My siblings and I have been doing some texting and in the course of the conversation I received some photos of my grandmother’s wedding dress that I thought you might find interesting. My grandparents were married on November 15, 1913.
Here’s a picture that shows the detail work a little better:
Writing in McLean’s Kevin Milligan makes an interesting argument—that the conditions required for Keynesian stimulus just don’t obtain in Canada right now. Here’s the kernel of his argument.
The Keynesian multiplier is predicted to be reduced in small, open economies like Canada’s
The effectiveness of fiscal stimulus is relatively lower in countries with flexible exchange rates.
Canada doesn’t have a shortfall in aggregate demand.
A national program would be insufficiently focus geographically to compensate for the industry that’s contracting—oil production.
The strategies that are being contemplated are insufficiently focused in time.
I made some of those arguments with respect to our own Keynesian stimulus plan in 2009. I was also concerned that political pay-offs would be disguised as fiscal stimulus which in fact turned out to be the case. Maslow’s Hammer seems to have international appeal.
It sounds to me like Canada gambled and lost. I guess that’s why it’s called “gambling”.
I can see from the comments in my earlier post on the situation with migrants in Europe that there’s quite a bit of confusion on that subject. According to the United Nations High Commission on Refugees there are about 50 million displaced persons worldwide in three different categories. 3-5 million of them are refugees with the greatest number of those coming from Syria. The other two classifications are people who have fled their homes but remain within their countries of origin (internally displaced persons) and those who have fled their homes to other countries (externally displaced persons).
Not every one who leaves his or her home country even when that country is at war or in in civil war is a refugee. To be a refugee you must meet certain specific criteria and most migrants don’t qualify.
In addition to the tally reported by the UNHCR there are probably tens of millions, possibly hundreds of millions of people who would leave their home countries for economic reasons if they thought they could manage it.
We don’t have a refugee crisis here in the United States. Neither does Germany. We’re hosting about 300,000 refugees and the Germans another 200,000 but we can manage that and so can they. The only countries that I would say have refugee crises are Turkey and, possibly, Rwanda.
In general refugees flee. They don’t shop for the best venue. When a Syrian leaves his or her home country and flees to Turkey she or he may or may not be a refugee. When refugees leave Turkey and wash up on shore in Greece, making a pit stop on the way to Germany, they are no longer refugees. They’re migrants. I think it’s likely that Turkey is exploiting its refugee population for political purposes but that’s another subject. At the very least the Turks are not living up to their treaty responsibilities respecting refugees and migrants.
I think we’re experiencing a migrant crisis. Just under 15% of the U. S. population today are immigrants. That’s as many as at any time in our history. By comparison about 5% of the German population are immigrants, 10% of the French population are immigrants, and 12% of the UK population are immigrants. Those are numbers much higher than they’re accustomed to but it’s still not a crisis.
I think we have a crisis because of
The sheer numbers
They have come so quickly (mostly since 1975, many since 1985)
So many of them have come from a single country (Mexico)
Economic growth and, particularly, wage growth is not as great here as it was during the earlier periods we experience heavy immigration, e.g. 1890-1900
Cultural changes here which have made assimilation more difficult
I think we’ll survive and even prosper by the new immigrants but I also think that we need a breather. The study most frequently quoted to prove that our Mexican immigrants ultimately adopt English as their first language also found that they do so on average a generation later than other immigrants. It’s going to take a while for our Mexican immigrants to be assimilated—50-75 years.
Some have pointed out the contributions that new immigrants may make. They’re right. New immigrants also present problems. Unemployment 20 years after their immigration among the Hmong refugees was still around 20%. Today it’s still nearly 10%. Unemployment among Somali refugees is nearly 50% and not going down. The honest truth is that we don’t need a lot of illiterate people without urban skills and scanty command of English any more. It’s pretty hard for subsistence farmers to make it in the 21st century United States.
Many Americans have a sort of Disney-fied view of the world in which the differences between countries are just differences in languages, national costumes, and cuisines. That’s not right. There are real differences between cultures. Just as an example in some cultures (ours) people are motivated by internalized guilt while in others they are motivated by externalized shame. There are differences in attitudes about government, the role of religion in life, family life, the roles of the sexes, and just about every other aspect of life and just because people move here doesn’t mean they leave those attitudes behind.
As I suggested in the post linked above, the European countries have a choice to make but it’s their choice. Whether we accept more migrants and whom we accept should be our choice, too. Recently, it hasn’t been. It’s been the choice of our elites who like lots of new immigrants because they keep wages down and they (the elites) can just retire to their gated communities and estates if they don’t want to put up with the problems.
I just finished watching an odd little picture I’d never heard of on Netflix—August. Eighth. It’s a Russian movie, set in the context of the Russo-Georgian War of 2008. It’s not dubbed (subtitled) so you need to be able to tolerate that to watch it. My Russian’s good enough that I followed most of it but I found the subtitles helpful, particularly during some of the action scenes. Of course, I’d find subtitles helpful during a Michael Bay picture and August. Eighth was pretty clearly influenced by Michael Bay pictures.
It presents a side of the war that’s pretty darned different from what we got in the press. Pretty romanticized. There’s a Medvedev character and a Putin character, both very handsome and charismatic.
The actual story is about a woman who send her eight year old son to visit his father from whom she is divorced on the Russian-Georgian border so she can go off for the weekend with her boyfriend. When war breaks out she goes to incredible lengths to reach her son. A lot of magical realism in the parts told from the point of view of the kid.
I found it pretty entertaining throughout, the heroine is pretty, the Russian soldiers are handsome and heroic. Interesting to get a different point of view.
I wanted to put my two cents in on how our European cousins will deal with the large number of refugees they’ve accepted. I’m reminded of John Lyly’s famous wisecrack (often incorrectly attributed to Benjamin Franklin) about guests and fish growing stale after three days.
For years I’ve been pointing out that the Europeans have a choice. They can either remain the ethnic states they’ve been or they can become multi-ethnic, multi-confessional states. The decision will become much more urgent. I don’t know what they’ll do. It’s up to them. Countries like Hungary are in a real pickle. It’s a small country with distinctive customs that speaks a language spoken by no one else in the world. Unless it can remain an ethnic state those will cease to exist.
Don’t expect the Europeans to react as Americans would. They are much more rules-oriented and have much more respect for their governments than we do.
Growing numbers of Germans worry about the large influx of Muslims. In a survey by INSA, a pollster, 61% of respondents have become less happy about accepting refugees since the assaults; 63% think there are already too many asylum-seekers in Germany, and only 29% still agree with Mrs Merkel that the country can handle it. The sceptics are not only on the populist right. Alice Schwarzer, Germany’s leading feminist, says that Germany is “naively importing male violence, sexism and anti-Semitismâ€.
For now Mrs Merkel and her governing coalition have responded by talking tough. At a gathering of her centre-right Christian Democrats, she promised that the offenders will “feel the full force of the law†and suggested that more asylum-seekers who commit crimes would be deported. Even her centre-left coalition partners, the Social Democrats, want to crack down hard. Sigmar Gabriel, their boss, wants offenders to serve their prison time in their home countries to spare German taxpayers.
If there’s a reaction, I’d expect it in the more independent (and red-necked) areas of the country first, e.g. Bavaria, Saxony, and, to a lesser extent, North Rhine-Westphalia.
For well over a decade, China has been the engine of global growth. But the blistering pace of economic expansion has slowed.
The first sentence makes me lament the state of contemporary journalism. There are ways that could have been expressed with facts and figures. Instead, the editors chose vague generalities, spiced with opinion. That a few sentences previously they bought into the 7% growth that the Chinese authorities are reporting despite solid arguments that China’s growth rate is closer to 3% doesn’t help.
“Engine”, “global”, and “growth” are interesting words. Is that actually what happened? Or did Chinese subsidy to increase industrial capacity result in a buying spree and bubbles in commodity exports by countries like Brazil and Australia? We may never know.
But I loved their reaching into the not-so-distant past and bringing this up:
“WHAT if we could just be China for a day?†mused Thomas Friedman, an American columnist, in 2010. “…We could actually, you know, authorise the right solutions.†Five years on, few are so ready to sing the praises of China’s technocrats.
It points out how greatly the Internet has changed things. When nothing every really vanishes whether you’re a politician or a celebrity journalist your old excesses can come back to haunt you. Will it incline Tom Friedman to moderate his effusive praise of authoritarians? It would make an interesting study and we can only hope.
When I read this:
China has a semi-fixed currency and semi-porous capital controls. Partly because a stronger dollar has been dragging up the yuan, the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) has tried to abandon its loose peg against the greenback since August; but it is still targeting a basket of currencies. A gradual loosening of capital controls means savers have plenty of ways to get their money out.
A weakening economy, a quasi-fixed exchange rate and more porous capital controls are a volatile combination. Looser monetary policy would boost demand. But it would also weaken the currency; and that prospect is already prompting savers to shovel their money offshore.
I wondered whether the authors remembered why the Chinese authorities started pegging the yuan to the dollar in the first place? Back in the early 90s after a series of disastrous inflations the Chinese authorities despaired of managing their currency in a way they found satisfactory so they decided to rely on the greenback.
More recently they had to have “semi-porous capital controls”. Otherwise they couldn’t get their own money out of the country in time. Those multi-million dollar houses in British Columbia, California, and Florida don’t buy themselves, you know.
When they write this:
The problem is that the expectation of depreciation risks becoming a self-fulfilling loss of confidence. That is a risk even for a country with foreign-exchange reserves of more than $3 trillion. A sharply weaker currency is also a threat to China’s companies, which have taken on $10 trillion of debt in the past eight years, roughly a tenth of it in dollars. Either those companies will fail, or China’s state-owned banks will allow them to limp on. Neither is good for growth.
what they haven’t mentioned is that when 70% of businesses and nearly all of the big ones are state-owned “Chinese companies” is just the Chinese government under another guise.
I’ve now presented three opportunities The Economist might have seized on to disambiguate the data: how important China has actually been to global growth, the amount of capital that has fled China into real overseas assets, and the role of SOEs in total Chinese corporate debt. But that would have taken reporting and stuff. It only takes two sentences to say “Don’t worry. China will be just fine” but I guess they had a 1,000 word hole to fill in the last issue.
My own view is that over a 30 year period China has used its currency and capital controls as a sort of siphon, exporting inexpensive manufactured goods and importing employment. Meanwhile, we and the Europeans, except for Germany which was busy building Chinese factories, imported the goods and de-industrialized. Over the last half dozen years China has built enormous industrial capacity, over-capacity by practically any measure. How we’re all going to pry ourselves out of this fix I don’t really know. No one seems particularly eager to relive the last 20-25 years, taking every decision and doing the opposite.
The people who’ve really been injured in all of this are people in poor countries other than China who’d like to use the model used by Japan, South Korea, and China to pull themselves up by our bootstraps. But now there’s all that Chinese overcapacity without enough Chinese, European, or American consumption for them do to that.
Update
I see that Barry Ritholz had about the same reaction that I did, expressed considerably more tersely.
I want to commend an excellent post by Jeffry Snider at RealClearMarkets to your attention. The post begins with the value of error in the decision-making process but actually is pointing out the necessity of errors in producing good decisions. Here’s a snippet:
There is efficiency in seeming randomness. In the natural world, there is tendency for physical forms to find the most efficient shapes possible. The sphere, for example, is the most efficient distribution of forces which the material in it can displace maximum volume for finite quantities. The soap bubble is a perfect example of that. Economies and other complex systems are in many important ways similar; always searching for the most efficient manner of distribution given finite quantities of everything. There is no way to find such efficiency and thus true progress at the direct exclusion or dismissal of error. The Federal Reserve, had it existed in 1879 and assigned itself the task under its current rules, would have told Edison to stop after only a few tries at the light bulb and instead use whatever he had at that point. In other words, monetary intrusion is a purposeful deformation of the efficient shape because economists have assumed they can, with no wisdom of the crowd, define better what is and is not error and prudence.
Read the whole thing.
We’d better hope that errors are a necessary part of good decision-making. We’ve made some whoppers in recent years. I hope we can benefit by them. I see few signs that’s the case.
I’ve mentioned before the number of times that Chicago’s credit rating has been lowered since Rahm Emanuel was elected mayor. Each time the city’s credit rating is lowered it means that the interest payments on that debt go up. Let’s put that into a little context. The graph above illustrates the city’s long term debt. The red vertical line is when Rahm Emanuel was elected mayor.
The Chicago way of borrowing works like this: The mayor asks city council members for bonding authority, and they give it to him.
That’s changing now that Mayor Rahm Emanuel is under siege from a federal investigation into the misconduct of his police department. A sign of just how much the scandal has undermined the mayor’s influence came this week when the council trimmed a $3.2 billion bonding plan by $600 million and delayed voting on another $200 million.
“It’s a new day where aldermen want new questions answered,†Alderman Ricardo Munoz said Wednesday. “The city council as a body is not as trusting as it used to be.â€
While most of the borrowing was approved by the council, the resistance reflects a subtle power shift in Chicago, where mayoral omnipotence has long been the custom. Emanuel’s predecessor, Richard M. Daley, ruled Chicago for 22 years, as his father, Richard J. Daley, did for 21. Emanuel, a former White House chief of staff for Barack Obama, won a second four-year term in April.
All of those multi-million dollar settlements for police killings and torturing? It’s all borrowed money. And Chicago’s population is declining slowly. In 2000 the U. S. Census reported Chicago’s population as right around 2.9 million people. In 2010 it reported 2.7 million—a 6.7% drop in ten years. Each drop in the city’s population means the debt per resident rises.
Can Chicago afford three more years with Rahm Emanuel as mayor? Don’t blame me—I didn’t vote for him.
You know that your reputation has been irreparably damaged if, when confronted with a decision with two alternative courses of action, whichever course you select is condemned. That’s now the situation that Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel faces. You see, the city has been fighting the release of a video showing Chicago police gunning down another kid and yesterday, inexplicably, the city stopped objecting. Fox 32 Chicago reports:
CHICAGO (AP) — A federal judge on Thursday granted the release of 2013 surveillance video showing a white Chicago police officer fatally shooting a 17-year-old black carjacking suspect after the city withdrew its objection to it being made public.
The city could release the video of 17-year-old Cedrick Chatman’s death within hours, but a spokesman for the city’s Law Department didn’t immediately respond to an email asking when it would do so.
The universal reaction to the city’s action was to condemn it as politically motivated. Now in Chicago any action by City Hall can reasonably be characterized as “politically motivated” but I think this story illustrates that at this point Mayor Emanuel just can’t win.
In his Washington Post column Fred Hiatt points to something interesting in President Obama’s State of the Union message. Whatever optimism it expressed with respect to the United States, it exhibited substantial fatalism with respect to foreign policy, particularly in the Middle East:
“The Middle East is going through a transformation that will play out for a generation, rooted in conflicts that date back millennia,†Obama said.
And “instability will continue for decades in many parts of the world — in the Middle East, in Afghanistan, parts of Pakistan, in parts of Central America, in Africa, and Asia.â€
Why would a president ask Americans to assume that the problems of Central America, say, are intractable and inevitable? Of the region’s seven small nations (total population: 42 million), some, such as Costa Rica, have been enviably stable for decades. Others, it’s true, have problems: gang violence in El Salvador; corrupt, pseudo-leftist, Venezuela-fueled authoritarianism in Nicaragua.
Bear with me for a moment. Let’s assume that’s right and the problems of Central America or the Middle East are simply intractable, things that must be coped with with.
Issues like instability, poverty, and violence aren’t free-standing. They come from people. Is our culture so overwhelming that when the people who are experiencing these problems come over here they leave the problems behind? Or do they bring their problems with them? Or is it some of both?