write authoritatively on the goings-on here in Chicago and Walter Russell Mead’s latest post at The American Interest is no exception. After some introductory material Dr. Mead gets to the meat of his post:

First, the Windy City’s economic strength over the last generation was facilitated, in part, by a sharp decline in violent crime. Experts differ as to why crime fell, but aggressive policing probably played a role, just as it did in cities across the United States. Yet that aggressive policing also led to more confrontations between cops and civilians, and contributed to the development of a culture and ethos on the force that made civilian deaths more likely. It’s unclear how far Chicago (or any other American city) can go in dismantling the structure of aggressive law enforcement without seeing a resurgence of the crime levels that once ravaged urban communities across the country and sparked an intense political backlash.

Frankly, I doubt it and I’ll need more quantitative analysis before I’d believe it. Has Chicago’s crime rate gone up or down? I have no idea and neither does anyone else because the city has been cooking the books.

I recall a study that was done some years ago (I think in Kansas City) in which the police department took three different precincts that were similar demographically, in economics, and in crime statistics. They doubled the number of police officers in one, cut them in half in another, and left them the same in the third. It had no effect. Does more aggressive policing or just plain more police officers reduce crime? Nobody knows but there are reasons to doubt it.

I think that crime has demographic, social, and economic causes. Might aggressive policing have an effect? It might but so might lack of economic opportunity, transportation, diversity, the age of the population, family structures, lead paint, and any number of other factors.

Second, the police problem is partly an offshoot of an even wider and more intractable problem: the consequences of public sector unions and life tenure for city employees. There is a harsh conflict of interest between the city’s employees and the city’s voters. The pension crisis, now forcing Chicago (and many other cities and states across the country) to raise pension contributions at the cost of reduced spending on vital city functions, is a big part of the problem. The city’s bloated pension obligations have already forced Emanuel to make severe education cuts. It will continue to force cuts in city services in various cities, making it harder and harder for mayors to govern, and increasing the antagonism among various constituencies.

The late Mayor Daley was a famously skilled labor negotiator. He used a simple strategy. He brought the union representatives into a room, closed the door, and then gave them whatever they wanted. That worked for years.

Rahm Emanuel has a different strategy. He alienated the leaders of the Chicago Teachers Union. Indeed, its president, Karen Lewis, has formed a personal animosity for him. During his first term as mayor the Chicago teachers went out on strike for the first time in more than two decades. Then he gave them whatever they wanted.

Pensions are deferred income. Total compensation is counted by adding present period compensation to benefits which include pensions. From the early Aughts to the start of the Great Recession in Chicago and Illinois more generally public employees’ total compensation rose sharply while Illinois politicians borrowed from public employees’ pension funds to pay for their other spending priorities without raising taxes (and, of course, they didn’t raise taxes because they wanted to keep their jobs).

They were gambling that incomes, retail sales, and property values, the three things on which state and local revenues are primarily based, would continue to increase. They lost.

Public employees were gambling too but they didn’t realize that. They haven’t lost yet but it’s inevitable that they will because neither Chicago nor Illinois can raise taxes fast enough to give them everything they want.

Third, there is a public sector quality problem as well. It is in the interests of public sector unions to shelter employees from oversight and threats to their job security, regardless of how well they perform. Teachers don’t want to be evaluated on the basis of student achievement and they don’t want subpar teachers to lose their jobs. The police feel the same way. So do sanitation workers, firefighters, and clerks in City Hall. While there are plenty of hard-working, committed people across the municipal workforce, the unions in which that workforce is organized have made it progressively more difficult for the city to manage its employees. That naturally leads to a decline in the quality of services rendered and to a corruption of the culture inside the workforce—again, despite the efforts of the many teachers, cops, and other public servants who continue to do their jobs with integrity.

When Chicago police commanders collude in the torturing of suspects, it’s gone way beyond “subpar performance”. The incentives are completely bolluxed up. When the commanders are charged and/or convicted of nothing and the civil penalties are paid primarily by the city, other than ordinary decency what is to stop the police from criminal behavior. The basic problem is the deficit in ordinary decency.

Chicago’s teachers have never presented a plan for improving Chicago’s schools. Wouldn’t you think that professionals have an obligation to do that? Why bother when it’s so much easier just to persuade city officials to fudge the statistics for you?

Fourth, cities today face entrenched cost problems that make economic growth both uneven and fragile. This is partly due to the rising cost of big city governance. It’s harder, for example, to repair the complex infrastructure on which a modern city depends than it is to keep the sewer and road systems running in a small town or a suburb. Those expensive services require high taxes and other costs, driving many kinds of employers away. Partly as a result, cities are losing their middle class populations. In many cities, inequality is rising, the middle class is shrinking, the power of public sector unions over the politics system is growing, and the population is becoming more divided by class antagonisms and ethnic identity politics without a strong middle class to anchor them.

Are there no economies of scale in cities? I think it’s obvious that there are—otherwise there would be no cities. I also think that a) economies of scale probably end at some point, presumably small than 8.5 million (or even 2.7 million) people and b) we’ve been thwarting those economies with subsidies to suburban and exurban development for the last sixty years. Indeed, quite a substantial chunk of our total economy is devoted to exploiting those subsidies.

Dr. Mead concentrates on the equivalent of “white flight”. The opposite is just as likely with gentrification of city centers and poverty being concentrated in a ring of suburbs. That’s what’s happened in Europe.

Fifth, native-born citizens, whatever their race, are moving out of many cities, as immigrants move in. This exacerbates income inequality, as in most cases first-generation immigrants (often without good English language skills or higher educational credentials) earn less than the native-born. It also exacerbates tensions between the unionized city work force that reflects the ethnic make-up of the previous generation and the more diverse incoming population. Immigration creates tension between the dominant ethnic groups in city politics (African-Americans in many cities) and newcomers, whether immigrants or highly-skilled affluent people drawn to the remaining dynamic, high-wage sectors of the local economy and to the richer cultural life that cities provide.

Forty years ago 4.5% of Americans were Hispanics. Now it’s about 17%. Obviously, the percentage who are native speakers of Spanish is much smaller than that. Urban schools are struggling to deal with the increase. And that’s just one language and one that’s fairly closely related to English at that.

Most of our immigration over that period has been from Mexico and much of the rest from Latin America. The demographics of Latin America strongly suggests that immigration won’t continue. Instead much of our immigration in the years ahead will be from Asia and Africa.

Many of those new immigrants won’t speak either English or Spanish. The languages they do speak will be much more different from either of the U. S.’s two major languages than English and Spanish are from each other.

35 years ago my wife’s first classroom in Los Angeles had eleven kids in it. Those kids had six different first languages. That’s the future of urban education in the United States. If you think we have problems now, just wait.

Sixth, cities have long been ruled by political machines, defying the efforts of progressives earlier in the 20th century to tame them. These machines can make good governance difficult, as the cases of Detroit and New Orleans, show. But even in a city like Chicago, where the machine has attempted to govern the city with attention to the promotion of economic development (as opposed to the suicidal emphasis on short-term looting that long characterized cities like Detroit), the ethnic and economic polarization of the city is making it harder for the machine to function “intelligently.” The imperatives of good governance and urban development push in one direction, but the forces that push toward short-termism, ethnic demagoguery, and fiscal irresponsibility are getting stronger.

There’s something that I think that many Americans, particularly libertarians, fail to understand. Corruption isn’t an aberration in our system. It’s the lubricant that makes our system work. It fills up the gaps, the inadequacies that are inevitable in any human creation operated by humans. Without it the gigantic system that is our society would seize up, fail to function at all.

Our problem is now one of scale. There is a limit to just how corrupt our society can be without it failing to function. A few hundred people filling phony jobs is one thing. When it gets to thousands (in Chicago) or millions (nationwide) its something else again.

Let’s return to synecdoche. The title of Dr. Mead’s post is “Why the Rahm Story Matters” but he doesn’t really explain why. The answer is that the story of Chicago and Rahm Emanuel is a synecdoche illustrating many of the problems with American society. It also is an exemplar of many of the things I write about in this blog. Why technocracy is an illusion. The challenges that immigration poses for us. Economics. Politics. What makes for an effective government.

Chicago’s problems are those we’re facing as a country. Synecdoche.

19 comments

When the News Isn’t News

You’d think that this story reported by the Associated Press, via The Hill would be big news:

Newly released emails show that Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s office, police and the group responsible for investigating police shootings in the city coordinated their response after the death of Laquan McDonald in October 2014, the Associated Press reported Friday.

The AP, which filed open-records requests, said that thousands of emails were released regarding the case of McDonald, the black 17-year-old shot by a white police officer, including messages indicating Emanuel’s advisers recognized within months the case’s political ramifications.

but it’s barely creating a ripple for a couple of pretty good reasons. First, the timing of the story’s release is impeccable. It was released on New Years Day as Chicagoans like millions of other Americans recover from hangovers and munch on chips and pizza, watching various bowl games.

It’s also just confirmation of things that those of us who’ve been following the story all along have known for quite a while. Mayoral aides acknowledged this stuff weeks ago. And no one who’s even barely aware of how things work in Chicago could have done anything but believe that there was coordination among the mayor’s office, the Chicago Police Department, and the so-called Independent Police Review Authority. You can believe in a mayor who’s blithely unaware and unconcerned about events that might cost him the election, sure signs of incompetence, or in one who manipulated events to help him be re-elected. Take your pick.

2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Why $250,000?

I’m surprised that Megan McArdle, writing at Bloomberg, doesn’t include the obvious explanation in her (short) list of explanations for why Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton have put a stake at $250,000 as the designation of the upper end of the middle class:

I can propose a couple of answers to this. The first is that Democrats never got over their reputation as the party of tax hikers, and what it did to them in the 1980s. They regrouped, rebranded as “the party of hiking taxes on really rich people who stole it all from the rest of you anyway” and came back to Clintonesque victories. There’s no appetite for trying again to be “the party of taxing everyone, a lot.”

The second is that those affluent-but-pinched progressive folks in coastal cities may not be a large fraction of the electorate, but they are a huge fraction of two very important groups: the professional political class, and the media. That provides two choke points for any plan to enact the broad and high taxes on the moderately affluent needed to pay for the expanded welfare state that Democrats want.

Try this explanation on for size: they don’t want to start calling a big city cop married to a big city teacher rich. That’s the real third rail of Democratic politics these days. The possibility that quite a few public employees are not exactly middle income any more.

I’ll provide a more benign mathematical explanation: 95% is two standard deviations above normal distribution. Not that either Bernie or Hillary knows that or that income occurs in a standard distribution.

18 comments

“Dead Drunk” Given New Meaning

I’ve been out drinking with Russians now and again and this story, reported by RT, doesn’t surprise me one bit:

A man in Russia’s Far East woke up in the morgue after having been declared dead, local media report. Before the incident, he had been doing vodka rounds with friends – and after the “miraculous awakening,” he went back to the party.

The man who was mistakenly taken for dead passed out after drinking too much, local Khasanskiye Vesti newspaper reported Wednesday. However, it is not clear when exactly the incident took place. Khasanky Region is a coastal area in Russia’s Far East, which is home to some 35,000 people scattered over the territory of 4,100 square kilometers.

His friends called an ambulance and medical staff hastily declared the man dead before taking him to the morgue, according to the daily. However, the man eventually came back to his senses (somewhat) – only to find himself in a mortuary freezer.

“That night the local morgue was filled to its capacity, the bodies were not only on the shelves, but also on the floor of the freezer room, where our ‘dead’ hero was allocated,” Aleksey Stoyev, a police spokesman, told the newspaper.

“At some point, the man woke up, failing to understand where he was. It was very dark and cold. In addition his brain was foggy due to the influence of alcohol. In the darkness, he felt someone’s completely cold limbs and in fear rushed to the door. But it was locked.”

He started screaming for help and pounding on the door. His calls drew the attention of the morgue’s guard, who reported the situation to the doctors. The latter thought that the guard was imagining things, according to the local report. Nonetheless, out of cautiousness the doctors called police.

Opening the door police were met by the ‘resurrected’ man who in panic ran out of the room, according to the department of criminal investigations. Police questioned the man and released him.

Returning to the place of the party, he found his friends were still drinking, but this time commemorating him. The person who opened the door was so shocked that he fainted, Khasanskiye Vesti says. The commemoration ceremony was quickly revamped into a re-birthday party.

Be very careful out there this evening. Seeing the sights is one thing. Becoming one of them is something else again.

3 comments

What Is It About “Reasonable Accommodation” That They Don’t Understand?

I find stories like this one reported in the Denver Post endlessly frustrating:

About 190 workers, most of them immigrants from Somalia, have been fired from a meat packing and distribution plant on Colorado’s Eastern Plains for walking off the job to protest a workplace prayer dispute.

Ten days ago more than 200 workers walked off their jobs at Cargill Meat Solutions in Fort Morgan.

Some workers later returned, but the majority stayed away as representatives of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) negotiated on their behalf.

It seems to me that this is covered rather neatly by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and there’s a lot of case law that would support an action by the discharged workers. Employers are obligated to make reasonable accommodations for the religious obligations of their employees.

This also illustrates the point I was trying to make (rather clumsily I’m afraid) in this earlier post. Whatever the context and whatever the final outcome, this will be cited forever more as an illustration that Americans are anti-Muslim and there’s nothing we can do about it.

4 comments

Work Ethic

When I drove downtown to work this morning, I was reminded of those 1950s-1960s movies dramatizing the aftermath of a nuclear war—newspapers blowing through empty streets, etc.

Very few people are here. Things really have changed.

2 comments

Why Fight on Their Terms?

Back from hiatus to his cozy column at the Wall Street Journal, James Taranto makes a point that I think is too much ignored:

Then there was this much-discussed remark from inevitable presidential nominee Hillary Clinton during a little-watched Democratic debate 1½ weeks ago:

He is becoming ISIS’ best recruiter. They are going to people showing videos of Donald Trump insulting Islam and Muslims in order to recruit more radical jihadists. So I want to explain why this is not in America’s interest to react with this kind of fear and respond to this sort of bigotry.

It’s not clear what she imagined Trump was saying in these videos, but it is clear she imagined the videos, as the Blaze reported on debate night. But Mrs. Clinton’s fabrication obscures the real, albeit rhetorical, question—to wit, who cares what ISIS wants, thinks or says?

To be fair to Mrs. Clinton, it’s possible she got confused and mistook Trump for another baby boomer politician who has appeared in an ISIS video. As the Daily Beast reported last month: “A new English-language video put out by ISIS calls Bill Clinton a ‘fornicator’ and George W. Bush a ‘liar.’ ”

Our purpose here is not to cast aspersions on President Clinton (or Bush), merely to underscore the silliness of Mrs. Clinton’s attack on Trump. If he were in an ISIS video, would that be to his discredit? Well, does knowing Mr. Clinton was in such a video change your opinion of him? Should it change anyone’s?

If anything, you’d think being cited in an ISIS video would be a point of pride. It is to Rick Santorum: “The only person that’s been listed in ISIS’ magazine as an enemy of ISIS is me,” BuzzFeed quotes Santorum as telling Breitbart radio.

but I don’t think he quite appreciates its logical conclusion. We should ban the phrases “terrorists have won” and “what terrorists want” from our political discourse entirely. Couching our discourse in those terms plays on turf on which they have the advantage. We can’t discern what they want and we actually don’t care what their objectives are. We only care about their tactics and strategy and stopping them.

For an example of what I’m talking about, consider the Christmas Day Texas mosque fire. As it turns out the arsonist appears to have been not just a Muslim but a member of that very mosque’s community. In the original reports it was widely portrayed as a hate crime. What is it now? It’s still a hate crime but the hate is directed against non-Muslims. We can’t control how the false story will be used. That’s the nature of media today. And if we can’t control it we mustn’t be concerned about it.

Regular readers of this blog must realize by now that I am extremely reluctant to wage war under any circumstances. What may not be as obvious is that I also believe that if you must go to war you are obligated to pursue your objectives. That’s the problem with our “War on Terror”. We insist on playing the enemy’s game.

If we insists on war in the Middle East (which I, hopelessly, continue to oppose) we should wage it to achieve our objectives which means that we should wage it on terms favorable to us which in turn means that we should wage a war of materiel, mass production, and mass destruction. Which in turn means ignoring what the terrorist want and also what potential terrorists want or what will turn potential terrorists into terrorists. The people who are the sea in which the terrrorists swim. Go big or go home.

12 comments