The Kauffman Foundation on Business Startups

I would like to think that the findings of the Kauffman Foundation, that the lower labor force participation rate we’ve seen since the end of the Great Recession results in fewer business startups, are correct:

The current U.S. labor force stands at a little under 158 million people, which represents a labor force participation rate of 62.6 percent (a tick up from October 2015, which was the lowest level in 30 years). Importantly, the growth of the labor force remained relatively flat for approximately 20 years until declining markedly since the Great Recession.

In both papers, the authors contend that the slowing growth rate of the labor force had negative consequences for startups because the startup rate is particularly sensitive to the labor supply. However, this slowing rate does not affect incumbent firm dynamics. With a reduction in startups, there are fewer new jobs because new and young firms are responsible for the vast majority of all net new jobs. This tightening of the labor market in turn shifts employment into incumbent firms. Incumbent firms grow stronger as a result, and the economic environment for startups worsens.

but it’s very difficult for me to believe that the causality doesn’t go in the opposite direction—that the drop in the LFPR is due to the small number of startups, i.e. there just aren’t enough jobs.

4 comments

Shuffling the Deck Chairs—TPP Edition

The most thorough independent review of the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement to date from the Peterson Institute has found that

  1. the agreement would result in no net job creation
  2. the agreement would result in wage increases
  3. the agreement would result in substantial job losses every year

A Pacific Rim trade deal championed by the Obama administration represents a “landmark accord” that would yield considerable economic gains for the United States and 11 other nations, boosting exports by 9 percent a year and increasing wages, according to an analysis released Monday.

But the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) would not increase job creation overall, and it could force 50,000 U.S. workers each year to find new jobs, a process that might require them to pursue new training, the nonpartisan Peterson Institute for International Economics said in its report.

Those workers, mostly in low-wage manufacturing, “may experience serious transition costs including lasting wage cuts and unemployment,” economists Peter A. Petri and Michael G. Plummer wrote.

If the list of their board of directors is any gauge, the Peterson Institute is not a partisan outlet. They sound like square shooters.

This is not convincing me to support the agreement. In the present environment of low job creation with the preponderance of jobs being created low wage jobs it just doesn’t sound like a particularly good deal. It’ll be good for somebody but not for most of us.

As I’ve been saying all along, managed trade bills are not about free trade. They’re always about picking winners and losers.

7 comments

Why Is There an Opioid Epidemic?

I don’t think I buy Laudan Aron’s explanation for the opioid epidemic in the United States, as expressed in her post at RealClearPolicy. In essence she blames it pharmaceutical companies and their diabolically effective advertising campaigns:

he sharpest increases in opioid use began in 1996, exactly one year after Purdue Pharma introduced OxyContin, an extended release form of oxycodone. Purdue Pharma’s activities culminated in a policy decision to make pain the “5th Vital Sign” to raise awareness about identifying and treating pain in clinical settings, along with the help of smiley faces for pain rating scales. Many groups and organizations were on board: the American Pain Society, the American Academy of Pain Medicine, the Federation of State Medical Boards, The Joint Commission (which accredits hospitals), as well as pain patient groups. But there was no central coordinating entity paying attention to the effects of these changes on community or population health, or to possible unintended consequences.

I don’t deny that there’s been an enormous increase in the use of opioids or that companies have advertised them or that straight to consumer advertising of pharmaceuticals places stresses on physicians. I’d add another explanation: the increasing treatment of patients as customers. “Give the Lady What She Wants!” is a perfectly good slogan for a department store but not for physicians. In states that have tightened up on prescription painkillers (like Florida) the rate of opioid abuse has gone down, too.

Attitudes probably play a role as well. Emotions, including agitation, emotional pain, regret, and sorrow, used to be thought of as normal, ordinary parts of life rather than something to be medicated away.

7 comments

Unions, Public Employee Pensions, and Willingness to Pay

I actually agree with a lot of what’s in Catherine Fisk and Brian Olney’s article in On Labor, “Public Employee Unions and Pensions”. It’s a pretty good backgrounder on public employees, pensions, and how we got where we are, if one-sided. Here’s the kernel of their point:

Pension shortfalls do not pose an immediate crisis for states under budgetary pressures for the same reason a homeowner need not pay the entire balance of her mortgage together with the month’s bills. Current accounting rules allow states to specify an extended period (typically thirty years) to pay off or “amortize” liabilities. Some studies have estimated that state and local governments can fully fund their pension plans by increasing their annual contributions over the next thirty years. Alternatively or in addition, states can address shortfalls through modest changes to employee contributions or benefits, as most states have already done.

Unfortunately, dealing in generalities as the article does obscures real problems. What I’d like them to explain is where Chicago is going to get the half billion dollars that the state of Illinois requires the city to pay into its pension fund this year? And where it’s going to get the future payments the state has mandated?

For me the bottom line is that total compensation for public employees, regardless of who they are or what they do or what they might earn in the private sector (if there were private sector jobs for them to fill), must be constrained to the ability of the communities they serve to pay. You can pontificate as much as you care to about the history and efficiency but that’s where the wheel hits the road.

2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

How We Got Here and Where We’re Going

If you’re interested in that sort of thing, over at RealClearMarkets Jeffrey Snider’s article does a deep dive into banking history, weaving together themes of interest rates, exchange rates, inflation, and employment to arrive at a single conclusion: the Fed’s policies have been absurd. Here is his peroration:

If this year turns out the way it is already shaping up, can you really not imagine Janet Yellen (or her successor, assuming she doesn’t survive the growing debacle) doing the same as the Bank of Japan? There has already been a steady growth of stories and rumors, all emanating carefully from that policy corridor, of intellectual flirtations with negative interest rates. Not only that, the FOMC in June 2003, just as Greenspan was achieving his “ultra-low”, ridiculed the Bank of Japan for its first two (of ten or eleven, depending on how you count) QE’s – only to follow them almost exactly just five years later.

Central bank measures have, again, become increasingly absurd; everywhere they have been so has been only further deprived of true and sustainable economic growth. I won’t waste your time here revisiting the subject of this “recovery” as there is no longer any point to reciting the catalog of woe. The reconciliation of this disparity is simply reputation alone. Volcker’s goodwill still lingers in the institutional sense even if Greenspan as “maestro” has more and more rotted. It is all the more frustrating that such reputation was given in the first place, unearned as it really was.

Central planning never works and the episode of 1969 demonstrates exactly why; bureaucracies cannot cope with dynamic conditions. When faced with those, bureaucracies instead react hostilely (if not in outright denial), searching for a way to induce or maintain stasis and sclerosis so that control and power become the dominant goal in religious proportions. There is no more dynamic surface than banking, especially banking freed from the strictures of money.

Thus, the more dynamic that seeps out or leaks into function beyond the self-narrowed gaze and limited apprehension of the central bank, the more absurd lengths the central bank must take to project, even if only to itself, its domination on only its own terms. Last month, the current incarnation of the FOMC took once more to the federal funds rate even though there is nobody there because that is what they do and that is what shall rule. This drastic misplacement was apparent before the first QE or the first FOMC vote on ZIRP; it was all right there in at least March 2007, Bernanke seated in front of Congress full of self-righteous arrogance. That, too, had become something of a quasi-currency. The more he expressed what was just plain wrong but couched in the soothing tones of Volcker-type confidence, the more the world just bought it – and headed right over the cliff.

My concern is that with all of the backstops, subsidies, and incentives, bankers have forgotten how the banking industry works or at least worked. And now we’ve returned to the old standby topic: deadweight loss. We can only tolerate so much deadweight loss. There are limits.

2 comments

The End of the Creed

I want to commend Peter Berkowitz’s recent post at RealClearPolitics to your attention. Here are the opening paragraphs:

Contrasting positions on American exceptionalism go to the heart of what distinguishes the 2016 Republican presidential field from its Democratic counterpart.

However much they disagree among themselves, the pronounced tendency among Republicans—particularly Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio—is to celebrate the spirit and forms of constitutional self-government that have historically set America apart.

In contrast, Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders, like President Obama, are inclined to call attention to America’s flaws and failures stretching back to the nation’s founding. Inspired by a doctrine that treats unequal outcomes as evidence of political deficiency, they seek to ensure equality of result through extensive government supervision of the economy and substantial provision of entitlements—and to look to Europe for models of how to enlarge the regulatory and social welfare state.

I don’t think he has that quite right. Conservatives look to the past, real or imagined. They love America for what they think it is or has been. Progressives have their eyes firmly fixed on the future. They love America for what it might become rather than for what it is.

Both will always be disappointed. The past and present will never live up to the imagined past and present. And with their focus on the future, for progressives present day America will always fall short.

A century ago in his essay “What I Saw in America” G. K. Chesterton noted that America is a country founded on a creed. That is our distinction, our exceptionalism. I’m not sure that anyone believes in that creed anymore and without that America is nothing.

5 comments

Taking Sides

In an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, Republican Party apparatchik Michael Mukasey remarks on the ongoing drip, drip of revelations about Hillary Clinton’s use and abuse of her rogue email server:

The current news, reported in the Journal and elsewhere, is that her server contained information at the highest level of classification, known as SAP, or Special Access Program. This is a level so high that even the inspector general for the intelligence community who reported the discovery did not initially have clearance to examine it.

The server also contained messages showing her contempt for classification procedures. This was bred at least in part by obvious familiarity with exactly “how it works”—such as when, an email shows, she directed a staff member simply to erase the heading on a classified document, converting it into “unpaper,” and send it on a “nonsecure” device.

Information disclosed by the State Department also reflects that in August 2011, when the State Department’s executive secretary suggested that he could provide Mrs. Clinton with a BlackBerry that would keep her identity secret but might generate communications that would be discoverable under the Freedom of Information Act, Huma Abedin, Mrs. Clinton’s closest aide, intervened and said the idea “doesn’t make a whole lot of sense.”

concluding:

The FBI’s criminal investigation of messages on the server initially related solely to Mrs. Clinton’s possibly unlawful mishandling of classified information. The investigation has now metastasized to include “the possible intersection of Clinton Foundation donations, the dispensation of State Department contracts and whether regular processes were followed” as Fox News’s Catherine Herridge reported Jan. 19, quoting an intelligence source.

Which is to say, the FBI wants to know whether those messages, combined with other evidence, show that donors to the Clinton Foundation received special consideration in their dealings with the agency Mrs. Clinton headed.

Whatever the findings from that part of the probe, intelligence-community investigators believe it is nearly certain that Mrs. Clinton’s server was hacked, possibly by the Chinese or the Russians. This raises the distinct possibility that she would be subject to blackmail in connection with those transactions and whatever else was on that server by people with hostile intent against this country.

No criminality can be charged against Mrs. Clinton in connection with any of this absent proof that she had what the law regards as a guilty state of mind—a standard that may differ from one statute to another, depending on what criminal act is charged.

Yet—from her direction that classification rules be disregarded, to the presence on her personal email server of information at the highest level of classification, to her repeated falsehoods of a sort that juries are told every day may be treated as evidence of guilty knowledge—it is nearly impossible to draw any conclusion other than that she knew enough to support a conviction at the least for mishandling classified information.

I’m afraid that this is wishful thinking:

The simple proposition that everyone is equal before the law suggests that Mrs. Clinton’s state of mind—whether mere knowledge of what she was doing as to mishandling classified information; or gross negligence in the case of the mishandling of information relating to national defense; or bad intent as to actual or attempted destruction of email messages; or corrupt intent as to State Department business—justifies a criminal charge of one sort or another.

But will it be brought? That depends in part on the recommendation of FBI Director James Comey, a man described by President Obama, at the time the president appointed him, as “fiercely independent.” If no recommendation to charge is forthcoming, or if such a recommendation is made but not followed by the attorney general, what happens then?

Would the public stand for it? My guess is not. However, my guess is also that we won’t be put to that test because our public officials will do their duty.

Everyone already seems to have taken sides and the facts be damned. Hillary Clinton’s supporters will dismiss Mr. Mukasey’s remarks or those of anyone else as partisan-inspired lies. Sec. Clinton is already attributing FBI actions to her perennial bugaboo, the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy, regardless of the party affiliation or politics of those involved. As far as those who oppose Sec. Clinton are concerned, it all merely confirms what we’ve believed all along.

There are already prima facie cases against Sec. Clinton in this matter for violations of the Records Act, the Freedom of Information Act, the Hatch Act, perjury, and conspiracy. That so many Americans are able to dismiss these out of hand makes me believe that equality under the law and, indeed, the rule of law are dead as a doornail.

20 comments

There’s a Difference

I found George Will’s most recent column in the Washington Post on the Chinese economy interesting enough. Here’s a snippet that bears mentioning:

China consumes almost half the world’s cement, coal, iron ore and steel, and 40 percent of the aluminum and copper. Beijing has six ring roads, and the seventh, under construction, will be almost 600 miles long, encompassing an area as large as Indiana. (Washington’s Capital Beltway is 64 miles long.) Demand for roads so exceeds supply that a 2010 traffic jam extended 62 miles and lasted 12 days. China has six of the world’s 15 tallest buildings (the United States has three) and eight of the 10 tallest under construction. In four years, beginning in 2011, the government built enough housing to shelter the population of the 12th most populous nation, the Philippines. Two months after the September 2014 $25 billion initial public offering for the Chinese Internet company Alibaba, the world’s biggest IPO, the company had a $280 billion market capitalization, bigger than Amazon and eBay combined.

China’s prosperity has been fueled by the traditional modernization trek of people from the countryside to cities — 300 million so far, with another 300 million by 2030. But China has also relied perilously on exports and excessive, grossly inefficient infrastructure spending to employ the former peasants and make burgeoning metropolises habitable. Just between 2010 and June 2013, local government debt alone surged 70 percent to $2.9 trillion.

I think the Chinese Communist Party is a sorrow for China and, increasingly, an impediment to its growth but I don’t fret over it the way Mr. Will seems to. There’s a big difference between the CCP and Soviet communism. After about 1930 Soviet communism was nothing more than a stalking horse for Russian imperialism. The authoritarian thugs of the CCP have always been about enriching themselves and their families and holding on to power within China. I don’t see the Chinese as expansionist.

What does worry me is its unfathomably enormous size, illustrated in the first paragraph quoted above. That’s not a threat to us in any meaningful sense but it is a threat to other countries trying to grow beyond subsistence agriculture. As I said in a previous post China’s gargantuan overcapacity means that they’ve climbed the economic ladder and pulled it up behind them.

Back in the earlier days of this blog I would fairly frequently point out the substantial overcapacity in the auto industry. Basically, eight years ago there was enough productive capacity in automobiles to satisfy any foreseeable world demand for autos and countries like China, India, and Brazil were still building auto plants. I found and continue to find the deadweight loss frightening.

China now has that sort of deadweight loss in any number of industries. I honestly don’t see how we’re going to dig ourselves out of the hole they’ve dug for us.

9 comments

Will Public Employees Go On Strike in Illinois?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal comment on the contract negotiations in Illinois between AFSCME and the state, i.e. the governor:

Although the union’s contract expired last summer, a “tolling agreement” means the previous contract’s terms continue until a new contract is signed. That gives union leaders little incentive to bargain in good faith. Mr. Rauner has made deals with other unions, including the Teamsters, and he recently said he’d start a merit-pay system for state workers, giving them a chance to earn bonuses. But Afscme rejected the idea, calling bonuses based on “subjective” criteria “tone-deaf and heartless.”

Afscme leaders prefer the status quo, in which union clout matters more than worker performance. That has been costly for Illinois taxpayers. Between 2005 and 2014, Afscme base salaries increased 49%, to an average base of $66,582 in 2014 from $44,583 in 2005. That cost the state some $3.5 billion more than it would have if salaries had grown at the rate of inflation. State pension obligations to Afscme workers have also grown at an unsustainable pace in the high-tax, slow-growth Illinois economy.

If the labor board rules that contract negotiations are at an impasse, Mr. Rauner will make a final offer and the union will vote on it. If Afscme rejects the deal, the union would go on strike, a less than appealing option since Afscme lacks a strike fund to cover salaries. The union strategy is to break Mr. Rauner or wait him out until the next Democratic Governor arrives. Mr. Rauner isn’t blinking despite seven months without a state budget, and at this point he can’t afford to without letting down the taxpayers who elected him in 2014.

Note those figures in the second paragraph. Base salaries have increased 49% over ten years in which inflation has been notably low, at least official inflation. But that ain’t the half of it. The number of AFSCME state employees has risen by 17% since 2008. And most Illinois public employees still have defined benefit retirement contracts, something that has all but vanished from the private sector and which the state is powerless to change due to provisions in the state constitution. Increasing salaries means bigger pensions, too.

Look, I get it. Most of Illinois’s AFSCME employees aren’t eligible for extravagant pensions but there is such a thing as economic reality. State, county, and city governments depend on three things for revenue: incomes, real estate values, and retail sales. Growth in all of those has been tepid in Illinois. The contracts were negotiated when the economic landscape for the state looks a heckuva lot different than it does now.

We really need a change from the status quo. The borrow and tax strategy that’s been used for the last couple of decades (if not longer) just doesn’t cut it any more.

3 comments