There is a fascinating study at Pew Research on how income and expenditures have recovered since the Great Recession. The graph above illustrates both. As you can see real expenditures are just about where they were in 2007. Real income has not fared so well. Here are Pew’s remarks:
From 2004 to 2008, median household income grew by only 1.5 percent,3 while median expenditures increased by about 11 percent. During that period, the expenditure-to-income ratio (the percentage of a household’s budget used for spending) jumped by 9 percent. As the recovery began, median household expenditures returned to pre-crisis levels, but median household income continued to contract. By 2014, median income had fallen by 13 percent from 2004 levels, while expenditures had increased by nearly 14 percent. This change in the expenditure-to-income ratio in the years following the financial crisis is a clear indication of why and how households feel financially strained.
The different class of expenditures have not all increased at the same rate:

A number of things jump out from that graph. Two classes of expenditures, healthcare and housing, have grown substantially relative to income since 1996. And most of that growth has been since 2012. Spending on food as a share of income has essentially been flat since 1996 while spending on pets, toys, and entertainment has decreased a tiny bit as a share of income.
How can real expenditures have increased so much while real incomes barely increased at all? I think the most likely explanation is that prices in healthcare and housing have continued to rise and supply and demand has taken care of the rest.
How can expenditures be outstripping income? It’s possible that people are dipping into nonexistent savings but by far the more likely explanation is the substantial increase in credit card debt that has occurred over the period.
A couple of other things from the study. The lower third of income earners are actually worse off now than they were before the Great Recession. Rent now consumes half of their incomes, a shocking figure.
Do these results fit your idea of a robust and sustainable recovery? The business cycle has still not been repealed. What do you think is going to happen in the next inevitable recession?
My prescription, as it has been for some time, is that healthcare spending must be not merely controlled but actually brought down and we need to create a lot more jobs that pay more. Neither of these things look particularly likely without major changes in policy.






