The insurance companies offering policies through the Healthcare.gov exchange are continuing to lose money. The editors of the Wall Street Journal provide what I presume is the expected commentary:
While Aetna reduced its ObamaCare losses from what it had previously predicted, the business remained unprofitable in 2015 “and we continue to have serious concerns about the sustainability of the public exchanges,†said CEO Mark Bertolini in a call with analysts.
“Specifically, we remain concerned about the overall stability of the risk pool, including enforcement of standards related to special election period enrollment,†he added. The Department of Health and Human Services has made some helpful changes, “but more needs to be done.†He’s referring, among other things, to the fact that to goose enrollment in the exchanges HHS made it easy for customers to wait until they were sick to buy insurance. This stocks the risk pool with sicker people and disrupts normal insurance actuarial calculations.
In some markets it won’t take a lot of insurance company defections to create havoc. We’ll see what materializes.
There seem to be two conflicting schools of thought on the PPACA: that it was incredibly stupid or that it was fiendishly clever. Both can’t be right. Those who believe it was stupid look at a structure that appears to have been designed to fail and think of it as a mistake. Those who believe it was fiendishly clever look at a structure that appears to have been designed to fail and assume it’s strategic.
I won’t bother linking to any of the various analyses of the outcome of the Iowa caucuses. I have only two points to make. First, it was only remarkable in how unremarkable it was. The candidates with the strongest organizations won both sides. On the Republican side that was the most credible candidate palatable to evangelicals and on the Democratic side it was the candidate who received the most union support.
Second, a lot of money was spent but money didn’t decide the election. Maybe money kept Hillary Clinton’s head above water.
Now on to New Hampshire which I predict will be just as unremarkable as Iowa.
The mayor’s job approval is down by nearly half from a poll conducted in March 2015, when Emanuel was locked in a runoff election with Cook County Commissioner Jesus “Chuy” Garcia. At that time, 52 percent of voters approved of Emanuel’s job performance while 33 percent disapproved. The mayor’s previous low job-approval rating was 35 percent in August 2014, as he prepared his re-election bid.
A year ago, Emanuel was able to boost his approval rating after spending millions of dollars airing a steady stream of TV ads designed to rehabilitate his political image. The success was thanks in large part to African-Americans coming back around. In August 2014, only 26 percent of black voters approved of the mayor’s job performance, but that number jumped to 51 percent during the campaign. Now, in the aftermath of the McDonald shooting, only 20 percent of African-American voters approve of Emanuel’s leadership while a record 71 percent disapproved.
Among Hispanic voters, two-thirds said they don’t like the job Emanuel is doing, while only 23 percent approve. A majority of white voters — 55 percent — also aren’t satisfied with his job performance, while 37 percent approve. Those approval numbers from both groups are record lows for Emanuel in Tribune polling.
Underlying that deep public disapproval is a widespread lack of trust in Emanuel, the poll found.
Overall, 59 percent of city voters said they viewed Emanuel as not honest and trustworthy, including 64 percent of Hispanics, 63 percent of African Americans and 51 percent of whites. Only 27 percent of city voters said they considered the mayor to be honest and trustworthy.
Low as that is it doesn’t really threaten his job yet. For that I think it will need to go into single digits. He still has a couple of years.
As we know from previous elections, polls in Iowa routinely miss the mark, and late surges can produce unexpected results.
There’s a reason for that. The Iowa caucuses are caucuses, not primaries. Well-prepared and organized people can swing the caucuses, especially the Democratic caucuses.
The short version of Dr. Sabato’s remarks is that we’ll soon have our first gauge of whether Trump’s support is real on the Republican side and just how formidable a candidate Sanders actually is on the Democratic one.
By all means read John Kass’s Trib column on Hillary Clinton’s problem in claiming the presidency. Here’s the kernel:
She has experience, yes. She knows politics. She’s a creature of the Democratic establishment, yes. And she’s a survivor.
But she cannot be trusted. People think she’s a liar. Poll after poll reflects this. And so, it does not bode well for a Clinton Restoration.
Sanders has the crowds, the excitement and, though he’s 74, young liberals like him. And Hillary? She’s the establishment candidate. They tolerate her.
There’s an interesting article over at the Beeb you might want to look over. It starts being an article about the imbalance between the sexes among 16-17 year olds in Sweden but it takes a sort of left turn. As it turns out the number of migrants presenting themselves for asylum in Sweden is remarkably skewed towards a) males, b) teenagers, and c) people from Afghanistan and Syria. After examining some of these teenagers a little more closely it turns out that some of them are in their late 20s.
If the truth be told, I suspect that we’d learn that the asylum seekers were from all over the Middle East, North Africa, and West Asia and they’re telling the stories they think need to be told to be granted asylum. There are all sorts of possible explanations for why they skew so heavily male but my own pet theory is that they’re mostly draft dodgers, military deserters, criminals, and present or former terrorists. That would be understandable under the circumstances but not as sympathetic as young families fleeing war.
There’s an uncomfortable truth reflected in this article. How in the heck do you check the bona fides of people from countries where patronymics are used as names and reliable censuses haven’t been conducted for years if ever? In Europe people were forced to adopt permanent surnames coincidentally right about the time that modern states were forming and reliable censuses began to be taken. That’s an interesting story and one I’ve written about before.
I think the sad truth is that the only country that’s really capable of screening asylum seekers is United States and we’re only capable of screening a small number: those who’ve worked with our military and we do that by direct testimony. Yes, that’s the guy. Yes, he worked for us.
As it is Sweden, Denmark, Germany, et al. will end up granting permanent asylum to the guys who tell the best sob story. In my cynical view those will skew heavily towards criminals and terrorists but we’ll see. It will be a learning experience for all involved.
Thankfully, there’s a way out of this mess. Let the Fed keep interest rates and the dollar stable. No more tightening. Meanwhile, the Republican Congress can pass a significant tax cut for large and small businesses. Push the rate down to 15 percent for C-corps and S-corps. Provide easy repatriation of U.S. money overseas. And permit immediate tax write-offs for new-business-investment expenses.
Congress could also push for reduced regulatory burdens, although it looks like there’s no stopping the Obama administration’s unconstitutional march toward even greater regulations.
But a big business tax cut would be the most stimulative way to move the economy from near recession to 4 or 5 percent growth. That’s what we need. Put it together with a stable and reliable dollar, and we can move from pessimism to optimism.
While I presume I agree with Mr. Kudlow that the optimal business income tax is zero, I don’t see any way that will pass the Senate but here’s something that might. Bring our corporate income tax laws into line with the rest of the OECD countries. Reduce our rate to a level just below Germany’s 15% and stop taxing overseas earnings.
There is a fabulous graph attached to Nat Silver’s post at Five Thirty Eight pouring water on the hopes of Sanders supporters. It illustrates by state the share of primary and caucus voters from 2008 who were both white and liberal. It’s too large or I’d, er, sample it.
As Alec Trebek might say I’ll put it in the form of a question: what is one thing that makes Vermont, New Hampshire, Iowa, and Massachusetts different from every other state in the Union? How about Oregon, Utah, Connecticut, Rhode Island, and (of all places) Montana?
If you’re taking your lead from those states, I suggest a radical re-think.
I’m a little less skeptical about Sanders’s chances than I think that Nate is. Oh, I still think he’s a long shot. But the scenario goes something like this.
Sanders wins Iowa and New Hampshire. The big donors desert Clinton in droves and the media pundits start dumping on Clinton in earnest. Turnout is extremely low in South Carolina.
Hillary Clinton’s support has always been a mile wide and an inch deep.