Manage

In a post at City Journal Aaron Renn covers some of the same territory about Chicago’s woes that I did yesterday:

So long as reformers are constitutionally prevented from curtailing union power in Illinois and Chicago, the pension crisis will continue to worsen. And, so long as it does, the financial environment in Chicagoland will deteriorate and people will keep leaving. Because the current Illinois constitution acts as a one-way ratchet on retirement benefits, it’s hard to see a way out of this catastrophic situation.

There are actually several possible strategies. The first is to amend the state’s constitution. Given that both houses of Illinois’s legislature are controlled by Democrats and how beholden those Democratic politicians are to public employee unions, that would be difficult but it’s not impossible.

The second is bankruptcy. With what appears to be a rapidly accelerating crisis in Chicago, abetted by Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s fecklessness, the previously unthinkable is becoming a lot more thinkable. Even appealing. The powers of judges in cases of bankruptcy are nearly limitless. They can set aside contracts, demand that taxes be raised. They can have uncooperative politicians thrown in jail. However, allowing Chicago or CPS or both to declare bankruptcy will require an act of the legislature which makes it much harder.

My advice is manage the decline. Acknowledge that Chicago is going to decline in population, economic activity, and tax base. Don’t expand schools or build new roads, bridges, etc. Prioritize what’s important and maintain them as well as you can.

Of course if our political leadership were actually able to prioritize what’s important we wouldn’t be in this mess.

1 comment

It Isn’t American Exceptionalism

In his column at the Boston Globe examining the differences in experience and, presumably, behavior of Muslims in Belgium with those in the United States:

The United States has been far more successful at assimilating and integrating Muslim immigrants into American society and culture than has Western Europe. There are no Muslim ghettoes here like those in Molenbeek or the Paris suburbs, where authorities turn a blind eye to antisocial behavior and aggressive incitement by radicals preaching jihad. Of course there have been some heinous exceptions, such as the Tsarnaev brothers, the Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hassan, or the killers in San Bernardino. And mosques in American cities have often been built with funding from Saudi Arabia, which promotes a harsh and puritanical version of Islam.

[…]

Given America’s wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, the bloody battles with Islamic regimes and insurgents, and the threat to homeland security from “lone wolf” terror attacks, it might seem surprising that Muslims in Detroit or Brooklyn aren’t at least as alienated as those in Molenbeek. But they aren’t. For despite the rise of identity politics and the balkanizing pressures of multicultural correctness, America’s melting pot still works. Generations of Muslim immigrants have come to America to escape repression, poverty, or war in their homelands. The life they have made for themselves here has been freer, safer, more prosperous, and more embracing than the existence they left behind. There are tensions, but not enough to keep most Muslims from fitting themselves comfortably into the American mosaic.

I think there are some important considerations he fails to take into account. First, the European states are ethnic states (in the case of Belgium bi-ethnic). Their identities are completely bound up in considerations of blood, language, and culture and some, as in the case of France, have historically enforced these considerations quite ruthlessly even if they aren’t doing so today.

Consequently, immigrants from the Middle East and North Africa who have no ties of blood, religion, or culture with Belgium and may speak neither of Belgium’s languages, present special challenges to a society that has never faced them before. In other words, don’t be too hard on the Belgian’s. We’ve had hundreds of years of practice. They’re just beginners.

Secondly, just as the United States is the natural destination for Mexicans and Central Americans seeking better jobs and less repression than in their home countries so is Europe the natural destination for people from the Middle East and North Africa. Our Muslim population is very different from Europe’s because we’re selecting them as well as their selecting us. Just as one example, Muslim immigrants to the United States tend to be better educated on average than the native population.

My advice would be that we shouldn’t rely too heavily on American exceptionalism. If we adopt Europe’s methods, we’ll have Europe’s problems.

5 comments

The Questions That Will Receive Scant Attention

In his examination at Rolling Stone of why young voters are casting their votes overwhelmingly for Bernie Sanders, Matt Taibbi asks what should be crucial questions about Hillary Clinton’s presidential ambitions:

Is Hillary really doing the most good that she can do, fighting for the best deal that’s there to get for ordinary people?

Or is she just doing something that satisfies her own definition of that, while taking tens of millions of dollars from some of the world’s biggest jerks?

but in the handwringing over the horrors of the Republican candidates, at least one of whom can reasonably be numbered among the “world’s biggest jerks, I suspect they’ll receive scant attention.

Let me ask another question that I guess is only tangentially related to those questions. Why is this the best that we can do?

13 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

We’re #1!

ChicagoY0YPopulationChange2015
Chicago and the Chicago metropolitan area, known around here as “Chicagoland” or “the collar counties”, has lost more population than any other U. S. city and area. Via the Chicago Tribune:

By almost every metric, Illinois’ population is sharply declining, largely because residents are fleeing the state. The Tribune surveyed dozens of former residents who’ve left within the last five years, and each offered their own list of reasons for doing so. Common reasons include high taxes, the state budget stalemate, crime, the unemployment rate and the weather. Census data released Thursday suggest the root of the problem is in the Chicago metropolitan area, which in 2015 saw its first population decline since at least 1990.

Chicago’s metropolitan statistical area, defined by the U.S. Census Bureau, includes the city and suburbs and extends into Wisconsin and Indiana.

The Chicago area lost an estimated 6,263 residents in 2015 — the greatest loss of any metropolitan area in the country. That puts the region’s population at 9.5 million.

Why are we losing population?

The main factors in Chicago’s population dip are diminished immigration, the aging of the Mexican immigrant population that bolstered the city throughout the 1990s as well as an exodus of African-Americans, experts say.

More than any other city, Chicago has depended on Mexican immigrants to balance the sluggish growth of its native-born population, said Rob Paral, a Chicago-based demographer who advises nonprofits and community groups. During the 1990s, immigration accounted for most of Chicago’s population growth. The number of Mexican immigrants rose by 117,000 in Chicago that decade, according to data gathered by Paral’s firm, Rob Paral and Associates.

After 2007, falling Mexican-born populations became a trend across the country’s major metropolitan areas. But most of those cities were able to make up for the loss with the growth of their native populations, Paral said. Chicago couldn’t.

The homicide rate and bad publicity aren’t helping, either. The city’s black population has been declining for more than a decade and its Hispanic population has peaked.

I’ve read some defenses of Chicago and Illinois on the grounds that we’re losing fewer residents per 100,000 population than some other places, i.e. that our losses just seem bigger. However, taxes aren’t levied per 100K and spending isn’t determined per 100K. From my perspective all of this means that there will be fewer Chicagoans and fewer Illinoisans to bear a rapidly increasing burden of spending and commitment for future spending.

Think twice about building more schools and expanding those roads.

The obvious solution, as quoted in the article, is to focus on economic growth. People don’t come to Illinois for the climate or the scenery. They come here for opportunity. They come here to work. Without those the future is bleak.

3 comments

Managed Trade Is Not Free Trade

I agree with a few things in Megan McArdle’s latest defense of free trade at Bloomberg. For example, this:

I’ve already confessed that I, like many free traders, underestimated the effect of China’s 2001 accession to the World Trade Organization, which gave it broad access to global markets. The sudden addition of several hundred million low-wage workers to the world labor market has been a catastrophic event for parts of the U.S. economy that suddenly had to compete. The protectionists were right that free trade was causing problems, and we were wrong.

I’m not a protectionist (more about that later) but I’ve been warning about looking at China through rose-colored glasses for the last 35 years. It’s good of her to acknowledge that she was wrong. She was and is. Granting China Most Favored Nation trading status as well as admission to the WTO should have been predicated on China’s divesting publicly-owned industries and opening up its banking system rather than taking those steps under the assumption that they would. And I agree wholeheartedly with this:

For one thing, China really was unique; there’s no other country that’s going to suddenly add so many workers to the market.

which is precisely why China should have been required to reform first.

Managed trade which is what we have is not free trade. You cannot attribute the benefits of free trade to a system of managed trade in any meaningful sense. Rejecting that managed trade ipso facto has the benefits of free trade does not make me a protectionist. Just the opposite.

IMO Megan would benefit from quantifying her claims. It would stop her from making excessive statements like this:

The Big Three made a pretty good car in the 1950s, even though they were effectively an oligopoly shielded from foreign competition. But by the 1970s … well, there’s a reason few people fantasize about owning a mint-quality 1977 Chrysler Cordoba.

The difference between regulating trade China as we do now and more restrictively isn’t the difference between getting modern automobiles and being stuck with 1970s automobiles. It means paying less than $100 more for an iPhone, a couple of hundred bucks more for that 70 inch flatscreen, and a couple of hundred bucks more for a small automobile than we do now. A slightly small quantity will be sold and you’ll have neighbors who make or build iPhones, flatscreen TVs, and engines for small automobiles.

It means more prosperity not just here but in Mexico and the Philippines and Brazil and a hundred other places where competition from China and its unenforced or nonexistent labor and environmental laws keep costs so cheap.

I think that tariffs on Chinese goods manufactured by forced labor or in unsafe conditions or that doesn’t meet environmental standards will meet WTO muster and if China protests to the WTO, protest right back. China still hasn’t made the reforms it agreed to when it was admitted to the WTO. It’s about time.

3 comments

The Greeks Had a Word For It…

Is there a word for when somebody agrees with you but responds angrily, his or her affect suggesting disagreement rather than agreement? I find it happens all the time.

6 comments

Go For Broke!

Let me bring you up to date on the soap opera that is Chicago. The City of Chicago had cobbled together a pension reform plan that included requiring city workers to chip in more for their own retirements, raised the retirement age, and trimmed cost of living adjustments. The other day the Illinois Supreme Court struck down that plan as I’ve been saying all along it would. Illinois’s constitution makes public employees’ pension plans legally enforceable rights that cannot be diminished. Let me say that again: if your plan diminishes public employees’ pensions, it will be struck down by the Illinois Supreme Court as unconstitutional.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal put in their two cents:

The ruling further limits Mr. Emanuel’s fiscal options as pension payments take an ever-growing share of city revenues. On Thursday the gracious souls at the Chicago Teachers Union announced a one-day walkout on April 1. The CTU isn’t allowed to strike until this summer, but CTU president Karen Lewis told her members not to worry: “What are they going to do, arrest us all? Put us all in jail? There’s not 27,000 spaces in the Cook County Jail right now.” Ah, she cares so deeply for the children.

The ruling may be better news for Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner, who has been trying to reform the state pensions amid a hostile Democratic legislature. The court said in its Chicago ruling that a reform would be constitutional if workers had a choice to go into a modified or lower-benefit structure.

Meanwhile, the city has just borrowed another $220 million to meet its pension payment obligations. I wonder how the city will manage to pay the interest on that loan let alone the principle.

Is it my imagination or is the city’s race to bankruptcy accelerating?

7 comments

Europe Is Already Lost

One paragraph jumped out at me in David Ignatius’s recent Washington Post column entitled “Fix Europe or Lose It”:

The second requirement is fairness. The European Union has largely been a project of the elites. The powerful companies (and nations) have prospered. The weak have suffered. When the bills came due, the haves told the have-nots to tighten their belts. Should it surprise us that this arrogant system is cracking at the seams?

Does that sound a bit familiar to you? Is it just barely possible that description doesn’t apply solely to Europe? Or even primarily to Europe?

As to the bulk of his prescriptions, we’ve already infantilized the Europeans enough. They need to learn to defend themselves or not be defended. Which leads me to something I’ve written about before: I don’t think the Europeans can afford to do what they need to do to make their societies secure, at least not and continue to support their systems of social spending.

That’s what I mean by saying “Europe is already lost”. The Europe that was imagined is dying. It’s been murdered.

9 comments

The Agony of Defeat

In her most recent column at the Wall Street Journal and reacting to the terror attacks in Brussels, Peggy Noonan weighs in on defeating radical Islam:

There are said to be 1.6 billion Muslims in the world. Most are and have been peaceful and peaceable, living their lives and, especially in America, taking an admirable role in the life of the nation.

But this is a tense, fraught moment within the world of Islam, marked by disagreements on what Islam is and what its texts mean. With that context, the child’s math: Let’s say only 10% of the 1.6 billion harbor feelings of grievance toward “the West,” or desire to expunge the infidel, or hope to re-establish the caliphate. That 10% is 160 million people. Let’s say of that group only 10% would be inclined toward jihad. That’s 16 million. Assume that of that group only 10% really means it—would really become jihadis or give them aid and sustenance. That’s 1.6 million. That is a lot of ferociousness in an age of increasingly available weapons, including the chemical, biological and nuclear sort.

My math tells me it will be a long, hard fight. We will not be able to contain them, we will have to beat them.

This is a widely-held view and a lot of policy is predicated on it. I also think it’s wrong. It assumes a steady state system.

Quite to the contrary I think that, since Islam is sola scriptura and lacking in a magisterium (teaching authority) which means that anybody’s interpretation of the sacred texts is as good as anybody else’s, there will always be idiots who give those sacred texts literal and bloody interpretations, something to which Islam lends itself distinctively because of the high incidence of bloody prescriptions in its sacred texts compared with, for example, the Christian New Testament. The New Testament isn’t without bloody prescriptions and historically there have been literal and bloodthirsty interpretations of it but a difference in degree is a difference in kind and objectively the Muslim sacred texts are considerably more violent than the New Testament. My point here is not that all Muslims are violent radical jihadists; it is that violent radical jihadism is in a sense endemic in Islam.

The choices then are extermination of the good with the bad, something I think that any right-minded person should reject, containment which will be painful, difficult, and go against the grain of most liberal Westerners (liberal in the old sense rather than liberal in the sense of progressives), or acceptance of risk in a world of increasing individual empowerment in which a handful of jihadis can do more damage than a regiment could have a couple of centuries ago.

Those aren’t appealing alternatives which explains why we’ve been so reluctant to select one. Grasp the nettle, as me auld mither used to say.

6 comments