Ted Cruz’s Tax Plan

You might want to take a look at Louis Woodhill’s commentary at RealClearMarkets on Ted Cruz’s tax reform plan. I referred to the Tax Foundation’s analysis of the plan while I was reading it.

The Reader’s Digest version of Sen. Cruz’s plan is that it:

  • Replaces the present individual income tax with a 10% flat tax.
  • Imposes a 16% subtraction method VAT.
  • Eliminates the payroll tax.
  • Eliminates the corporate income tax.
  • Eliminates all personal deductions except the charitable deduction and the home mortgage interest deduction.
  • Increases the exemption for dependents and the Earned Income Tax Credit.
  • Depends heavily on growth assumptions for solvency.
  • Would result in a federal revenue decrease of $768 billion over 10 years.

My observations about it are:

  1. I agree with Mr. Woodhill about the objectives of a tax system.
  2. The plan seems to be a solid one. You will note that it incorporates a number of things I’ve advocated here over the years.
  3. Finding offsetting cuts at the level required should be easy.
  4. If you can’t find the cuts, the plan will, ironically, become a poorly-constructed Keynesian stimulus plan.
  5. It would be a more effective way of discouraging tax avoidance schemes by corporations, e.g. inversions, than anything that Sen. Sanders or Sec. Clinton have proposed.

I also note that it will be extremely difficult to enact because of the large number of sacred oxen it will gore. Opposition to the plan will be fierce and will come from all directions.

40 comments

Apt Skewering

Whatever you may think of Camille Paglia, I found the characterizations of original field Republican presidential hopefuls in her Salon piece amusingly apt:

The humiliating wholesale rejection of cash-glutted Jeb Bush, dynastic crown prince, should have clued the GOP moguls into how out of touch they are with primary voters this year. Jeb’s first mistake (perhaps due to his wife’s dislike of the public eye) was not to run for president soon after serving as Florida governor, when he still had his chops. His second mistake was to loaf on the sidelines and play no role whatever in public debates over pressing national issues. By the time he returned to the scene, he was both uncertain and irrelevant. Then someone foolishly prodded him to lose weight, which reduced his gravitas along with the flab by now highlighting his bland, snub-nosed baby face.

Another victim of perpetual-boy syndrome is Marco Rubio, who at 44 seems to have strangely stalled in post-pubescence. How is it possible that Rubio played football (defensive back) in college and none of it shows? During high-wire gigs in Washington or at the primary debates, he chronically flubbed, either by autopilot glibness or painfully palpable anxiety attacks. Oh, right, we’re going to have this skittish, sweaty guy with five o’clock shadow and a bad comb-over going toe-to-toe with Vladimir Putin. Rubio seems bright and affable, but there’s nothing remotely presidential about him.

As for the rest of the GOP pack, they all flamed out in one way or another. Despite his bold history of confronting and defeating the greedy public-sector unions, Scott Walker with his wide, wary eyes and pretty-boy pout looked like a deer caught in the headlights at the first debate. Bobby Jindal and Rand Paul also struggled with boy-regression—is this a Republican disease? On TV, the snarly, petulant Paul, with his sprig of retro forehead curls, looked like a mummified Dorian Gray dressed by Sears Roebuck, circa 1959.

Carly Fiorina: smart and nimble but too taut and wired, like a buzz saw. Too much of a political novice and without Trump’s bumptious exuberance and slashing humor. Her campaign imploded when she went all histrionic (voice tragically breaking) about the secretly taped Planned Parenthood videos, a serious issue that the mainstream media had tried to bury but that should not have been used for blatant political grandstanding. Ben Carson: a thoughtful, dignified private citizen with an illustrious medical career. But was he ever remotely credible as a statesman on the international stage in the age of terrorism? His rote deep-think mode was to close his eyes and press his fingers together, like Madame Arcati conducting a séance in Blithe Spirit.

Chris Christie: the lib Manhattan media just loved him to death. He was their fave Republican—he licked their boots, and they licked his. This blathering, gassy, waddling narcissist with his over-trimmed Pinocchio nose and lispy, quacking voice never had a prayer of a chance on the national stage. The Christie boomlet was always a media mirage. John Kasich: the man who could have been king. I think Kasich won the first GOP debate but then blew it. He has exactly the kind of gubernatorial executive experience and legislative budget-balancing record that are sorely needed in the White House. But Kasich’s unfocused, overblown, compulsively self-referential rhetoric is a major liability. And his skills as a public figure are embarrassingly rudimentary: he blurts, lurches, and waves his arms around like a windmill. He lacks patience, subtlety, and finesse. Not presidential.

Sadly, deft, concise skewering of public figures is all but a lost art in the United States. Too much political commentary devolves into not much more than “Oh, yeah?”. I’m always reminded of this scene from the movie It Happened One Night:

I agree with her that a Trump v. Clinton match-off will be a national nightmare. I disagree with the way she’s characterized it. I think it will be more like Godzilla vs. the Smog Monster except without the rubber suits.

8 comments

It Could Happen to You

Maybe I’m reading something that isn’t there in Peter Müller’s piece in Der Spiegel about how uniquely vulnerable Belgium is to terrorist attack:

Belgium’s society, government and structures spent years, perhaps decades, underestimating the problem posed by violent Islamists. Salah Abdeslam, who was involved in the Paris attacks, was able to hide out here for four months after the attack with friends, family and acquaintances. He was even seen at the barber getting his hair cut and at a shop buying clothes. Apparently nobody thought to notify the police.

Accomplices of those who carried out the Paris attacks were apparently able to spend months planning new horrors, undisturbed by the authorities — attacks that seem to have been hurriedly carried out on Tuesday. That demands an explanation, as does the fact that Belgium, relative to its population, sends more young Islamist radicals into the Syrian civil war than any other European country.

Ever since the attacks in Paris, Belgians have been concerned that they too could be targeted. Now they have been. The people of Brussels have been astonishingly calm in the face of violence. People have taken stranded tourists into their homes and teachers wrote emails to parents on Tuesday evening assuring them they would do all they could to make the last three days before Easter vacation as normal as possible for the children. It shows the people’s courage.

Unfortunately, the brave Belgians don’t have the government they deserve. Since the attacks in Paris, Belgian officials and politicians have seemed unable to cope. That applies not just to the terror investigations; it also applies to the way in which the authorities have communicated with the populace. Last November, the government put Brussels on lockdown and the terror alert was raised to its highest level, as it was after Tuesday’s attacks. Schools and subways remained closed. But it was never communicated where the danger was coming from and how people should act. The result was that schools reopened of their own accord even as the terror alert remained extreme.

but I detect a smug, self-assured complacency in it that is wholly unjustified. Major terrorist Islamist terrorist attacks have now taken place in the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Spain, and Belgium, just to name European and North American countries. Preparation for the attacks on 9/11 didn’t take place in feckless, unprepared Belgium. It took place in efficient, competent Germany. All it will take is one major terrorist attack in Germany and that confidence will be swept away. There is no foreseeable amount of preparation and planning that can prevent it.

1 comment

Painfully Detached from Reality

Most of the editors of The Economist’s remarks about the terror attacks in Brussels are pablum but this:

The best protection would be peace in the Middle East—a distant dream, alas. The coalition has made progress against IS in its caliphate, which is shrinking and losing people. But eradicating it needs Iraqi troops (as yet unprepared) and ground forces in Syria (as yet non-existent). Meanwhile, IS’s ability to command and inspire terrorists will persist and, anyway, the West has its own, self-radicalised jihadists to deal with.

is painfully detached from reality. I guess it depends on your operational definition of “peace” and “Middle East”. If by “peace” you mean a new Ottoman who ruthlessly subdues the fractious sectarian and tribal factions that prevent the countries of the Middle East from being modern states let alone at peace and by “Middle East” you mean everywhere that Muslims live, I guess it’s tautologically correct if unhelpful.

I think that what we’re seeing is the gauzy imaginings of the Europeans of a world pacified by law, good will, and the common recognition of our shared humanity disappear in a haze of blood. Law did not produce the peace that has prevailed in Europe over the period of the last 80 years. Leviathan did.

0 comments

Why?

There’s a good article at FiveThirtyEight by Clare Malone you might want to take a look at. Ms. Malone tries to get her head around what’s happening in the presidential campaign. Here’s a snippet:

Trump has offered people something more potent than party allegiance: empowerment. Bernie Sanders is presenting something similar, though his message is more catholic in its demographics; John Kasich speaks about empathy as a balm for the scathed electorate; but Trump’s silent majority, a mostly white, working-class cohort, wants to talk about their problems for once.

I sympathize with her. I don’t honestly understand what’s happening, either. I don’t think she quite captures the anger, even desperation, that’s motivating people or that it crosses not just party lines but all of the conventional dividing lines in American politics including ideology and race.

If you think you know what will happen, be prepared to be surprised.

18 comments

I Wonder What They Meant By That?

Among the many famous anecdotes surrounding the French diplomat Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord, one of the most famous was related by the equally famous Austrian diplomat Klemens von Metternich at Talleyrand’s funeral. On hearing of the death of the Turkish ambassador, Metternich claimed that Talleyrand waggishly said “I wonder what he meant by that?”

President Obama recently arrived in Cuba. As president of the United States he is both head of government and head of state. Under the circumstances it would have been appropriate for him to be received by the Cuban president. He was received by the Cuban Foreign Minister.

I wonder what they meant by that?

2 comments

Can Europe Afford Its Immigrants?

Something I’ve been noodling over for the last day is the net costs or benefits of its migrant population to European countries. Most immigrants to European countries are economic migrants—relatively few are refugees. The European countries have made conscious decisions to import this migrant population. Many explanations have been brought forward, the most common being that they had aging populations and needed more young workers to pay for their ambitious social programs.

What is clear from the terrorist attacks that have become all too common in the United Kingdom, Spain, France, and now Belgium is that the countries of Europe have imported their new residents’ social problems along with them and they haven’t adjusted to that fact yet.

Concurrently with this European countries that we blithely think of as “our NATO allies” have been scrimping on their defense spending. Germany, Italy, Spain, and Belgium all spend considerably less than the 2% of GDP to which they’ve committed to spend on their military as part of their responsibilities as NATO members and their forces are no longer at the highest level of readiness. As a consequence they have lost the ability to project power. They are dependent on the United States and U. S. military spending.

Just as European countries aren’t spending enough on their militaries, the terrorist attacks over the last couple of years show they aren’t spending enough on domestic security.

With the exception of the United Kingdom, all of our major NATO allies’ economies are growing at less than 2% per year. Spending more on security will decrease that even farther. They need more growth if they are to ameliorate the economic conditions that some say underpin the alienation promoting radicalization and terrorism.

I’m beginning to wonder if the countries of Europe can afford their immigrant populations.

8 comments

Tertium Non Datur

I think that Dean Baker is being unnecessarily harsh in characterizing supporters of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement as either fools or liars:

The long and short is that the TPP offers almost none of the classic benefits associated with free trade, since it does very little in terms of reducing trade barriers. The deal is about increasing corporate profits at the expense of the public in all of the countries that are parties. And you are stupid protectionist Neanderthal if you don’t go along. Got it?

I think that Dr. Baker has the facts right. The case in support of the TPP is remarkably weak and, more amazingly, the administration has hardly bothered to make it.

The “classic benefits” of trade assume conditions that do not apply in the case of the TPP. It isn’t free trade; it’s managed trade. I’d like to see someone make the case that it’s managed trade that benefits most Americans (rather than just a few) but so far I’ve been disappointed.

5 comments

The Brussels Terror Attacks

I don’t have a great deal to say about the terrorist attacks in Brussels that have left scores of dead and wounded that I haven’t already said. My heart goes out to the Belgian people.

The ethnic nation states of Europe have problems that they need to address. They need to make conscious decisions as to whether they will remain mostly Christian (or post-Christian) ethnic states or become multi-confessional, multi-ethnic, multi-racial countries. The decision should be conscious rather than willy-nilly because they’ll need to make some choices in either case. One major complication is that a single decision probably won’t be acceptable for all of Europe. Schengen may be dead for good.

I don’t think that we have quite the same problems as our European cousins do, at least not yet, and we should take care not to import their problems. We have plenty of problems of our own.

5 comments

How Much More Can Brazil Sustain?

How much more can poor Brazil sustain? It’s got its current president (at least as of this writing), Dilma Rousseff, and its former president, known for short as Lula, ensnared in a corruption scandal involving Petrobras, the country’s public-private hybrid oil company. Petrobras is by most accounts the most indebted company in the world and the low price of oil won’t do much to improve its ability to pay.

Then there’s the Brazilian economy. Most Americans are at least marginally aware that the United States and China have two the largest economies in the world but I strongly suspect that most are blithely unaware that Brazil has the seventh largest economy. That economy is presently in a steep slump—it’s contracted about 10% over the last five years. There are lots of reasons: it depended too highly on purchases of raw materials by China, the price of oil, you name it.

The summer Olympics are scheduled to begin on August 5 in Rio. Can anyone possibly believe that all of the preparations will be completed smoothly and with a minimum of corruption? The IOC has been kvetching about Brazil’s lack of preparedness for the Olympics or some time. And what about security?

And then there’s the Zika virus. The number of cases of microcephaly attributed to the Zika virus in Brazil is now variously reported as anything from more than nearly 900 to 4,000.

It’s practically the perfect storm for poor Brazil.

I’m thinking of expanding this post for Outside the Beltway to include citations, some elaboration on the various issues, and some commentary by some old friends of mine who are living in Brazil. It’s really a shame that Americans are so disinterested in our neighbors’ problems.

1 comment