The Globalization Bubble

Writing at Project Syndicate, Daniel Gros puts forward the idea that globalization is ending:

BRUSSELS – China has just announced that last year, for the first time since it began opening up its economy to the world at the end of the 1970s, exports declined on an annual basis. And that is not all; in value terms, global trade declined in 2015. The obvious question is why.
While global trade also fell in 2009, the explanation was obvious: The world was experiencing a sharp contraction in GDP at the time. Last year, however, the world economy grew by a respectable 3%. Moreover, trade barriers have not risen significantly anywhere, and transport costs are falling, owing to the sharp decline in oil prices.

Tellingly, the so-called Baltic Dry Index, which measures the cost of chartering the large ships that carry most long-distance trade, has fallen to an all-time low. This indicates that markets do not expect a recovery, meaning that the data from 2015 could herald a new age of slowing trade. The obvious conclusion is that the once-irresistible forces of globalization are losing steam.
The situation in China is telling. In recent decades, as it became the world’s leading trading economy, China transformed the global trading system. Now the value of both imports and exports have fallen, though the former have declined more, owing to the collapse of global commodity prices.

From there he continues with an analysis of the relation between changes in commodity prices and globalization.

I don’t think he quite has the story right. What I suspect is the case is that there was never quite as much foreign trade as we thought there might be. The comparison I would make is with the housing bubble.

Demand comes in two flavors: demand on the part of end users and demand on the part of resellers. When end users and resellers are competitors, as was the case with a big chunk of the housing industry, it produces some eccentric effects. One of those effects is convincing people that end user demand could be a lot higher than it actually is.

IMO at the height of the housing bubble not only were there an enormous number of flippers buying houses but there were a lot of ordinary people buying too much house because they thought the value would go up and they could always sell.

Something like that has been going on in commodities. The Chinese have been buying enormous amounts of most commodities in a credit-fueled spending binge and they’ve been spending on expanding manufacturing facilities. Now they have all of that excess capacity sitting around and it looks as though the bottom has fallen out of commodities. The reality is that there was never really that much demand. The Chinese were speculating.

So I don’t think that globalization is ending. I just don’t think that China is going to be able to export its way to wealth.

1 comment

Strengthening the Second Amendment?

It has been noted that libertarians come in multiple flavors. In the United States one of the broad dichotomies is between First Amendment libertarians and Second Amendment libertarians. For First Amendment libertarians the First Amendment to the Constitution has primacy; for Second Amendment libertarians, it’s the Second Amendment.

The latter category shouldn’t be dismissed as “gun nuts” any more than the former as “speech nuts”. They have a legitimate point of view, they’re serious, and at least for the time being they have the law on their side.

Every week the Watcher’s Council posts a forum in which the members weigh in on some single question or issue. This week the question is whether the Second Amendment needs to be strengthened. I’m not a Second Amendment libertarian and the question is not of vital interest to me; I didn’t participate in the forum this week.

However, you can see what other Council members had to say by checking out the Forum on the Watcher’s site.

3 comments

The Trib Demurs

The editors of the Chicago Tribune have endorsed Marco Rubio on the Republican side and declined to endorse a Democratic candidate. Here’s the conclusion of the editorial:

Agree or disagree with Marco Rubio on various issues, he offers Illinois voters the framework of a presidency that realistically could exist. Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders have not met this fundamental economic test. We’re keeping an open mind, hoping that whichever of them prevails will meet that test in the general election campaign. Because promises, pledges and policies mean nothing to a gravely indebted American government that can afford only to window-shop.

In the Republican primary contest, the Tribune endorses Marco Rubio. In the Democratic contest, no endorsement.

Agree or disagree with their conclusions on the candidates but don’t dismiss them. Hillary Clinton may be the inevitable Democratic candidate but that alone won’t make her electable. Her electability will hinge on her ability to energize voters who are presently being energized by, among other things, rejection of Marco Rubio and Hillary Clinton and establishment politics, generally.

1 comment

In Illinois It’s Very, Very Close

According to a new Chicago Tribune poll Illinois Republicans, like Republicans elsewhere in the country, have lost their ever-loving minds. But it’s close:

Republican Donald Trump leads his three rivals in Illinois’ presidential primary, according to a new Chicago Tribune poll that shows many of the fissures affecting the GOP nationally have come to the Midwest.

The survey, conducted Wednesday through Sunday, also found Trump holds his advantage despite having the highest unfavorable rating of any of the Republican contenders ahead of next Tuesday’s election.

Overall, Trump had the support of 32 percent, followed by Texas Sen. Ted Cruz with 22 percent, Florida Sen. Marco Rubio with 21 percent and Ohio Gov. John Kasich with 18 percent. An additional 7 percent were undecided. The poll of 600 registered voters likely to cast a ballot in the Republican primary has an error margin of 4.1 percentage points.

7% undecided suggests a Trump victory but maybe the millions that are being spent here on a “stop Trump” campaign will have some effect. I don’t have nearly so much of a problem. Next Tuesday I’ll be voting for Bernie Sanders.

35 comments

Mister, We Could Use a Man Like Theodore Vail Again

Writing in Atlantic, Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson believe they have found a villain to blame for the water crisis in Flint, Michigan—the erosion of the U. S.’s “mixed economy”:

It is tempting to search for a single villain in the Flint crisis: the austerity measures of state Republicans and especially Governor Rick Snyder, the weakness of local protections, the missteps of the EPA. But the reality is that these threats to public health and social well-being are at work across the United States, and they have much deeper roots. Figuring out where responsiveness broke down, punishing those responsible, and fixing systems of accountability are all imperative. But that won’t solve the deeper problem—America’s retreat from an effective mixed economy.

Begin with the plummeting investment in the physical underpinnings of communities, the roads, bridges, water systems, and other public goods that make the places where people live and work safe, livable, and productive. American infrastructure once used to be the envy of the world and a major source of Americans’ improved living standards. But in an era of government-bashing, it has been allowed to crumble, risking health, safety, and economic success.

Yes, there’s nothing like a grotesque failure of government at all levels for building support for more aggressive government action.

Let me tell a different story about Flint. In the 1920s and 1930s significant numbers of African Americans moved from the American South to the North, simultaneously fleeing the racially oppressive South and seeking good-paying jobs in the factories that were opening in Northern cities. From 1910 to 1930 Flint, Michigan’s population ballooned from 39,000 people to 156,000 on the strength of the growing General Motors which originally called Flint home. Many blacks found jobs at GM, in the other, smaller companies serving the automobile industry, and in the hotels and restaurants that served these companies.

In the 1970s and 1980s under competitive pressure from German and Japanese auto companies, GM shut down many of its factories and began employing overseas subcontractors rather than the domestic ones it had fostered for half a century. Flint citizens who were most portable, i.e. could find jobs elsewhere the easiest, mostly white, left Flint for better prospects, leaving the city with a majority black, generally poor citizenry, the situation there today.

There are fundamental assumptions in the very decentralized form of government that has grown up in the United States. By and large counties have assumed that its cities would take care of themselves and states have assumed that its counties would take care of themselves. Another assumption is that Americans would show initiative rather than waiting for someone else to solve their problems.

Those assumptions have grown progressively weaker over time. Not only have poor minorities tended to concentrate in the cities, the compensation packages of the cities’ workers have grown out of proportion to the abilities of the cities’ residents to pay them, and counties and states have grown decreasingly willing to fund these cities’ bloated budgets, seeing them as corrupt and, frankly, due to racial and/or class prejudice.

I see Flint’s problems as due to a combination of globalization, deindustrialization, white flight, and a failure of the model of governance. Flint can’t take care of itself and neither Genesee County, the State of Michigan, nor the U. S. government is willing to devote the resources to take care of it.

I have written frequently about the “Fordist model” that Mssrs. Hacker and Pierson are referring to as a “mixed economy” and would point out to them that it isn’t merely failing in Michigan. It’s failing everywhere under the pressures of globalization and modern technology.

I would very much like to see Mssrs. Hacker and Pierson quantify some of their claims. I see few signs that the federal government is regulating less. As one objective measure, the trend in the number of pages in the Federal Register published annually continues to be up. I do think there are ample reasons to believe that the federal government is decreasingly able to regulate effectively. IMO that stands to reason. The modern world moves too quickly and is too complex for effective regulation.

9 comments

Not Clear on the Concept

Michael Bloomberg’s statement at Bloomberg:

In a three-way race, it’s unlikely any candidate would win a majority of electoral votes, and then the power to choose the president would be taken out of the hands of the American people and thrown to Congress. The fact is, even if I were to receive the most popular votes and the most electoral votes, victory would be highly unlikely, because most members of Congress would vote for their party’s nominee. Party loyalists in Congress — not the American people or the Electoral College — would determine the next president.

As the race stands now, with Republicans in charge of both Houses, there is a good chance that my candidacy could lead to the election of Donald Trump or Senator Ted Cruz. That is not a risk I can take in good conscience.

strongly suggests he does not understand how the U. S. system of electing presidents works. Here’s the Constitution’s meager explanation:

Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress: but no Senator or Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the United States, shall be appointed an Elector.

The Electors shall meet in their respective States, and vote by Ballot for two Persons, of whom one at least shall not be an Inhabitant of the same State with themselves. And they shall make a List of all the Persons voted for, and of the Number of Votes for each; which List they shall sign and certify, and transmit sealed to the Seat of the Government of the United States, directed to the President of the Senate. The President of the Senate shall, in the Presence of the Senate and House of Representatives, open all the Certificates, and the Votes shall then be counted. The Person having the greatest Number of Votes shall be the President, if such Number be a Majority of the whole Number of Electors appointed; and if there be more than one who have such Majority, and have an equal Number of Votes, then the House of Representatives shall immediately choose by Ballot one of them for President; and if no Person have a Majority, then from the five highest on the List the said House shall in like Manner choose the President. But in choosing the President, the Votes shall be taken by States, the Representatives from each State having one Vote; a quorum for this Purpose shall consist of a Member or Members from two thirds of the States, and a Majority of all the States shall be necessary to a Choice. In every Case, after the Choice of the President, the Person having the greatest Number of Votes of the Electors shall be the Vice President. But if there should remain two or more who have equal Votes, the Senate shall choose from them by Ballot the Vice-President.

From Article II< Section 1 of the Constitution.

I seem to recall that 48 states have a winner-take-all rule so we elect presidents by state rather than by district and IIRC a third party candidate hasn’t carried a state since 1912. And he thinks his presence in the race would throw the election into the House? That’s either incredible chutzpah or he doesn’t understand how we elect presidents.

2 comments

All Politics Is Local National

It isn’t very often that the president of the United States intervenes in a primary election for a seat in the state legislature, particularly against an incumbent of his own party, but that’s what has happened today. President Obama appeared in an election spot for Juliana Stratton, running to unseat incumbent Ken Dunkin from his seat in the Illinois House. From the Chicago Tribune:

In a rare political move, President Barack Obama has inserted himself in a Democratic state legislative primary race in his home state, backing challenger Juliana Stratton over Rep. Ken Dunkin of Chicago.

In a TV and radio ad, Obama says he learned from his days in Chicago that “follow-through is everything.”

“The people of Chicago deserve leaders who follow through. Juliana Stratton has spent her career serving our community, improving the juvenile justice system and protecting public safety,” Obama says in the TV ad.

This isn’t actually all that surprising. In February the president criticized Dunkin in remarks he made before the Illinois legislature in Springfield. Coincidentally, Rep. Dunkin has been bucking moves made by Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan. Break party discipline and not only do you get primaried, the president of the United States endorses the challenger.

1 comment

Only in Chicago

Candidate stapled by the other guy’s supporters. From WGN TV:

CHICAGO — A candidate for the Illinois House says he was attacked by his opponent’s supporters.

Bob Zwolinski is running for Illinois’ 4th District, against incumbent Cynthia Soto.

He says Sunday night a man and a woman were stapling posters for Soto outside his campaign office Ashland and Chicago in East Ukrainian Village.

Zwolinski says he asked them to stop and that’s when the man punched him in the chest then the woman hit him in the head with a beer bottle and then shot a staple gun at him — leaving him with a staple in his forehead.

Chicago police say Zwolinski has filed a police report and the accused attackers are claiming they are the victims in this case.

Hat tip: Capitol Fax

8 comments

That Is the Question

From Inside Science, an interesting post on a basic question facing archaeology: who owns the past?

0 comments

The Fine Print

You’ve got to get to the second to last paragraph in Ed Dolan’s defense of Bernie Sanders’s healthcare reform plan,into the fine print as it were, before you get to the real problems with our healthcare system and why reforms that only target how care is paid for are inadequate:

Another reason for the higher cost of US healthcare services are higher earnings of physicians. US doctors earn considerably more than their European counterparts do, even when we adjust fees for differences in expenses and cost of living. But changing compensation practices for American doctors would not be easy without reforming other pieces of the healthcare complex. European doctors typically receive free education, so they don’t begin practice with tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in student debt. Entry into medical schools is not as tightly restricted in Europe as in the United States. And less adversarial systems to deal with malpractice claims free European doctors from a major cost item while giving them less incentive to practice unproductive defensive medicine.

Additionally, although they do exist in Europe for-profit hospitals are something of a rarity there and in the United Kingdom.

Incremental reforms or reforms that only affect the payment end of the healthcare system aren’t enough. If you really want to reduce costs, you’ve got to change the whole system at once in pretty basic ways. Which is why we haven’t done it.

3 comments