Scott Burns’s recent post at RealClearWorld starts out propitiously enough with a condemnation of interventionist foreign policy that I can get behind:
Throughout the post-World War II era, the United States has embraced its self-assigned role to “make the world safe for democracy” in three main ways: through direct military intervention; through indirect interventions, such as by arming rebel groups to help overthrow hostile regimes; and through economic sanctions. The best of intentions may drive these interventions, but in most cases the outcome has been disaster.
but then he descends into madness. What is his alternative to interventionism? Mass immigration:
Surprisingly, part of the answer lies in loosening immigration quotas for refugees to come into relatively peaceful and developed countries such as the United States, which in the long term can have better results for us and for them.
The number of reasons that this is wrong-headed is so large it’s hard to know where to start. Let me just list a few:
- Limited employment opportunities
- Unacceptable risk
- Superempowerment
- Societies have carrying capacities
- We’re not all missionaries
Limited employment opportunities
The United States is a different country than it was in 1850, 1900, or even 1950. The unemployment rate among Somali refugees is around 20% and for decades was around 50%. As it turns out there just aren’t that many opportunities for people without modern skills who don’t speak English.
Unacceptable risk
In all we’ve accepted about 200 Chechen refugees into the United States, a very small number. Of those about 10% were either perpetrators of the Boston Marathon bombings, directly involved with the Boston Marathon bombings, or indirectly involved with the Boston Marathon bombings. I’ll leave explaining why such a high percentage hate us so much to someone interested in the question. I think it’s clear that those refugees present an unacceptable risk. These are not the post-WWII or Ellis Island refugees or even Mexican economic migrants.
Superempowerment
Modern technology makes individuals much more capable of producing enormous carnage than was the case in the past. A 19th century anarchist could kill a couple of dozen people. A modern terrorist can kill or injure thousands. Times have changed.
Societies have carrying capacities
I believe that societies have carrying capacities in terms of the number of immigrants they can support without producing serious social upheaval and that for the United States that’s about 20%. We’re there now: we have the highest proportion of immigrants in our population as at any time in U. S. history—the same as at the turn of the 20th century. We need time to absorb the immigrants we have rather than to bring in a lot more.
We’re not all missionaries
The reality is that most Americans don’t have the impulse or feel the mandate to save the world, whether by going out as missionaries or by overthrowing tyrannical foreign governments. When a missionary goes to a foreign land, that’s his or her right. Bringing the poor and downtrodden here where it’s more convenient and comfortable to care for them is drafting all of us into their missionary efforts and that’s actively immoral.
If you want to save the world, go ahead and do it. Just don’t force me to help you.

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.




