In his most recent column in the Washington Post George Will gets one of the important economic lessons right:
If there is going to be growth-igniting tax reform — and if there isn’t, American politics will sink deeper into distributional strife — Brady will begin it. Fortunately, the Houston congressman is focused on this simple arithmetic: Three percent growth is not 1 percent better than 2 percent growth, it is 50 percent better.
If the Obama era’s average annual growth of 2.2 percent becomes the “new normal,†over the next 50 years real gross domestic product will grow from today’s $16.3 trillion (in 2009 dollars) to $48.3 trillion. If, however, growth averages 3.2 percent, real GDP in 2065 will be $78.6 trillion. At 2.2 percent growth, the cumulative lost wealth would be $521 trillion.
and that is the power of compound interest. Small differences over time can make an enormous difference. But he fluffs the other:
Trump, who works himself into a lather because Nabisco is making some Oreo cookies outside the country, is obsessed with the United States’ trade with China. “We’re going to get Apple to start building their damn computers and things in this country,†he says, aiming to raise the price Americans pay for Apple products that today are assembled in China, which, according to trade attorney Scott Lincicome, makes about $6 by assembling an iPhone from parts (many of which China has imported).
Trump favors a 45 percent tariff to protect customers of Walmart and similar retailers from the onslaught of inexpensive Chinese apparel, appliances and food. He can explain the glorious privilege of paying taxes-as-tariffs when he makes his next visit to a Walmart, perhaps the one in Secaucus, N.J., just seven miles from his Fifth Avenue penthouse.
which is absurd. If you make the tariffs on bringing iPhones into the U. S. from China high enough, it won’t result Apple paying huge tariffs and increasing the price of an iPhone by 45%. Using Mr. Will’s figures, Apple nets about $6 per unit by assembling iPhones in China. According to IHS as cited at Forbes it’s more like $8.
The price of an iPhone is about $300. I don’t think increasing that price by $8 will result in any lost sales for Apple but imagine that it would. What would it be? 1%? Raising those tariffs will result in Apple assembling iPhones here rather than in China.
That would mean an extra $2 billion in wages that would go to American workers rather than to a handful of people who own a lot of Apple stock. Those people are already multi-millionaires. I honestly don’t care whether they divvy up that $2 billion among them or not. Overwhelmingly, they won’t take that 2 bil and invest it in more U. S. plants which would create U. S. jobs. They’ll invest overseas (creating jobs there) or in financial assets which creates practically no jobs.
So here’s the other lesson: what is done with the money derived from trade matters. When the factors of production are themselves transportable (as is overwhelmingly the case today) comparative advantage no longer applies. Only absolute advantage does.
We shouldn’t care about gross domestic product. We should care about median income.