One of the great gaps in my knowledge is the history of India. I know very little about it. I have made considerable study of Russian history and Chinese history (more Russian history than is good for one). Like most Americans (at least in the old days) I studied English history as American history and like other St. Louisans of my vintage I have a smattering of ignorance of French history.
But not Indian history. You can’t know everything about everything and that’s a subject I’ve largely avoided.
My understanding is that the very idea of India as a unified whole is a British colonial one, that Gandhi largely embraced the British colonial ideal in that regard, and that the Gandhian dream of a multi-confessional India was dealt a serious blow with the creation of the Dominion of Pakistan after World War II.
All of that is what came to mind when I read this article in The Hindu:
It is in this context that we need to place the quiet revolution in higher education that has taken place over the past two decades. Today, in most non-technical institutions of higher learning women equal or exceed male students in numbers. After the 93rd constitutional amendment extended reservations, the caste (and class) composition of elite universities has been transformed. While Muslims remain under-represented, most others have gained access, making our universities the only public spaces in contemporary India where almost all groups (barring the poorest) can meet and mingle in a relatively egalitarian setting. This newly democratised site is proving to be a massive source of anxiety and resentment for the current regime. Campuses like those of the University of Hyderabad or Jawaharlal Nehru University are seen as particularly dangerous because they are spaces where Dalits are not only assertive but are making common cause with other marginalised groups including Muslims.
Hence the vicious campaign against radical students and campuses, and the relentless repetition of the charge of being “anti-nationalâ€. The bitter irony here is that while the accused have been describing the India — and, as with Rohith Vemula, the world — that they stand for in passionate detail, the accusers have offered only the thinnest and emptiest of descriptions. Nothing illustrates this better than the bizarre proposal to hoist gigantic national flags in universities. Even more telling is the plan to showcase tanks and artillery on campuses in the hope that they will exude patriotism and provide immunity against the dreaded disease of critical thinking.
That makes me wonder just how stable India is, anyway? Like many countries including the United States the Internet is changing the very nature of social cohesion in India and I suspect that is most true among the educated people there.
What I’m speculating about is the possibility that not only might India unravel along caste and religious lines but along geographic, cultural, and educational ones as well. It’s a very complicated country, with hundreds of languages, ethnic groups, and sects. De Gaulle’s wisecrack about the difficulty in governing any country with 150 different kinds of cheese must be true in spades in India.