The Graph

There is a fabulous graph attached to Nat Silver’s post at Five Thirty Eight pouring water on the hopes of Sanders supporters. It illustrates by state the share of primary and caucus voters from 2008 who were both white and liberal. It’s too large or I’d, er, sample it.

As Alec Trebek might say I’ll put it in the form of a question: what is one thing that makes Vermont, New Hampshire, Iowa, and Massachusetts different from every other state in the Union? How about Oregon, Utah, Connecticut, Rhode Island, and (of all places) Montana?

If you’re taking your lead from those states, I suggest a radical re-think.

I’m a little less skeptical about Sanders’s chances than I think that Nate is. Oh, I still think he’s a long shot. But the scenario goes something like this.

Sanders wins Iowa and New Hampshire. The big donors desert Clinton in droves and the media pundits start dumping on Clinton in earnest. Turnout is extremely low in South Carolina.

Hillary Clinton’s support has always been a mile wide and an inch deep.

4 comments

The Answer

I had the greatest of difficulty in getting past the slug that followed the title of Stephen Walt’s recent article in Foreign Policy. The title is “The United States Should Admit It No Longer Has a Middle East Policy”. Here’s the slug:

If the current — and future — U.S. administration wants to battle the Islamic State, save Syria, and keep ties with Israel, it’s got to ditch the Cold War playbook.

The reason I had a problem getting past that slug is that I don’t think anything of those things have the vital interest that most Americans seem to which I gather is Mr. Walt’s point. Here’s how he characterizes the effects of U. S. Middle East policy over the last 25 years:

If you can stand it, just look at the record: 1) “Dual containment” in the Gulf helped convince bin Laden to launch the 9/11 attacks; 2) two decades of U.S. stewardship over the Israeli-Palestinian “peace process” has killed off the “two-state solution” that Washington favored; 3) the invasion of Iraq in 2003 was a policy blunder of vast proportions whose ill effects continue to multiply; 4) U.S. interference in Libya, Somalia, and Yemen helped create failed states there, too; and 5) Washington has not exactly covered itself in glory in Syria either. Given that record, it is hardly surprising that Americans and Middle Easterners openly question what the U.S. role should be and why some of us think trying to “manage” the Middle East is a fool’s errand.

Let’s consider those objectives again. Why are we interested in DAESH? IMO only the fear that they’ll foment terrorist activity domestically here in the United States. There are other ways to address that than making war on pickup trucks and mortar emplacements in the Middle East. We’ve already spent billions fighting DAESH and if we keep along our present path not only will we spend billions more but willy nilly we’ll be fighting them with the notorious “boots on the ground”.

As long as Islam is Islam (sola scriptura, condoning of violence against non-believers within the actual texts, lack of a magisterium) there will be halfwits promoting violence in its name. Do we really care what alphabet soup of letters they use as its name?

If by “Syria” you mean a multi-confessional nation-state with more or less secular values, that particular Humpty Dumpty can’t be put together again. Why we’re working as hard as we are to dismember its corpse eludes me. If we really want to save Syria, we’ll get the heck out of the Russians’ way. They’re doing a pretty fair job of saving what’s left.

And I guess I’m really the cheese standing alone on the subject of Israel. I think that John Quincy Adams’s warning of nearly a century ago rings true today: America is the well-wisher of freedom and independence for all but the vindicator and champion only of her own and for precisely the reasons the former president enunciated. Our glory should not be dominion but liberty. Whatever happened to that?

4 comments

Economic Growth in Two Lessons

In his most recent column in the Washington Post George Will gets one of the important economic lessons right:

If there is going to be growth-igniting tax reform — and if there isn’t, American politics will sink deeper into distributional strife — Brady will begin it. Fortunately, the Houston congressman is focused on this simple arithmetic: Three percent growth is not 1 percent better than 2 percent growth, it is 50 percent better.

If the Obama era’s average annual growth of 2.2 percent becomes the “new normal,” over the next 50 years real gross domestic product will grow from today’s $16.3 trillion (in 2009 dollars) to $48.3 trillion. If, however, growth averages 3.2 percent, real GDP in 2065 will be $78.6 trillion. At 2.2 percent growth, the cumulative lost wealth would be $521 trillion.

and that is the power of compound interest. Small differences over time can make an enormous difference. But he fluffs the other:

Trump, who works himself into a lather because Nabisco is making some Oreo cookies outside the country, is obsessed with the United States’ trade with China. “We’re going to get Apple to start building their damn computers and things in this country,” he says, aiming to raise the price Americans pay for Apple products that today are assembled in China, which, according to trade attorney Scott Lincicome, makes about $6 by assembling an iPhone from parts (many of which China has imported).

Trump favors a 45 percent tariff to protect customers of Walmart and similar retailers from the onslaught of inexpensive Chinese apparel, appliances and food. He can explain the glorious privilege of paying taxes-as-tariffs when he makes his next visit to a Walmart, perhaps the one in Secaucus, N.J., just seven miles from his Fifth Avenue penthouse.

which is absurd. If you make the tariffs on bringing iPhones into the U. S. from China high enough, it won’t result Apple paying huge tariffs and increasing the price of an iPhone by 45%. Using Mr. Will’s figures, Apple nets about $6 per unit by assembling iPhones in China. According to IHS as cited at Forbes it’s more like $8.

The price of an iPhone is about $300. I don’t think increasing that price by $8 will result in any lost sales for Apple but imagine that it would. What would it be? 1%? Raising those tariffs will result in Apple assembling iPhones here rather than in China.

That would mean an extra $2 billion in wages that would go to American workers rather than to a handful of people who own a lot of Apple stock. Those people are already multi-millionaires. I honestly don’t care whether they divvy up that $2 billion among them or not. Overwhelmingly, they won’t take that 2 bil and invest it in more U. S. plants which would create U. S. jobs. They’ll invest overseas (creating jobs there) or in financial assets which creates practically no jobs.

So here’s the other lesson: what is done with the money derived from trade matters. When the factors of production are themselves transportable (as is overwhelmingly the case today) comparative advantage no longer applies. Only absolute advantage does.

We shouldn’t care about gross domestic product. We should care about median income.

2 comments

Just Because You Believe It

…does not make it right. I don’t think this assertion from Tucker Carlson:

Clinton begat Bush, who produced Obama, whose lax border policies fueled the rise of Trump.

can be defended on the basis of the facts. If you don’t believe me, compare net Mexican migration under the three presidents. There are reasons to believe that President Obama believes in more or less open legal immigration or to believe that his position is confused or purely political, if you’d prefer, “nuanced”.

I don’t think the “rise of Trump” has anything to do with Democrats at all. I think it’s purely a Republican phenomenon, fueled by the internal contradictions of the present Republican coalition.

17 comments

Dealing With the Zika Virus

I’m glad the editors of the New York Times stepped up to the plate and wrote about the Zika virus:

Regrettably, despite these actions, the World Health Organization seems, once again, to be dozing and has yet to generate a broad and coordinated international response. By coincidence, the W.H.O. executive board is currently meeting in Geneva, so this is the perfect time for the agency to show leadership by convening an emergency committee of experts to take stock of the Zika pandemic and advise the W.H.O. director general, Dr. Margaret Chan, on how best to combat it.

I want to contribute one tiny fact I haven’t seen mentioned in the reports: Brazil is seeing one case of microcephaly for every 850 or so live births. That’s huge. 4,000 cases in a year is about 6,000 instances per year if it were translated to the United States. Do I need to say that the cost of coping with that will be enormous?

From my point of view the highest priority should be given to confirming or refuting the link between the Zika virus and microcephaly in newborns as quickly as we can. There is a test for the Zika virus but it’s not widely distributed and I presume it’s expensive. We should dig into our pockets and pay up. At this point it’s at least 4,000 tests. Time’s a wastin’.

We might start with Koch’s Postulates. The medical community seems to have forgotten them. They’re not perfect but they’re a start.

Update

The JAMA Network has this to say about Zika:

The disease now has “explosive” pandemic potential, with outbreaks in Africa, Southeast Asia, the Pacific Islands, and the Americas.

and this

Brazil has reported nearly 4000 cases of suspected microcephaly in 2015, representing a 20-fold increase from 2010 through 2014.1 Evidence of the virus has been found in the placenta and amniotic fluid of mothers and in the brains of fetuses or newborns. Yet causation between Zika virus and microcephaly is not yet established. On January 15, 2016, Hawaii reported the first domestic case of microcephaly in a newborn whose mother had lived in Brazil. Days later, Florida, Illinois, and Texas reported several infected individuals (some pregnant) after international travel.

As I said above, this should be a very high priority. Pull out the stops.

11 comments

System Failure

I haven’t posted much about the water/health/political problem in Flint, Michigan. At this point I just want to mention one thing. I think it was a system failure. That’s an idea that’s pretty common on the libertarian sites but almost nowhere else.

Did race play a part in the failure? Absolutely. But that’s part of the system failure and unless we start recognizing the nature of the failure we’re going to have a lot more similar or even worse failures.

16 comments

Big Things I Was Right About

In my last post I mentioned that Megan McArdle had thrown down the gauntlet. The challenge she’d made was that it was not enough just to be right about China. I’ll take this opportunity to pay myself on the back. Here are three big things I have been right about over the years:

We were too quick in opening trade with China.

I opposed extending Most Favored Nation trading status to China and I opposed admitting China to the WTO. IMO the entire world needed to open trade with China in a much slower, more measured and measurable fashion than was adopted. I don’t think too many people disagree with that now.

Confucius said, “If your plan is a one year plan, plant rice. If your plan is a ten year plan, plant trees. If your plan is a 100 year plan, teach children.” We should have had a 100 year plan. We had a one year plan.

We should never have invaded Iraq.

Who disagrees with that now? I opposed it from the start not because I’m a pacifist (I’m not) but among other reasons because I was worried about the stability not just of Iraq but of the entire Middle East after we’d overthrown Saddam.

Race relations are still lousy.

Starting 40 years ago, I thought the single most important domestic problem was improving the circumstances of black Americans, the descendants of slaves. My initial opposition to mass immigration was for that reason. It was obvious to me that the new labor force the immigrants would provide would give those with the inclination the opportunity to kick the race problem can down the road yet again.

I don’t write about race much because it’s such an unsatisfying and discouraging topic. It’s still our most pressing domestic problem. Unfortunately, I think it has now become intractable.

Note that in my list I don’t include anything that is at all controversial. There are lots of other things I think I’ve been right about but I’m quite certain I’d get an argument about (the Gulf War, nuclear power, a gas tax, German re-unification, Russia, healthcare reform just to name a few). I’ll try thinking about some things I was wrong about. That’s a harder job. Right now I can only think of one: I thought Barack Obama had a greater ability to learn on the job than turned out to be the case.

15 comments

The New Understanding of China

Following up on an article I posted about earlier, over at Bloomberg Megan McArdle argues that it’s pretty darned understandable if Americans blame China for our own economic woes:

It’s fashionable for columnists to write “I was wrong” pieces, and if this work by Autor et al holds, this will go down as one of the four things I was most mistaken about: the Iraq War, the severity of the financial crisis that followed Lehman’s collapse, the rise of Donald Trump, and now, China trade. It’s been obvious for a while that China has played some role (though not the biggest) in the decline of labor-market opportunities for workers without a college diploma. But the authors suggest that the effect is both bigger, and longer lasting, than I would have predicted. Nor has much seemed to help the adjustment: workers are less mobile than expected, domestic American industries less able to absorb the surplus, particularly among the lower-skilled workers whose human capital was job- and industry-specific.

Free traders — and I include myself — have often sounded too glib about the offsetting benefits of cheap imports. Cheap imports are great. But people value work, and the ability to build some sort of reasonably predictable, stable economic future, more than they do cheap flat-panel televisions. With effects this large, the cost to people who are forced into economic precariousness by permanent labor market changes is larger in human welfare terms than the benefits of affordable electronics.

I don’t think a mea culpa is quite enough under the circumstances. It’s important that Megan understands why she was wrong.

The answer, as she suggests later than the passage I quoted, is that China is a special case because of its size, its politics, its history, and its society. Granting China WTO membership isn’t like granting it to Sierra Leone. There are levers that can be applied to encourage Sierra Leone to change its behavior that simply won’t work with China.

And old China hands have been telling Americans the things that China can be expected to do or not do for decades without much effect. Many of the same lessons apply to India. I wonder if they’ll pay attention now?

However, I do intend to take up the gauntlet that Megan threw down. But I’ll do it in another post.

6 comments

U. S. Politics Is On the Ropes

There’s a good point that emerges in the conversation between Gail Collins and Arthur C. Brooks in the New York Times this morning on the frequently asserted “implosion” of the Republican Party to the effect that both parties have some pretty significant problems. Here’s the kernel of the observation:

I’m not quite ready yet to concede that the Republican Party per se has fundamentally changed, mostly because Donald Trump is an island — an island where all the press has crowded. Most of the other candidates are trying to talk about things besides building walls. And downstream at the state level, the number of Republican governors has expanded to 31 from 19 during the Obama administration. When Republicans win Massachusetts, Maryland and Illinois, you know they are doing something right.

and

But about those governors. It’s true that a number of blue states have Republican governors right now. And New York City has had a lot of Republican mayors. To get elected, they convince voters that they’re basically just thriftier Democrats. It works fine for state and local elections. But I’m deeply dubious that these guys are a pipeline of potential presidential nominees. It’s too hard for them to convince real, hard-core Republicans that they’re reliable.

So I would concede that it’s a weakness for the Democrats not to be developing a bigger farm team of politicians who can get Republicans to vote for them.

But now, having shown my evenhanded spirit, I would point out that the G.O.P.’s local talent isn’t translating well on the presidential stage.

A funny thing happened on the way to both the Democratic and Republican Parties becoming programmatic parties rather than the “catch-all” parties they’ve always been. The Republican Party is on the cusp of becoming a populist party with who knows what implications while the Democratic Party which likes to think of itself as the people’s party can’t manage to muster a presidential candidate who isn’t Caucasian or below the age of 70.

The conclusion I draw from all of this is that party politics, generally, is decadent and I look on whatever is replacing it with a certain amount of foreboding. It certainly looks like the “cult of personality” to me. I’d rather have the party bosses and the smoke-filled rooms.

29 comments

Another Precinct Heard From

There’s a letter to the editor in the Wall Street Journal this morning from Roberta Lynch, Executive Director of the Illinois chapter of AFSCME. In her letter she complains about the WSJ editorial I mentioned on Gov. Rauner, Illinois’s budget impasse, and the negotiations between the state and AFSCME:

It is Gov. Rauner, not our union, who has chosen confrontation over compromise at every turn. More than six months into the fiscal year, state government has no budget because the governor won’t sign one unless legislators first enact his agenda that includes stripping collective bargaining rights [ed. that’s an accurate charge], cutting help for people injured on the job [ed. reforming Workman’s Compensation] and reducing construction workers’ wages [ed. dumping Davis-Bacon wages]. He’s taking the same my-way-or-no-way approach in union contract negotiations, demanding that public-service workers pay double their current costs to keep their health coverage while getting no pay increase for four years.

Now, in keeping with his campaign vow to force public-service workers to bow to his demands by causing a strike instead of negotiating a compromise, the governor has walked away from the bargaining table, declaring an impasse when none exists.

In the governor’s defense that’s not “negotiating in bad faith” as the title given to the letter suggests. It’s being a hard bargainer.

Note, too, the assumptions made by the executive director: that wages should be set by the government or construction workers’ soviet rather than by the forces of supply and demand and that there need be no relationship between what the community is willing to pay and what the workers have a right to demand.

3 comments