The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Too Hot, Too Cold, or Just Right?

I found this characterization, which appeared in David Ignatius’s Washington Post column, of Robert Gates’s analysis of the Obama foreign policy singularly unhelpful:

The interview with Gates followed a speech he gave the previous night in which he parsed the long-standing dispute over whether “realism” or “idealism” should govern U.S. foreign policy. A wise strategy has a measure of both, Gates told the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

“It is neither hypocrisy nor cynicism to believe fervently in freedom while adopting different approaches to advancing freedom at different times along the way — including temporarily making common cause with despots to defeat greater or more urgent threats,” he said in his speech.

In general “foreign policy realism” means a foreign policy grounded in the material interests of your country, e.g. security, trade, and an acknowledgement that other countries pursue their own interests while “foreign policy idealism” means the pursuit of objectives like the promotion of democracy or human rights, taking less account of the material interests.

No president operates purely from a position of realism or idealism. Every president combines both, sometimes in adjacent sentences, a habit dismaying to our allies and adversaries alike. Rather than getting into a discussion of how many diplomats can dance on the head of a pin, let’s phrase the question another way. Was ousting Moammar Qaddafi, something U. S. action was instrumental in, in our material national interests or not? Has leaving as many troops in Afghanistan as we have for as long as we have been in our national interests or not? Would removing them be in our national interest?

My own view is that for administration after administration we’ve been relying too heavily on military force as a sort of Maslow’s hammer. Is interventionism really in our national interest or not?

5 comments

Preaching to the Choir

I see that the same Salon article caught James Taranto’s interest as it did mine. He makes an interesting observation:

It seems to us he, like most Democrats, is overconfident about the general election. We wouldn’t say she’s a sure loser, or even that Trump or Cruz would be likelier than not to defeat her. But victory is far from a sure thing.

Her reaction to the Black Lives Matter pressure is one reason to think there may be trouble ahead. Fox News notes that she told the Sharpton conference: “White Americans need to do a much better job of listening. . . . We need to recognize our privilege and practice humility.”

You can see why she’d say such a thing. Black voters have been her bulwark against Sanders in the primaries, and she needs them to turn out in large numbers in November, as they did for Barack Obama four and eight years ago. But she can’t win with black votes alone, and a message like “white Americans . . . need to recognize our privilege” may alienate other voters she also needs.

That highlights the careful balancing act Sec. Clinton is performing. She’s running based on her husband’s record without embracing it and running on President Obama’s record without fully embracing that, either. She needs to tailor her messages to the specific audiences in the Democratic coalition. As with any highwire act, it’s a long way down.

And it’s always easier when you’re preaching to the choir.

8 comments

The Burden of Federal Regulation

The graph above, taken from this post at RealClearPolicy, illustrates pretty clearly that federal regulations impose a greater burden on Red States than they do on Blue States.

Is this coincidence? Why are red states red in our heatmap, and why are blue states blue? Our index is completely data-driven, and two factors explain much of this pattern: the specialization of a state in one or a few industries and the growing importance of environmental regulations.

It’s not a coincidence but I do not think the cause is political, either, at least not in the way that we usually understand politics. Consider this slightly dated map from August 2015 of the unemployment rate by state:

They aren’t identical by any means but I think there’s a certain resonance between the two maps, just as there is between both of them and maps of Red States and Blue States.

I really wish I could see a map of the actual enforcement of federal regulations by state. I suspect it would tell the story even more clearly. You can have all of the regulations in the world; it’s how or whether they’re actually enforced that really makes the difference.

I think that what the disparate burden indicates is a difference of opinion, a difference in priorities among states. That’s the rationale for federalism and IMO a key reason we should be suspicious of an activist federal government.

4 comments

China’s Opportunity Missed

I strongly recommend that you read Ambrose Evans-Pritchard’s column at The Telegraph to get a better sense of the actual situation in China. It’s full of interesting observations. For example:

Maurice Obstfeld, the IMF’s chief economist, said the trade-off for this year’s growth spurt is even more trouble down the road. “While we have upgraded near-term projections, we have downgraded the farther out projections,” he said.

“Our concern is some of the stimulus is likely to take the form of higher credit growth, more support for sectors that are in a secular sense declining and not that productive. We worry about the quality of growth more than the quantity of growth,” he said.

There you have the nub of the matter. Stripped of IMF circumlocutions, he is telling us that the Communist Party has once again let rip with debt-driven stimulus for the housing market and rust-bowl industries already chocking with overcapacity, stoking yet another mini-cycle to put off the day of reckoning.

The likelihood that China will fail to grasp the nettle of reform in time to avert a structural crisis is rising from probable to almost certain. As the well-meaning premier Li Keqiang keeps warning his colleagues in the Standing Committee, the current course leads straight into the middle income trap.

The factors that Mr. Evans-Pritchards documents include China’s exchange rate, credit overhang, lengthening delays in payments to suppliers, total debt, and growth of the working age population. Overall it does not paint a picture of an economy in robust health.

This observation may be heartening or disheartening, depending on your outlook:

We can put away those charts projecting China’s ‘sorpasso’, the moment when the country overtakes the US to become the world’s biggest economy. It is not going to happen in 2020, and will look even less likely in 2030, when China’s demographic dividend turns to deficit and the workforce goes into precipitous decline.

Add to this that China has yet to live up to the commitments it made when it was admitted to the WTO more than 15 years ago (it’s far behind schedule) and that China’s trading partners are chafing under China’s system of export subsidies—in violation of international agreements. China’s challenges are mounting rather than abating.

1 comment

Reforming Copyright Protection

As I read The Hill’s article on the Department of Commerce’s proposals for reforming our system of copyright protection, I searched in vain for anything about reducing the obscene duration of copyrights under present law. While that duration grants legal monopolies to corporate owners of copyrights, I have yet to see empirical evidence that it promotes the purpose of copyrights, in the words of the U. S. Constitution, “To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts”.

0 comments

The Real and the Unreal

One of the things that all inveterate China-watchers can tell you is that there’s a discrepancy between real, observable, measurable phenomena and the growth figures being reported by the Chinese government. At Wolf Street Wolf Richter observes:

While China’s economy was strong, rail freight volumes were soaring. For example, in 2010, when China was pump-priming its economy, rail freight volume jumped 10.8% from a year earlier. In 2011, it rose 6.9%. It had soared 44% from 2005 to 2011! But 2011 was the peak.

In 2012, volume in trillion ton-kilometers declined one notch and in 2013 stagnated. But in 2014, volume skidded 5.8%. And in 2015, volume plunged 10.5% to 3.4 billion tons, according to Caixin, citing figures from the National Railway Administration. It was the largest annual decline ever booked in China.

It was a year that the People’s Daily, the official paper of the Communist Party, described in this elegant manner:

Dragged by a housing slowdown, softening domestic demand, and unsteady exports, China’s economy expanded 6.9% year on year in 2015, the weakest reading in around a quarter of a century.

Which is precisely where things stop making sense: rail freight volume plunges 10.5% in 2015, and the economy still increases 6.9%? I mean, come on.

What if, rather than growing by more than 6%, China’s economy was contracting in real terms? Which would be more consistent with real, observable, measurable phenomena? What would that imply? What would the policy implications be?

The United States is far less exposed to a downturn in the Chinese economy than other countries including Germany, Australia, Canada, and Brazil are. That is clearly demonstrated by our enormous trade deficit with China. Will the Chinese stop selling to us because their economy is in a tailspin? That’s nonsense. They might buy less from us but so much of what they’re buying from us, e.g. “electrical equipment”, is actually being assembled into products that are in turn being sold back here in the U. S. that even that is dubious.

Hat tip: Business Insider

2 comments

The Mad Dash for the Extremes

I think there are a few things that Steve Almond is missing in his post at Salon warning the Democrats of the problems their own party is facing. For example, in this:

Obama’s signature legislative achievement, the Affordable Care Act, is essentially the program Bob Dole proposed back in 1993. His solution to our suicidal dependence on fossil fuels—cap-and-trade—is yet another recycled Republican idea.

he doesn’t seem to understand that the Overton Window had changed. What was pretty conventional moderate Republican thought in 1993 was anything but by 2009. What was completely unacceptable to Democrats in 1993 had become completely acceptable by 2009. Characterizing the PPACA as a “Republican plan” is a failure to understand the dynamic nature of politics.

And note that he’s implicitly characterizing President Obama as a moderate. In his Senate career Barack Obama had the farthest left voting record of any sitting senator. He was as far left as you could be and still be in the political mainstream. Thinking of him as a moderate is buying into what the Republicans have been saying for years: that President Obama has dragged his party to the left.

What I think has actually happened is that the Overton Window hasn’t merely shifted it’s expanded. Somebody (George Will?) described American politics as a football game played between the 40 yard lines. A half century ago Brits pointed out that both the American Democratic and Republican Parties fit neatly within the British Conservative Party.

I think that has changed. I don’t know what the implications of the change are but I think that has changed.

4 comments

The Meltdown Scenario

In all of the strategizing and imagineering about the primaries there’s an eventuality I’ve only heard mentioned a couple of times. Imagine that Hillary Clinton is the Democratic candidate and Ted Cruz is the Republican candidate. Not too much of a stretch, eh?

Now imagine that Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump both make third party runs for the presidency, all four of the candidates take states, and none of the candidates wins enough electoral votes to be elected to the presidency outright.

8 comments

Forum Question: Favorite Sports

The Watcher’s Council Forum question this week had to do with favorite sports. Most of the sports I’ve participated in have involved beating the snot out of people. I was astonished that there was another kendoka on the Watcher’s Council. There aren’t that many in the United States. I wasn’t quite as surprised that several of the other Watchers practiced martial arts. I don’t think any others taught as I did.

If you’re interested in the Watchers’ responses, the forum post at the Watcher’s site is here.

4 comments