The Decided, the Undecided, and the Persuadeable

I disagree with the take of the editors of the Wall Street Journal on the impact of the interminably unfolding Hillary Clinton email scandal:

The former Secretary of State wants voters to believe that her private email server scandal is old news, but every month brings new evidence that she put state secrets at risk in order to hide her emails from the public. The slow public release of new emails commanded by a judge, combined with an expanding FBI probe, may be making Democratic voters wonder if they should nominate such an ethically challenged nominee.

The latest cache hit Friday when the State Department released 1,262 more of Mrs. Clinton’s emails. That dump contained another 66 emails deemed classified, which means State has now discovered some 1,340 instances of the nation’s top diplomat handling sensitive material on an unsecure server—including spy satellite information and the name of at least one confidential CIA source. Given that we know Mrs. Clinton’s server was the target of attempted hacks, this is grossly negligent behavior.

Mrs. Clinton’s assurance that none of these emails were classified “at the time,” and that she always handled such material properly, also looks to be undercut by one recently released message. In a June 17, 2011 email thread, aide Jake Sullivan tells Mrs. Clinton that he can’t get her certain documents she wants because “They say they’ve had issues sending secure fax.” Mrs. Clinton appears to direct Mr. Sullivan to ignore protocol and send the information by insecure methods. “If they can’t, turn into nonpaper [with] no identifying heading and send nonsecure,” she wrote.

I don’t think it really matters much. There are already prima facie cases against Sec. Clinton for violations of the Records Act, the Hatch Act, the Freedom of Information Act, for conspiracy, and for perjury. Despite that her favorability rating is about where it was nine month ago, even improving a little. Her name recognition approaches 100%.

In a pre-election context voters are divided into the decided, the undecided, and, of the undecided, the persuadeable. The questions that need to be addressed are:

  • For Democratic primary voters how many are still persuadeable? Who will shift support from Clinton to Sanders? Or vice versa?
  • For Democratic general election voters how many are still persuadeable? Who among them would shift support from Clinton to Trump, Cruz, or Rubio?

With respect to the second question, I think the answer is “very few”. Maybe I’m just out of touch.

And with respect to the first question, the most likely to be persuadeable are new voters. Historically, young voters have not tended to turn out for primary elections. There are exceptions but that’s the rule. Will the email scandal persuade young voters to support Sanders over Clinton? And, more importantly, to vote in the primaries? Or are they more likely to discourage them?

In my view what matters in the email scandal is what the Justice Department does. If the Department indicts or if, as some have predicted, a failure by the Justice Department to indict results in a revolt within the Department, that will be a whole ‘nother question.

2 comments

Physician, Heal Thyself

In his Wall Street Journal column James Taranto has belated advice for the president in framing his State of the Union message:

It would have been more interesting—and shown real self-awareness—if the president had acknowledged his political talents are in some respects wanting when compared not with the universally acknowledged great presidents but with the successful presidents of his own lifetime. We’re thinking here of Reagan and Clinton, who like Obama held office during fractious (if not quite as fractious) periods under divided government. In terms of both compromising with the opposition and emerging victorious from confrontations with it, Reagan and Clinton each enjoyed considerably more success than Obama.

There’s a glaring disconnect in Obama’s characterization of partisan “rancor and suspicion” as being among his “few regrets.” What he’s saying is that he does not regret his actions, only their inevitable consequences. In his 2008 campaign he aspired to unify the country, but he also aspired to “transform” it, “fundamentally” no less. Transformation turned out to be the priority.

His signature “achievements”—we’re thinking here of ObamaCare and the Iran deal—were won by bullying doubters in his own party, shutting the other party out entirely, and, crucially, ignoring overwhelming public opposition. He’d have accomplished a lot more had the country been on his side, but had the country been on his side, there would be no need for fundamental transformation. He seldom evinces any doubt that he is right and his detractors—even if they include the large majority of the American people—are wrong.

while in her Washington Post column Ruth Marcus wonders where in the heck campaign finance reform, which featured so prominently in the State of the Union message, has been during the seven years of President Obama’s tenure in office:

Where has this guy been for the past seven years, especially on the issue of campaign finance reform? “It’s great for him to talk about it, but he’s done nothing for the last seven years,” said Democracy 21 President Fred Wert-heimer. “It’s a fundamental failure of his presidency.” Still, he credits the administration for helping to stop some legislative changes that would have made matters even worse.

In 2008, Obama put the nail in the coffin of the public financing system for presidential campaigns, becoming the first presidential candidate since Watergate to run a campaign fueled entirely by private money. Obama vowed then that he was “firmly committed to reforming the system as president.” Uh-huh.

following that with a list of the roadblocks the Obama Administration has placed in the way of campaign finance reform.

The ingrates. The president has been to the mountain; he won’t lead us to the Promised Land. That’s being left to other, lesser figures.

2 comments

Why Do We Have Law Enforcement Officers?

There’s an obvious answer to that question—to enforce the law—but that’s pretty facile. Without much comment let me suggest some possible reasons:

  • To deter crime.
  • To protect people from criminals.
  • To avenge crime. I’m using “avenge” with a very specific meaning of investigating crimes after they’ve been committed and arresting those for whom there is a probably cause that they’ve committed a crime.
  • To preserve order. Again, I’m using “preserve order” with a very specific meaning of reducing the likelihood that ordinary citizens will start enforcing the law themselves.

Any other suggestions? How good a job are our present LEOs doing at the first three? Let me suggest that the worse a job is done at the first three, the more likely the last one becomes.

11 comments

The Death of a Thousand Cuts?

The editors of the Chicago Tribune take another whack at Rahm Emanuel:

A police scandal has swallowed Emanuel’s mayoralty, yet it’s only one of three debacles that have cost him the trust of so many Chicagoans:

Even after a huge hike in property taxes, citizens see that his borrowing binge buries today’s and tomorrow’s Chicago under enormous debts.

Meanwhile his school system is on the verge of financial collapse. What does he tell Chicagoans? He wants $6 million in tobacco taxes to give incoming freshmen a transition program. Transition to what? High schools possibly closed by a teachers strike, a financial reckoning or both?

Once again, a mayor confronted by crisis changes the subject, answering a question nobody asked. Best to maintain the facade that all will be well — even as his Democratic allies in Springfield reject a budget deal that would begin to rescue Chicago and its children.

This yearning to control the message citizens hear is why Rahm Emanuel is losing Chicagoans. Crises that demand the constancy, competence and resolve he projected to voters five years ago instead get bluster, spin and fleeting assurances. The mayor stands behind his police superintendent, then flips and fires him. The mayor opposes a U.S. Department of Justice probe of police practices, then flips and welcomes it. The mayor says his Law Department doesn’t require third-party scrutiny, then flips and says it does.

Theatrics to win each news cycle suggest to Chicagoans that their mayor focuses on the wrong question: What would make us look good? rather than What’s the right response?

Oh, fiddle-dee-dee. Why theatrics instead of substantive responses? Because it’s all he’s got. He doesn’t have “constancy, competence, or resolve”. He doesn’t have a local constituency. All he’s got is the ability to raise political contributions from donors who don’t live in Illinois.

And by the way a little more contrition on the part of the Trib’s editors would be welcome. Why the heck did they endorse his re-election? It was obvious to a lot of us that Emanuel was an empty suit back then. I’ll close with their conclusion, addressing the mayor:

You have squandered believability. Face it. Own it. Chicagoans sense that you are not leveling with them. Latest example: When you quickly follow a big property tax hike with a request for more billions in borrowing authority, they also sense that you have no strategy beyond running from problems. That you’ve doomed them and their children to … more big tax hikes. Five years in, your City Hall still spends far more than its income justifies.

Many Chicagoans who voted for you expected a confrontation with reality — even if fixing city finances ended your political career. A private-sector CEO who answered a financial free fall with ever more massive borrowing would be long gone.

We expect, Mr. Mayor, that you aren’t leaving, that you’ll serve the last three years of this term. We aren’t calling for your head. We wish we could suggest how you can restore the credibility that got you elected. We don’t know that you can. If we had to reduce the task at hand to three imperatives that may go against your grain:

Less talking, more fixing.

Less politics, more governance.

Less fealty to other leaders in your party, more direct dealing with Gov. Bruce Rauner. You have to have his signature.

Just bear in mind, as you try to revive your city and your mayoralty, that the McDonald case alone doesn’t dictate your legacy. If you can rescue a debt-drenched City Hall, if you can save an imploding school system, if you can make peace in Springfield and stop the free fall, you can regain the trust of those who elected and re-elected you.

It sounds like wishful thinking to me but maybe it’ll catch his attention. Assuming he reads the Trib rather than the New York Times, the Washington Post, or the Los Angeles Times.

0 comments

How Exposed Are We to a Global Economic Downturn?

Writing at The Wall Street Journal Ruchir Sharma of Morgan Stanley makes what is to me a rather tepid argument that we’re much more exposed to a global economic downturn than we were in 1997-1998 when the U. S. economy continued to perk along nicely despite the Asian financial crisis:

The first signs of U.S. weakness emerged in manufacturing, which is deeply influenced by the global economy. Though manufacturing represents a shrinking share of the U.S. economy, now 12% of GDP, it is still a leading indicator, in part because of the outsize role it plays in the financial markets. Manufacturing industries account for some 60% of profits among companies on the S&P 500, which are increasingly reliant on foreign sales. In this decade, American companies have earned 27% of their profits overseas, compared with 17% in the 1990s. By the second half of last year, surveys of manufacturing had started signaling a significant slowdown, with one suggesting a possible contraction.

In 1998 manufacturing and export weakness was offset in the U.S. by falling oil prices, declining interest rates and surging consumer demand. But here too much has changed. In the past, Americans spent virtually all of the windfall from falling oil prices, boosting the economy. This time they are saving 40% of the windfall, perhaps still unnerved by the 2008 crisis.

Since 1998 the U.S. has also emerged as the world’s largest oil producer. The shale energy boom has increased oil production from eight million barrels a day to 12 million. Though America is still a net importer of crude oil, it has become a net exporter of petroleum products, and investment in energy has been hit hard by the sudden drop in oil prices. When oil prices rallied a bit to $60 a barrel in mid-2015, markets expected the price to stabilize. Then it dropped again, driven in part by falling demand in China, to just above $30.

The reason it strikes me as it does is his persistence in conflating overall numbers with numbers dependent on trade. For example, that 12% of GDP is now manufacturing does not mean that 12% is dependent on global trade. Presumably, it’s some smaller percentage, possibly a much smaller percentage. If he’s saying that our manufacturing isn’t manufacturing any more but just repackaging things that were actually manufactured somewhere else, he should say that.

It’s the same with all of the other measures he cites. He doesn’t really tell me how exposed we are.

I’m not saying he’s wrong. I just can’t tell whether he’s right or wrong based on his explanation.

0 comments

A Voyage of Discovery

When I read about this at the Wall Street Journal:

The case against the IRS for targeting conservatives isn’t over after all. On Tuesday a federal judge in Ohio certified a class-action lawsuit against the IRS by conservative groups whose applications for tax-exempt status were slow-rolled between 2010 and 2013.

The lawsuit by the NorCal Tea Party Patriots was filed in May 2013, shortly after the targeting came to light. It will represent more than 200 groups. In July 2014 Judge Susan Dlott dismissed parts of the lawsuit but allowed key portions to go forward. Those include claims that the IRS engaged in retaliation and viewpoint discrimination in violation of the First Amendment, and that the tax agency violated Section 6103 of the U.S. Code, which protects confidential taxpayer return information.

my immediate reaction was what remedy can they possibly be seeking? I concur with the judge’s assessment:

At a Sept. 24, 2015 hearing on an IRS request to conduct discovery on Citizens for Self-Governance, a nonprofit funding the lawsuit against the agency, Judge Dlott eviscerated Justice. “My impression is the government probably did something wrong in this case,” she said, “Whether there’s liability or not is a legal question. However, I feel like the government is doing everything it possibly can to make this as complicated as it possibly can, to last as long as it possibly can, so that by the time there is a result, nobody is going to care except the plaintiffs.”

I think “the government did something wrong”. I think that the Justice Department decided not to pursue it stinks. By and large the guilty parties have left the scene of the crime. To quote somebody or other at this point what difference does it make?

If you’re wondering about the title of this post, I can only speculate that the plaintiffs are hoping that a real smoking gun will emerge in discovery.

4 comments

The 2016 State of the Union Message

The editors of the Washington Post were favorably impressed with the president’s annual State of the Union message this year:

PRESIDENT OBAMA took the biggest stage in politics Tuesday night aiming to calm a fearful nation and offer realistic ways to fix the country’s worsening politics. In his final State of the Union address, Mr. Obama acknowledged that partisanship has worsened during his presidency and accepted a share of blame — but said correctly that goodwill and leadership alone cannot repair the situation. It will take systemic reform, he said, to change the tone and substance of American governance.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal saw it quite differently:

As he begins his final year in office, President Obama’s legacy project is already in high gear. This includes Tuesday night’s State of the Union, which is best understood as the start of a campaign to persuade Americans that the last seven years have been better than they believe. He needs to start early because this reality makeover won’t be easy.

Start with the economy, which Mr. Obama’s Boswells are attempting to reframe as a “boom.” Mr. Obama certainly inherited a deep recession, but recessions always end and deep ones usually rebound faster and higher. The test of economic policy is the pace and quality of the recovery, and this one has been the slowest since World War II.

The jobless rate has fallen to 5%, but in May 2007 under George W. Bush it was 4.4%. Today’s rate has been able to fall as low as it has in part because so many working-age Americans have left the workforce; the labor participation rate of 62.6% hasn’t been this low since 1977. Real incomes for most households have only recently begun to rise above what they were at the end of the recession in June 2009.

I found the president’s message slightly uplifting in tone but thought it would have benefited from being half as long. For those of you who pine for the long laundry lists of legislative proposals so characteristic of SOTU messages in recent years there were plenty of them. They were, however, expressed aspirationally. Rather than saying “I will present legislation” the president said “We need”.

I only have two observations to make about the message. First, more than anything and more than any of Barack Obama’s previous SOTU messages it sounded like a stump speech. I presume he’s trying to cement his position as leader of the Democratic Party. That’s something that hasn’t been mentioned much lately. There will be a contest for influence in the party, President Obama has signalled that he wants some, and President Obama’s primary opponent will be Hillary Clinton, implying that at the very best they will be frenemies.

Although he didn’t mention them by name, the SOTU contained criticisms of each of the leading Republican contenders for nomination to the presidency, couched in general terms, e.g. “those who say America’s economy is in decline”, etc.

Which brings me to my second observation. To my ear this speech was more representative of Barack Obama than any of his previous SOTUs. It was highly partisan, airily high-minded, and utterly confident in the correctness and rectitude of his judgments, to the point of branding anyone who disagreed with them as either irrational, self-serving, or otherwise biased.

To be sure there were criticisms Washington’s toxic political environment but I don’t think the president fully appreciated how much he has contributed to that environment. His proposed remedies for the political environment, as so many of his preferred remedies are, only tangentially related to the problem. Reforms of gerrymandering are the province of the states rather than the federal government and in a country in which 44.5% of the people approve of the job President Obama is doing while 50% disapprove, it doesn’t suggest a problem that will be corrected by more fairly drawn Congressional districts. There are actual, closely held, strongly felt, and even some reasonable differences of opinion. I don’t think the president really appreciates that.

There is money in politics because there is money in government. I would welcome reforms that restricted the amount an individual to contribute to a political campaign, party, or cause; prevent entities other than actual individual living people from making political contributions; and prohibit people from making contributions to candidates for whom they are ineligible to vote. Poison pills in the guise of reform are less interesting to me. I’m not under any illusions that any of those would fly (and, yes, I recognize that most of them would require constitutional amendment) or that they would actually solve the problems posed by money in politics. As I say, if you want to get money out of politics, get it out of government.

Regardless of the president’s views the country still hasn’t recovered from the last recession and unless something miraculous happens we won’t have when the next recession comes around as it unquestionably will. How much of that can be laid at the president’s door is a matter of debate. It shouldn’t be a matter of debate that he hasn’t helped much but it obviously is. Contrary to the president’s claims I’d say that to whatever extent the economy has recovered has been despite the president’s efforts rather than because of them. As evidence I’d submit that the counties that are most likely to have recovered fully from the recession are those where oil is being pumped.

Jobs? Jobs have only recovered if you believe the adjustments that the BLS has studiously applied every month. As a matter of process when the adjustment is an order of magnitude larger than what is being adjusted it’s suspect.

How is President Obama doing on foreign policy? That’s another question on which where you stand apparently depends largely on where you sit. I’m not as impressed with the president’s willingness to follow through on President Bush’s commitment to withdraw troops from Iraq, pointless build-up and then withdrawal in Afghanistan, or bombing campaign against DAESH in Syria. I’m also not particularly impressed with the Iran agreement or the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement. On the former, all I can say is we’ll see. I still haven’t seen an argument in other than the most general terms that the TPP helps most Americans. I’m looking and I’d like to see one.

Are we better off today than in January 2009? Sure. Are we as well off as we should be? I don’t think so.

1 comment

Trade Unions or De-Industrialization?

As I’ve mentioned before the governor and the state legislature have been at an impasse over Illinois’s budget for the last nine months. The governor has refused to sign the budget enacted by the legislature because a) it’s out of balance—a violation of the state constitution and b) it doesn’t reflect any of what he sees as the economic realities facing Illinois, what’s referred to as “his agenda”. The legislature has refused to budge on the grounds that the governor’s agenda would hurt unions, hurt middle income people, etc. The legislature has also refused to override the governor’s veto although Democrats have the votes to do it which I think, at the very least, calls their stated rationale into question. I can’t help but wonder if the incomes they’re worried about are their own.

But that brings me around to a question I’ve been mulling over. I’ve been wondering whether the emphasis that Democrats and some economists, e.g. Paul Krugman, have placed on the role of the decline of union membership in the United States on increasing income quality. I can’t help but think that they’re engaging in a little cargo cult thinking, i.e. reverse causality.

Isn’t it possible that both the decline in union membership and increasing income inequality have a common cause: the de-industrialization of the United States? In other words an industrial America is a unionized America and an America with lots of heavy industry also provides higher incomes for more Americans? Especially Americans other than those with professional degrees?

I suppose some would quibble with me over whether the U. S. has de-industrialized. That manufacturing has declined as a percent of total GDP is hardly a state secret but that could be explained by the tremendous increase in the contributions of finance, healthcare, and education to the economy.

Here’s a pretty fair proxy:

or, in other words, U. S. production of iron and steel is half what it was 30 years ago. Or this:

We could argue about the reasons for the decline but I don’t think we can argue about the fact of it.

I don’t think that white collar jobs are nearly as fertile a ground for labor organizing as heavy industry, especially with the enormous increase in temporary workers and, in particular, foreign temporary workers over the last 25 years.

12 comments

A Plague On Both Your Houses!

Once again Gallup has found party identification with the two major political parties to be at historic lows:

PRINCETON, N.J. — In 2015, for the fifth consecutive year, at least four in 10 U.S. adults identified as political independents. The 42% identifying as independents in 2015 was down slightly from the record 43% in 2014. This elevated percentage of political independents leaves Democratic (29%) and Republican (26%) identification at or near recent low points, with the modest Democratic advantage roughly where it has been over the past five years.

If you include those who lean Democratic or lean Republican these are the results:

Last year, in addition to the 29% of Americans who identified as Democrats, another 16% said they were independents but leaned toward the Democratic Party, for a combined total of 45% Democrats and Democratic leaners among the U.S. population. Likewise, 26% of Americans identified as Republicans and an additional 16% identified as independents but leaned toward the Republican Party, for a combined total of 42% Republicans and Republican leaners.

Lest Democrats become too complacent how does that compare with 2008?

That three-percentage-point Democratic advantage matches what the party enjoyed in 2014, but is down from 2012 and 2013. The high point in Democratic strength was in 2008, a time when President George W. Bush was highly unpopular in the midst of the prolonged Iraq war and the emerging economic recession. That year, Democrats had a 12-point advantage in party identification and leaning.

That’s a very substantial difference.

As I’ve been saying for some time, the 2016 presidential election will hinge on turnout. Whichever candidate gets his or her voters out to the polls to actually vote and/or discourages her or his opponent’s voters from voting will be inaugurated president in January 2017.

Which candidates are most likely to accomplish that?

8 comments

The Business Cycle Has Not Been Repealed

In his latest column at The Washington Post Robert Samuelson muses over whether the stock market’s gyrations suggest that we are or soon will be in recession:

It’s hard not to wonder: Is the stock market telling us something? True, the market’s record in forecasting recessions is horrendous. Stocks often move according to whim or fad. But just because the market is wrong much of the time doesn’t mean it’s wrong all of the time. Could last week’s turbulent trading be one of the times it’s right? By Friday’s close, stocks had dropped 6 percent for the week, a paper loss of $1.5 trillion, says Wilshire Associates. Are we staring at the next recession?

The short answer to that is “no”. The stock market is responding nervously to the sell-off in the Chinese stock market which has been aggravated by the Chinese authorities’ policy responses.

The longer answer is that economic growth is slowing everywhere and, however connected or disconnected we are from the Chinese economy, a global downturn won’t be good for us, either. As I’ve posted previously, the World Bank has already forecasted slower growth for the US in 2016 than they had previously been predicting and I think that even that’s too rosy.

Besides, based on the NBER’s records the average time between contractions has been 5-6 years so we’re due. The last recovery was pretty darned phlegmatic, the Fed is ill-prepared for another downturn, and it’s pretty darned hard to be optimistic about the measures that Congress is likely to take in the event of another recession.

Look out below!

4 comments