The Department of Justice has withdrawn its suit against Apple seeking to compel the company to assist it in breaking the encryption of one of an iPhone that had belonged to one of the San Bernardino terrorists. Here’s what ABC News had to say:
Federal officials announced Monday night they successfully cracked into an iPhone belonging to one of the San Bernardino shooters and no longer needed Apple’s help in unlocking the device.
In doing so, authorities succeeded in their goal of breaking into an iPhone used by Syed Farook but did not set any sort of legal precedent that could be used in a future case, making it a sort of lukewarm win for both Apple and federal authorities.
Superficially, that looks like a win-win solution. Both parties got what they said they wanted. The FBI has decrypted the phone. Apple wasn’t forced to help. However, I think this particular outcome is a significant loss for Apple and I’ll try to explain why.
While both parties accomplished their stated objectives they each had unstated objectives which might have been more important to them than the stated objectives. The FBI clearly wanted a test case for compelling a technology company to assist them in this way and it didn’t get it. But that wasn’t something they didn’t already have. Failing to achieve an unstated objective isn’t a loss. It’s just a missed opportunity and there will be other bites at the apple, so to speak, in the future.
But the phone has been decrypted. Now Apple does not know if that feat was accomplished by brute force, whether it employed some exploit in the particular model of that one iPhone, or if it exploited some more general flaw. If it employed an exploit in that particular model, it reveals that Apple was lying in its claim that assisting the FBI could put all smartphones at risk. If decrypting the iPhone exploited a more general flaw that Apple doesn’t know about, Apple’s worst fears will be realized, all smartphones are at risk, and Apple’s marketing strategy is in a shambles.
The company’s reputation has been injured. Either for probity or technical superiority or both. In other words Apple no longer has something it used to possess. It should have helped decrypt the iPhone.







