So we see that Ted Cruz and Ben Carson ran well in counties with high shares of married couples with families. This is consistent with them running well among voters in the religious right. Indeed, if you check the long-term RCP Averages, you will see Carson’s decline coinciding almost perfectly with Cruz’s rise.
You’ll see the middle box that Chris Christie, Jeb Bush, Rand Paul, Kasich and Rubio all ran well in counties with high incomes, high levels of college graduates, high numbers of new homes, and recently transplanted populations. This is consistent with these five candidates splitting the “establishment†vote among themselves, with no one able to obtain a solid lead.
Then in the bottom right corner, we see Mike Huckabee and Trump running well in counties of self-described “Americans,†people of Scots-Irish descent (which overlaps with “Americanâ€), and high levels of unemployment. This is consistent with our understanding of Trump as the continuation of the Buchananite tradition of insurgencies within the Republican Party, rather than what we might call religious or libertarian Tea Party-ism.
Note that the “Buchananite tradition” goes back for several decades. When you’ve been ignored for long enough, the impulse to tear the house down can become hard to resist.
At RealClearPolicy Vance Ginn and Kiara Pillay make a pretty typical comparative advantage argument in favor of trade. It can be summarized as “don’t worry about huge trade deficits with China—we benefit from them”:
If having imports greater than exports really made people worse off, there would be widespread unemployment and poverty. This misconception goes back to the mercantilist argument that isolationism and government export supports are the keys to prosperity. Rejecting this ideology has led to massive prosperity.
Simply, free trade allows Americans the ability to satisfy their desires by purchasing goods and services of better quality or lower price elsewhere. If that happens to lead to more purchases from other countries than they purchase from us, and therefore a trade deficit, then so be it.
Imports support job creation and are an essential part of a well-functioning economy. By importing cheaper electronic equipment from China, for example, not only do consumers pay less for the things they want, but producers also pay less for the technology they need to run their businesses. Collectively, this generates more economic activity in the U.S. than there would be otherwise.
I had the following reactions to that.
I probably understood comparative advantage before you were born.
I’ve read David Ricardo’s works. Have you?
There is nothing whatever in his works that would lead one to the conclusion that the income realized through increased economic activity (GDP) realized attributable to comparative advantage is allocated in a fair, equitable, optimal, or even desireable manner.
Persistent large trade deficits with China mean that the Chinese are subsidizing American consumption at the expense of American employment.
There’s a deeper question that I think needs to be considered. When more than 90% of the increases in income go to the top 1% of income earners (the point that Bernie Sanders hammers in practically every stump speech), ordinary people are not much vested in increases in economic activity. On top of that when they’re losing their jobs and, as has been highly publicized with respect to the Disney organization, forced to train their replacements who’ve been brought in from abroad, increasing hostility to foreign trade is understandable.
You might want to check in on Michael Barone’s analysis of the South Carolina primary results at Washington Examiner. It basically confirms what I’ve been warning about for some time—if Democrats are counting on the turnouts that elected Barack Obama to the presidency to bolster Hillary Clinton’s prospects, they might want to reconsider:
1. Clinton got many more votes from blacks this year than she did in 2008, but fewer blacks voted for her this year than voted for Obama in 2008. This is evidence that can be cited by those who have predicted that Democrats will have a hard time inspiring as many black voters to the polls in November than they did when the first black president was on the ballot.
2. Sanders did miserably among black voters. Historically, black Americans have tended to vote near-unanimously, in primaries and in general elections, for candidates they feel have the deepest commitment to civil rights issues. This is a rational response for people who feel themselves to be members of a minority that has been the object of discrimination and bad treatment.
American voters are now divided into three broad groups: Democrats, Republicans, and the disaffected. The outcome of the 2016 presidential election may well be decided by the disaffected.
Nonetheless, with due humility, it’s worth trying to gain some insight by comparing what’s happening now to what has happened at the beginning of other recessions. To that end, consider six indicators that cover at least some of the period since the stock market plummeted in early January: consumer spending, job openings, new unemployment claims, new manufacturing orders, orders for capital goods and building permits.
In the first three months of the last five recessions, on average, all these indicators pointed toward trouble. By contrast, during the three months through January (and through most of February for unemployment claims), they look largely positive. The number of people filing for jobless benefits is up a bit, but not much. Capital goods orders could be better, but they’re not falling in inflation-adjusted terms. The stock market is the only indicator that is decidedly pointing down.
I’d like to suggest that he’s looking at the wrong end of historic recessions. Rather than looking at the front end he should be looking at the middle or the tail.
More than 90% of U. S. counties haven’t recovered from the Great Recession. As you can see from the map in the WSJ post to which I linked, most of those that have fall into one or more of the following classifications:
they’re experiencing a recovery based on oil
they contain a state or federal capitol or are adjacent to one
they’re seeing a lot of foreign money spent on real estate
When you’ve never recovered any slowing of growth is bound to feel like a recession.
ANTI-MIGRANT violence in Germany has become so severe over the past year that it is a miracle that no refugee has yet been killed. In one case, inebriated thugs threw a Molotov cocktail through a window into a room where an 11-year-old refugee would have been sleeping, had he not crept into bed with his mother in another room. Another xenophobe fired a gun into a refugee home and hit a Syrian man in the leg. Elsewhere, someone lobbed a hand grenade into a processing centre for asylum seekers. It did not go off.
There were 13,846 “right-extremist†crimes in Germany in 2015, according to preliminary estimates, about 30% more than in 2014. Of those, 921 were violent. This year the pace has accelerated, especially in the former East Germany. On February 18th about 100 people in Clausnitz, in the eastern state of Saxony, tried to block a bus carrying 20 refugees, including children. In another Saxon city a cheering crowd interfered with firefighters dousing flames in a building being converted into an asylum home. One police chief warns of a “pogrom atmosphereâ€.
To place that number in perspective it’s nearly three times as many as were reported here in hate crimes of all sorts in 2014, the most recent year for which data are available.
The moral of the story seems to be that it’s a lot easier for the Germans to avoid being anti-immigrant when they don’t have many immigrants.
I agree with Robert Samuelson’s latest Washington Post editorial to the extent that I think that the increase in income inequality in the United States has many causes. Among those causes I would list excessive compensation of top management, increasing financialization of the U. S. economy, and rent-seeking—all mentioned in the column.
I think he’s too dismissive of excessive executive compensation as one of the reasons:
First — summarizing other studies — it attributes much inequality to differences between companies and not to individuals in the same firm. It’s not so much that the gap between the chief executive and the janitor at company A has widened; it’s that company A is falling behind company B, which is more profitable and pays both the CEO and the janitor better.
There has long been a sizeable gap between top managers and ordinary workers in American companies. I’m just going from memory here but IIRC 30 years ago top managers in the U. S. enjoyed incomes 17 times that of ordinary workers compared to 7 times in France and 9 times in Germany.
However, today that gap hasn’t just increased. It’s multiple orders of magnitude higher. Early in Bill Clinton’s first term as president there was a change in the tax law limiting the deductibility of top managers’ wages but not limiting the compensation that could be paid in the form of stock options. Consequently, boards of directors began paying an increasing proportion of executive compensation in the form of stock options. Foolishly in my opinion—it looked like free money.
After that it was off to the races and top managers’ total compensation is now hundreds of times that of ordinary workers.
That financialization produces income inequality can hardly be exaggerated. It’s darned hard to pay someone a billion dollars in compensation without its producing income inequality.
That rent-seeking is producing income inequality is a frequent topic here at The Glittering Eye. Consider the enormous growth in the healthcare and education sectors over the period of the last 30 years.
However, I found this very distressing:
On page 62, we learn that the growth of state and local government spending on services (schools, police, parks) has been the slowest of any recovery since World War II. One reason: Payments into underfunded pensions are draining money from services.
That’s facetious. Pensions are nothing but delayed compensation. Consequently, “payments into underfunded pensions” should be counted as an increase in services as much as paying the salaries of present police officers, firefighters, and teachers are.
Another factor that goes largely unmentioned in Mr. Samuelson’s column is our present slack labor market, promoted by legal and illegal immigration. A slack labor market vitiates the bargaining power of present workers. There are plenty more where they came from.
Yesterday morning I watched the debate among the candidates for Cook County States Attorney—Anita Alvarez (the incumbent), Kim Foxx (the candidate endorsed by the Democratic establishment), and Donna More. The debate, actually a joint press conference, was hosted by ABC 7 Chicago:
CHICAGO (WLS) — It was a spirited one-hour State’s Attorney debate Friday night in the ABC7 debate studio. The three candidates for State’s Attorney had virtually nothing good to say about each other.
“Both my opponents should be under investigation for their wrong doing,” said Donna More.
Candidate Donna More claimed the outsider’s role as incumbent Anita Alvarez focused on the heavily-endorsed Kim Foxx, Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle’s former Chief of Staff
“She’s standing up here because Toni Preckwinkle has been trying to get somebody to run against me for the past three years,” Alvarez said.
“My work on these issues pre-dates Ms. Preckwinkle and will continue on,” Foxx retorted.
Alvarez repeatedly called Foxx a liar for allegedly exaggerating her trial experience and violating campaign finance laws.
“So what else is she lying about? Don’t you think it’s important for the citizens of Cook County to elect someone who’s not a liar,” said Alvarez.
“Why don’t we elect a prosecutor that we can actually trust?” said More.
For the last half century at least the main job of the Cook County States Attorney has been to protect incompetent, corrupt, or misbehaving Chicago and Cook County elected officials. Over the period of the last 30 years quite literally hundreds of Chicago and Cook County judges, lawyers, and miscellaneous officials have been indicted and many convicted.
Nearly all of this has been done by federal authorities. The Cook County States Attorney’s office has been conspicuous by its absence in these prosecutions. Why? Because the States Attorney is on the other side.
If there is a credible explanation for Ms. Alvarez’s actions over the last year other than that she’s been covering up wrongdoing on the part of Chicago Police Department, I don’t know what it is. But now she’s damaged goods and is being thrown under the bus.
Kim Foxx is her designated replacement and can be expected to maintain the same sorry practices.
The only hope (and it’s a slim one) for reforming Chicago and Cook County would be by electing the only actual reform candidate and that’s Donna More.
I don’t usually watch the Academy Awards presentation program but last night I tuned in just to catch Chris Rock’s opening monologue. Which, unfortunately, exceeded my expectations.
He had a point to make; he could have made it in 30 seconds; he stretched it out to the entire length of his monologue.
Tavis Smiley had a much better take in his commentary on the CBS Sunday Morning program: they should quit their belly-achin’.
In the case of the Oscar nominations for best actor and actress there are a bunch of multi-millionaires boycotting the industry responsible for their wealth and fame because they’re not getting enough recognition. A certain lack of self-awareness is practically a prerequisite to be an actor or actress but for me that takes the cake.
Most people don’t get much if any recognition for the jobs they do whether they do a good job or a bad one. Deal with it.
The Academy Awards are promotional devices. They were conceived as promotional devices for movies when they began almost 90 years ago and they’re still marketing tools. Want to get more recognition? Put more butts in seats. That’s what the Oscars are about.
The ceasefire in Syria has entered its second day and appears to be holding as well as might be expected. The Guardian reports:
Syria’s fragile ceasefire has entered its second day with reports of scattered airstrikes and bombings, but overall the slowdown in fighting – regarded as the most successful effort yet to reduce the bloodshed in the five-year civil war – appeared to be holding.
Warplanes, believed to be either Syrian or Russian, bombed seven villages in the provinces of Aleppo and Hama, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights. Several airstrikes hit central and northern Syria on Sunday, a monitor said.
The Russian coordinating unit in Syria said there had been nine breaches of the ceasefire, although the partial cessation of hostilities appeared to be broadly intact. Rami Abdel Rahman, the head of the Britain-based monitor, said one person had been killed in Aleppo province.
In the course of 24 hours, 9 events of violation were registered.
On the 27th of February from 6.25 till 11.30 a.m. 6 mortar and MLRS attacks on inhabited areas in city Damascus (Karadzh, Abasin, Asiya, Dzhaubar, Mamunia, Maisilun) were registered.
In total, there were 20 explosions of artillery munitions, 2 civilians were killed and 8 – wounded.
The fire was delivered from the areas of Dzhaubar and Eastern Guta, which are occupied by groups of the «moderate» opposition, which included in the American list of of those who joined the ceasefire regime. Upon the request of Russian Center, the Syrian government forces did not shoot back.
The group of militants (up to 100 men strong) crossed the frontier of Syria from the Turkey in the Raqqah province. Then the group was reinforced (the number of people reached up to 250) and ceased the northern part of Et-Tell-al-Abiyada (82 km to the north from the city of Raqqah). The actions of militants were supported by the shellfire from the Turkish side. Kurdish rebel groups knocked militants out from the town and blocked them in Munbatih.
Militants of the international terrorist organization Jabhat al-Nusra engaged the Desert Falcons militia detachment with a mortar fire near the village Kbana (Aleppo province) from the territory controlled by the «moderate» opposition. The mortar-fire killed and wounded many members of the militia and civilians.
On the highway, 1 km to the east from Homs, a suicide bomber set off a car bomb moving from the area controlled by the «moderate» opposition.
The American reconciliation group in the city of Amman (Kingdom Jordan) has been informed about all facts of ceasefire violation.
In general, the ceasefire regime is being observed in Syria, however some violations by «moderate» opposition and by international terrorist organizations are being registered.
As you can see from the map above, the implication of the ceasefire is that western Syria is largely secured so the Syrian government need not watch its back any longer and Syria’s northern border is somewhat secured other than a chokepoint still controlled by DAESH and however porous the Kurdish areas are.
That provides the Syrian government, the Russians, the Iranians, Hezbollah, et al. the opportunity to focus their attention on the worst of the worst: DEASH and the Al Nusra Front.
Expect an encircling movement to close the border with Turkey and prevent resupply from there. We should also expect continued expressions of despair from those who’d rather see a Syria controlled by violent, radical Islamists than by the Syrian government. Unfortunately, that includes the United States and its alleged allies, Turkey, Israel, and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
I tend to be in agreement with Paul Winfree’s conclusions in his post about a universal basic income program at The Daily Signal. The reasoning has been well-known for hundreds for years and was summarized well by Voltaire: “Work saves us from three great evils: boredom, vice, and need.” I would add several things.
First, even if need were eliminated boredom and vice would remain and there are no ready replacements for work in alleviating those. Second, work also provides something else: a sense of identity and purpose and those are as necessary as food, water, or air. A world without work will be a desperate one.
Finally, there is no practical way to eliminate the fraud which will overwhelm any system.
Here’s Mr. Winfree’s peroration:
The policy challenge is not to find a more equitable way to distribute national income, but rather to support opportunity and a strong civil society through work.
There are any number of ways that could be accomplished. Mr. Winfree’s proposal (reducing disincentives to work) assumes that jobs that pay an adequate wage are available, something for which he provides no evidence.
There are other strategies. For example, we could subsidize wages. We could recognize that half or more of the population will never become doctors, lawyers, or accountants, find such work unsatisfying, and need to work with their hands. The reason that working with your hands no longer pays a living wage is a combination of the distaste for such jobs on the part of elites, an uneven playing field with China and other countries with large, unskilled populations, and our immigration policy.
Or we could implement a guaranteed jobs program, as has been suggested by a regular commenter here.