Creature of the Media

Every morning I check out the opinion page of the New York Times. Above is a screen capture of the page as I saw it this morning. I have circled all of the articles focused on Donald Trump. Some of the uncircled articles may have a similar focus. I can’t tell just from their slugs. You can click on the image for a large version if you need it, God help you.

If you have any questions about how the United States found itself staring the prospect of having Donald Trump elected president in the face, look no farther.

I have tagged this post journalism, politics, and show business. I think that says it all.

10 comments

A Sad Day

Donald Trump’s Super Tuesday victories weren’t the only sign of the apocalypse announced today. Netflix is renewing Fuller House for a second season:

Critics be damned. The “House” party will continue.

Netflix on Wednesday announced that it has rewarded a second season to “Fuller House,” the spinoff of the popular 1980s sitcom “Full House.”

The renewal comes less than a week after the show premiered on the streaming site. It also comes despite plenty of scorn-filled reviews from critics and even some fans. The show scored a lowly 32 on Rotten Tomatoes.

Still, “Fuller House,” which triggered an avalanche of social-media buzz during the buildup to its premiere, must have tugged on the nostalgic heart strings of millions of devotees. But we don’t know for sure how many viewers streamed the show since Netflix has a policy against releasing audience data.

Nobody every lost money by betting on the poor taste of the American public.

But here’s a question for you. What “classic” TV series would you like/dread seeing in a modern reincarnation with or without the original cast?

17 comments

The Danger of Mass Engineering Projects

Here’s an interesting story. The Guardian is reporting that lack of maintenance and the dangers of the vicinity of the Mosul dam of the Tigris could result in catastrophic failure:

Iraqi engineers involved in building the Mosul dam 30 years ago have warned that the risk of its imminent collapse and the consequent death toll could be even worse than reported.

They pointed out that pressure on the dam’s compromised structure was building up rapidly as winter snows melted and more water flowed into the reservoir, bringing it up to its maximum capacity, while the sluice gates normally used to relieve that pressure were jammed shut.

The Iraqi engineers also said the failure to replace machinery or assemble a full workforce more than a year after Islamic State temporarily held the dam means that the chasms in the porous rock under the dam were getting bigger and more dangerous every day.

The Iraqi government has contracted the necessary repairs to an Italian company (words fail me) and the Italian government has committed to sending several hundred troops to protect them. That strikes me as ill-considered.

How bad could a catastrophic failure of the dam be? This bad:

The engineers warned that potential loss of life from a sudden catastrophic collapse of the Mosul dam could be even greater than the 500,000 officially estimated, as they said many people could die in the resulting mass panic, with a 20-metre-high flood wave hitting the city of Mosul and then rolling on down the Tigris valley through Tikrit and Samarra to Baghdad.

One of the Iraqi engineers, now living in Europe, described as “ridiculous” the Iraqi government’s emergency policy of telling local people to move 6km (3.5 miles) from the river banks.

This story highlights just how dangerous mass engineering projects—like the Mosul dam—can be in the developing world. They don’t have the political stability, the social stability, or the infrastructure necessary to maintain them. Smaller projects are smarter but don’t have the prestige value and it’s all about prestige, isn’t it?

We can barely keep the Boulder Dam in repair and yet the Iraqis expected to keep the Mosul dam in repair? The Mosul dam is almost ten times as long as Boulder.

4 comments

Nothing Continues Forever

and that includes Moore’s Law, the rule of thumb that the number of microchips on a transister would double roughly every 24 months. Moore’s Law is nearing its end of life:

Nature recently published an article on the forthcoming end of Moore’s Law. In case you don’t keep up with tech buzz, this refers to Intel founder Gordon Moore’s empirical observation that the number of transistors in a microchip doubled every 24 months, running from roughly 1965 to the present. To the layman, this meant that computers roughly doubled in power every two years and became 1000 times more powerful every two decades.

Moore’s Law is more than just geek arcana. It’s a philosophical statement about the progress of technology. We live in times with such rapid growth in scientific knowledge, manufacturing capability, and global economic power that we have come to expect technology to improve so fast we can’t even keep up. We’re used to our computers and phones and entertainment systems and internet resources upgrading at a blinding tempo. So much so that we take it for granted.

Well, things are about to change.

One of the implications is that poorly-designed software that banks on faster, better hardware coming along just in time to remedy its deficiencies and companies that have grown into behemoths by developing such software can no longer make that assumption. That poorly-designed operating system, platform, or application may run no better in five years than it does now.

1 comment

No Book Contains All Knowledge

The moral of this article at The Economist, on the extremely high rate of cousin marriage in the Middle East is that the Qur’an was written before we had much knowledge of genetics. Cousin marriage is stigmatized but legal in most of the developed world but commonplace and accepted in the Middle East.

Unfortunately, the practice can render genetic disorders more common as this snippet from the article suggests:

MAHA SAAD ZAKI, a professor of clinical genetics, ushers Ahmed, Fatima and their family into her room at Egypt’s National Research Centre. At least three of their six children have a rare neurological illness that manifests itself around age four, causing mental retardation, loss of the use of their limbs and, later, death. The couple’s nine-year-old daughter slumps, twitching. This congenital illness has appeared because, as well as being husband and wife, Ahmed and Fatima are also first cousins (their names have been changed).

Cases like these are all too common in the Middle East and north Africa. Marrying a close relative markedly increases the chance that both parents are carriers of dangerous recessive genes, which can then cause disease when a child inherits a copy of the gene from both parents, as will happen in 25% of cases. The gamut of such illnesses runs from known ones such as microcephaly (in which children have unusually small heads) cystic fibrosis and thalassaemia, a blood disorder, to wholly new disorders. “Ninety percent of the cases I see are caused by consanguineous marriages,” says Ms Zaki.

The conclusion of The Economist from this, no doubt, is that we should be importing a lot more people from the Middle East to the United States.

7 comments

The Federal Government’s Joke Book

For your humorous reading today, you might want to check out this post at RealClearScience on the incredibly silly federal dietary guidelines for Americans. Here’s a snippet:

Recently, my colleagues and I published research in Mayo Clinic Proceedings that examined dietary data from almost 50 years of nutrition studies. What we found was astounding; these data were physiologically implausible and incompatible with survival. In other words, the diets from these studies could not support human life if consumed on a daily basis. The reason for this is simple; the memory-based data collection methods (M-BMs) used by nutrition researchers are unscientific because they rely on both the truthfulness of the study participant and the accuracy of his or her memory. Stated more simply, these methods collect nothing more than uncorroborated anecdotal estimates of food and beverage consumption.

Importantly, vast amounts of taxpayer dollars are directed away from rigorous scientific investigations and squandered every year on the collection of uncorroborated anecdotes via M-BMs. Approximately 80% of the data in the USDA’s National Evidence Library consists of uncorroborated anecdotes as well as 100% of the dietary data from every major epidemiologic study over the past 50 years (e.g., Nurses’ Health Study, Health Professionals Follow-Up Study, REGARDS project, and EPIC study). In other words, most of what nutrition researchers call “scientific evidence” is in reality a vast collection of nearly baseless anecdotes. Nevertheless, despite a century of unequivocal evidence that human memory and recall are woefully inadequate for actual scientific data collection, the data from these methods are used to create public health policy.

Read the whole thing. And weep. Of, if you’re of Irish descent, laugh. The federal dietary guidelines, since their beginnings in 1980, have been an improbable combination of marketing, science, anecdote, folklore, and political hobbyhorse. It underscores why I’m so skeptical of technocracy. “Technocracy” is supposed to mean “rule by experts”. In practice what it means, has always meant, and will always mean is “rule by idiots who think they’re experts”.

I’ll only add one thing. There is abundant paleontological and anthropological data supporting the reality that human beings preferentially seek out the highest fat-containing food source in their environments. It has been that way for tens of thousands of years, is that way today, will continue to be that way as long as we’re human beings and there’s nothing we can do to change it. We’re hardwired for it. It’s part of how we’re built. Whether it’s good for us or not is irrelevant.

6 comments

Just How Stable Is India, Anyway?

One of the great gaps in my knowledge is the history of India. I know very little about it. I have made considerable study of Russian history and Chinese history (more Russian history than is good for one). Like most Americans (at least in the old days) I studied English history as American history and like other St. Louisans of my vintage I have a smattering of ignorance of French history.

But not Indian history. You can’t know everything about everything and that’s a subject I’ve largely avoided.

My understanding is that the very idea of India as a unified whole is a British colonial one, that Gandhi largely embraced the British colonial ideal in that regard, and that the Gandhian dream of a multi-confessional India was dealt a serious blow with the creation of the Dominion of Pakistan after World War II.

All of that is what came to mind when I read this article in The Hindu:

It is in this context that we need to place the quiet revolution in higher education that has taken place over the past two decades. Today, in most non-technical institutions of higher learning women equal or exceed male students in numbers. After the 93rd constitutional amendment extended reservations, the caste (and class) composition of elite universities has been transformed. While Muslims remain under-represented, most others have gained access, making our universities the only public spaces in contemporary India where almost all groups (barring the poorest) can meet and mingle in a relatively egalitarian setting. This newly democratised site is proving to be a massive source of anxiety and resentment for the current regime. Campuses like those of the University of Hyderabad or Jawaharlal Nehru University are seen as particularly dangerous because they are spaces where Dalits are not only assertive but are making common cause with other marginalised groups including Muslims.

Hence the vicious campaign against radical students and campuses, and the relentless repetition of the charge of being “anti-national”. The bitter irony here is that while the accused have been describing the India — and, as with Rohith Vemula, the world — that they stand for in passionate detail, the accusers have offered only the thinnest and emptiest of descriptions. Nothing illustrates this better than the bizarre proposal to hoist gigantic national flags in universities. Even more telling is the plan to showcase tanks and artillery on campuses in the hope that they will exude patriotism and provide immunity against the dreaded disease of critical thinking.

That makes me wonder just how stable India is, anyway? Like many countries including the United States the Internet is changing the very nature of social cohesion in India and I suspect that is most true among the educated people there.

What I’m speculating about is the possibility that not only might India unravel along caste and religious lines but along geographic, cultural, and educational ones as well. It’s a very complicated country, with hundreds of languages, ethnic groups, and sects. De Gaulle’s wisecrack about the difficulty in governing any country with 150 different kinds of cheese must be true in spades in India.

4 comments

America’s Role in the Middle East

Here’s David Ignatius’s take on the U. S. role in the Middle East from his most recent Washington Post column:

Fitting together the altered pieces of the puzzle brings many risks, but it does provide new openings. And it’s clear that even in its diminished role, the United States remains the indispensable stabilizing power, like it or not.

As the late Mayor Daley used to say, let’s look at the record.

Israel Since 1967 has become Israel’s primary if not only supporter. ?
Kuwait Kicked Saddam Hussein out after his invasion and occupation of the country. Stabilizing
Saudi Arabia Stationed troops in Saudi Arabia, setting the stage for the 9/11 terrorist attacks. Destabilizing
Iraq Left Saddam Hussein in power after ousting him from Kuwait, set up a “no fly” zone in the north, invaded and removed Saddam Hussein, then left the country to degenerate into a downward spiral of sectarian violence, setting up the pins for DAESH. Destabilizing
Iran Agreement with the mullahs ?
Yemen After more than a decade of drone war, the never-too-stable country is even less stable than it was before. Presently being attacked by KSA (who is using US-supplied weaponry). Destabilizing
Egypt Threw Mubarak under the bus, supported the Muslim Brotherhood. Destabilizing
Libya Overthrew Qaddafi, setting stage for present chaos. Destabilizing
Syria Supporting Syrian rebels’ campaign to overthrow the internationally-recognized government. Destabilizing

U. S. policy with respect to Israel and Iran may ultimately prove to have been stabilizing but right now it’s clearly destabilizing. Consequently, I rate our influence with respect to those countries as mixed.

I don’t see how any honest appraisal of our relationship with the countries of the Middle East can characterize the U. S. as a stabilizing influence. At least not over the period of the last 20 years.

Mr. Ignatius is either living in the past, mistaken, or is using a very eccentric definition of “stabilizing”.

5 comments

Council Forum: Favorite Pets

Every week the members of the Watcher’s Council weigh in on a single issue in a feature called “the Forum”. This week the Council turns its eyes away from politics to something more interesting: pets. Here’s a snippet:

Dogs and humans were natural hunting partners, since dogs could sniff and chase, while humans, using weapons, could do a long distance kill. (Dogs could only do close kills, which put them at risk.) When humans transitioned to farm life, dogs protected them against predators, both human and animal.

In other words, where would we be without dogs? And can anyone say the same thing about the human/cat relationship?

As I wrote in my offering over the course of my adult life I’ve had cats, rabbits, and dogs. I like ’em all. We presently have four dogs: three Samoyeds and an Australian Shepherd.

3 comments

Income Growth By State

If you’ve been wondering why I keep banging on the table, look no farther than the graph above illustrating the income growth rate by state for each of the states since 2007. If you look right down there second from the bottom, you’ll find Illinois. For a larger image check the original post at Pew Research (hat tip: CapitolFax).

Annualized, that’s .5% income growth every year since 2007.

4 comments