Two Myths and Three Truths About China

The use of the word “myth” to characterize an error is something we’ve become accustomed to through repeated usage although a better definition might be something which while not literally true reveals a greater truth. Consequently, when I read Eswar S. Prasad’s piece in the Washington Post, “5 myths about China”, I expected to have some errors revealed. Imagine my surprise when three of the “myths” are actually true. Here are the five:

  1. China’s stock market losses reflect an ailing economy. that’s false or, at the best, misleading. China’s stock market losses and its ailing economy share a common cause: bad policy.
  2. China’s economic growth is driven primarily by cheap exports. As it turns out this is true as reflected in the piece itself:

    The main economic driver has been investment in physical capital, including factories and infrastructure such as roads and railways. Such investment has accounted for more than half of China’s growth in the past decade.

    When investment is driven by borrowing as has been the case in China and exceeds the actual productive capacity of the economy, it does not produce growth. It produces a bubble as is also the case in China. Most of China’s non-frothy growth has been produced by, in the words of the article, “cheap exports”.

  3. China is actively manipulating its currency. That’s true, too. What is offered in the article as a refutation:

    Except that this recent fusillade from Capitol Hill was prompted by China doing exactly what the United States has been asking it to do: ease up on management of the renminbi’s exchange rate, relative to other currencies, so that its value can be more freely determined by market forces.

    does not contradict the assertion. And in recent months China has been selling dollars ferociously. That is by any definition “active manipulation”.

  4. China cooks the books to make its economy look stronger. That’s also true. And the article confirms it:

    Reported GDP growth is usually suspiciously close to official growth targets. And although China’s official growth rate is 7 percent, some Western economists estimate it at 3 percent or less.

    There’s some handwaving in the article about short term about short-term and long-term prospects but the Chinese authorities reporting 7% growth this year where 3-4% is probably what is supported by the facts this year is cooking the books by my standards. Unless the author has turned to the “revealing a greater truth” definition of a myth?

  5. The renminbi’s new status threatens the dollar’s dominance. That’s false. It has always been false and it’s not even vaguely true. I don’t know what all the hubbub has been about.

There are other myths about China I wish the author had explored. For example, the myth that China has transformed itself into a free market economy. You can’t be a free market economy with 70% state-owned enterprises. Or China’s economy is now the most influential in the world. We’d better hope that’s not the case or China’s problems, mostly induced by bad policy over which the rest of the world has no influence let alone control, will spread.

4 comments

There Is No There There

Via Business Inside respected China analyst Charlene Chu points out something interesting. In China the growth in secondary industry is less than interest owed on loans outstanding:

“We expect China’s GDP growth to continue to slow in 2016 driven by further deterioration of secondary industry, which comprises 43% of economic output and whose growth plummeted to a record low of 1.2% yoy in 3Q15,” Chu wrote in the note.

China’s secondary industry is drowning in debt. Old China’s companies are not growing fast enough to keep up with interest payments on their debt.

What China bulls will tell you is that other parts of the economy are coming in to save the day. Chu writes that that is simply not the case.

“Consumption and services remain bright spots. However, we doubt these areas can accelerate enough to offset a further slowdown – and likely contraction – of secondary industry in 2016, particularly as it increasingly weighs on household income growth, the principal driver of consumption and services expansion,” she wrote.

Let me decompress that a bit for you. “Secondary industry” is consumer industry—industry other than mining, agriculture, and other primary industries. When interest is greater than the growth in secondary industry it’s going to be darn hard for the secondary to grow. And Keynesian pump-priming can’t work in the absence of inadequate excess aggregate product and shortfall in aggregate demand.

That’s more evidence for the hard landing that those other than the “China bulls” are suggesting is likely at this point. That’s unfortunate for China but it’s a direct consequence of poor policy.

0 comments

Chinese Contagion

I see that Paul Krugman and I are in broad agreement on the subject of how much we have to worry about in China’s economic downturn:

So, will China’s problems cause a global crisis? The good news is that the numbers, as I read them, don’t seem big enough. The bad news is that I could be wrong, because global contagion often seems to end up being worse than hard numbers say it should. And the worse news is that if China does deliver a bad shock to the rest of the world, we are remarkably unready to deal with the consequences.

The basics, as I explained and supported with a few facts and figures last week, are:

  1. China’s economy has deteriorated more than its leaders are letting on.
  2. It’s likely to experience a “hard landing”.
  3. We aren’t actually very exposed to a Chinese economic downturn.

and I’ve been perseverating on how poorly prepared we are for an economic downturn here for several years.

The more serious questions are about the geopolitical implications of a severe Chinese economic downturn. That would affect us.

1 comment

The Emanuel We Knew

As a sort of follow-up to my post, “These Are Our Political Leaders”, writing at the Tribune Kristen McQueary provides this characterization of our mayor and his administration:

Emanuel’s aides routinely resist the release of public records, from red light camera data to city financial records to Emanuel’s own schedules and calendar. His press staff keeps tabs on the city’s reporters, often hovering over their shoulders at City Hall to eavesdrop on interviews. Emanuel himself bristles at being challenged or interrupted. He abruptly leaves press conferences when the questions get too tough.

He ignored criticism in his first term that he was neglecting struggling neighborhoods. He continued to devote resources and attention to tourist destinations — Navy Pier, a new basketball arena for DePaul University, riverwalk renovations — instead of focusing laser-like on crime-infested low-income neighborhoods.

In 2014, he proposed building a new selective enrollment high school named after President Barack Obama to be located on the North Side, months after he closed nearly 50 schools, mostly in black neighborhoods on the South and West sides. He suggested using controversial tax increment finance money to pay for it at a time of heightened skepticism over TIFs in general. He could not have appeared more out of touch.

And Emanuel consistently rejected the notion that his Police Department operated in a code of silence. In 2012, he defended a legal settlement between the city and a bartender who got beat up by an off-duty police officer, all caught on video. The city wanted to vacate one of the jury’s findings that a code of silence existed within the Police Department. The city’s lawyers fought to have that conclusion omitted.

Even in recent days he defended the city’s Law Department (until he didn’t), despite a federal judge citing examples of city attorneys withholding evidence in two police misconduct investigations.

Again, nothing new, but relevant to the underlying fervor to oust him in the wake of Laquan McDonald’s death. This is, and always has been, a City Hall of walls and control. And so when a video of a brutal police shooting emerged, it was not out of character for the city to close ranks. We still don’t know the story behind the missing Burger King surveillance video or why other officers on the scene haven’t been disciplined for filing false reports.

This is to add insult to injury. As my old business partner used to say, “I agree with what you say but I will oppose to the death your right to say it”. Emanuel’s re-election was endorsed by both the Tribune and the Sun-Times. If he was so bad, why did they endorse him? If the endorsements were just the editors’ opinions, why was there no revolt among the newspapers’ reporters and non-editorial staff.

I think it was fear. I don’t think they agreed with him or supported him so much as feared him and those who stood behind him. And these are our political leaders.

2 comments

Credit Where Credit Is Due

It’s nice to see Chicago doing something right for a change, so I was please to read this article at Citylab on how Chicago is using an improved scheduling algorithm to schedule inspections of establishments that prepare food and it’s had good results:

For years, Chicago, like most every city in the U.S., scheduled these inspections by going down the complete list of food vendors and making sure they all had a visit in the mandated timeframe. That process ensured that everyone got inspected, but not that the most likely health code violators got inspected first. And speed matters in this case. Every day that unsanitary vendors serve food is a new chance for diners to get violently ill, paying in time, pain, and medical expenses.

That’s why, in 2014, Chicago’s Department of Innovation and Technology started sifting through publicly available city data and built an algorithm to predict which restaurants were most likely to be in violation of health codes, based on the characteristics of previously recorded violations. The program generated a ranked list of which establishments the inspectors should look at first. The project is notable not just because it worked—the algorithm identified violations significantly earlier than business as usual did—but because the team made it as easy as possible for other cities to replicate the approach

The article goes on to bemoan the fact that few other cities have imitated Chicago’s approach despite the city having made the information readily available to anyone interested.

There’s one niggling little detail with which I take exception:

But there’s still a significant benefit to having more data experts within city governments, says Eric Potash, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Chicago’s Center for Data Science and Public Policy. He’s working with Chicago’s public health department on a project to use data to predict lead contamination in housing before it poisons children. He points out that collecting data is a messy task, with different troves of information stored separately in different departments. Having an advocate “on the inside” can really help speed up that process.

The odds are overwhelming that the people who developed the algorithm weren’t “on the inside”. As said in the body of the article:

If the code belongs to someone, another city can’t just take it. The open data approach deals with this problem: cities can choose to share their work with whomever may be interested. But if the programmers build a project using expensive paid or proprietary software, other city governments probably won’t have access to it. That’s why the Chicago team worked with R, an open-source statistics program.

Based on my experience with city government that suggests that it was probably built by some folks at University of Illinois. Just for your edification and enlightenment here’s a list of the contractors used by the Department of Innovations and Technology. You’ll probably get bored after the first hundred or so but it does make for illuminating reading.

The point is, if it was done by an arm of government, it was probably done by a contractor.

1 comment

Who’s a Socialist?

I always find it ironically amusing when people throw around accusations that such and such is a socialist. Right now that’s most commonly observed among the Republican challengers for their party’s presidential nomination and used to characterize Democrats generally.

The reason I find it amusing is that, with the possible exception of Rand Paul, they’re all socialists. Socialism is the belief in centralized control of the means of production. The most important means of production today is money. Unless you believe in a hard currency and nothing other than head taxes, you’re a socialist. Basically, nearly all of us are socialists today.

The “flat tax” doesn’t cut it since it posits that people with higher incomes should pay higher taxes than those with lower incomes. It still provides control over the means of production.

You can’t maintain things like a modern army or modern regulatory state without something other than a head tax.

Rather than throwing around insults that we barely understand, how about we talk about what works and what doesn’t work? Let’s start with the idea that the Laffer Curve doesn’t say that tax cuts will always pay for themselves and produce economic growth.

11 comments

Watch Your Phraseology

I think there’s a kernel of truth in Salena Zito’s column at RealClearPolitics but I genuinely wish she’d use different words. Here’s the kernel:

Data provided to The New York Times by Civis Analytics, a Democrat firm, shows Trump’s support is strongest among self-identified Republicans, a coalition that uniquely follows the migration and settlement patterns of early Scots-Irish Jacksonian Democrats. That places their concentration across the industrial North, through the Rust Belt, down into Appalachia and the Deep South.

These are Democrats by birth, a legacy of their New Deal-Democrat parents and grandparents, who largely stopped supporting a party that began cutting them loose after winning their support in the 2006 midterm elections.

That explains the odd choices between Trump and Sanders, or Trump and Clinton: They’re straddling between one party that used to include them and another that now is trying to fit them in.

I think what she’s writing about goes back a lot farther than 2006 to the 1970s but otherwise that’s about right. However, this is what makes me uncomfortable:

Since the 2008 presidential campaign, Democrats have purposefully cut white, traditional-values, working-class, predominantly male voters from their coalition in favor of building an urban- and cosmopolitan-centered coalition of minorities, elites and women.

and word is “cosmopolitan”. “Rootless cosmopolitan” was a term used by the Soviets after World War II in a campaign directed against Soviet Jews, suggesting pro-Western sentiments and lack of patriotism. Find a better word. That one has a bad pedigree.

9 comments

Bring Back Empiricism!

Empiricism is the belief that knowledge comes from things that can be measured. Do you remember my caution that the recent rosy job figures might be an artifact of unmeasured adjustments in the figures? A regular commenter pointed out this post at Zerohedge that suggests that was precisely the case:

Here’s a newsflash that CNBC didn’t mention. According to the BLS, the US economy generated a miniscule 11,000 jobs in the month of December.

Yet notwithstanding the fact that almost nobody works outside any more, the BLS fiction writers added 281,000 to their headline number to cover the “seasonal adjustment.” This is done on the apparent truism that December is generally colder than November and that workers get holiday vacations.

Of course, this December was much warmer, not colder, than average. And that’s not the only deviation from normal seasonal trends.

The Christmas selling season this year, for example, was absolutely not comparable to the ghosts of Christmas past. Bricks and mortar retail is in turmoil and in secular decline due to Amazon and its e-commerce ilk, and this trend is accelerating by the year.

So too, energy and export based sectors have been thrown for a loop in the last few months by a surging dollar and collapsing commodity prices. Likewise, construction activity has been so weak in this cycle—-and for the good reason that both commercial and residential stock is vastly overbuilt owing to two decades of cheap credit—–that its not remotely comparable to historic patterns.

Never mind. The BLS always adds the same big dollop of jobs to the December establishment survey come hell or high water. In fact, the seasonal adjustment has averaged 320,000 for the last 12 years!

For crying out loud, folks, every December is different—–and not just because of the vagaries of the weather. Capitalism is about incessant change and reallocation of economic activity and resources. And now the globalized ebbs and flows of economic activity have only accentuated the rate and intensity of these adjustments.

Read the whole thing. It includes some very interesting graphs.

The way that people behave is based on what they experience. Keynes’s famous “animal spirits” derives partly from what people have heard is happening rather than what they’re actually experiencing in their own lives but over time what they actually experience will figure more prominently.

We’re not the only ones who goose our numbers based on unmeasured phantoms. The Chinese government continues to claim 7% annual GDP growth when things that can actually be measured like electricity use and containers loaded or unloaded from ships suggest it’s more like 4%. Look at what people are doing, how they’re behaving. If they’re not behaving as though the economy were booming, it probably isn’t.

Jobs growth isn’t the only area in which abandoning empiricism may mislead. Even the hard sciences are falling victim.

The Phillips Curve, a hypothetical relationship between employment and inflation, which was taught as gospel when I tool economics, has fallen on empirical hard times, as this remark from Larry Kudlow illustrates:

More people working does not cause inflation. And the chief goal of the Fed should be price stability, or near-zero inflation. That’s what we have now.

The Fed’s Phillips curve model isn’t working anyway. The unemployment rate has come down to 5 percent and the inflation rate is near zero. According the Fed, inflation ought to be 4 or 5 percent. It’s not.

and String Theory, which has been taught for 30 years, is sadly lacking in empirical evidence, as pointed out by this Scientific American article:

Is string theory science? Physicists and cosmologists have been debating the question for the past decade. Now the community is looking to philosophy for help.

Earlier this month, some of the feuding physicists met with philosophers of science at an unusual workshop aimed at addressing the accusation that branches of theoretical physics have become detached from the realities of experimental science. At stake is the integrity of the scientific method, as well as the reputation of science among the general public, say the workshop’s organizers.

More here on String Theory as science. The failure of wages to rise may not be a mystery. It may be because the job growth that the BLS has been reporting faithfully month after month has been illusory. The figures released every month by the Bureau of Labor Statistics inform the views of otherwise uninformed op-ed and editorial writers and, what’s worse, naive or agenda-driven policymakers. Rationalism isn’t enough. Policymakers need to know what works.

4 comments

The Scope of China’s State-Owned Enterprises

In my last post I mentioned China’s need to start divesting its state-owned enterprises. Just how big a problem is that for China? This big:

Hat tip: Fortune

Bloomberg remarks:

The impact of the SOEs on private enterprise is getting more damaging as the economy’s growth slows. “Many of China’s structural distortions, both economic and otherwise, are due to the dominating positions of the SOEs,” says Chen Zhiwu, a finance professor at Yale University and an adviser to China’s cabinet in 2007. State enterprises have “made competition unfair and the legal system biased against private firms and individuals.” The 150,000 SOEs account for 17 percent of urban employment, 22 percent of industrial income, and 38 percent of China’s industrial assets, according to JPMorgan Chase. With $16 trillion in assets, the SOEs do everything from building spacecraft to trading silk. These enterprises, says BNP Paribas, are also big borrowers. BNP figures corporate debt, mostly owed by SOEs, rose to 167 percent of gross domestic product in 2014, from 97 percent in 2008. The state sector stands in the way of China’s transformation into an economy driven by services and consumption.

or, in other words, a major problem China has in transforming its economy from one dependent for growth on exports and, more specifically, exports of low margin goods to one that relies more on internal demand for goods and services is its state-owned enterprises.

1 comment

Will China Avoid a Hard Landing?

The editors of the New York Times call China’s policy responses to a plummeting stock market and slowing economy “obsolete”:

The Chinese economy, the world’s second largest, is growing at nearly 7 percent a year — down from 10.6 percent in 2010 but still a healthy pace for a country at its stage of development. The problem is that the boom was fueled by lavish investment and spending as well as profligate borrowing, a lot of which will probably not be paid back. China’s central government orchestrated that binge by pumping billions of dollars into the economy in the aftermath of the 2008 global financial crisis and by failing to enact needed reforms that would make it easier for private and foreign companies to compete with inefficient state-owned enterprises.

Beginning last year, Chinese officials also used state-owned media to encourage individual investors to pour their savings and borrowed money into the stock market, leading to a massive bubble. When the market started to tumble over the summer, the government blamed rumormongers and speculators, and ordered securities firms and state-owned companies to keep buying, which simply disguised the underlying problems.

The lesson here is clear: Instead of trying to micromanage stock prices, Chinese officials ought to be strengthening the economy, foremost by shifting its emphasis from investment to consumer spending and services. This is important because China can no longer grow by taking people off the farm and putting them to work in factories. It needs to move people into white-collar jobs. To take one example, officials could help create more such jobs and make the economy more competitive by easing the way for private companies to get into industries like telecommunications and insurance that are currently dominated by a handful of state-owned corporations.

China also has to clean up its financial system. Many businesses and local governments have borrowed billions of dollars to build high-speed rail lines, real estate developments and other projects, many of which are not going to produce the returns needed to pay off those debts. The government should encourage lenders and borrowers to quickly restructure loans that paid for those projects so that banks are not crippled by bad debts and can continue making new loans. Officials also need to shut down highly inefficient state-owned businesses.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal think they’re “in disarray”:

But monetary easing is complicated by capital flight. The U.S. Federal Reserve’s interest-rate rise last month has caused the dollar to strengthen, and aggressive PBOC easing could exacerbate capital outflows and put more pressure on the yuan. China’s reserves stand at $3.3 trillion, but it used $108 billion defending the yuan in December, the biggest monthly drop since 2003. In theory capital controls should limit money leaving, but China’s wealthy can bypass them.

Meanwhile the slowing economy has exposed the excesses of the post-2008 credit boom. In response to the global panic, Beijing deployed $586 billion in stimulus, largely on infrastructure. It also encouraged lending for housing construction and purchases, creating a bubble in smaller cities. The borrowing pushed China’s debt-to-GDP ratio above 240% from 160% in 2007. Star banking analyst Charlene Chu predicted last year that nonperforming loans will top 20% of total assets during this deleveraging cycle.

This looming bill explains why Beijing’s economic policy is in disarray. Some officials want more stimulus and industrial policy, while others realize that structural reform and less government intervention are key to sustainable growth. In recent months Mr. Xi has endorsed the latter point of view, but as the short-term pain intensifies he will be tempted to return to Keynesian pump-priming that would only postpone the day of reckoning.

I think the characterization I’d use is that they’re late. These are the steps they should have taken a decade ago:

  • Divest state-owned enterprises
  • Live up to the obligations they assumed when they joined the WTO, particularly with respect to their banking system.
  • Stop subsidizing exports and limiting imports.

If they had started this process a decade ago, the SOEs would not have been as large as they are now, there wouldn’t have been so much air in the economy, their trading partners would have been stronger, and there wouldn’t have been nearly as far to fall.

But China’s leaders had conflicting objectives. They wanted to hold onto their own wealth and power, they wanted China to be more prosperous, and they wanted China’s economy to be the largest in the world. Their dilatory behavior has placed all of those at risk.

2 comments