Strike Two

Tomorrow Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner is scheduled to give the second “State of the State” message of his term of office. Would anyone care to bet that the commentary that will be written or pronounced afterwards could just as well have been written or said before the speech?

He faces a state that is facing economic decline and dwindling population with a legislature with veto-proof Democratic majorities in both houses that are determined to fight his every initiative tooth and nail for any number of reasons not the least being his emphasis on reducing the power of Illinois’s public employees’ unions.

The state is going on nine months without a budget. Gov. Rauner has said he won’t sign an unconstitutionally unbalanced budget and wants some action on his priorities. The legislature has refused to enact a balanced budget and won’t have any part of his priorities.

Good times.

2 comments

The Wheat from the Chaff

Sometimes you’ve got to read a lot of op-ed to find a few sentences that are worth considering. I found these acorns in a Wall Street Journal op-ed from Gerald O’Driscoll, Jr.:

The Fed’s monetary policy of extraordinarily low interest rates helped create the asset bubbles in stock and commodity prices that are now bursting. Low rates also distorted investment decisions.

The second sentence isn’t at all controversial. That’s exactly what Fed policy over the last eight years has been intended to do. And the first sentence flows from the second. When you combine excess Chinese demand with what’s called “accommodating” Fed policy, you get a commodities bubble. That’s a lot of deadweight loss.

I don’t think the foreign debt China owes is likely to be troublesome for China. No one knows how much it is but it’s probably a drop in the bucket compared to the $28 trillion of debt in the country.

It will be more difficult for other, smaller economies.

Meanwhile, IMO in the long run the deadweight loss will probably be more problematic but in the short run foreign debt is more likely to cause the global “meltdown” the op-ed is purportedly about.

1 comment

Debt and Taxes

Unsurprisingly, Illinois Senate President John Cullerton and Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel have rejected the idea of the the state taking over the Chicago Public Schools out of hand:

Illinois Senate President John Cullerton says in a statement that the plan backed by Gov. Bruce Rauner is “mean spirited and evidence of their total lack of knowledge of the real problems facing Chicago Public Schools.”

Cullerton says the “ridiculous” idea is distracting Republican leaders from other state issues.

The nation’s third-largest school district is facing a nearly $1 billion budget deficit, due largely to pension debt.

and

A spokeswoman for Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel says he is “100 percent opposed” to a plan from Republicans in the Illinois Legislature that would have the state take over the financially troubled Chicago Public Schools.

Spokeswoman Kelley Quinn says if GOP Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner wanted to help Chicago students he would pass a state budget that “fully funds education and treats CPS students like every other child in the state.”

I understand where they’re coming from but I wish that President Cullerton and Mayor Emanuel had proposals other than the state issuing blank checks and continuing the same old process of endlessly increasing debt and taxes.

More than anything else Illinois and Chicago need economic growth. I’m missing how increasing the debt overhang and the tax burden will effect that.

1 comment

Fighting Back

This story from the Orlando Sentinel was brought to my attention by a regular commenter yesterday. It seems that a number of former Disney IT workers have filed a class action suit against Disney and Disney’s outsourcing companies for H-1B violations:

Two former Walt Disney World tech employees filed federal lawsuits against the company Monday, accusing it and two outsourcing firms of conspiring to replace workers with less costly foreign ones using H-1B visas.

The lawsuits were filed in federal court, in the Middle District of Florida, by Leo Perrero and Dena Moore, who were among 250 Disney tech workers laid off about a year ago. The lawsuits seek class-action status.

Defendants include HCL Inc. and Cognizant Technologies.

Sara Blackwell, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said the lawsuits aim to “kick them [outsourcing companies] at their business model, to stop them from systemically abusing the immigration system.”

Maybe I’m underestimating their case but I think it’s going to be hard for the plaintiffs to prevail. A good proposal writer can make a case for practically anything, i.e. that re-aligning qualifications to require new employees is an absolute necessity.

2 comments

The Dilemma

Reported by RT:

A police patrol of 10 officers was forced to flee a refugee center in Sweden after being surrounded by a mob of violent migrants. Law enforcement officials had arrived to relocate a 10-year-old boy after reports of his repeated rape at the facility.

One of the officers described what had happened in a police report obtained by the Vestmanlands Läns Tidning newspaper.

“Even more people appeared behind us. I was mentally prepared to fight for my life. We were 10 police officers in a narrow corridor. And I hear someone yell that there is an emergency exit,” the officer said.

The incident took place in the Signalisten asylum in Västerås last Wednesday but police didn’t provide any information to the press until Monday this week.

Decisions, decisions. More police. Fewer migrants. More police. Fewer migrants. Maybe both.

It does bring up a big difference between guilt cultures and shame cultures. It takes a lot more law enforcement to keep order in shame cultures than it does in guilt cultures.

9 comments

How Not to Manage Europe’s Refugee Emergency

The editors at Bloomberg do a pretty fair job of summarizing the proposals that are on the table for the EU to deal with the refugee crisis that Angela Merkel created and their shortcomings:

At least three proposals are being discussed. The first is to end the EU’s so-called Dublin rule, which requires the first EU nation in which an asylum-seeker sets foot to take the application. This hardly seems worth debating: The Dublin rule has already been repealed by force of events.

A second proposal is for EU nations to set refugee quotas. Horst Seehofer, leader of Germany’s Christian Social Union party, has been trying to press this approach on Chancellor Angela Merkel. And Austria recently said it would set its own cap on the number of asylum applications it will accept in 2016, at 37,500 (compared with 90,000 last year).

The problem with this is easy to see: What happens to genuine refugees who are turned away? Will other countries be willing to take up the slack? More likely the opposite: The pressure will mount on other governments to accept fewer people. The spurned refugees won’t go home, so one way or another they will remain Europe’s problem. Shunted from place to place, their distress will be compounded, and Europe’s citizens will be no happier.

Denmark advocates a third idea. It wants to rewrite the 1951 Refugee Convention so it would no longer be possible for people fleeing the Syrian war to spend time in the relative safety of Turkish or Lebanese refugee camps and then claim asylum in the EU. In principle, there’s some logic to this, but again it’s impractical. Lebanon already has one refugee for every four inhabitants. Turkey is host to more Syrian refugees than the 28 nations of the EU combined. Neither country will agree to a treaty change that eases the burden on rich nations at their expense. Nor should they.

but their alternative proposal borders on lunacy:

It should spend far more on helping countries such as Lebanon provide a haven for refugees. (Governments are providing the United Nations with barely half of what’s needed.) It should create a greatly expanded resettlement program, so that refugees in countries such as Turkey can be vetted for a safe and orderly move to the EU. It should collectively secure the bloc’s outer borders, so sea crossings to Greece and Italy become less attractive to attempt. Once all that is in hand, it should regard accepting the refugees who do arrive as a joint responsibility, and strive to spread the burden equitably.

Europe is a rich continent, of 500 million people. It can accommodate more of Syria’s refugees. Indeed, in the longer term, it can benefit from having them. Leaders should be mindful of their citizens’ concerns and not deny the short-term stresses or the longer-term challenges of integration, but it’s their job to drive the larger message home. Here too, as long as they act together, they can do it.

First, the Germans will never go for it. Open any German newspaper and you’ll see what the Germans want: quotas (alternative #2 above). The Germans’ preferred strategy is nuts, too. It doesn’t matter what Hungary’s or Slovakia’s or Estonia’s quota is. The migrants want to go to Germany or Sweden and that’s where they’ll go.

Second, does anybody really believe that tiny, teetering Lebanon can accommodate more than a tiny fraction of the number of refugees that are streaming across the border?

Here’s my alternative proposal. Pay the Turks a lot to keep the refugees. By “a lot” I mean at least €7,000 per refugee. Inspect the camps to make sure the Turks are treating the migrants humanely. Dangle the carrot of EU membership before the Turks’ noses. Stop paying if the Turks aren’t living up to their part of the bargain and keeping the migrants within Turkey.

My prediction is that the flood of migrants will stop miraculously.

4 comments

Too Soon—Old;Too Late—Shmart

In his column at Bloomberg, Noah Smith notes that economists seem to be rethinking the advice they gave 20 years ago:

Ask any economist what issue they agree on, and the first answer you’re likely to hear is “free trade is good.” The general public disagrees vehemently, but economists are almost unanimous on this point.

But look at actual economics research, and you will find a very different picture. The most recent example is a paper by celebrated labor economists David Autor, David Dorn and Gordon Hanson, titled “The China Shock: Learning from Labor Market Adjustment to Large Changes in Trade.” The study shows that increased trade with China caused severe and permanent harm to many American workers:

Adjustment in local labor markets is remarkably slow, with wages and labor-force participation rates remaining depressed and unemployment rates remaining elevated for at least a full decade after the China trade shock commences. Exposed workers experience greater job churning and reduced lifetime income. At the national level, employment has fallen in U.S. industries more exposed to import competition…but offsetting employment gains in other industries have yet to materialize.

Autor, et al. show powerful evidence that industries and regions that have been more exposed to Chinese import competition since 2000 — the year China joined the World Trade Organization — have been hit hard and have not recovered. Workers in these industries and regions don’t go on to better jobs, or even similar jobs in different industries. Instead, they shuffle from low-paid job to low-paid job, never recovering the prosperity they had before Chinese competition hit. Many of them end up on welfare. This is very different from earlier decades, when workers who lost their jobs to import competition usually went into higher-productivity industries, to the benefit of almost everyone.

Let’s examine that a little more closely. First, we have never had a free trade agreement with China and I would be happy to bet that we never will have. We have had a system of trade in which the Chinese were largely free to trade here while they preserved their system of autarky over there. Call it “one-way autarky”. India does the same thing.

Second, I defy anyone to find in anything that the 19th century economist David Ricardo said or wrote that even suggested that managed trade brought the benefits he attributed to free trade in his On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation in which he laid out the principles of comparative advantage.

Let me explain the remarks I made about my yardstick for trade agreements a tad more. Imagine that a trade agreement will result in $1 trillion of additional U. S. GDP and every penny of that $1 trillion will go to Warren Buffett while several million Americans lose their jobs. Should we approve such an agreement? Look at all of the increased GDP! I dare say that only Warren Buffett and, possibly, a few of the people to whose causes he contributes would vote for such a plan.

How about if the $1 trillion were to go to 10 people? How about 100 people? 1,000? 10,000? That’s almost precisely what we’ve done over the period of the last 30 years.

Doing business with China has always been a risky venture. It’s not, as you might have read in the opinion pages, a country with more than a billion prospective customers. To be a customer you must have the ability and desire to pay, called “willingness to pay” in the trade. Most Chinese don’t have that. China is a country with, probably, a couple of hundred thousand prospective customers.

I opposed granting China Most Favored Nation trading status. I opposed China being given permanent membership in the WTO. Don’t blame me.

7 comments

The High Bar

Over at Moody’s Analytics Adam Ozimek writes about economists’ reconsideration of the net value of trade:

While some politicians think that the answer to the costs of trade lies in tariffs or in subsidies to struggling industries, those ideas ignore the net benefits of trade and risk imposing costs by just delaying the inevitable. There is also the risk that political considerations could make these programs poorly targeted and protective of unproductive or uncompetitive firms.

However, there are better options. Policies should be aimed at re-employing those who lose jobs to trade. There are costs for pursuing such policies, but the evidence from David Autor, David Dorn, and Gordon Hanson shows that the employment losses themselves cost money. The following chart from their study shows that each $1,000 in Chinese imports per U.S. worker increases the cost of government benefits by $57.73. It is worrisome that these costs show up in disability benefits and retirement benefits, suggesting permanent, not temporary, labor market losses. Trade Adjustment Assistance, which is meant to help those who have been harmed by trade, is a smaller cost than disability benefits.

Let’s not confuse the situation with handwaving about free trade. We haven’t enacted a free trade agreement in my lifetime. What we have enacted are managed trade agreements and those, necessarily and intentionally, help some people at the expense of others.

The yardstick I use is that any trade agreement must help more than it hurts and it must help more people than it hurts. How high a hurdle is that? The top 1% is about a million households, the top .l% 100,000 households, the top .01% 10,000 households, and so on. You be the judge.

7 comments

The Spoiler

In his Wall Street Journal column yesterday James Taranto argued that former New York City Mayor (and present media billionaire) Michael Bloomberg a) can’t win the presidency; b) is very liberal by national standards; and c) could well tip the election to Trump in a Trump-Clinton-Bloomberg three-way presidential match.

If Davos and Aspen were states, Bloomberg would easily carry their six electoral votes. Could he carry, say, New York state? Maybe, but one can also imagine a scenario in which he makes it possible for Trump to do so with a plurality. That’s how Jim Buckley got to the Senate in 1970 and Al D’Amato a decade later.

The Bloomberg base usually votes Democratic in presidential elections, so that the result of an independent bid would be to fracture the Democratic coalition, putting blue states in play, while leaving the Republican coalition largely intact. Unless, of course, he were able to broaden his appeal somehow. But our sense of Bloomberg is that he has too much integrity (or, to put it less charitably, is too stubborn) to adjust his views on abortion, gun control and other hot buttons out of political expediency.

Given such a choice, I’d vote for Bloomberg. I guess I’m part of the problem.

1 comment

The Void

We’re going through one of the those fallow periods. There’s lots of news but not a great deal of commentary. Either everybody has said everything they have to say or they’ve said everything they dare say.

Or their nice, comfortable narratives don’t conform to the actual events on the ground.

13 comments