Pay No Attention to the Little Man Behind the Curtain Law Department

If the situation in Chicago weren’t so tragic, it would be funny. The Tribune reports that Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel doesn’t want the city’s Law Department added to the Department of Justice’s investigation:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel on Tuesday said U.S. Justice Department investigators do not need to add his Law Department to their probe of police use of excessive force, a day after a federal judge’s finding that a city lawyer intentionally concealed evidence in a trial over a fatal Chicago police shooting.

Emanuel said he trusts city Corporation Counsel Stephen Patton to make sure the Law Department is following the proper procedures, even as U.S. District Judge Edmond Chang faulted lax training and oversight at Patton’s department for hampering the production of Police Department records when officers are accused of misconduct.

When the mayor was asked about adding the Law Department’s handling of lethal force cases to the federal probe, he laughed and did not directly answer the question. Pressed again, Emanuel said that step is not needed to give Chicagoans confidence that necessary changes are being made.

“No. I think that (federal investigators) are working where they are,” Emanuel said a day after Chang imposed sanctions against the city and overturned a jury verdict in a lawsuit brought by the family of a man fatally shot by police. “Steve (Patton) has my support to make sure that this doesn’t happen again.”

Monday’s ruling marked the second time in less than a year the judge sanctioned the Law Department for withholding records in a police misconduct lawsuit and ordered a new trial. Emanuel, however, said he does not believe the Law Department is part of a culture of cover-ups on police shootings.

He would say that, wouldn’t he?

The report goes on to explain that Judge Chang found that the city lawyer had intentionally concealed evidence. That’s official misconduct (not to mention malpractice). The head of the city’s Law Department has already resigned.

Money that the city can ill afford to spend is flooding out of the city in civil judgments because of the persistent, repeated criminal conduct on the part of the police and city officials. We don’t condone their actions but we can’t recall them. Give us the tools; we’ll finish the job.

7 comments

The Voice of Experience

At the Sun-Times Chad Merda reports that New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie has offered Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel some good advice:

“I absolutely think that what would be smart for the mayor to do is get out there in front of the Chicago press corps and the national press corps and answer every question just like I did for an hour and 50 minutes until they have no questions left,” Christie said. “And that’s where you start to regain the trust of the people that you represent.”

I’m dusting off my roll of shiny new dimes to bet that Mayor Emanuel won’t take it. So far what he’s done has been to try to deflect criticism and so far it hasn’t worked.

2 comments

We Are the World’s Rogues

I didn’t get a lot out of this Wall Street Journal editorial but I was struck by one passage:

Second term Presidents typically reap what they’ve sown on foreign policy, and Mrs. Clinton can’t repeat the Obama 2012 mantra that “the tide of war is receding.” The chaos in the Middle East and Africa is to some extent beyond their control, as are the world’s rogues. Russia’s Vladimir Putin and Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Khamenei can read the U.S. political calendar and may become more aggressive to lock in more strategic gains while Mr. Obama is in office.

in which the editors apparently didn’t get their own joke. At least as perceived by much of the world we are the “world’s rogues”. Whether we should be is a reasonable topic of discussion but you can’t begin such a discussion unless you recognize that’s the way we’ve been behaving since the collapse of the Soviet Union at least.

2 comments

Outrage at the Outrage

I’m not really outraged, more like bemused over the outrage that Americans aren’t reacting the same way towards people who haven’t killed anybody but do oppose the federal government that we do to people who do kill ordinary civilian Americans.

24 comments

Death of the Old

Without dwelling on it too much, I think it’s worth considering that what’s going on right now in the incipient conflict between Iran and Saudi Arabia and maybe in the whole Middle East is a consequence of generational change among the Saudi leadership. There is an enormous gulf between the older generation of leaders who, quite literally, grew up in tents in the desert and the younger generation who have had a mostly urban life experience.

Note, too, that the present Iranian leadership is still composed of old revolutionaries. There will be substantial change when they’re replaced by a younger generation who don’t remember anything but the rule of the mullahs.

1 comment

How to Stop the Hollowing

I have some points of disagreement with Robert Samuelson’s latest Washington Post column in which he takes exception to the notion that the American middle class is being “hollowed out”:

We’ll be hearing a lot about the middle class in the coming months. That’s one sure bet for 2016, as both parties compete for votes. What’s less sure is whether we’ll get an accurate assessment of the middle class’s condition. By now, the conventional wisdom is familiar: The top 1 percent has skimmed most income gains for itself, producing decades of stagnant living standards for most Americans. Wall Street has slaughtered Main Street.

Now comes a report from the Pew Research Center that paints a more complex picture. It’s not that the Pew study contradicts all the conventional wisdom. It finds (as have others) that economic inequality is increasing. One of the study’s main conclusions is that the middle class is being hollowed out, as more Americans find themselves in either upper- or lower-income households. The extremes grow at the expense of the center.

Consider. In 1971, about 61 percent of adults lived in middle-income households (defined as three-person households with incomes from $41,869 to $125,608 in today’s dollars). By 2014, that share had dropped to 50 percent. Meanwhile, the share of low-income households (households with incomes of $41,868 or less) grew from 25 percent to 29 percent, and the share of upper-income households (incomes above $125,608) increased from 14 percent to 21 percent.

But the study convincingly rebuts the notion that the living standards of most Americans had stagnated for many decades. Pew calculated household incomes, adjusted for inflation, all along the economic spectrum and found that, until the early 2000s, most households reaped slow but steady increases. Growing inequality did not siphon off all gains for those who are not rich . Here’s how Pew describes this period:

For example, I think he might want to take into account disposable income, debt load, housing costs as a proportion of total income, and what proportion of household actually fit the definition of middle-income that he’s using before drawing any conclusions.

But why quibble? I want to focus on where I can agree with him:

We need a prudent agenda — not a vendetta against the rich or the poor but a purging of policies that abet inequality with few offsetting benefits. Tax breaks that favor the rich, starting with the infamous “carried interest” subsidy, should be abolished. Limits on unskilled immigrants, who inflate the ranks of the poor, should be enacted as part of comprehensive immigration legislation. Half of Hispanic immigrants have low incomes, Pew says.

That’s his list of ways to bolster the middle class. I’ll present some of mine.

  • Start helping the poor by giving them money rather than professional services. How much that benefits the poor is debatable and it increases income inequality.
  • Rationalize our system of intellectual property. Giving so much to the owners of intellectual property increases income inequality.
  • Stop subsidizing the financial sector and the real estate sectors. Those subsidies are major contributors to income inequality and mostly benefit the highest income earners. If you must subsidize them, increase the taxes on those sectors in the amount of the subsidies.
  • Our immigration system needs a lot more reform than that. Abolishing the emphasis on family reunification and the diversity lottery, for example, are vestiges of the America of a half century ago, largely counter-productive now. Prevent H-1B and L-1 visas from being used as tools to lever the wages of middle income people down.
  • How about free trade pacts rather than managed trade pacts that injure the middle class to the benefit of the wealthiest? If you insist on those managed trade pacts, why not tax the winners to help the losers?

Those would be something anyway.

1 comment

Taking Things Personally

People are so petty. They just can’t look at the big picture. When you swear at people, alienate them, close their neighborhood schools, raise their taxes and fees, spend money on river walks and other pet projects that nobody you know wants or uses, and boogie off to Cuba as though you didn’t have a care in the world while people are taking to the streets to demonstrate against you, they take it personally as the Washington Post reports:

CHICAGO — Mayor Rahm Emanuel cut short a family vacation this past week and returned to a city in crisis: On the North Side, more than a dozen people stood outside his house, hurling insults. On the West Side, a close aide was punched and kicked while attending a prayer vigil for a police shooting victim. And all week long, there were protesters, haunting one of Emanuel’s biggest political donors, haranguing his police force, beating a papier-mâché likeness of his face at City Hall.

More than a month has passed since a judge forced Emanuel (D) and other city officials to release a graphic video of a white Chicago police officer shooting a black teenager 16 times.But public anger over the fatal shooting of Laquan McDonald in October 2014 has not dissipated. Instead, it has grown bitter and more personal.

“Oh, it’s personal, all right. We’re making it personal,” yelled Ja’Mal Green, 20, a former Emanuel supporter who spent hours in bone-cold weather on the sidewalk outside the mayor’s spacious Ravenswood home, mocking him and urging him to resign.

The ingrates. Don’t they know who you are?

0 comments

KSA Severs Ties With Iran

Following the storming of the Saudi embassy in Tehran by protestors, CNN is reporting that Saudi Arabia has severed diplomatic ties with Iran:

(CNN)First, one man’s execution spurred sectarian protests and violence in the Middle East. Now, it appears to have sparked a serious diplomatic rift.

Saudi Arabia’s foreign minister said Sunday that his country is severing ties with Iran. Iranian diplomats in Saudi Arabia have 48 hours to leave the country, Saudi Foreign Minister Adel al-Jubeir told reporters.

The two countries have long been at odds, but Saudi Arabia’s execution of Shiite cleric Nimr al-Nimr Saturday kicked off a new round of sparring between them that analysts say could mark a dangerous shift in an already volatile region.

“I think you’re going to see a period of very harsh rhetoric, and the cutting of diplomatic ties comes at a very bad time. … This is Saudi Arabia saying, ‘The gloves are off,’ ” said Bobby Ghosh, a CNN global affairs analyst and managing editor of Quartz.

A few quick, hipshot reactions:

  • Can anybody really believe that the storming of the Saudi embassy did not take place with, at the very least, the consent of the Iranian regime? Protestors make a very handy cover just as “students” did 35 years ago.
  • The mullah regime is a rogue regime.
  • The civil war within Islam is escalating. Let’s try not to get caught in the crossfire, shall we?
  • I am trying very hard to resist the temptation to play the transactional game “Let’s you and him fight”.
  • The Saudis will whine but I doubt they’ll do much more than that. Just look at how much trouble they’ve had with Yemen which is practically supine.
  • If they do much more than that, the Saudis will have their ears pinned back unless they can get someone else to do their fighting for them. Please, let it not be us.

Update

My blogfriend Joe Gandelman has contributed one of his characteristically extensive round-ups of news and opinion on the matter.

6 comments

Corruption in Government, Puerto Rican Style

I’m surprised that so few of those commenting on Puerto Rico’s financial meltdown, like this article at CNBC:

Like a homeowner with too big a mortgage, Puerto Rico has finally started falling behind on its payments.

And it doesn’t look like there’s an easy way to refinance its huge pile of debt to make it more affordable.

Gov. Alejandro Garcia Padilla announced Wednesday that the Caribbean island territory will be able to make most — but not all — of the nearly $1 billion in interest payments due Jan. 4. He told reporters he plans to meet with bondholders in early January.

The down-to-the-wire negotiations over just which bondholders will get paid centered on a haphazard juggling act that saw the commonwealth shuffling funds from one account to another to pay its debts. That “clawback” process will likely be the subject of a series of lawsuits from investors who won’t get paid what they’re legally owed.

fail to mention something I would think is important. Puerto Rico just goosed its government employee compensation

Debt-ridden Puerto Rico started paying Christmas bonuses to public employees on Sunday and aims to complete the process within the next three days, the commonwealth government said.

It had been unable to confirm for weeks if it could meet the Dec. 20 deadline required under a 1969 law for the seasonal bonus. The payments total about $120 million, government officials said earlier this month.

Bonuses will be paid to government officials and regular employees of at least six months, and irregular employees who had worked at least 960 hours in a 12-month period.

presumably in expectation of a bail-out from the U. S. government which so far has not been forthcoming.

I included the graphic at the top of this post because of the guest appearance of the state of Illinois. There’s a bit of a gap between Illinois’s credit rating and Puerto Rico’s but that just means we have something to which we can aspire. Also, check out which state is just above us.

1 comment

Where Did All the Creativity Go?

I’m glad to see that my view that excessively robust regimes of intellectual property protection reduce creativity is gaining empirical support. The National Bureau of Economic Research has a new study that suggests that an increasing pool of patents actually inhibited innovation (as illustrated in the graph above).

Here’s one interesting conclusion:

Interestingly, the data yield no evidence that copyright extensions encourage creativity.

One of my earliest posts contained evidence that there were fewer copyrights previous to the 1999 copyright extension than before it. We are working under a flawed 18th century theory of creativity under which innovations spring fully formed from the brows of their creators like Athena from the brow of Zeus. The reality is that every innovation is built on previous innovations and creation de novo is extremely rare.

1 comment